Jennifer Colby
Librarian
Huron High School
Ann Arbor Public Schools
Melissa Gordon
CTE Teacher
Huron High School
Ann Arbor Public Schools
ABOUT US
Melissa Gordon is Career and Technical Education (CTE) teacher at Huron High School. She specializes in teaching accounting, personal finance, and business management. Recognized as a Distinguished Educator by NextGen Personal Finance, she was introduced to ChatGPT by her students when it first launched. Last school year, she co-lead the Ann Arbor Public Schools AI Study Group with Jennifer Colby to explore the ethical, pedagogical, and creative dimensions of using AI technology in school. She has completed the Artificial Intelligence Explorations for Educators course by the International Society for Technology in Education (ISTE) and holds certifications as an educator for Diffit, Magic School, and her favorite tool, SchoolAI.
Jennifer Colby is a Teacher Librarian at Huron High School. Starting her career immediately before the school's IB consideration phase in 2014, she is responsible for creating, implementing, and improving library services support for the MYP Personal Project, DP Extended Essay, CP Reflective Essay, and other IB course work in collaboration with teachers and IB coordinators. Last year she co-lead the Ann Arbor Public Schools AI Study Group with Melissa Gordon to explore the ethical, pedagogical, and creative dimensions of using AI technology in school. She attended this Summit last year and spoke with Sal Khan. FUN FACT! Melissa went to the same elementary school that Jennifer’s dad taught 5th grade at… but did not have him for a teacher.
LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD. | MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG
What is ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE?
Technology programmed to mimic human intelligence. AI allows machines to learn, adapt, and perform tasks like humans.
REACTIVE
Tools that respond to specific “inputs” without learning from past experiences.
PREDICTIVE
Tools that analyze historical data and experiences to predict future events or behaviors.
GENERATIVE
Tools that generate new content or “outputs” from learned patterns.
Slide content: thomasc@aaps.k12.mi.us
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG/AISUMMIT
Agenda
Ethical Considerations of Using GenAI
Student Dependency
Intellectual Property and Plagiarism
Impact on Teaching
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG/AISUMMIT
Ethical Considerations
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG/AISUMMIT
Ethical Considerations: Key Components
Bias and Fairness: AI can perpetuate bias, reinforce stereotypes, and/or exclude certain groups.
Privacy and Data Security: Many AI tools collect and analyze personal data. Consider: FERPA, COPPA, HECVAT
Equity and Access: Not all students have access to AI technologies.
Environmental Impact: Data servers consume HUGE amounts of energy.
Student Dependency: Using GenAI as the ‘go-to’ is very tempting.
Intellectual Property and Plagiarism: GenAI raises questions about originality and ownership.
Impact on Teaching: GenAI changes teacher roles and interactions w/students.
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Student Dependency
Using GenAI as the ‘go-to’ is very tempting/pervasive.
We must encourage the thoughtful use of GenAI as a supplement, not a replacement, to foster critical thinking and problem-solving skills.
Students, teachers, AND districts need guidance in place.
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG/AISUMMIT
Educational Paradigm Shift
Think about when wide access to calculators came to be, and how that compares to GenAI use in education.
�
AI as a Resource Tool
Like calculators, AI should be viewed as a helpful tool, not a replacement for learning.
Support, Privacy & Safety
Focus on teaching others to use AI appropriately and safely.
Shift from Product to PROCESS
Emphasize the learning process over just the final product.
Clear Use Guidelines
Empower educators while enhancing learning and protecting rights and well-being.
