1 of 217

VTPBIS Refresher Training

Lauralee Keach

Laura Ellis

BEST 2021

2 of 217

Zoom 101

Turn your microphone and webcam on and off

(Please stay muted when presenter is speaking)

Post your questions in the chat and keep an eye out for posted links or files.

Use the “Reactions” to raise your hand, give a thumbs up, and other interactive reactions.

You can raise your hand if you have a questions or post your question in the chat.

Open the Participants panel to see who’s here and update your name:

* Hover over your name in the list and click “More”

* Then click “rename” to change your display name

3 of 217

Zoom Breakout Rooms: Join Your Room

For group-specific breakouts

Click on “Breakout Rooms” on the toolbar

Find your room and click “Join”

4 of 217

“The fundamental purpose of PBIS is to make schools more effective and equitable learning environments.”

Rob Horner, OSEP Technical Assistance Center for PBIS

5 of 217

Coming Together

Please share in the chat box . . .

Something you are grateful for today.

6 of 217

Day 1 Agenda

  • Coming together
  • Training and materials overview
  • PBIS foundations
  • Teaming
  • Closing

7 of 217

Learning Vision

Together, you will have:

  • Become fluent in PBIS systems, data, equity & practices
  • Used a shared framework
  • Considered how to meaningfully involve students, families, and staff in planning and implementation
  • Developed action plans for next steps to implementation
  • AND had fun while doing it.

8 of 217

Participant Schools Level of Implementation

9 of 217

Highest Priorities for Training + Support

(from pre-training survey)

  • Evaluate current systems and determine areas for development and revision
  • Increase implementation fidelity of Universal and Targeted systems already in place
  • Improve staff and administration buy in
  • Create a plan to include clear systems and procedures to roll out to staff at start of the year and to train newly hired staff
  • Consider teacher- and classroom-specific supports
  • Use data, including fidelity assessments, for decision making and action planning
  • Dissemination of data

10 of 217

Objectives:

By the end of this training, you will have…

  • clarified what PBIS is and is not.
  • edited or created team structure, norms, roles, and routines.
  • developed an implementation action plan.
  • finalized a draft collective statement of purpose.
  • reflected on/begun development of a process to ensure equity in all aspects of PBIS implementation.
  • edited or created procedures for teaching and encouraging expected behaviors, addressing concerning behaviors through a continuum of supports, and record keeping and decision making
  • determined format/s and content for staff professional development on PBIS foundations and implementation specifics
  • considered coaching needs, roll-out planning, and other next steps.

11 of 217

Personal Reflection

Who are you here for?

12 of 217

Community Agreements: How we will be together

Behavioral Norms

  • Take care of yourself
  • Be fully engaged & take risks
  • Be mindful of other learners
  • Be fully present

What do I need from the group?

What do others need from me?

Procedural Norms

  • Start & finish on time
  • Planning & work time included
  • Support available during break-outs
  • Exit tickets will help guide next day’s work

What systems do we need in place to help the training be effective?

What will make this learning environment equitable and effective for everyone?

13 of 217

Tools

*Click link, “Make a Copy,” name, and share with team

14 of 217

PBIS Foundations

15 of 217

PBIS: Positive Behavioral Interventions & Supports

  • Preventive, culturally responsive framework
  • Tailored to school’s unique culture
  • Integrated continuum
  • Evidence-based practices
  • Based on principles of ABA
  • Improved academic and behavior outcomes

16 of 217

Correcting Misconceptions About PBIS

  • NOT a packaged curriculum
  • NOT a scripted intervention
  • NOT a manualized strategy
  • NOT a reward system

It’s an evidence-based framework, tailored to our school community, that provides a continuum of supports and, when implemented with fidelity, leads to positive and equitable academic and behavioral outcomes.

17 of 217

18 of 217

The PBIS Framework

SYSTEMS

PRACTICES

DATA

Supporting

Staff Behavior

Supporting

Decision

Making

Supporting

Student Behavior

EQUITY

  • Evidence-based
  • Smallest effort
  • Biggest, durable effect

Social competence & Academic achievement

19 of 217

Educational Equity . . .

exists when educational policies, practices, interactions, and resources are representative of, constructed by, and responsive to all people so that

EACH INDIVIDUAL has access to, meaningfully participates in, AND has positive outcomes from high-quality learning experiences, regardless of individual characteristics and group memberships.

(Fraser, 2008; Great Lakes Equity Center, 2012)

means that EVERY CHILD receives whatever she/he/they need to develop to her/his/their full academic and social potential and to thrive academically and social-emotionally. Every child, every day. Period.

(Aguilar, 2020)

20 of 217

PBIS is not fully implemented until it is culturally responsive.

Situational Appropriateness

Voice

Supportive Environment

Data for

Equity

Identity

Cultural Responsiveness

21 of 217

Foundational Elements of Equity in PBIS

  1. Collect, use, and report disaggregated discipline data
  2. Implement a behavior framework that is preventive, multi-tiered, and culturally responsive
  3. Use engaging instruction to reduce the opportunity (achievement) gap
  4. Develop policies with accountability for disciplinary equity
  5. Teach strategies for neutralizing implicit bias in discipline decisions

22 of 217

(Payno-Simmons, 2021)

23 of 217

Equity is a Tier 1 issue. Inequitable outcomes MUST be addressed at Tier 1, Providing Tier 2 & 3 supports does not address inequities!

24 of 217

25 of 217

Continuum of Support for “Dylan”

Universal

Targeted

Intensive

Math

Reading

Adult relationships

Regulation

Attendance

Peer Interaction

Science

26 of 217

Share: Current Practices Within a Continuum

What is already in place for academic and behavioral support?

  • Tier 1: Universal practices provided to all students; intended to sufficiently support most students
  • Tier 2: Strategic/Targeted practices provided to some students for support
  • Tier 3: Individualize/Intensive practices provided to a few students for support

27 of 217

Label Supports, not Students!

Essential Agreement:

We will consistently correct language to ensure equity and personhood, even if doing so causes some discomfort.

“Targeted Kid/s”

“S/he’s Intensive”

“Student/kid who is receiving or needs targeted supports”

“S/he is receiving or needs intensive supports”

28 of 217

SEL, Trauma-Informed, & Restorative Practices Within the PBIS Framework

  • Same end goals in mind
    • To build a safe, respectful, and productive learning environment
    • To establish a positive school climate where students and adults have strong, positive relationships and students understand what is expected of them as learners at school
  • Whole-school
  • Positive, strengths-based
  • Proactive/prevention-focused
  • Contribute to and depend on an equitable learning environment

29 of 217

SYSTEMS

PRACTICES

DATA

Supporting

Staff Behavior

Supporting

Decision

Making

Supporting

Student Behavior

EQUITY

  • Evidence-based
  • Smallest effort
  • Biggest, durable effect

30 of 217

Core Features of PBIS Implementation

  1. Statement of purpose
  2. 3-5 behavioral expectations
  3. Procedures for teaching expected behaviors
  4. Procedures for acknowledging positive behaviors
  5. Procedures for addressing behavior concerns through a continuum of supports
  6. Procedures for record-keeping and decision-making

PBIS is not fully implemented until it is culturally responsive.

31 of 217

PBIS Research: Highest Level of Evidence

When implemented with fidelity, PBIS shows these outcomes:

  • Decrease in concerning behavior
  • Improved school climate
  • Improved consistency
  • Improved organizational health
  • Decrease in bullying
  • Increase in academic achievement

32 of 217

Fidelity of Implementation

  • Fidelity = the degree to which an intervention is delivered as intended
  • The closer you are to meeting the benchmark for the fidelity measure, the better your odds for improving student outcomes
  • Implementation depends on fidelity AND how well you fit the intervention to your context

Fidelity Assessments ➞ Action Planning

  • Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI)
    • TFI-Cultural Responsiveness Companion (TFI-CR)
  • Self-Assessment Survey (SAS)
  • School Climate Survey

33 of 217

Message to Staff

All (insert school name) staff are responsible for implementing PBIS with fidelity: implementing in the intended way.

If you need more information or assistance with understanding and implementing our PBIS components, procedures, and/or practices, please ask for help from the PBIS team.

34 of 217

Team Time Activity 1

Your

Compelling Why

Discuss:

  • What are the behavioral needs at our school?
  • What does our data show?
  • What burning concerns do staff, students, and families have?
  • What does the research say?
  • What are the consequences of maintaining status quo?

