1 of 99

Animals on the Move�Navigation, Migration, and Movement

Matt Babb

Georgia State University

2 of 99

Migration

  • What comes to mind when you think of migration?
  • What is migration?

​

2

3 of 99

Animal Movements

  • Migration: seasonal movement of animals from one region to another.
    • Usually involves a return
  • Dispersal: permanent movement of animals to a new region
    • Common in primates as juveniles get older

3

4 of 99

Emigration vs Immigration

  • Immigration: process of an animal moving to a new habitat, region, or location.
  • Emigration: process of an animal moving away from a previous habitat, region, or location

​

4

Emigration

Immigration

5 of 99

Animal Movements

  • Immigration, and Emigration can be classified under both:

5

Dispersal

Migration

6 of 99

Migration

  • Examples of Migration?

​

6

7 of 99

Why Move?

  • Why might animals need to move?
    • Lack of food or resources
    • Climate becomes too cold or too hot
    • Avoid Predators
    • Find a Mate/Reproduce
    • Natural Disaster
    • Overpopulation
    • Human encroachment/pollution

​

​

​

7

8 of 99

Golden Jellyfish

8

  • Daily Migration
    • Sunrise: Swim to surface
    • Sunset: Swim to deeper water
  • Symbiotic Relationship
    • Zooxanthellae: algae-like organisms
    • Provide jellies with energy from photosynthesis
  • Advantages
    • Predators in the shade
  • Ecosystem Impact
    • Daily movement stirs the water churning nutrients

9 of 99

Golden Jellyfish

9

10 of 99

Golden Jellyfish

10

11 of 99

Golden Jellyfish

11

12 of 99

Golden Jellyfish

12

13 of 99

Beluga Whale

13

  • Annual Migration
    • Summer melts sea ice
    • Swim toward warm shallow estuaries
    • ~ 6,000 km (3,800 miles)
  • Only some populations migrate
  • Why?
    • Safer for newborn calves
    • Stimulates metabolism
    • Avoids Orcas (predator)
  • Climate Change
    • Migration strategy was related to sea-surface temperature conditions (Bailleul et al., 2012)

​

14 of 99

Types of Migration

14

  • Obligatory Migration:
    • Migration that occurs at a predictable time in response to a predictable stimuli
    • “Hard-Wired”
    • Regular, Consistent, Predictable
      • Examples: Mating Season, Avoid the Cold
  • Facultative Migration:
    • Migration that occurs in response to current environmental conditions
    • Sometimes occurs, sometimes doesn’t
    • irregularity, inconsistency, and unpredictability
      • Examples: Dry season, El niño year

15 of 99

Obligatory Migrants

15

  • Features:
    1. Individuals leave before food resources are absent
    2. Timing is consistent year to year
    3. Similar behavior each year
    4. Tight genetic control of Migration
    5. ~~Long Distance~~ (not required)
  • Example: Lesser Whitethroats

Wernham et al. (2002)

16 of 99

Genetic Basis of Migration

16

  • Example: European Blackcaps
  • Evidence of Genetic Basis of Migration
  • Migration Location
    • Some migrate SW
    • Others migrate SE
    • Hybrids migrate S

​

  • 2. Migration Timing

- Correlation between parent and offspring migration timing

- Early parents have Early offspring

​

17 of 99

Facultative Migrants

17

  • Features:
    1. Proportions of a population that migrate vary year-to-year
    2. Distance migrated and timing are variable
    3. Individual behavior varies
    4. Usually a direct response to a lack of food
    5. Less genetic control of migration
  • Example: Common Redpolls

Winter 1965-1966

Winter 1972-1973

Zink and Bairlein (1995)

18 of 99

Why NOT Move?

