1 of 82

Library Workshop Part 2

SSDB 220: Introduction

to Theories of Sexuality

2 of 82

YOUR UPCOMING ASSIGNMENTS: ��which parts relate the library, library help, and these SLIDES?

​

SAMPLE FOOTER TEXT

2

3 of 82

Annotated Bibliography

In your Proposal, you have already included your preliminary bibliography of five academic peer-reviewed sources. You can continue working on the same sources or modify your bibliography, if you find alternative sources are more relevant or interesting.�

What is important is that you have five academic sources (journal articles or book chapters) that are directly related to your topic and help to answer your main research question.�

Annotated bibliography includes two parts:

  1. Full bibliographical citation of the source in any style of your choice (Chicago, MLA, APA, etc.).
  2. Annotation, a short description of the source’s main argument and its relevance to your topic.

Each annotation should be 200-250 words. It must include a brief summary of the article or book chapter with clearly identified theoretical approach, main argument and conclusions (50 words). It must also include a detailed description (about 150 words) of the relevance of this particular source to the key research questions and the main argument of you Final Paper Proposal / Outline. This is the most important component of the assignment that demonstrates that you have a strong knowledge of the source and understand how it can be used in the analysis of a particular topic in sexuality studies.

3

4 of 82

[ A COUPLE OF REMINER SLIDES…

5 of 82

as part of your

Critical Thinking group assignment, you must each:

​

  • Find and select a scholarly/peer-reviewed article on a topic related to sexuality [tip: it doesn’t have to be a super specific topic, that will come with other assignments]

​

  • write a short review that:
    • briefly explains the article’s main argument
    • outlines its theoretical framework
    • identifies what kind of knowledge about sexuality �is produced by such a theoretical approach.

​

  • Include a full bibliographic reference (with author, date, page numbers…) and online link.

5

hint: these 2 articles by Rupp and by Samudzi clearly outline their theoretical framing or approach

6 of 82

Individual relevant journals

​

you can get started/get ideas by browsing individual academic journals such as: Sexualities, Journal of Sex Research, GLQ, Transgender Studies Quarterly, Journal of the History of Sexuality, Psychology & Sexuality, Archives of Sexual Behavior, Sexuality & Culture, etc.

​

​

SEE ALSO, even more journals:

Journals related to sexuality studies (from your Sexuality Studies Subject Guide)

6

7 of 82

…END OF REMINDER SLIDES ]

8 of 82

LET’S JUMP RIGHT IN

ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES using ZOTERO

DEMO & PRACTICE

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

9 of 82

How do you set up Zotero? REVIEW

  1. Register for account: zotero.org/user/register�
  2. Download the desktop application: zotero.org/download�+ sync with your account�
  3. Install the browser connector: zotero.org/download� + PIN the extension in your browser

​

10 of 82

What is Zotero?

A CITATION MANAGER

    • store and organize citations from various sources (journal articles, books, websites, etc.).
    • create collections / folders for easy organization.
    • generate bibliographies and in-text citations in multiple styles.

11 of 82

CITATION GENERATORS

12 of 82

CITATION MANAGERS

Programs that build a database of your research material.

​

At Concordia we use: ZOTERO

​

13 of 82

Where does Zotero live on your computer or device?

  • As an extension in your browser (Chrome works best)�
  • As a downloaded stand alone application on your computer�
  • As menu option in your wordprocessing application (MSWord, Google Doc)

​

13 /

14 of 82

ZOTERO FEATURES - HOW IT WORKS

14 /

2) Manage references in your desktop application

(or use the Web browser version)

1) Save citations via a browser extension

3) Enter parenthetical references within writing software and generate a bibliography

15 of 82

ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES

16 of 82

ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES - FORMAT

  • Lots of library help guides to choose from:

​

17 of 82

Annotated Bibliography HELP GUIDE

  • How to write an annotated bibliography includes APA example with format

18 of 82

�Annotated Bibliography FORMAT�-more GUIDES & EXAMPLES

From the Purdue OWL Writing Lab:

Detailed Instructions on format:

  • APA Citation Guide: Annotated Bibliography (University of Nevada, Reno)
    • see the section: Basic Tips for Formatting

​

19 of 82

JOURNAL ARTICLE FORMAT: APA EXAMPLE

Maak, T. (2007). Responsible leadership, stakeholder engagement, and the emergence of social capital. Journal of Business Ethics, 74, 329-343. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9510-5

​

This article focuses on the role of social capital in responsible leadership. It looks at both the social networks that a leader builds within an organization, and the links that a leader creates with external stakeholders. Maak’s main aim with this article seems to be to persuade people of the importance of continued research into the abilities that a leader requires and how they can be acquired. The focus on the world of multinational business means that for readers outside this world many of the conclusions seem rather obvious (be part of the solution not part of the problem). In spite of this, the article provides useful background information on analysis of a public servant.

20 of 82

ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES: CONTENT

Questions about your assignment instructions?

21 of 82

TODAY

  • ZOTERO & ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES�
  • CITING & REFERENCES for bibliographies & papers�
  • RECAP & REVIEW from last library workshop�
  • SEARCHING FOR TOPICS & ADJUSTING�
  • EVALUATING SOURCES: scholarly & beyond�

​

​

​

​

​

22 of 82

Citing, Citation Formats & References

22

23 of 82

but why do we care so much about citing??

23

24 of 82

CASE STUDY (and personal aside):

vocational awe

​

  • where has it ended up when cited without sufficient care?

24

25 of 82

Thoughts about citing and citational practices

This is a challenge for all of us:  Reflect on the way you approach referencing the work of others in your own writing, presenting and thinking. Whose work do you build on to make arguments ... Who are you citing, and why do you cite them (and not others)?�Eve Tuck, K. Wayne Yang, Rubén Gaztambide-Fernández,"Citation Practices" Critical Ethnic Studies, April 2015

​

​

I am interested in how references, citations, and bibliographies are central to the project of black studies. …I believe that bibliographies and endnotes and references and sources are alternative stories that can, in the most generous sense, centralize the practice of sharing ideas about liberation and resistance and writing against racial and sexual violence. �Katherine McKittrick, writing "Footnotes (Books and Papers Scattered about the Floor)", Dear Science and Other Stories, 2021

​

See also, from our Critical Information Literacy Toolkit: Who's Citing Whom and Inclusive Voices

25

more THOUGHTS ABOUT CITING

26 of 82

CITATION BASICS

Next set of slides adapted from those of Aeron MacHattie​, Teaching & Research Librarian

27 of 82

HOW, WHEN & WHERE ��TO CITE

HOW

  • Use only one citation style per paper/assignment
  • Use automatic citation generators (optional)
  • Identify what your source is before you cite it
  • Use a citation style guide (APA, MLA , Chicago)

​

​

WHEN

  • Information or facts that are not common knowledge
      • ex. the Eiffel tower is in Paris vs. the Eiffel tower receives 7 million visitors per year
      • both “direct quotes” and paraphrasing

​

WHERE

  • In-text citations at the end of the sentence
  • End-of-text citations in a list of sources (References/Bibliography)

28 of 82

REMINDER: CITATION GENERATORS

29 of 82

REMINDER: CITATION MANAGERS

Programs that build a database of your research material.

​

At Concordia we use: ZOTERO

​

30 of 82

CITATION STYLE GUIDES

​

​

Many more style guides with extra details & examples

​

31 of 82

IN-TEXT CITATIONS

  • Come at the end of the sentence where you quote or at the end of a passage where you paraphrase a source.

​

  • Refer the reader to a list of sources at the end of your paper.

32 of 82

IN-TEXT CITATIONS: DIRECT QUOTES

Hakkinen and Akrami (2014) found that “individuals are receptive to climate change communications, regardless of ideological position” (p. 65).