Tool:

  • Universal Training Action Plan & Activities

35 of 217

Teaming

36 of 217

Breakout Room Activity #1

Consider other teams you have been part of. �What has made them work well?

Who is represented on your teams and whose voice is missing?

Students reflecting on schoolwide data at Rick Marcotte School PBIS team meeting

37 of 217

PBIS Universal Team Membership

  • Coordinator(s)
  • School administrator(s)
  • School staff representatives
  • Family/community member(s)
  • Student(s)
  • Individuals able to provide:
    • Applied behavioral expertise
    • Coaching expertise
    • Knowledge of student academic and behavior patterns
    • Knowledge about the operations of the school across grade levels and programs

Whose voices are missing?

How can we support meaningful participation, especially by students/families from communities which have been marginalized?

38 of 217

Tier 2/3 Consideration: Team Functions

Targeted Systems Planning Team:

    • Monitors effectiveness of CICO and other targeted intervention
    • Reviews data to make decisions on improvements to the interventions themselves
    • Students are NOT discussed

Problem Solving Team:

    • Develops & monitors plans for one student at a time
    • Every school has this type of meeting (e.g., EST)
    • Teachers and families are typically involved

39 of 217

Developing Team Roles

Sample Role

Sample Definition

Facilitator

Maintains the flow of the meeting, introduces agenda items, decides if items need additional meeting time

Note taker/Recorder

Sets up meeting minutes prior to the meeting, assigns time limits, records the meeting minutes and parking lot items

Data Analyst

Prepares and brings data to the meeting, reports out trends

Time keeper

Maintains the time, provides 2 minute warning, indicates when time is up

Wellness Wielder (optional)

Facilitates connections and reflections

40 of 217

PBIS Team Member Responsibilities

During meetings

  • Share team roles and tasks
  • Attend regularly scheduled team meetings (at least monthly)
  • Actively engage and participate in meetings
  • Encourage and support shared voice

Outside of meetings

  • Complete team action steps
  • Advocate and act as PBIS cheerleader!
  • Promote PBIS implementation plans to representative group in school
  • Model and provide implementation support to staff

41 of 217

Develop Team Agreements/Norms

  • Agreements/Norms:
    • Make collaboration more effective by guiding team behavior
    • Enable team members to hold each other accountable
    • Promotes efficiency

  • How often will your team revisit these norms?

How will we ensure that our team norms promote equity by inviting voice and ensuring a supportive environment?

42 of 217

What should team meetings look like?

  • At least monthly (many schools schedule more frequently)
    • How can you make this a guarantee?
  • Regular meeting format/agenda/minutes
  • Defined roles
  • Current action plan
  • Data-driven

Allen Brook School PBIS Leadership Team

meeting with 2nd graders

43 of 217

Working Smarter, Not Harder

Consider eliminating all initiatives that:

  • do NOT have a defined purpose and outcome measure
  • are not tied to School Improvement Plan

Consider combining initiatives that:

  • have the same outcome measure and same target group
  • have 75% of the same staff

44 of 217

Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI) - TEAMS

1.1 Team Composition:

Tier I team includes: a Tier I systems coordinator, a school administrator, a family member, and individuals able to provide (a) applied behavioral expertise, (b) coaching expertise, (c) knowledge of student academic and behavior patterns, (d) knowledge about the operations of the school across grade levels and programs, and for high schools, (e) student representation.

TFI-CR (Voice):

Team actively elicits ownership, voice, and broad representation of families and communities, especially underserved families and cultures.

1.2 Team Operating Procedures

Tier I team meets at least monthly and has (a) regular meeting format/agenda, (b) minutes, (c) defined meeting roles, and (d) a current action plan.

TFI-CR (Supportive Environment):

During data analysis, team members examine the system and policies for potential changes, rather than placing the responsibility for change on families and students.

45 of 217

Team Time Activity 2

Teaming Tasks

Review and edit in Handbook:

  • Team Membership, Roles, and Responsibilities (including who will provide back-up)
  • Team Agreements/Norms
  • Meeting Procedures, Agenda, Minutes, Action Plan
  • Working Smarter, Not Harder

Tools:

  • School Handbook
  • Refresher Training Action Plan & Activities
  • Slides

46 of 217

Day 1 Closing

  • What questions do you have?
  • Individual Share: I’m feeling . . .
  • Exit ticket
  • For Coming Together tomorrow, representative from each school report out:
    • How things are going, what you have accomplished, any “aha” moments

You’ve got this!!!!!

47 of 217

Day 2 Agenda

  • Coming Together
  • Core Features of PBIS:

1. Statement of Purpose

2. Behavior expectations

3. Teaching behavior expectations

  • Closing

48 of 217

Coming Together

Please share in the chat box . . .

I am going to take care of myself during this training day by ___________.

49 of 217

Coming Together

Representative from each school . . .

Please share something about your team process so far:

  • How things are going
  • What you have accomplished so far
  • Any “aha” moments

Day 1 Exit Ticket feedback & response

50 of 217

Community Agreements: How we will be together

Behavioral Norms

  • Take care of yourself
  • Be fully engaged & take risks
  • Be mindful of other learners
  • Be fully present

What do I need from the group?

What do others need from me?

Procedural Norms

  • Start & finish on time
  • Planning & work time included
  • Support available during break-outs
  • Exit tickets will help guide next day’s work

What systems do we need in place to help the training be effective?

What will make this learning environment equitable and effective for everyone?

51 of 217

Core Features

52 of 217

Core Features of PBIS Implementation

  1. Statement of Purpose
  2. 3-5 behavioral expectations
  3. Procedures for teaching expected behaviors
  4. Procedures for acknowledging positive behaviors
  5. Procedures for addressing behavior concerns through a continuum of supports
  6. Procedures for record-keeping and decision-making

53 of 217

Example Purpose Statements

The mission of the____’s PBIS team is to foster and promote a safe, equitable, and positive school environment that enhances student learning through teaching and recognizing positive behavior.

To enhance the capacity of our school to provide the best behavioral supports for students that maximize academic and social achievement. The purpose of our school-wide PBIS team is to establish a climate in which positive behavior and equitable outcomes are the norm.

54 of 217

Tier 2/3 Consideration:

Targeted Team: Example Purpose Statement

To effectively and efficiently match children who have not responded to universal interventions with targeted strategies more likely to produce successful outcomes.

55 of 217

Statement of Purpose

What will your school LOOK like and SOUND like when a positive, proactive, and instructional approach to discipline is fully implemented?

  • Positively-stated
  • 2-3 sentences
  • Includes behavioral and academic outcomes
  • Contextually/culturally appropriate (e.g. age, level, in all home languages)
  • Communicated to all stakeholders
  • Included in all publications

Please share in the chat: What is one way that your statement of purpose can be revised to incorporate equity and change?

56 of 217

Team Time Activity 3

Statement of Purpose

Consider:

  • What are the intended OUTCOMES for your school?
  • How does your “compelling why” inform your statement of purpose?
  • What revisions do you want to make to your current statement of purpose?
  • How are you informing staff, students and community stakeholders of your purpose of implementation?

Tools:

  • Handbook
  • Universal Training Action Plan and Activities
  • Slides

57 of 217

Core Features of PBIS Implementation

  1. Statement of Purpose
  2. 3-5 behavioral expectations
  3. Procedures for teaching expected behaviors
  4. Procedures for acknowledging positive behaviors
  5. Procedures for addressing behavior concerns through a continuum of supports
  6. Procedures for record-keeping and decision-making

58 of 217

School-Wide Expectations

  • 3-5 expectations (less is more!)
  • Clearly-defined
  • Positively-stated
  • Focus on teaching social/emotional/ behavioral competencies
  • Respectful of students’ cultures
  • Determined through meaningful participation of students, families, and staff
  • For engagement, not compliance
  • Have a legitimate purpose, not just school tradition or status quo

59 of 217

Why Set Clear School Wide Expectations?

