Google Ad Grants vs. Microsoft Ads for Social Impact�How do they compare? New platforms, new features, new strategies
Presentation at Nonprofit Technology Conference #23NTC�
Jason King
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Jason King…
Google Ad Grant Certified Professional
Google Product Expert—active in Ad Grant, Google Ads & Search forums
Trainer—Google Ads, Microsoft Ads, Google Analytics 4
Homestead in rural France—14 acres of woodland and pasture, orchards, food forest and edible hedges, sheep, and Gauloise Saumon Doré chickens
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
warning—there’s jargon ahead!
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Based on data from�
26 Google Grant accounts��9 Microsoft Ads for Social Impact accounts��Stats from 1 June 2022 - 31 March 2023
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
The Google Ad Grant in 2023
The program is 20 years old
It puts your ads into Search results on Google
The rules changes of five years ago have led to better managed accounts
Average Click Through Rate (CTR) is far higher than it used to be
Average monthly spend is higher than it used to be
But Cost Per Click (CPC) has risen a lot over the last few years, so more spend doesn’t necessarily mean more clicks
Generally less useful for donation revenue than it used to be, but still useful for awareness
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
In 2023 your Google Ad Grant should be using
Responsive Search Ads (RSA), not Expanded Text Ads (ETA)
Image extensions (now called assets)
Business name assets
Business logo assets
A conversion-based bidding strategy
Conversion tracking set up in Google Analytics 4 (only a few months left to transition)
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Microsoft Ads for Social Impact
New program, started on 1 June 2023
Can be spent on Search or Display ads (Google only allows Search)
Shown not just in Bing but also Yahoo, AOL, Outlook, MSN and other places
Initially available to multiple countries, then restricted to US only
Initially offered $3,000 per month’s worth of ads, but recently reduced to $1,000
Paused to new applications from April 2023
The interface is very similar to Google Ads and you can even auto-import campaigns from Google Ads
Some interesting and unique types of extension, such as action extensions
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Ad Grant Bingo
Download the worksheet:
Use it to define your advertising goals and the audiences you want to target, then find out whether Google or Microsoft Ad Grants might be the more appropriate platform to use.
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
How generous are they?
$10,000 per month
A few nonprofits still have the legacy $40,000 per month, but that’s not been available to new applicants for several years
Impossible to over-spend
MICROSOFT
$1,000 per month
But if you spend $800 of your own money per month, they will raise it to $3,000
Until April 2023 it was $3,000 for all
Possible to over-spend, so set the daily budget carefully
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
How competitive can your ads be?
MICROSOFT
Free ads and paid ads are not bundled separately
In the same bidding auctions
Impression share 7% - 44%
Can bid as high as necessary, regardless of bidding strategy
Free ads shown below paid ads
Free and paid ads in separate bidding auctions
Impression share <10%
Can bid as high as necessary if you use a conversion-based bidding strategy
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Ease of spending the daily budget
MICROSOFT
So very easy!
Therefore put only your priority ads on Microsoft (donations, signups)
Don’t be afraid to target precise audiences
Difficult for niche keywords
Difficult for donation keywords
Difficult for organizations with only a local reach
Impression share <10% except for brand terms
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Conversion tracking
MICROSOFT
Not so easy, depending on what you need to track
Tag needs to be added to website
But you are not required to use a conversion-based bidding strategy, so it’s less vital
And you can still see conversions via Bing in Google Analytics
Relatively easy due to integration with Google Analytics
Google Analytics 4 deadline is approaching fast!
GA4’s flexible conversion tracking methods *might* make Google Tag Manager unnecessary
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
How does Cost Per Click (CPC) compare?
Lowest account average: $1.62�(cerebral palsy)
Highest account average: $9.92�(international aid)
Cost Per Click (CPC) has risen each year for the last few years, see upriseup.co.uk/blog/latest-google-ad-grant-data-trend/
MICROSOFT
Lowest account average: $0.23�(reason: brand ads only)
Highest account average: $3.78�(cerebral palsy)
Low CPC coupled with ease of spending, means the budget goes further than you might think
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Click Through Rate (CTR)
Lowest account average: 6.31%�(international aid)
Highest account average: 25.14%�(cerebral palsy)
Overall average: 10.57%
Minimum allowed: 5%
MICROSOFT
Lowest account average: 1.64%�(international aid)
Highest account average: 3.53%�(cerebral palsy)
Overall average: 2.3%
No minimum CTR rule
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Demographic differences
Younger
More international
More computer literate
More likely to volunteer or get involved in activism
MICROSOFT
Older
In the US
Higher level of education
Higher income
Bigger spenders online
More likely to be parents
More likely to donate, and donate higher amounts
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Donations (example: a UK mother and baby charity)
One-off donations: 10
Avg. amount: $35
Monthly donations: 2
Avg. amount: $7
MICROSOFT
One-off donations: 34
Avg. amount: $170
Monthly donations: 7
Avg. amount: $10
Near-identical campaigns ran on each platform
Remember that during this period the Microsoft Grant budget was < one third of the Google Grant
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Audience targeting methods
Age, gender, household income
Interests
Industry
Remarketing
But using too-narrow targeting can flatline impressions
MICROSOFT
Same as Google, plus…
Job roles
Working in specific companies
Can often get a high level of traffic even with narrow targeting
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Remarketing
Only available in Ad Grants since early 2018
Limited in its reach because of impression suppression
Easy to set up audiences using Google Analytics
Useful for bigger-spending nonprofits with well-visited websites
MICROSOFT
Available
Ads are likely to be shown to a niche audience
Not such a straightforward process to set up custom audiences
You might be able to run an entire campaign using competitive keywords and a sizable remarketing audience
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Do your audiences work in healthcare or education?
There are identical targeting options to reach people working in specific industries or with specific interests, which include:
Education, healthcare, nursing education, medical education, medical jobs
But these are much more effective in the Microsoft Ad Grant. Why?
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
LinkedIn Ad Grant
For nonprofits that are focused on the following areas:
Opens a couple of times a year for new applications for short-term projects.
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason
Also… paid ads
Ad Grants are not the only way to advertise.
Google requires you to run paid-for ads in a separate account to the grant. Generally you will get very different results as a paid account enables more competitive advertising.
Microsoft allows you to run paid and grant ads in the same account. Generally you will get similar results in both.
An advantage of paid ads in both platforms is that you can use other types of ad.
It’s a whole different conversation…
kingjason.co.uk
twitter.com/jasoncsking
linkedin.com/in/kingjason