APA

Hakkinen and Akrami (2014) found that “individuals are receptive to climate change communications, regardless of ideological position” (65).

Chicago

author-date

33 of 82

IN-TEXT CITATIONS: PARAPHRASING

FOR THIS ASSIGNMENT

People from any ideological background are open to hearing about climate change (Hakkinen & Akrami, 2014, p. 65).

APA

People from any ideological background are open to hearing about climate change (Hakkinen and Akrami 65)

MLA

People from any ideological background are open to hearing about climate change (Hakkinen and Akrami 2014, 65)

Chicago

author-date

34 of 82

BIBLIOGRAPHY EXAMPLE:�APA JOURNAL ARTICLE REFERENCES

References

​

Doherty, T. J., & Clayton, S. (2011). The psychological impacts of global climate change. American Psychologist, 66(4), 265-276.

​

Hakkinen, K., & Akrami, N. (2014). Ideology and climate change denial. Personality and Individual Differences, 70, 62-65.�

McCright, A. M., & Dunlap, R. E. (2011). Cool dudes: The denial of climate change among conservative white males in the United States. Global environmental change, 21(4), 1163-1172.

​

35 of 82

BIBLIOGRAPHY EXAMPLE:�CHICAGO AUTHOR-DATE JOURNAL ARTICLE REFERENCES

Reference List

​

Doherty, Thomas. J., and Susan Clayton. 2011. “The psychological impacts of global climate change.” American Psychologist 66, no. 4: 265-276.

​

Hakkinen, Kristi, and Nazar Akrami. 2014. “Ideology and climate change denial.” Personality and Individual Differences 70: 62-65.�

McCright, Aston M., and Riley E. Dunlap. 2011. “Cool dudes: The denial of climate change among conservative white males in the United States.” Global environmental change 21, no.4: 1163-1172.

​

36 of 82

BOOK CHAPTERS: APA & CHICAGO

Guillen, R. (2017). Growing Justice in the Fields: Farmworker Autonomy and Food Sovereignty. In D. G. Peña, L. Calvo, P. McFarland, & G. R. Valle (Eds.), Mexican-origin Foods, Foodways, and Social Movements: Decolonial Perspectives (pp.235-250). Fayetteville: University of Arkansas Press.

​

APA

Guillen, Rosalinda. “Growing Justice in the Fields: Farmworker Autonomy and Food Sovereignty.” In Mexican-origin Foods, Foodways, and Social Movements: Decolonial Perspectives, edited by Devon Gerardo Peña, Luz Calvo, Pancho McFarland, and Gabriel R Valle, 235-250. Fayetteville: University of Arkansas Press, 2017.

​

CHICAGO

37 of 82

REMINDER:��CITATION STYLE GUIDES

​

​

Many more style guides with extra details & examples

​

38 of 82

TODAY

  • ZOTERO & ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES�
  • CITING & REFERENCES for bibliographies & papers�
  • RECAP & REVIEW from last library workshop�
  • SEARCHING FOR TOPICS & ADJUSTING�
  • EVALUATING SOURCES: scholarly & beyond�

​

​

​

​

​

39 of 82

RECAP & REVIEW

40 of 82

past assignments:��WHERE DID YOU GET STUCK?

41 of 82

WHERE CAN YOU GET HELP?

42 of 82

GETTING HELP IN THE LIBRARY

  1. Ask Us desk, chat, email or phone

FOR ANY QUESTION UNDER THE SUN

Google: ask concordia library

2) Contact your subject librarian

FOR MORE IN-DEPTH CONSULTATIONS

Icons on this slide are from the noun project

Every Tuesday 12-3

(near Ask Us desk)

Webster Library

Writing Assistance

43 of 82

Susie Breier (she/her/elle)�Sexuality Studies Librarian

AskUs desk Wednesdays 1-3 pm

​

43

FIND ME:

​

  • Google: �concordia library sexuality

​

  • concordia.ca/library/guides/sexuality�

​

�

​

44 of 82

�SIMONE DE BEAUVOIR INSTITUTE�LEARNING CENTRE & LENDING LIBRARY

ER building, 2155 Guy Street, 6th floor

​

Monday-Thursday: 10 am - 7 pm

​

contact: isabelle.lamoureux@concordia.ca

45 of 82

TODAY

  • ZOTERO & ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES�
  • CITING & REFERENCES for bibliographies & papers�
  • RECAP & REVIEW from last library workshop�
  • SEARCHING FOR TOPICS & ADJUSTING�
  • EVALUATING SOURCES: scholarly & beyond�

​

​

​

​

​

46 of 82

Searching for Topics & Adjusting

SAMPLE FOOTER TEXT

46

47 of 82

MY TOPIC

47

48 of 82

posts I found about bisexuality and non-monogamy

"One persistent stereotype—and an important one, since it may lead non-bisexuals to avoid relationships with bisexuals—is that bisexuals are...traitors, promiscuous... incapable of monogamy or commitment to one person."

�Are Bisexuals Really Less Monogamous Than Everyone Else? Psychology Today blog

"The researchers found that bisexual women, compared to lesbians and heterosexual women, were evaluated as more confused, promiscuous, non-monogamous…. [The researchers] hope that shedding light on this prejudice can help reduce it and the heavy toll it takes on bisexual individuals." ��“Many heterosexuals view bisexual women as promiscuous and confused”. PsyPost

49 of 82

my emerging thesis statement

  • Will use both ‘primary’ sources (blogs, posts, videos…) and ‘secondary’ sources (scholarly articles)

​

  • Should first learn more via Google (or other favourite tools) + course readings �
  • Then, I will need to perform several different keyword searches in:
  • library databases + Google scholar
  • ​
  • I can always try searching or browsing very relevant journals�

​

As evidenced in mainstream magazine columns and advice blogs, popular discourses purporting to debunk stereotypes around bisexuality often instead serve to reinforce persistent normative and colonial constructs around non-monogamy.

50 of 82

Find articles: �USE YOUR �SUBJECT GUIDE

Google:

sexuality concordia library

​

50

51 of 82

Google Scholar�

51

52 of 82

one of my searches in ….

Google scholar

​

type: constructs non-monogamy bisexuality

results: a few interesting articles, not always directly related to my topic, not all super recent

  • articles have “cited by” links leading to hundreds of additional more recent articles
  • I can click on the “cited by” link and:
    • browse the results, or:
    • check off the “search within” box and enter my search terms again
  • limit to 2011 onwards, or try limiting to even more recent articles to see what’s there, such as 2022 onwards

52

53 of 82

Google Scholar: search strategies �Boolean operators and more

  • use OR for alternative terms

​

  • use quotation marks " " for phrases

​

  • DON'T use AND (it is implied)

​

  • DON'T use * for truncation (happens automatically)

​

​

53

54 of 82

All about: Google Scholar

  • Huge and multidisciplinary
  • Great for finding RECENT articles and tracing scholarly conversations
  • No “peer-reviewed” checkbox – not everything is scholarly!
  • Lots of theses and dissertations, sometimes harder to find journal articles

​

** tip: SET UP Google Scholar to access Concordia resources

​

54

55 of 82

Library Databases (EBSCO, etc)

55

56 of 82

Find articles: DATABASES

  • Academic Search Complete (EBSCO)
    • Large multidisciplinary database indexing thousands of journals�

​

  • LGBTQ+ Source (EBSCO)
    • Small specialized database
    • Contains references to articles in �scholarly journals & popular sources��
  • SocINDEX (EBSCO)
    • Database with sociology-focused lens

​

  • ​

NOTE: EBSCO databases can be searched combined together. Just click on the database name and you’ll see more to select.