Students

  • know and understand what’s expected of them throughout entire school day - increases confidence, safety, security
  • monitor themselves and take more responsibility for own behavior and learning
  • spend more time on task - academic learning time increases

Teachers

  • more easily recognize and motivate positive behaviors

Climate

  • Classroom & school cultures become more positive overall
  • Decreased classroom stress for students and teachers

60 of 217

10 Questions for Ensuring Equity Activity

  1. What is the expectation? (state explicitly)
  2. Why is this the expectation? (promoting what? Safety? Order? Learning?)
  3. Who decided that this expectation was necessary? (has it always been an expectation?)
  4. What do YOU believe about this expectation? (fair, right, just, oppressive, necessary, not necessary?)
  5. Whose values are reflected and reinforced by this expectation?
  6. Whose values are erased by this expectation?
  7. Who would have difficulty meeting this expectation?
  8. What would happen if this expectation did not exist? (implications, good and bad)
  9. How can this expectation be revised to accommodate all cultures/sets of values, OR
  10. Should this expectation be removed because it causes cultural or racial erasure and provides real threat to student safety or learning and provides no tangible benefit to students?

10 Questions for Ensuring Equity in School Discipline, School Leadership for Social Justice

61 of 217

Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI) - IMPLEMENTATION

1.3 Behavioral Expectations

School has five or fewer positively stated behavioral expectations and examples by setting/location for student and staff behaviors (i.e., school teaching matrix) defined and in place.

TFI-CR (Situational Appropriateness):

Expectations and specific rules are identified based on a legitimate purpose within the setting, as opposed to simply school tradition or maintaining the status quo. Behavior expectations focus on high standards for all students, can be taught and learned, and are respectful of students’ cultures.

62 of 217

Identifying Potential Behavior Expectations

What information do you already have?

  • Input about desired and concerning behaviors from students, families, and staff
  • Behavior data that points toward behavior skill deficits
  • Behavior that students, families, and staff complain about

How can we ensure that our behavior expectations reflect student/family voice and are culturally responsive?

What expectations could help support your statement of purpose/vision?

What expectations might leave too much room for subjectivity?

63 of 217

Differing Expectations

When expectations between home/community and school differ:

  • Examine these differences critically and determine whether to
    • change/adapt school expectations OR
    • develop a clear rationale for having different expectations at school

  • Explicitly teach:
    • the skills needed to demonstrate the expectation
    • the rationale for having a different expectation
    • Include increased opportunities for practice and feedback until students demonstrate the skill fluently

64 of 217

BIG IDEA!

Expectations should be clear, simple, and reflect the values of your whole school community.

Their purpose is NOT to enforce compliance, but to provide common language and a framework for teaching desired behavior to fluency.

65 of 217

Break Out Room Activity

  • Choose 2-3 questions (more if you have time!) from the 10 Questions to Ensure Equity list to discuss

  • What adjustments do you need to make to your expectations?

66 of 217

Ideas for Keeping Expectations Visible

    • What are your ideas?

Other ideas:

    • Post in classrooms, hallways, computer wallpaper, and/or screen saver
    • Print in the school handbook
    • Videos
    • Flags hanging in the hallway outside of classrooms
    • Staff and/or student lanyards
    • Hats, t-shirts, bracelets, bumper stickers
    • Students design murals

67 of 217

Team Time Activity 4

Identifying & Defining

Behavior Expectations

Tasks:

  • Review current expectations using the 10 Questions to Ensure Equity list and determine:
  • Are each of them clearly defined?
  • How are/will you get feedback about which of/whether these expectations match your school community & its needs?
  • Do you need to make any adjustments?
  • How do you keep them visible and alive?

Tools:

  • Universal Training Action Plan & Activities
  • Slides

68 of 217

Core Features of PBIS Implementation

  1. Statement of Purpose
  2. 3-5 behavioral expectations
  3. Procedures for teaching expected behaviors
  4. Procedures for acknowledging positive behaviors
  5. Procedures for addressing behavior concerns through a continuum of supports
  6. Procedures for record-keeping and decision-making

69 of 217

Share

Think of a situation in which you might not understand or know how to meet the behavior expectations.

    • What would you need?
    • What would help?

70 of 217

Educators Teach

“If a child does not know how to read, we teach.�If a child does not know how to swim, we teach.�If a child does not know how to multiply, we teach.�If a child does not know how to drive, we teach.�If a child does not know how to behave, we…�

…teach…punish?

Why can’t we finish the last sentence

as automatically as we do the others?”�– John Herner

71 of 217

Explicit Teaching

All students need and deserve explicit teaching about behaviors necessary to be successful at school:

  • What it looks and sounds like in all settings
  • How to do it
  • When to do it
  • Why it is important in the school setting
  • Re-teaching, prompts, & pre-corrections
  • Additional practice until behavior is fluent

Tools:

  • Matrix/matrices
  • Lesson plans

How can we ensure that any differences between home/community and school expectations are explicitly and respectfully taught, with additional opportunities for practice and feedback?

72 of 217

73 of 217

Repetition: Key to Learning New Skills

How many repetitions does it take:

requires an average of 8 repetitions!

  • to unlearn an old behavior & replace it with new one?

requires an average of 28 repetitions!

  • to learn something new?

74 of 217

Prompting and Pre-Correcting

Prompt - reminds students of expectations for familiar tasks or situations.

Pre-correction - tells students how to approach a new task or situation.

Proactive, effective, and efficient strategies

  • Remind students of behavior expectations
  • Prevent or interrupt predictable concerning behavior from occurring and increase the likelihood of expected behavior taking place
  • Anticipate concerning behavior based on the student(s) previous behavior patterns or knowledge of student behavior in general

75 of 217

Review Expectations Frequently

Before

  • You begin an activity
  • Challenging activities or settings

After

  • Weekends & vacations
  • Data review

76 of 217

Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI) - IMPLEMENTATION

1.4 Teaching Expectations

Expected academic and social behaviors are taught directly to all students in classrooms and across other campus settings/locations.

TFI-CR (Situational Appropriateness):

Team has a process and procedures for staff to teach students the behaviors necessary to be successful in the school setting regardless of previous learning and without disrespecting families’ beliefs. When expectations differ between home or community and school, staff examine these differences critically, and if determined to be necessary, explicitly teach the skill and clear rationale for the different expectation at school, and provide opportunities for practice and feedback until students demonstrate the behavior fluently.

77 of 217

Teaching Matrix

Clearly communicates expectations throughout the building

Includes:

  • Expectations
  • All settings and locations
  • Positively stated behavior examples
    • Classroom teachers and students will co-develop behavior examples for their classroom at the beginning of each year

Visuals for each setting posted throughout the building

How can we ensure that the matrix is accessible to non-readers, students/ families with other home languages, and those with vision or height differences?

78 of 217

79 of 217

80 of 217

81 of 217

82 of 217

Teaching Practices Info for Staff

83 of 217

Staff Matrix

84 of 217

What cells would you change?

 

 

 

Classroom

Lunch Room

Bus

Hallway

Assembly

Respect Others

No food in class

Eat your own food

Stay in your seat

No harassing

No violence

Arrive on time to speaker

Respect Spaces & Property

Recycle paper

Return trays

Keep feet on floor

Do not litter

Leave the auditorium as clean as you find it

Respect Yourself

Do your best

Wash your hands

Be at stop on time

Use your words

No hats

No gum

Respect Learning

Have materials ready

Eat balanced diet

Go directly from bus to class

Go directly to class

Discuss topics in class w/ others

85 of 217

How can we ensure that all visuals reflect diversity and are accessible to all?

86 of 217

Lesson Plans

Developed for:

  • Implementation roll-out (each year)
  • Behavioral focus areas
    • identified by data review (monthly)
    • identified through student/family/staff feedback

To use in these settings:

  • Schoolwide (assemblies/large group)
  • Every setting from matrix
  • Classrooms

87 of 217

Lesson Plan Example

88 of 217

Unit/Lesson Re-Design Worksheet (udlpbis.pbworks.com)Course/Lesson: Playground Instructor(s)

Key Goals/Outcomes

(Usually tied to CCSS or SW Rules)

What I Want Students to Do to Demonstrate Learning

What I Do Now

Applying UDL:�Representation of Content

Applying UDL:

Student Actions/

Expression

Applying UDL:

Student Engagement/

Motivation

Students will be safe at the playground  

 

 

 

 

 

Keep hands to themselves,

Play by the rules,

Stay where an adult can see them

Show them the poster at the playground and remind them of their rules

Provide pictures as prompts for students

Use video examples of the expectations

Role play and practice examples and non-examples

Social Narratives/

Powercards

Students use different ways to communicate they understand the expectations- create posters/videos, use voice output devices, state what the expectations look like and sound like

Meaningful reinforcement

Leadership in supporting safety at the playground-

Peer-mediated Interventions

Social Narratives

Self-management/

reinforcement

89 of 217

Determining Which Skills To Teach

Behavior =

Inappropriate Language

Tardiness

Linked SW Expectation

Respectful

Responsible

What Does This Look Like?

