1 of 24

Survey findings and next steps

Tim Riley

2

Liesl Rowe

2 of 24

Previously…

3 of 24

Oh my GOOOOOOOOOD!

They’re going to eat me!

© Filmirage, 1990

4 of 24

Key questions

How big of a problem is this?

​

What can we do about it?

5 of 24

The survey

15 questions covering:

  • Claims – number and nature
  • Handling claims – who and how
  • Support needs

​

Sent out via lis-copyseek + other lists

6 of 24

Thank you!

7 of 24

Findings

8 of 24

Respondents

1

Australia

4

Canada

26

UK

5

USA

36 total responses

9 of 24

Responsibility

13

copyright specialist

11

Organisational legal team

5

receiving department

8

no one / �don’t know

10 of 24

Prevalence of claims

2/3 organisations had a claim in the past 3 years

Typical organisation received 2 claims

​

Range of 0-48 claims

11 of 24

Unknown data

True prevalence unknown as organisations’ data is incomplete

12 of 24

Trolling vs Non-Trolling

18% non-trolling

82% trolling*

* “unfounded, unreasonable or excessive”

13 of 24

Material Targeted

85% photos��on public-facing webpages

14 of 24

AI

Automated search and contact – �these are�tech firms

​

“In our experience it was an AI crawler used by a stock image media company”

15 of 24

Reactions

“The wording in the emails sent from trolling companies is aggressive, and this is what makes my institution react.”

Variety of responses from pushback to payment

16 of 24

Anti-troll measures

Most popular:

  1. Approved image sources
  2. Written guidance
  3. Training and workshops

​

30% of organisations have no measures in place

17 of 24

Possible remedies

  • Scoping advice
  • Background info on companies and relevant law
  • Claims guidance
  • Awareness-raising material

18 of 24

Next steps

19 of 24

The Copyright trolling research Group

  • Tim Riley (Aberdeen) and Liesl Rowe (LBU), Co-Chairs
  • Chris Morrison (Oxford)
  • Jane Secker (City St George’s)
  • Simon Cox (UWE)
  • Deborah Ferns (Strathclyde)
  • Ami Pendergrass (Oxford)

20 of 24

Shining A�Light on the�Problem

21 of 24

The Form

  • Anonymous submissions permitted
  • Month/year received
  • Which company
  • Kind of media
  • Payment amount
  • How was the claim handled

22 of 24

Future Plans

23 of 24

Acknowledgements

Illustrations adapted from Public domain vectors on Unsplash

​

24 of 24

Questions