57 of 82

one of my searches in….

library databases

LGBTQ+ Source EBSCO database:

type: monogamy – see that most articles are tagged with “monogamous relationships”

adjust: monogam* – get too many results

adjust: monogam* AND bisexual* - worth going through results, can limit by adding another concept:

for example: monogam* AND bisexual* AND stereotyp*

or: monogam* AND bisexual* AND (colonial* OR normative OR construct* OR discourse)

– if there are not enough hits, just remove one of the ANDs

​

THEN adjust to peer-reviewed and to 2011 onwards for the most recent 15 years (or more recent)

57

58 of 82

library database: sample search

Google scholar: sample search

58

monogam* �

AND

​

bisexual*

�AND

​

colonial* OR normative OR construct* OR discourse OR narrative*

�

monogamy bisexuality (colonial OR normative OR constructs OR discourse OR narrative)

59 of 82

library datatabases: search strategies �Boolean operators and more

AND

OR

*

“ ”

​

59

see this handout

60 of 82

search results - TIPS:

60

  • Use Findit@concordia to connect to the full text or use Sofia to find the PDF�
  • Don’t settle for the first few hits�
  • Make the most of those few articles that ARE very relevant:
    • STOP searching and read/skim those relevant articles, looking for new ideas and keywords, authors, interesting articles in the bibliography�
    • use “cited by” in Google scholar

61 of 82

BROWSE JOURNALS:

Possibly useful scholarly journals

​

​

61

You can browse/search these journals or collections individually but remember that you can also search these and many other related journals at the same time using our recommended article databases or Google Scholar.

​

62 of 82

REVIEW: Finding Stuff

SAMPLE FOOTER TEXT

62

63 of 82

SOFIA: LOCATING/ACCESSING STUFF:

  • Find what we own: books, videos, articles �
  • REQUEST material from Quebec University Libraries & libraries around the world�
  • Try quick topic searches� for books�
  • Introductory Video:
    • Searching Sofia

​

63

64 of 82

Requesting stuff from other libraries: Sofia

64

Quick How-to Videos:

​

    • Requesting Books (print books)

​

    • Requesting Articles & Chapters (online)

65 of 82

�YOUR TURN: get started on your annotated bibliography

Find & evaluate some possible articles/sources if necessary- save the citations to Zotero

​

Practice writing an annotation and pasting it in the Extra field in Zotero�

Practice using the “Create Bibliography from Collection” option in Zotero to create a sample Annotated Bibliography, and open it in MSWord

65

66 of 82

TODAY

  • ZOTERO & ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES�
  • CITING & REFERENCES for bibliographies & papers�
  • RECAP & REVIEW from last library workshop�
  • SEARCHING FOR TOPICS & ADJUSTING�
  • EVALUATING SOURCES: scholarly & beyond�

​

​

​

​

​

67 of 82

EVALUATING WHAT YOU FOUND

what are you looking at anyway? don’t be afraid to Google to find out more

68 of 82

EVALUATING SOURCES: is it scholarly?

68

69 of 82

REVIEW FROM OUR LAST WORKSHOP:�Is it scholarly or not?

69

70 of 82

Is it scholarly or not? ANSWER

Davies, A. W., Simone-Balter, A., & van Rhijn, T. (2023). Sexuality education and early childhood educators in Ontario, Canada: A Foucauldian exploration of constraints and possibilities. Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood, 24(4), 394–410. https://doi.org/10.1177/14639491211060787

70

This article is from a non-scholarly newsletter/magazine published by the American Association of Sex Educators & Therapists. The article is conversational rather than academic and does not report any scholary findings nor use any scholarly frameworks. It is closer to a news/editorial article. There are no references.

This IS an academic/scholarly/

peer-reviewed article. Important clues: Research article published in Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood, a peer-reviewed journal according to the Sage journals website. The article has distinct sections such as abstract, theoretical approach, research context, and it reports on the authors’ analysis of data from a qualitative study.

Long bibliography of references.