Use words that are appropriate to express the sentiment (e.g., considerate, polite, kind, professional, etc.)

Be in class when the bell rings

How does this expectation benefit the classroom community

(students and staff)?

Students and staff feel safe and comfortable in their environment; conflicts can be resolved

Learning isn’t disrupted; students are all able to participate in full lesson

Social and Emotional Skills to Teach

  • Stop-think-act
  • Deep breaths
  • Managing disappointment
  • Making a complaint
  • Reframing negative thoughts

  • Managing transition time
  • Planning ahead
  • Self monitoring
  • Using conversation enders (e.g., ‘catch you later’)

In partnership with NJDOE OSE funded by IDEA funds - Part B 2018-2019

Adapted from:

90 of 217

Teaching Expectations (Elementary)

91 of 217

Teaching Expectations (Middle)

92 of 217

Teaching Expectations by Setting (PreK)

93 of 217

Teaching Expectations by Setting (Elementary)

94 of 217

Teaching Expectations by Setting (High School)

95 of 217

BIG IDEA!

Behavior should be taught just as explicitly as academics. Opportunities to practice should be provided until behavior is fluent.

96 of 217

Team Time Activity 5

Teaching Expected Behavior

Tasks:

  • Develop outline for PD on explicit teaching of behavior expectations
  • Format teaching matrix with all settings
  • Develop lesson plan format/s for schoolwide, all-setting, & classroom lessons
  • Discuss ways to make lessons engaging and learning-centered (How will you get student input on this?)

Tools:

  • Handbook
  • Universal Training Action Plan & Activities
  • Slides
  • Dothan Brook Teaching Matrix

97 of 217

Team Time Activity 5 Considerations:

Discuss and record:

  • How can you engage students in learning the expectations?

  • How can you shift lessons to be more learning-centered vs. teaching-centered?

  • What teaching and learning formats can you use?

98 of 217

Day 2 Closing

  • What questions do you have?
  • Individual Share: I’m feeling . . .
  • Exit ticket
  • For Coming Together tomorrow, representative from each school report out:
    • How things are going, what you have accomplished, any “aha” moments

99 of 217

Day 3 Agenda

  • Coming together
  • Core Features of PBIS
    • 4. Encouraging & Acknowledging Positive Behaviors
    • 5. Data: Record-Keeping & Decision-Making

100 of 217

Coming Together

Please share in the chat box . . .

Where have you found peace during this crazy year?

101 of 217

Coming Together

Representative from each school . . .

Please share something about your team process so far:

  • How things are going
  • What you have accomplished so far
  • Any “aha” moments

Day 2 Exit Ticket feedback & response

102 of 217

Community Agreements: How we will be together

Behavioral Norms

  • Take care of yourself
  • Be fully engaged & take risks
  • Be mindful of other learners
  • Be fully present

What do I need from the group?

What do others need from me?

Procedural Norms

  • Start & finish on time
  • Planning & work time included
  • Support available during break-outs
  • Exit tickets will help guide next day’s work

What systems do we need in place to help the training be effective?

What will make this learning environment equitable and effective for everyone?

103 of 217

Core Features of PBIS Implementation

  • Statement of Purpose
  • 3-5 behavioral expectations
  • Procedures for teaching expected behaviors
  • Procedures for acknowledging positive behaviors
  • Procedures for record-keeping and decision-making
  • Procedures for addressing behavior concerns through a continuum of supports

104 of 217

Seeing the Positive

Think of a specific time when someone authentically acknowledged a strength in you.

Share in the chat box (in a few words), the impact that this had.

105 of 217

Encourage Expected Behaviors

  • Teach and reteach the expected behaviors
  • Provide opportunities to practice
  • Provide authentic positive feedback/behavior-specific praise
    • Behavior is learned
    • Learning is facilitated by guided feedback
    • Positive feedback has a greater likelihood of shaping behavior than negative feedback

106 of 217

“Big Ideas” on Reinforcing Positive Behaviors

  • Change adult behavior to change student behavior
  • Effective schools are consistent, predictable, and positive places
  • Higher rate of positive feedback than constructive feedback
    • (4:1 ratio – How can you measure this?)
  • Staff and families need reinforcement too

Acknowledging positive behavior

  • shifts adult’s attention to focus on the positive
  • reduces the amount of time spent on correcting student behavior

107 of 217

Elements of Effective Feedback

  • Immediate
    • As soon as student displays expected behavior
  • Sincere
    • Ensure that your feedback is genuine
  • Specific
    • Name the behavior you want to see continued
  • Contingent
    • Based on direct observation

108 of 217

Positive Reinforcement =

Consequence that will increase likelihood of a desired behavior; more effective than negative

Behavior-Specific Praise:

“Nakyah, it was so kind of you to notice Arun was feeling left out and ask him to join you!

Acknowledgement:

“Tyson, I notice you’re using a Level 1 voice in the hallway.

Thank you!”

Descriptive Feedback

Praise:

“Great job!”

Adult indicates student exceeded expectations

Adult notices & appreciates student displaying the expected behavior

Doesn’t hurt, but doesn’t help student know what was “great”

109 of 217

Behavior-Specific Praise (BSP)

  1. Description of desired behavior (social or academic)
  2. Specific to the student or class
  3. A positive praise statement

110 of 217

Research on Behavior-Specific Praise

Increases:

  • Expected behaviors
  • Instructional time
  • On task behavior
  • Correct academic responses
  • Student confidence
  • Positive classroom climate

Decreases

  • Teacher time spent correcting inappropriate behaviors

111 of 217

Acknowledging Positive Behavior in Action

112 of 217

4:1 Is Not Just for Kids!

Business Teams:

  • High Performance = 5.6 : 1
  • Medium Performance = 1.9 : 1
  • Low Performance = 1 : 2.7

(Losada, 1999; Losada & Heaphy, 2004)

Successful Marriages:

  • 5.1 : 1
  • 4.7 : 1
  • 1 : 1.3 (94% predictive of divorce)

(Gottoman, 1994)

113 of 217

4:1 Specific Positive Feedback

end video at 5:59

114 of 217

Share

How do you think it affects students when adults notice and

point out when they’re being successful?

115 of 217

Continuum of Positive Reinforcement/Feedback

Tangible

Social

External

Internal

Frequent

Infrequent

Predictable

Unpredictable

116 of 217

Using Tangible Markers Effectively

  • Recognize & celebrate achievements immediately
    • Don’t bribe!
  • Let the tangible marker be your reminder to acknowledge the behavior
    • Don’t make it all about the “thing”
  • Explicitly state the behavior you are acknowledging
    • Don’t make them guess what they did
  • Once they are given, they cannot be taken away
    • Don’t negate the previous positive behavior
  • Focus on group/social rewards
    • Don’t use loss of group rewards as a punishment
  • Tangible markers should be just one of the several acknowledgement methods used

117 of 217

Acknowledgement Procedure Example

  1. When staff observe a students engaging in school-wide expected behaviors, they give her/him/them specific verbal feedback, along with a ticket.

  • Students place their tickets in a classroom or school-wide ticket container.

  • When the container is filled (or other agreed upon benchmark), the class earns a class-wide celebration (extra recess, game day, pajama day, etc.)

  • Classroom tickets are added to the school-wide container, earning toward a monthly school-wide celebration (fort-building time, school-wide rock-paper-scissors, STOP/DROP/PLAY, Book Character day, twin day, etc.)

118 of 217

Responding to Worries About ”Rewards”

  • “The undermining effect of extrinsic reward on intrinsic motivation remains unproven.” (Reiss, 2005)

  • “It is not tangible rewards, per se, that undermine motivation; instead, undermining of motivation depends on instructions and the statement of contingency.” (Cameron, 2001)
  • �“…our research team has conducted a series of reviews and analysis of (the reward) literature; our conclusion is that there is no inherent negative property of reward. Our analyses indicate that the argument against the use of rewards is an overgeneralization based on a narrow set of circumstances.” (Cameron, 2002), (Cameron & Pierce, 1994, 2002), (Cameron, Banko, & Pierce, 2001)

119 of 217

Teaching Expectations & Procedures (Middle)

Why do you think the student who created this video focused on how to earn a ticket as well as on how to demonstrate expected behaviors? .

120 of 217

Acknowledgement System Procedure

What will acknowledging expected behavior sound like?