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
GenAI Guidance
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Key Principles
“There are no hard rules when dealing with AI. Educators should use their discretion with each student. If in doubt, refer to the following key principles:
Scenario | Outcome | |
1. | A student uses AI for a summary of key points for their essay and suggests references to cite. | Acceptable. |
2. | A student uses AI for a summary of counter-positions or alternative viewpoints on a question or issue and explores these further. | Acceptable. |
3. | A student uses AI to find quotes on the essay topic and simply copies them without investigating further. | NOT acceptable. |
4. | A student instructs AI to develop a research question grounded in an IB subject for investigation, with or without elaboration on a topic area. | NOT acceptable. |
5. | A student uses AI to write an essay for them and paraphrases it into their own words. | Depends on context – but generally NOT acceptable. |
6. | A student uses AI to generate a paragraph or two for the essay, such as the introduction or summary of an argument, and then uses this as a model for their own content. | Depends on context – but generally acceptable. |
Scenario | Outcome | |
7. | A student writes an essay, then copies it into AI and asks the tool to rewrite it for them. | Generally NOT acceptable – but nuanced. |
8. | A student writes the essay in one language and then uses AI to translate it into another language for submission. | NOT acceptable. |
9. | A student uses AI to suggest improvements for grammar and sentence construction but not a wholescale rewrite. | NOT acceptable for IB assessment. Probably acceptable in other contexts. |
10. | A student uses AI to “mark” their work and provide feedback for improvement. | NOT acceptable for IB assessment. Probably acceptable in other contexts. |
11. | A student asks AI to “re"ect” on a topic, process or question and uses this unchanged in their assessment. | NOT acceptable. |
12. | A student tries to hide their use of AI. Not acceptable, even if their use of AI was correct | NOT acceptable, even if their use of AI was correct. |
13. | A student uses AI to generate a template for the structure of their essay. | Depends on context – but generally acceptable. |
Preventing/detecting GenAI Use
Teacher-based approaches:
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Student-based approaches:
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
We know our students…
New tools to prevent/detect generative AI are being created every day…
as are new ways to subvert those tools.
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG/AISUMMIT
So we need District-wide guidance in place
AAPS AI & Data Security DRAFT Recommendations
PURPOSE
Ensure the use of emerging AI tools that are aligned with the AAPS Equitable Framework to protect student privacy and data.
DRAFT ONE-PAGER
Ensuring student data privacy and legal compliance is crucial when using AI in education. Addressing these concerns in advance can foster a safe environment for students and future AI integration.
CLICK ME!
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
AAPS AI Bill of Rights DRAFT
PURPOSE
Ensure that all students and educators benefit from the ethical and equitable use of artificial intelligence technologies in a teaching and learning setting.
DRAFT ONE-PAGER
Aims to protect individuals’ privacy, promote transparency and prevent algorithmic discrimination or bias in AI applications, fostering an inclusive learning environment.
CLICK ME!
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Intellectual Property and Plagiarism
Teachers must educate students about the importance of:
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG/AISUMMIT
GenAI Citation Guidance
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
MLA 9 Citation Guidelines
“Author: Do not treat the AI tool as the author. Instead, describe the output in the title.
Title of Source: Describe what the AI generated, some tools name the conversation. If this is not available, include the original prompt.
Title of Container: Name the AI tool (e.g., ChatGPT).
Version: Specify the version of the AI tool, including the version date if available.
Publisher: Name the company that created the tool.
Date: Provide the date the content was generated.
Location: Use a general URL for the tool. If a unique URL is available, include that instead.” (MLA)
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Citation for content on previous slide
"MLA 9 Citations for Generative AI." SchoolAI, 9 Oct. 2024,
https://app.schoolai.com/sc/cm220jm8d00z7srpksd3pe85a.
WHAT ABOUT INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY?
Original source citation for Works Cited:
“How Do I Cite Generative AI in MLA Style?” MLA Style Center, 17 Mar. 2023, https://style.mla.org/citing-generative-ai/.
TITLE OF SOURCE
TOOL
DATE
LOCATION (UNIQUE URL FOR CONVERSATION)
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
A note about using published texts…
“When considering the ethical concerns of sharing published texts with platforms like SchoolAI for text leveling and translation, here are some key points to consider:
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
MLA 9 Citation Examples for different GenAI uses
“Paraphrasing Text- Paraphrased content about the symbolism of the green light in The Great Gatsby.
"Describe the symbolism of the green light in the book The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald" prompt. ChatGPT, 13 Feb. version, OpenAI, 8 Mar. 2023, chat.openai.com/chat.
Quoting Text- Quoted material from an AI response about a literary theme.
"In 200 words, describe the symbolism of the green light in The Great Gatsby" follow-up prompt to list sources. ChatGPT, 13 Feb. version, OpenAI, 9 Mar. 2023, chat.openai.com/chat.
Generated Visual Work- An AI-generated image of a pointillist painting.
"Pointillist painting of a sheep in a sunny field of blue flowers" prompt, DALL-E, version 2, OpenAI, 8 Mar. 2023, labs.openai.com/.
Generated Textual Work- A poem titled "The Sunflower" generated by AI.