71 of 82

ENSURING YOUR SOURCES ARE ACADEMIC/SCHOLARLY

​

  • Check the academic/peer-reviewed/scholarly journals box or tab when doing searches in Library Databases and Sofia

​

  • Look up the journal name (or look for scholarly book reviews or books published by a university press if you are hoping to use a book or book chapter.)

​

72 of 82

Elements of a typical SCHOLARLY ARTICLE

Article title

Author/s

Abstract

Background/�Literature Review

​

Introduction

Methodology/ Theory

Journal name

Results / Argument

Bibliography

Journal name

Discussion / Analysis

Conclusion

73 of 82

Elements of a typical SCHOLARLY CHAPTER

Book chapter title

Author/s

Abstract (?)

Background/�Literature Review

Introduction

Theoretical framework

Book title

Main Results/�Argument

Bibliography

Book title

Discussion/ Analysis

Conclusion

74 of 82

EVALUATING SOURCES:

everything else

74

75 of 82

YOUR TURN to evaluate:

76 of 82

How would you evaluate this one?

​

listed in a database as related to the course reading:�

The Case Against Marriage: What You Lose When You Gain a Spouse from the Atlantic

76

77 of 82

ANSWERS from students and prof at workshop

How would you evaluate this one?

​

  • note the unsubstantiated and surprising claims, such as the “..hard truth: that when a nation fails to preserve the family, the state fails to preserve itself” or, p. 2 “One knows from universal experience that children are best raised in homes with their married mothers and fathers.”�
  • note that is is a “special report”, produced by the Heritage Foundation - look up that body, in something as simple as Wikepedia, along with the DeVos Center for Human Flourishing -which turns out to be another branch of the Heritage Foundation�
  • note the quite large number of authors, with one (only one) adding PhD to their credentials, most are “policy advisors” mnd “research analysts” - sure sign of vested interests rather than academic interests

​

  • note that there IS a long bibliography of references, including academic ones. But a deep dive might look at whether or not the articles cited actually substantiate the claims in the text.

​

​

​

77

78 of 82

Evaluating Sources - BASICS

  • Authorship: Who wrote/created this? In what publication/source? What is the author's expertise or experience in the subject area? What kind of institutions or organizations are they, or is the publication, affiliated with?
  • Documentation/back up: Can you confirm statements or claims in any other sources? Does this source refer to other sources?
  • Viewpoint/stance (‘bias’/‘objectivity’): Are opposing studies and viewpoints also considered? Is there any nuance? Is the author/creator’s standpoint or context made explicit, or ascertainable?
  • Audience/intent: What motivated the author to put this out there? Who are they likely speaking to or hoping to inform/convince?
  • Relevance: Does the source contribute to a more profound understanding of the topic?

​

Adapted from: General Guides: Evaluating & How to write a literature review

​

79 of 82

Evaluating Sources – BEYOND BASICS

  • Privilege: Is the author/creator writing from a position of privilege? Who are subject(s) of their research, and what is their relationship with the author? Who is being excluded or involuntarily included?�
  • Neutral/normal/status quo: is the source upholding normative assumptions and relying on ‘common sense’?�
  • Viewpoint/stance (‘bias’/‘objectivity’): What is your position and viewpoint in relation to this source? Is it challenging any of your biases and assumptions?�
  • Citation vs. extraction: Why are you using/including/citing this source? Are you doing the source justice?

​

Adapted from: ACT UP – Evaluation method & Citation Practices

​

80 of 82

readings about monogamy bit.ly/4bBaDEq

81 of 82

IN-CLASS EXERCISE:

EVALUATE those readings: bit.ly/4bBaDEq�

  1. Identify: 1) at least one source that IS scholarly and 2) at least one source that is NOT scholarly�
  2. For at least one source that is NOT scholarly:

81

82 of 82

IN-CLASS EXERCISE: ANSWERS

EVALUATE those readings: bit.ly/4bBaDEq�

  • scholarly sources from the list:

�

  • non-scholarly sources from the list:

​

​

  • non-scholarly sources that you would still use and why:

82