  • What are costs associated with migration?
    • Physically Demanding / Energy cost
    • Lack of Food or Water on Journey
    • Time Costs
    • Potential new Predators
  • What are alternatives to migration?
    • Hibernation
    • Estivation

18

19 of 99

Estivation of Kangaroo Mice

19

  • Desert Ecosystems
  • Nocturnal
  • Metabolically derives water from food it eats
  • Hibernate and Estivate

​

Ambient Temperature (C)

Oxygen Consumption

20 of 99

Is it time to go?

  • How does an animal know when its time to move?

​

    • Internal Signals
      • Hormones – mating and hunger
      • Metabolic patterns
      • Circadian Rhythms
    • External Signals
      • Daylight
      • Temperature
      • Resource availability
      • Population Density

20

21 of 99

Springtails

  • Dispersal, not Migration
  • Research Question: Can overcrowding cause dispersal?

21

22 of 99

Springtails

​

  • Research Question: Can overcrowding cause dispersal?

22

23 of 99

Springtails

  • Low population densities had very little dispersal
  • High population densities had very high dispersal

23

Number of Springtails

Number Dispersed

24 of 99

Red-Spotted Newt

  • Low population densities had little migration
  • High population densities had high migration

24

Low Medium High

% Migrated to Land

25 of 99

Examples of Migration

25

26 of 99

26

How?!

27 of 99

How do animals migrate?

  • What are some possible ways animals know where to go?
    • Mental Maps
    • Olfaction
    • Auditory Cues
    • Visual Landmarks
    • Star Compass
    • Sun Compass
    • Magnetic Field

27

28 of 99

Edward Tolman, 1946

  • Behaviorist
    • how environmental factors affect observable behavior
  • Cognitive Revolution
  • Cognitive Maps
    • Mental representation that an individual uses to acquire, maintain, and retrieve information about the relative locations and attributes of phenomena in their environment
      • (Kaplan et al., 2017)

28

29 of 99

29

N

S

E

W

N

S

E

W

N

S

E

W

N

S

E

W

Response-Learning

Place-Learning

Tolman et al., 1946

Turn Left

Turn Left

Turn Right

Turn Left

30 of 99

Cognitive Map Results

30

31 of 99

Niko Tinbergen, 1972

  • Ethologist
    • scientific study of animal behavior, usually with a focus on behavior under natural conditions, and viewing behavior as an evolutionarily adaptive trait
  • Digger Wasp Experiment
    • Dig burrows to hold larva
    • Female flies out to find food
    • Brings food back to burrow

31

32 of 99

Digger Wasps use Landmarks

32

33 of 99

Digger Wasps use Landmarks

33

What

the

…

34 of 99

34

  • Digger Wasps were using visual cues to remember the location of their burrow
  • Tinbergen tried all different kinds of stimuli
  • Even tried olfactory cues, they didn’t work
  • He always pranked the wasp

35 of 99

African Elephants

  • Partial facultative migrants
    • What does that mean?
  • Unpredictability of African Savanna
  • Dry Season and Wet Season
    • Migrate in response to seasonal rainfall (Purdon et al., 2018)
  • Groups migrate some years but not others

​

35

36 of 99

African Elephants

Purdon et al., 2018

36

37 of 99

Infrasound Cues

37

  • Human Hearing Range:
    • 20 Hz – 20,000 Hz
  • Elephant Communication
    • 14 Hz – 35 Hz
    • 120 decibels
      • Loud but we cannot hear it
  • Communicate using infrasound

​

20 Hz

20 kHz

Infrasound

Ultrasound

200 kHz

0 Hz

38 of 99

Infrasound Cues

38

  • Infrasound:
    • Longer wavelengths
    • Sound travels further distance
    • Elephants have complex social organizations but must separate when the herd becomes too large