"The Sunflower" villanelle about a sunflower. ChatGPT, 13 Feb. version, OpenAI, 8 Mar. 2023, chat.openai.com/chat.
Citing Secondary Sources- Information about the political unconscious from a secondary source via AI.
Oxford Reference. "Political Unconscious." Accessed through Bing AI. Oxford University Press, 2023.” (MLA 9)
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Impact on Teaching
GenAI changes teacher roles and student interactions.
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG/AISUMMIT
PAUSE!
Are you signed up/logged
into SchoolAI?
SchoolAI--Hold on to your seat!
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
SchoolAI
Learn SchoolAI in Under 15 minutes (watch later)
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
For teachers:
For students:
Why Use SchoolAI?
LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Tools (for teachers): | Assistants (for teachers): | Spaces…for students! |
|
|
|
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
SchoolAI TOOLS… each in 60-ish seconds
They aren’t automatically created FOR you, YOU are still responsible for the input!
SchoolAI IB Tool Resource
SchoolAI TOOLS Choice Board Activity
Engage in Task | Self-Reflection | Share Out |
|
|
|
Turn and talk.
SchoolAI Tools.
SchoolAI ASSISTANTS… each in 60-ish seconds
Your own personal assistant!
SchoolAI ASSISTANTS Choice Board Activity
Engage in Task | Self-Reflection | Share Out |
|
|
|
Melissa’s personal favorite: Ask Coteacher or Curriculum Coach to tell me what the misconceptions are going to be about my lesson and to give me solutions ahead of time :)
Turn and talk.
SchoolAI Assistants.
What is a Space? Link to a Space Designer
“SchoolAI Spaces are AI-powered learning experiences that teachers design for students within the parameters of the content or learning experience they would like their class to have.
The best place to begin with Spaces is on the Discover page, which can be found by selecting the Spaces drop-down menu at the top of the page.
This page hosts over 10,000 pre-created spaces ready to launch and learn. SchoolAI created these Spaces with the prompt language already added so that any user, despite skill level, can use a Space with minimal effort, allowing teachers and students to get started immediately.
The Discover page functions as a comprehensive library catalog of Spaces, meticulously organized into various collections to streamline the search process. It enables users to effortlessly find and utilize the resources best suited to their needs.“ (Level)
SchoolAI Spaces for Everyday Use
School Space Prompt Library
What do you want to create?
Need help getting started?
SchoolAI Space Prompt Library: �Stuck on how to design your Learning Experience?
SchoolAI IB Resource: International Baccalaureate Schools Space Inspiration Station
Media to Engage With
ListServs to sign up for:
People to follow:
Books to read:
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Jennifer Colby
colby@aaps.k12.mi.us
Melissa Gordon
gordonm@aaps.k12.mi.us
WORKS CITED
Brodkin, Jon. “School Did Nothing Wrong When It Punished Student for Using AI, Court Rules.” Ars Technica, 21 Nov. 2024,
“Ethical Concerns in Sharing Published Texts”. SchoolAI Coteacher chat. 21 Oct 2024,
https://app.schoolai.com/sc/cm2j1c1wc0ameybdddfv72xj5.
“How Do I Cite Generative AI in MLA Style?” MLA Style Center, 17 Mar. 2023, https://style.mla.org/citing-generative-ai/.
International Baccalaureate Organization. Evaluating 13 scenarios of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in student coursework. 2024,
Evaluating 13 Scenarios of Artificial Intelligence_long.pdf. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1i9M3TKd3qi-9sY
McKendrick, Joe. “Who Ultimately Owns Content Generated By ChatGPT And Other AI Platforms?”. Forbes. 22 Feb 2023,
“Level 1 Certified Educator.” SchoolAI, 21 Oct. 2024,
community.schoolai.com/c/level-1-certified-educator/sections/220670/lessons/846505.
“MLA 9 Citations for Generative AI”. https://style.mla.org/citing-generative-ai/?utm_campaign=sourcemar23&utm_
medium=email&utm_source=mlaoutreach.
"MLA 9 Citations for Generative AI." SchoolAI, 9 Oct. 2024, app.schoolai.com.
https://app.schoolai.com/sc/cm220jm8d00z7srpksd3pe85a.
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Extras if Internet Doesn’t Work…
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Extras if Internet Doesn’t Work…
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.
Extras if Internet Doesn’t Work…
MICHIGANVIRTUAL.ORG | LEAD. COLLABORATE. BUILD.