What will acknowledging expected behavior look like?

How will staff keep track of the 4:1 feedback?

Tangible markers

  • What will they look like and be called?
  • What do students do to earn them?
  • How frequently are they given out?
  • When are they given out?
  • How will they be managed in the classroom & school?
  • What celebrations/experiences/events will they lead to?
  • How will we keep track of their frequency and use with all students?

How can we involve students & families in the development of our acknowledgement system?

How can we ensure that it reflects student/family cultures?

121 of 217

BIG IDEA!

Change adult behavior to change student behavior. Positive reinforcement is all about changing from focusing on negative behavior to focusing on positive behavior.

122 of 217

Example: Charlotte

123 of 217

Example: JFK

124 of 217

Make it easy to use acknowledgements

Visual reminders for staff

Tickets and pen on lanyard

Computer printed stickers

Stacks of tickets

125 of 217

Break Out Room Activity

  • Consider what the current acknowledgement sounds like and looks like
    • How do students get recognized?
    • Do all students get recognized?
    • What is the tangible acknowledgement called?
    • What do students do with it?
    • How does your school keep track of staff, individual, classroom and school-wide reinforcement?
    • How do you build in student voice and choice in this process?

126 of 217

Reinforce Staff Behavior

Support school expectations AND expectations about implementing PBIS!

127 of 217

Why Acknowledge Staff?

  • Teacher emotional exhaustion is associated with low level PBIS implementation in the classroom (Reinke, Herman, & Stormont, 2013)
  • Teachers who experience high levels of burnout or feel emotionally exhausted demonstrate lower quality teaching and impaired relationships (Maslach & Jackson, 1981)
  • Teacher stress contributes to teacher turnover (Johnson, et.al, 2005)
  • High stress and low coping of teachers is correlated with poor student behavior and academic outcomes (Herman, Hickmon-Rosa, Reinke, 2018)

128 of 217

Break Out Room Activity

  • Discuss creative ways to reinforce the staff in your building
  • Be prepared to share out 1 idea to the group

The best way to know what will be reinforcing to staff? ASK!

129 of 217

Examples for Staff

Staff:

  • Note of appreciation
  • Recognition at assembly
  • G.O.O.S.E. (Get Out Of School Early)
  • Coffee Coupon
  • Chocolate in mailboxes
  • Lunch
  • One Free Period
  • Duty Free Day

130 of 217

Where can you find more ideas?

131 of 217

Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI) - IMPLEMENTATION

1.9 Feedback and Acknowledgement

A formal system (i.e., written set of procedures for specific behavior feedback that is [a] linked to school-wide expectations and [b] used across settings and within classrooms) is in place and used by at least 90% of a sample of staff and received by at least 50% of a sample of students.

TFI-CR (Supportive Environment):

Teams involve students, families, and communities in the development and use of acknowledgement systems in order to create systems that are meaningful and authentic. School teams consider the culture of the students they serve when designing recognition systems.

132 of 217

Team Time Activity 6

Procedures for Acknowledging Positive Behaviors

Tasks:

  • Consider what the current acknowledgement sounds like and looks like
    • What is it called? How do students get it?
    • What do students do with it? How do you build in student voice and choice in this process?
    • How do you keep track of this?
  • Discuss how to address possible concerns about tangible markers
  • Develop plan for seeking input on tangible markers from students, families, & staff

Follow-up Tasks:

  • Evaluate and edit plan for acknowledging and reinforcing expected behavior (in Handbook)
  • Develop outline for PD on acknowledging positive behavior

Tools:

  • Universal Training Action Plan & Activities
  • Slides

133 of 217

Core Features of PBIS Implementation

  • Statement of Purpose
  • 3-5 behavioral expectations
  • Procedures for teaching expected behaviors
  • Procedures for acknowledging positive behaviors
  • Procedures for addressing behavior concerns through a continuum of supports
  • Procedures for record-keeping and decision-making

134 of 217

Why Focus on Data?

“For PBIS to be sustained, it is key to establish efficient systems to collect, review and use fidelity and student discipline data for continuous improvement.”

Newton, Horner, Algozzine, Todd, & Algozzine (2012)

McIntoshK., et al. (2018)

135 of 217

Why Record Concerning Behaviors?

  • See schoolwide patterns
  • Determine if students’ concerning behaviors are habitual
  • Document pre-referral interventions
  • Determine whether a particular teacher needs support
  • Communicate with families and answer questions
  • Inform behavior support planning
  • Inform interagency collaboration
  • Comply with legal requirements

136 of 217

BIG IDEA!

We record concerning behavior to collect data for informed decision-making, NOT for punishing.

Writing it down, not “I’m writing you up!”

137 of 217

Information to Record

Your Behavior Observation and Data (BOD) form should include:

  • Name
  • Grade
  • Respondent
  • Date
  • Time
  • Location
  • Type of behavior
  • Others involved
  • Possible motivation/function
  • Which school-wide behavioral expectation was not met
  • Notes

138 of 217

Example Behavior Observation and Data (BOD) Form

139 of 217

Understanding Function of Behavior

  • “Function of behavior” - purpose, motivation, the why
  • Why should you think about it?
    • Minimize inadvertent reward of concerning behavior
    • Respond in a way that will reduce behavior
    • Helps you better understand students’ behavior
  • What if the function is not obvious?
    • ASK the student!

140 of 217

Think “Functionally”: Understand the Why of Behavior

Concerning Behavior

Obtain/Get Something

Escape/Avoid Something

Stimulation/ Sensory

Social

Tangible / Activity

Adult Attention

Peer Attention

141 of 217

Consider

Adults understanding “function-based thinking” is essential to behavior change.

How can you help ALL staff learn how to identify and consider the function of students’ behavior?

142 of 217

Shake It!!!

  • Shake it like a duck by the Super Fun Show (youthful)
  • Shake it off by Taylor Swift (pop)
  • Hippy Shake Shakes by the Swinging Blue Jeans (old rock & roll)
  • Shake your sillies out by the Learning Station (youthful)
  • Shake by L.L.A.M.A, Ne-Yo, Carmen DeLeon (hip hop)

143 of 217

Data System Features for Decision-Making

Decision-focused data system should provide:

  • Instantaneous access to graphed reports summarizing discipline data organized by frequency of concerning behavior events by:
    • Behavior
    • Location
    • Time of day
    • Individual student
  • Ability to disaggregate data by race/ethnicity, disability status, & gender

144 of 217

Tier 2/3 Consideration: How will you identify students that may need targeted interventions?

Using the Referrals by Student report as a Universal Screening Tool

145 of 217

SWIS Demo

School-Wide Information System

www.pbisapps.org

146 of 217

When to Use and Share Data

Monthly (at least)

  • Team reviews and uses school-wide discipline and academic outcome data for decision making

4x/year (at least)

  • Disaggregate core reports by race/ethnicity, disability status, & gender
  • Disproportionality metrics (risk ratios) calculated and analyzed for decision making
  • Schoolwide data shared with staff (successes and needs)

Frequently

  • Schoolwide data shared with all stakeholders for input and feedback

Annually

  • Team uses fidelity assessments (TFI and SAS) to action plan
  • Fidelity assessment data shared with all stakeholders

147 of 217

Other Possible Data Sources

  • School climate
  • Student/staff attendance
  • Nurse visits
  • Student perceptions about behavior (focus groups, surveys, etc.)
  • Student & family perceptions about fidelity of implementation
  • Family satisfaction
  • TFI Walkthrough (representation of interviewees, cultural imaging)
  • In/out-of-school suspension
  • Academic achievement
  • Staff retention

148 of 217

Data in Action

149 of 217

Foundational Elements of Equity in PBIS

  • Collect, use, and report disaggregated discipline data
  • Implement a behavior framework that is preventive, multi-tiered, and culturally responsive
  • Use engaging instruction to reduce the opportunity (achievement) gap
  • Develop policies with accountability for disciplinary equity
  • Teach strategies for neutralizing implicit bias in discipline decisions

150 of 217

Data for Equity

Inequitable outcomes are first examined from a systems perspective before viewing them as an issue with an individual student or family and before considering individual behavior support

  • Disaggregate data by race/ethnicity, disability status, & gender to assess and monitor equity in student outcomes
  • Team & staff take responsibility for outcomes for each student
  • Implementation fidelity is examined specifically with regard to the equity of outcomes for all students
  • Annual evaluation procedures are used to engage a wide and representative range of stakeholders in 2-way communication regarding goals and progress

151 of 217

Implement

Solution with

High Integrity

Identify

Goal for Change

Identify Problem

with

Precision

Monitor Impact

of Solution and

Compare against Goal

Make Summative

Evaluation

Decision

Meeting

Foundations

Team-Initiated Problem Solving (TIPS II) Model

Identify

Solution &

Create

Implementation

Plan with

Contextual Fit

Collect and Use Data

What, Who, When, Where, and Why?