20 Hz

20 kHz

Infrasound

Ultrasound

200 kHz

0 Hz

39 of 99

Infrasound Cues

39

40 of 99

African Elephants

40

1-5 km

41 of 99

African Elephants

41

42 of 99

42

Pacific Ocean

Atlantic Ocean

Sc

43 of 99

Coho Salmon

  • Anadromous fish
    • Spawn in freshwater streams
    • But live in the ocean
  • ~1 year after birth, they make it to the ocean
  • 3 years of age, they return to the same river where they were born to spawn
  • How do they do that?
    • Olfactory Cues
    • Magnetic Navigation

​

43

44 of 99

Coho Salmon Experiment

  • 4 Test Groups

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

44

Imprinted

Imprinted

Non-imprinted

Non-imprinted

45 of 99

Coho Salmon Experiment

  • 4 Test Groups

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

  • Released in the water at spawning age and measured where they went with GPS satellite tracking

​

​

45

Imprinted

+ Chemical

Imprinted

+ no Chemical

Non-imprinted with Chemical

Non-imprinted with no Chemical

46 of 99

Coho Salmon Experiment

46

Hasler et al., 1978

Imprinted with Chemical

Imprinted with no Chemical

Non-imprinted with Chemical

Non-imprinted with no Chemical

Test Site with Chemical Release

47 of 99

BREAK TIME!

47

48 of 99

48

Pacific Ocean

Atlantic Ocean

Sc

49 of 99

Sea Turtle Magnetoreception

  • Magnetoreception: an organism sensing the earth’s magnetic field for navigation and orientation

​

49

50 of 99

Sea Turtle Magnetoreception

  • Magnetic Fields differ by 2 components
  • Inclination Angle
  • Intensity

​

50

51 of 99

Sea Turtle Magnetoreception

  • Magnetic Fields differ by 2 components
  • Inclination Angle
  • Intensity

​

51

52 of 99

Sea Turtle Magnetoreception

  • Magnetic Coil: Experimental Methodology

​

52

53 of 99

Sea Turtle Magnetoreception

53

54 of 99

Sea Turtle Magnetoreception

54

55 of 99

Loggerhead Life History

  • Hatch at beaches along E. United States
    • Usually at night or early morning
    • Temperature Dependent Sex Determination
  • Make their way to the ocean, then swim 20-hours to the Gulf Stream

55

  • Live and feed in sargassum
    • Protection and food source

56 of 99

Loggerhead Life History

  • Hatch at beaches along E. United States
    • Usually at night or early morning
    • Temperature Dependent Sex Determination
  • Make their way to the ocean, then swim 20-hours to the Gulf Stream

56

  • Live and feed in sargassum
    • Protection and food source

57 of 99

Loggerhead Life History

  • Once large enough to not be eaten, they make their way to the N. Atlantic Gyre
  • Remain in the oceanic zone until they are large enough to return to the neritic zone (McClellan & Read, 2007)
    • Why?

57

58 of 99

Loggerhead Life History

58

59 of 99

Loggerhead Life History

59

60 of 99

Loggerhead Life History

  • Natal Homing: the process of returning to one’s birth place to reproduce
    • Sea turtles
    • Salmon
    • Bluefin Tuna

​

60

61 of 99

Title

  • TYPE

61

62 of 99

Ocean Waves and Animal Magnetism

  • Stage 1: Hatch
  • Stage 2: Make it to the ocean
  • Stage 3: Swim deeper
  • Stage 4: Find feeding grounds
  • Stage 5: Return to Mate/Lay eggs
  • Repeat

​

62

63 of 99

Stage 1: Hatch

  • A Boil: Hatching from the nest all at once
  • Immediately run to ocean

63

64 of 99

Stage 2: Make it to the Ocean

  • “Hurry! To the ocean!!”
  • Visual Light Cues
  • Orient to the brightest horizon
    • Lucas et al., 1992

64

65 of 99

Stage 2: Make it to the Ocean

  • Orient to the brightest horizon
    • Lucas et al., 1992
  • Experimental Condition