How do we want the problem to change?

What are we going to do to bring about desired change?

Did we implement with fidelity?

Has the problem been solved?

What next?

152 of 217

Tier 2/3 Consideration: Interventions Tracking Tool

153 of 217

Share

Please share in the chat box or aloud your response to one of these questions. . .

  • What kind of data are we collecting?

  • Is the data collection a contextual fit?

  • How are we using this data, if at all?

  • Do we need additional data? How can we collect it?

  • What does our data tell us about what to continue and what to change?

How are we examining our data to ensure that our practices and outcomes are equitable across all students?

154 of 217

Team-Initiated Problem Solving (TIPS)

Resources for using TIPS

  • TIPS Meeting Template
  • Schedule time with a VTPBIS Coach
  • Recorded Webinar at: https://vimeo.com/user18175786/videos

How can we ensure that students are engaged in each step of TIPS?

155 of 217

Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI) - EVALUATION

1.10 Faculty Involvement

Faculty are shown school-wide data regularly and provide input on universal foundations (e.g., expectations, acknowledgements, definitions, consequences) at least every 12 months.

TFI-CR (Voice):

School staff are actively engaged in all SWPBIS Tier 1 practices, demonstrate ownership of the system, and accept responsibility for sustaining practices that are effective for all students.

1.11 Student/Family/Community Involvement

Stakeholders (students, families, and community members) provide input on universal foundations (e.g., expectations, consequences, acknowledgements) at least every 12 months.

TFI-CR (Voice):

Team and staff see student, family, and community partnerships as vital to improving student outcomes. Teams engage families, students, and community members that are representative of the school’s demographics and any underserved populations.

156 of 217

Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI) - EVALUATION

1.12 Discipline Data

Tier I team has instantaneous access to graphed reports summarizing discipline data organized by the frequency of problem behavior events by behavior, location, time of day, and by individual student.

TFI-CR (Data for Equity):

Teams regularly disaggregate discipline data as an effective and objective way to assess and monitor equity in student outcomes. Teams are purposeful in examiling inequitable outcome data first from a systems perspective, before viewing it as an issue with an individual student or family.

1.13 Data-Based Decision Making

Tier I team reviews and uses discipline data at least monthly for decision-making.

FI-CR (Data for Equity):

Teams engage in active data-based decision making with a specific focus on equity. Team and school staff take responsibility for the outcomes for each student, regardless of their circumstances. Inequitable outcomes are first examined from a system perspective before considering individual behavior support.

157 of 217

Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI) - EVALUATION

1.14 Fidelity Data

Tier I team reviews and uses SWPBIS fidelity (e.g., SET, BoQ, TIC, SAS, Tiered Fidelity Inventory) data at least annually.

TFI-CR (Data for Equity):

Teams, staff, and stakeholders are committed to enhancing SWPBIS implementation with culturally responsive components. Teams use additional measures beyond the nationally recognized SWPBIS assessments, to examine the fidelity of their schoolwide system, specifically with regard to the equity of outcome for all students. (e.g. TFI Walkthrough, procedures to collect and use feedback from students/families/ community in multiple languages/modes of delivery regarding fidelity of implementation.)

1.15 Annual Evaluation

Tier I team documents fidelity and effectiveness (including on academic outcomes) of Tier I practices at least annually (including year-by-year comparisons) that are shared with stakeholders (staff, families, community, district) in a usable format.

TFI-CR (Data for Equity):

Annual evaluation procedures are used to engage a wide and representative range of stakeholders in two-way communication regarding goals and progress.

158 of 217

Team Time Activity 7

Data for Decision-Making

Tasks:

7a: Record-Keeping: Behavior Observation Data Form

7b: Staff PD on Data for Record-Keeping and Decision-Making

7c: Look at your SWIS data graphs. Use Atlas protocol to consider:

  • What do you see?
  • What does the data suggest?
  • What are the implications?

Tools:

  • Refresher Training Action Plan & Activities
  • Slides

159 of 217

Day 3 Closing

  • What questions do you have?
  • Individual Share: I’m feeling . . .
  • Exit ticket
  • For Coming Together tomorrow, representative from each school report out:
    • How things are going, what you have accomplished, any “aha” moments

160 of 217

Day 4 Agenda

  • Coming together
  • Core Features of PBIS
    • 5. Addressing behavior concerns through a continuum of supports
  • Anticipating Roadblocks and Increasing Buy-in
  • Next Steps
    • Action Plan
    • Follow-up Coaching
    • Data System
    • Planning for Staff PD & Roll-out
  • Closing

161 of 217

Coming Together

Please share in the chat box . . .

What can you do that you could not do a year ago?

162 of 217

Coming Together

Representative from each school . . .

Please share something about your team process so far:

  • How things are going
  • What you have accomplished so far
  • Any “aha” moments

Day 3 Exit Ticket feedback & response

163 of 217

Community Agreements: How we will be together

Behavioral Norms

  • Take care of yourself
  • Be fully engaged & take risks
  • Be mindful of other learners
  • Be fully present

What do I need from the group?

What do others need from me?

Procedural Norms

  • Start & finish on time
  • Planning & work time included
  • Support available during break-outs
  • Exit tickets will help guide next day’s work

What systems do we need in place to help the training be effective?

What will make this learning environment equitable and effective for everyone?

164 of 217

165 of 217

Core Features of PBIS Implementation

  • Statement of Purpose
  • 3-5 behavioral expectations
  • Procedures for teaching expected behaviors
  • Procedures for acknowledging positive behaviors
  • Procedures for addressing behavior concerns through a continuum of supports
  • Procedures for record-keeping and decision-making

166 of 217

Share

Please share in the chat box . . .

Think of a time when you were criticized or got negative feedback.

What was your initial reaction?

How did you feel?

167 of 217

Foundational Elements of Equity in PBIS

  • Collect, use, and report disaggregated discipline data
  • Implement a behavior framework that is preventive, multi-tiered, and culturally responsive
  • Use engaging instruction to reduce the opportunity (achievement) gap
  • Develop policies with accountability for disciplinary equity
  • Teach strategies for neutralizing implicit bias in discipline decisions

168 of 217

Prevention is the Best “Response”

  • Improves classroom climate
  • Creates shared ownership of the classroom
  • Develops students’ self-discipline

Decreased disruptive behavior concerns

Decreased teacher redirection

Increased instructional time

Increased academic learning time

Increased academic success

169 of 217

Practices for Preventing Behavior Concerns

  • Preventive classroom management
  • Organize environmental aspects of the classroom to optimize learning
  • Engaging and differentiated instruction
  • Opportunities to respond (OTR)
  • Build Authentic relationships
  • Develop adult and student social-emotional skills
  • Strengthen sense of belonging and ownership
  • Active supervision: Scan, Move, Interact
  • PEP strategy: Proximity, Eye contact, Privacy

How can we support teachers in the use of practices to prevent behavior concerns?

170 of 217

Evidence-Based Practices: Classroom Management

  • Maximize structure in your classroom
  • Establish and teach expectations
  • Establish a continuum of strategies to acknowledge expected behavior
  • Establish a continuum of strategies to respond to behavior concerns
  • Use self reflection and behavior data to progress monitor and problem solve

Brandi Simonsen, PhD, UConn

171 of 217

Function Based Approach

  • A process that focuses on assessing and systematically changing environmental factors.

  • Not about “changing” or “fixing” the student.

  • Think: are our responses to behavior compliance-based or needs-based?

172 of 217

Function Based Approach

  • A different perspective on response to challenging behavior in schools.

  • Traditional disciplinary systems are oriented towards punishment—removal from group, denial of access to privilege, etc.

  • These traditional approaches are typically not student-centered or function-based

173 of 217

Tier 2/3 Consideration:

Matching Interventions to Function of Behavior

TFI: Practices Matched to Student Need

A formal process is in place to select Tier II interventions that are:

  • matched to student need (e.g., behavioral function), and
  • adapted to improve contextual fit (e.g., culture, developmental level).

174 of 217

Tier 2/3 Consideration: Examples: Targeted Interventions Based on Functions of Behavior

  • Access Adult Attention/Support:
    • Check-In/Check-Out
    • Adult Mentoring Programs
  • Access Peer Attention/Support:
    • Social Skills Instruction
    • Peer Mentoring
    • Self-Monitoring with Peer Support (function: academic task escape)
  • Access Adult Attention (around academics):
    • Organization/Homework planning support
    • Homework completion club
    • Tutoring

175 of 217

Break Out Room Activities

Universal Teams: Consider these questions:

  1. What in-class prevention and response strategies should all teachers try?
  2. How can you ensure a balance between “discipline procedures” for responding to behaviors of concern and practices to prevent the recurrence?
  3. How are staff supported to learn effective response strategies for behaviors of concern?

Targeted/Intensive Teams: Consider these questions:

  1. What might your data look like if your Universal layers of supports are not implemented with fidelity?
  2. What can be done to increase this first?
  3. Consider your school’s current Tier 2 layers of support:
  4. Do you have interventions that match all of your student’s needs (function of behavior)? What else might you add?
  5. Do you have an organizational chart with all interventions listed for staff to see? Have you secured all of the resources needed to ensure quick access (i.e. people, time)?

176 of 217

Where: Identify Behavior Hotspots

  • Map the school/classroom activity (students & staff)
    • Put an X on top 3 challenging locations
    • For each location, identify behavior by what, when, and why

  • Classroom - most time spent here, most demand

  • Non-classroom - less supervision, structure, & explicit teaching
    • Common areas
    • Hallways
    • Transitions
    • Playground/recess
    • Bus

177 of 217

What: Defining and Sorting Concerning Behaviors

Minors

Behaviors that:

  • do not require administrator involvement;
  • handled in the environment in which they occur
  • do not significantly violate rights of others;
  • do not put others at risk or harm;
  • are not chronic.

Majors

Behaviors that:

  • are chronic minors;
  • may require administrator involvement;
  • significantly violate rights of others;
  • put others at risk of harm.

178 of 217

Develop Shared Understanding of Majors & Minors

179 of 217

Equity & Definitions of Concerning Behaviors

How can we ensure that staff understand the difference between universally unacceptable & situationally inappropriate behaviors?

How can we actively seek input on concerning behavior definitions from students, families, and staff?

How can we be especially attentive to how we define subjective behaviors such as defiance & respect?

180 of 217

Close Confusers

Calibrate your staff!

Identify and define minor vs. major behaviors

Define adult expectations prior to referring

The first grade class writes in a journal. The topic focuses on a specific letter each day. During the letter “F” day, Sarah writes an inappropriate word she learned from some of the older students on the playground. She shows her journal to all of the students around her.

DEFINE “Close Confusers”!

181 of 217

Rethinking Discipline: Academic & Social Problems: A Comparison of Approaches

Error type

Approaches for Academic Problems

Approaches for Social Problems

Infrequent Errors

  • Assume student is trying to make correct responses; error was accidental, a skill deficit.

  • Provide assistance (teach, model, guide, check)

  • Provide more practice and feedback; monitor progress.

  • Assume student has learned skill and will perform correctly in the future.
  • Assume student is choosing to be “bad;” error was deliberate, a performance deficit.

  • Use consequences/punish.

  • Practice not required.

  • Assume student has “learned” lesson and will behave in the future.

Frequent Errors

  • Assume student has learned the wrong way or has inadvertently been taught the wrong way.

  • Diagnose problem; identify misrule or determine more effective way to teach.

  • Adjust teaching arrangements to accommodate learner needs. Provide practice and feedback.

  • Assume student has learned skill and will perform correctly in the future.
  • Assume the student is refusing to cooperate; student knows what is right, has been told to stop, and is being insubordinate.

  • Provide more severe consequences; remove from normal context (office referral, detention, suspension)

  • Maintain student removal from the normal context.

  • Assume student has “learned” lesson and will behave in the future.

182 of 217

Consider this Mindset Shift

183 of 217

Procedure for Responding to Concerning Behaviors

1. Utilize effective classroom prevention & response practices

2. If minor behavior (classroom managed):

➤ review/reteach/restorative conversation

➤ document on BOD form

3. If major behavior (office managed):

➤ initiate referral to out of classroom space

➤ plan for relationship-building re-entry:

  • restorative conversation
  • plan to address needs/harm
  • plan for prevention

➤ document on BOD form

How can we ensure that behavior is addressed as high on the continuum as possible?

184 of 217

Practices for Responding to Minors

  • Signal that expectation has not been met
  • State expected behavior
  • Ask student to show expected behavior
    • Walk away to give the student time to make a choice OR
    • Offer help “What can I do to help you follow the expectation?”
  • Give positive feedback for any positive change in behavior

Consider use of scripts

  • “What are you doing?”
  • “What are you supposed to be doing?”
  • “What are you going to do?”

How can we ensure that our practices for responding maintain students’ dignity?

185 of 217

Preventing Concerning Behavior from Recurring

  • Revisit classroom management practices & environment
  • Analyze and address function & needs
  • Reteach
  • Strengthen relationships
  • Restorative conversation script:
    • “What happened?”
    • “What were you thinking about at the time?”
    • “What have you thought about since the incident?”
    • “Who do you think has been affected by your actions?”
    • “How have they been affected?
  • Ross Greene’s Plan B
    • “I notice that you are …. what’s up?”

186 of 217

Responding to Behavior Concerns by Re-Teaching

What concerning behavior/s do you think the PBIS Team identified as a need?

What do you think the focus behavior is for the month?

187 of 217

Provide Opportunity for Restorative Reflection

  1. What happened? Which expectation(s) was not honored?
  2. What led up to this?
  3. What were you thinking/feeling/hoping for at the time?
  4. Who was affected? How?
  5. What needs to happen to make things better right now?
  6. What support do you need to do things differently in the future? What would help you practice the expectations?

188 of 217

Creating a Behavioral Flow Chart

189 of 217

BIG IDEA!

The flowchart and t-chart of minor and major behaviors and definitions help create consistency for how adults respond to behavior concerns.

When administrators and all staff agree about how and where behaviors should be handled, anxiety and frustration levels are reduced.

190 of 217

Discipline Policies

Schools’ policies and procedures should describe and emphasize approaches to student behavior that are:

  • Proactive
  • Instructive (teaching-oriented)
  • Function-based
  • Restorative
  • Implemented consistently

How can we ensure that discipline policies, procedures, & practices are inclusionary to the greatest extent possible?

191 of 217

Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI) - EVALUATION

1.5 Problem Behavior Definitions

School has clear definitions for behaviors that interfere with academic and social success and a clear policy/procedure (e.g., flowchart) for addressing office-managed versus staff-managed problems.

TFI-CR (Situational Appropriateness):

Team and school staff understand the difference between universally unacceptable and situationally inappropriate behaviors and take responsibility for teaching what is wanted at school without devaluing what may be acceptable at home or in the community. Differences between school and home/community definitions of unacceptable or undesirable behaviors are discussed and mitigated with families and community so that the school truly reflects the communities it serves.

1.6 Discipline Policies

School policies and procedures describe and emphasize proactive, instructive, and/or restorative approaches to student behavior that are implemented consistently.

TFI-CR (Supportive Environment):

Team employs and supports an instructional approach to discipline that emphasizes teaching pro-social skills (rather than using exclusionary discipline and zero tolerance policies.) They examine policies and disciplinary practices for disparate impact and to ensure from a power (staff preference) versus purpose (linked to educational outcomes) perspective.

192 of 217

Tiered Fidelity Inventory (TFI) - EVALUATION

1.7 Professional Development

A written process is used for orienting all faculty/staff on 4 core Tier I SWPBIS practices: (a) teaching school-wide expectations, (b) acknowledging appropriate behavior, (c) correcting errors, and (d) requesting assistance.

TFI-CR (Identity):

Professional development processes and procedures focus on (1) implementation of the SWPBIS framework, (2) the TFI-CR cultural responsiveness components, and (3) historic context and present-day issues specific to the school’s underserved populations.

1.8 Classroom Procedures

Tier I features (school-wide expectations, routines, acknowledgements, in-class continuum of consequences) are implemented within classrooms and consistent with school-wide systems.