65

66 of 99

Stage 2: Make it to the Ocean

  • Orient to the brightest horizon
    • Lucas et al., 1992
  • Control

66

67 of 99

Stage 2: Make it to the Ocean

  • Orient to the brightest horizon
    • Lucas et al., 1992
  • Control

67

68 of 99

Stage 3: Swim Deeper

68

waves

waves

waves

69 of 99

Stage 3: Swim Deeper

69

70 of 99

Stage 3: Swim Deeper

70

Waves

Waves

Waves

Waves

71 of 99

Stage 3: Swim Deeper

71

Final Wave Direction

Beach

Wave Refraction Zone

Open Ocean

Initial Wave Direction

Wave refraction near shore

72 of 99

Stage 3: Swim Deeper

  • But how?!
    • Possible Explanations

1. Visual Cues

2. Doplar Shift

* Swim in different directions until a change in wave frequency is detected

3. Wave Acceleration

* Using the inner ear, do they detect the motion of the ocean?

72

73 of 99

Experiment 1: Visual Cues

  • How would we test if its visual cues?

​

73

74 of 99

Experiment 1: Visual Cues

74

75 of 99

Experiment 2: Doplar Shifts

  • How would we test if it’s a doplar shift?
  • AKA: Detecting wave frequencies

​

​

​

​

​

​

  • To do this, the turtle must swim in different directions a lot, but they don’t

​

75

Increased Frequency of Waves

Decreased Frequency of Waves

76 of 99

Experiment 3: Wave Acceleration

  • How would we test if it’s the motion of the ocean?

​

76

77 of 99

Experiment 3: Wave Acceleration

77

78 of 99

Wave Simulator

78

Positioned the Wave Simulator so that the “waves” came from different directions. Then we measured which direction they “swam” in.

79 of 99

Wave Simulator

79

80 of 99

81 of 99

turning left

turning right

swimming straight

82 of 99

83 of 99

Stage 4: Find Feeding Grounds

  • Olfactory Cues (Pfaller et al., 2020)
  • Remember feeding grounds with magnetic reception
  • Experiment:
    • Utilize Classical Conditioning
    • Feed at one “location” don’t feed at another
    • Measure Feeding response after the magnetic field is changed

​

​

83

84 of 99

Stage 5: Return for Reproduction

  • How do the turtles find their home beach?
    • Magnetoreception
  • Evidence

84

60°

59°

58°

85 of 99

Stage 5: Return for Reproduction

  • Secular Variation: change in the Earth’s Magnetic Field over time
  • Causes Isolines converge and diverge

85

60°

59°

58°

86 of 99

Stage 5: Return for Reproduction

  • Secular Variation: change in the Earth’s Magnetic Field over time
  • Causes Isolines converge and diverge

86

60°

59°

58°

87 of 99

Stage 5: Return for Reproduction

  • So this is what happens on a normal year, where the isolines are neither converging nor diverging

87

60°

59°

58°

88 of 99

Converging Isolines

  • What do we predict would happen here?

88

60°

59°

58°

89 of 99

Diverging Isolines

  • What do we predict would happen here?

89

60°

59°

58°

90 of 99

Results

90

No Change

Brothers & Lohmann, 2015

91 of 99

Sun and Star Compasses

91

92 of 99

Sun Compass

92

93 of 99

Sun Compass

  • Experiment

93

N

E

S

W

94 of 99

Sun Compass

  • Experiment

94

N

E

S

W

95 of 99

Sun Compass

  • Coordination with visual cues and circadian rhythm
  • Clock-shifted Birds
    • Performed poorly when placed outside because their circadian rhythm made them think the sun was in a different location.

95

96 of 99

Star Compass

96

97 of 99

Star Compass

  • Indigo Bunting
    • High flying migrant
    • Summer: North America
    • Winter: Florida and South America
    • Migrate South
  • Planetarium!

97

98 of 99

Star Compass

  • Planetarium Experiment

98

99 of 99

Star Compass

  • Planetarium Experiment

99