TFI-CR (Supportive Environment):

Teams support classroom teachers in the implementation of SWPBIS in classrooms. Classroom teachers ensure that all students in the class can see their lives, histories, cultures, and home languages incorporated into the classroom environment, curricula, and instructional practices on a daily basis.

193 of 217

Team Time Activity 8

Addressing Behavior Concerns Through a Continuum of Supports

Tasks:

  • Identify behavior concerns that your school is or will collect data on & use on BOD
  • Review definitions for major & minor behaviors & modify in the Handbook
  • Plan outline for staff PD on addressing behavior concerns through a continuum of supports, including equity considerations

Future tasks:

  • Review and edit Responding to Concerning Behavior Flow Chart & enter into Handbook
  • Review or create Reflection Sheet

Tools

  • SWIS Behavior Definitions & Dothan Brook Definitions/Non-examples
  • Refresher Training Action Plan & Activities
  • Handbook
  • Slides

194 of 217

Implementation

195 of 217

Core Features of PBIS Implementation

1. Statement of Purpose

2. 3-5 behavioral expectations

3. Procedures for teaching expected behaviors

4. Procedures for acknowledging positive behaviors

5. Procedures for addressing behavior concerns through

a continuum of supports

6. Procedures for record-keeping and decision-making

Developed in advance & reviewed annually

Daily throughout implementation

196 of 217

Predictors of Sustainability

  • Staff buy-in
  • Fidelity
  • Opportunities to learn & practice
  • Strong leadership team
  • Active support from school & district administration
  • Staff viewing data regularly

197 of 217

Expand Ability to Implement with Fidelity

  • Look at yourself & colleagues primarily as learners
  • Think through an inquiry lens
    • identify & analyze any problems/challenges
    • don’t jump to conclusions
  • Develop strategies to address problems and make progress toward goal

VTPBIS Buy-in, Momentum, & Sustainability resources (May 2017)

198 of 217

Anticipate Roadblocks

  • Ensuring consistency and fidelity
  • Ensuring equity
  • Finding time to train and support staff
  • How to involve ALL staff
  • Participation & buy-in
  • Competing needs
  • Staff culture and climate

How can we ensure that ALL staff members feel heard & included, and are supported as they learn how to implement?

199 of 217

Annual Calendar for PBIS Team

Start of school

  • Review action plan, adapt implementation as needed, & plan PD & roll-out
  • Provide staff PD prior to start of school
  • Roll out to students & families in first week of school

Monthly

  • Analyze data; Consider behavior & equity needs; Identify monthly focus behaviors and plan and communicate teaching & reteaching lessons/activities & schoolwide celebrations

Regularly

  • Elicit input & feedback, share data & information with stakeholders
  • Provide staff support & PD as necessary
  • Ongoing PD for team: Fall Forum, Coordinators’ Meetings (Jan. & May), BEST, Webinars
  • Consider coaching needs & contract with coach

Annually

  • Complete fidelity assessments (TFI, School Climate, SAS) (late winter/early spring)
  • Create Action Plan for following year
  • Communicate with district grant writer about Act 230 funds for training and coaching needs

How can we keep equity at the forefront of everything we do?

200 of 217

Implementation Science

Exploration

Installation

Initial Implementation

Full Implementation

Innovation

Sustainability

3-5 years

(this is normal!)

201 of 217

Building Buy-in

202 of 217

Change and Resistance

  • What if we replaced the idea of managing change with accepting resistance as a natural part of change?
  • People need to challenge new ideas before they can accept them
  • For full ownership, people need to be part of the conversation about how to change

203 of 217

How People Respond to Demands

  • Commitment
    • Passion, energy, enthusiasm
  • Compliance
    • Motivated by fear of losing relationship, position, status
  • Appearance of compliance
    • Driven by fear, frustration, or anger; Try to recruit others to share view; Highlight everything that’s wrong or not working
  • Rational Resistance 
    • lack needed knowledge, information, skill
  • Emotional Resistance 
    • evoked by perception of how change will affect them
    • Grief, anxiety, suspicion, insecurity, fear

Lorem 3

Lorem 1

Participators

Hard Core Believers

Hard Core

Resisters

Wait & See-ers

204 of 217

Why People Support Change

  • Believe the change makes sense & it is the right course of action
  • Respect people leading the change effort
  • Anticipate new opportunities & challenges that come from the change
  • Were involved in planning & implementation 
  • Believe the change will lead to personal gain – satisfaction, professional growth, relationships
  • Like and enjoy the excitement of change

Write in the chatbox: What have been factors that have led to successful change in your school/district?

205 of 217

Why People Resist Change

  • Believe the change is unnecessary or will make things worse
  • Don’t trust the people leading the change effort
  • Don’t like the way the change was introduced
  • Are not confident the change will succeed
  • Did not have input or role in planning & implementation
  • Feel threatened that change will mean personal loss — security, status, relationships, competence
  • Believe in the status quo
  • Have already experienced a lot of change and can’t handle any more disruption
  • Are afraid they don’t have the skills to do their work in new ways required by the change

206 of 217

5 MINUTE DANCE PARTY OR MEDITATION

207 of 217

Team Time Activity 9

Building

Buy-In

Discuss:

  • Think about staff buy-in for PBIS. Use the chart as a guide to discuss and note:
    • What’s already in place or readily accomplished
    • What is or might be challenging
    • What you will try

Tools:

  • Refresher Training Action Plan & Activities
  • Slides

208 of 217

How’s it going?

  • How are things going for your team?
  • What are you thinking about?
  • What questions do you have?
  • What do you need?

209 of 217

Next Steps

210 of 217

Now What?

By end of Team Time on Thursday:

  • Finalize action plan

Before School Starts:

  • Finalize all implementation components
  • Schedule Universal team meetings for the year (at least monthly, weekly or biweekly is better)
  • Plan Staff PD and roll-out for Fall
  • Obtain SWIS license (if using)
  • Contact sherry.schoenberg@uvm.edu to set up follow-up coaching

211 of 217

Team Time Activity 10

Staff PD & Roll-Out

For Staff: PD

For Students: Teaching & Learning activities

For Families: Communication

Tasks:

  • Design staff PD on all aspects of PBIS (see Action Plan for components)
  • Arrange time for PD prior to start of school next year
  • Design roll-out for students
  • Design roll-out for families

Tools:

  • Refresher Action Plan & Activities
  • Slides
  • School Handbook

212 of 217

Share

What will your school look like and sound like

when PBIS is fully implemented?

213 of 217

Vermont PBIS System of Support

214 of 217

School Coordinator

Facilitator and head cheerleader, not the solo worker bee!

  • VTPBIS Coordinator Handbook
  • School Coordinator Self-Assessment
  • VTPBIS Fall Forum & VTPBIS School Coordinator meetings/trainings - January & May
  • Monthly VTPBIS emails from TA
  • Regular update emails from Anne Dubie

215 of 217

VTPBIS State TAs

Three types of TA to VTPBIS schools and SU/SDs:

1. SYSTEMS: Specific supports include:

  • Determining readiness for VTPBIS training at all tiers;
  • Identifying other VTPBIS Professional Learning opportunities;
  • Seeking resources to support VTPBIS implementation; and
  • Understanding how to access VTPBIS Coaches/Trainers

2. DATA: Specific supports include:

  • Understanding and using the VTPBIS data tools (School-wide Evaluation Tool; Tiered Fidelity Inventory; Self-Assessment Survey; SWIS, etc.);
  • Assistance with problem solving using data; and
  • Assistance with developing and sharing data with stakeholders

3. PRACTICES: Specific supports include:

  • Implementing PBIS with fidelity at all tiers;
  • Identifying evidence-based practices; and
  • Consultation about implementation dips

216 of 217

Coaching Support

  • What?
    • Support for PBIS implementation & fidelity
    • Create school/SU/SD capacity for internal coaching
  • Why?
    • Brings experience, expertise, & external perspective
  • How?
    • SU/SD apply for BEST/Act 230 funds
    • Contract with state-approved VTPBIS Coaches directly

“Our coach was invaluable in our first year at the Universal level. She was incredibly supportive.”

“[Our coach] was very skilled in listening and then meeting our needs.”

“It’s very important to have a different set of eyes on the data and to provide external feedback.”

217 of 217

Day 4 Closing: L.E.A.R.N.

Like: What did you most like about the training experience?

Excite: What excited you most?

Anxiety: What created the greatest anxiety?

Reward: What can we celebrate about how we worked and learned together?

Need: What are the next steps we need to keep moving forward together?