1 of 35

FY26 Operating Budget�Draft Override Budget

Presented to the School Committee & Select Board�April 17, 2025

Connor Read, �Town Administrator

Dr. Lisha Cabral,�Superintendent of Easton Public Schools

Visit www.easton.ma.us/fy26budget

2 of 35

A Note About This Presentation

The Town and Easton Public Schools aim to present the final FY26 budgets by the April 29 hearing of the Select Board and Finance Committee:

1) A balanced FY26 budget without an override, achieved through cuts and reserves.

2) An override-dependent FY26 budget aligned with the Promoting A Sustainable Easton recommendations.

Easton voters will ultimately decide on the budget on May 19 and June 10.

To provide information ahead of the hearing, we are sharing a draft of the proposed FY26 override budget adjustments. Some items, such as the EPS budget and insurance, are still pending finalization.

These final items may lead to changes in both the non-override and override budgets. However, we do not anticipate significant changes to this recommendation and believe it's better to share this draft now rather than waiting until it's fully complete before the hearing.

3 of 35

Budgeting can be complicated. �The essence of our problem isn’t.

  • Property Tax (largest source of income) grows 2.5% a year
  • State Aid (2nd largest source of income) grows ≈1% a year�_______________________________________________________
  • Fixed costs have grown 10% a year for two years straight.*

The math just does not work, and it quickly creates a problem so large that innovation, regionalizing, etc. aren't enough - the immediate choices are:

  1. Large budget cuts & reserve funds
  2. Override���

* Health insurance, transportation, pensions, regional school assessments, etc.

4 of 35

Agenda

  • FY26 Non-Override Budget Recap – Where Things Stand
    • How Did We Get Here & Why Now?
    • Key Takeaways on FY25 & 26 Budget Posture
    • Understanding Easton’s Deficit Drivers
    • What is going on in Massachusetts?�
  • DRAFT FY26 Override Budget Recommendations
    • Info Resources to Stay Informed
    • Key FY26 Budget Dates

5 of 35

Recap of Where Things Stand �FY26 Non-Override Budget

High inflation, ballooning insurance costs, minimal state aid, and expiring pandemic grants will come to a head in FY26.

These forces are pushing fixed and operating budget requests far outside of Easton’s revenue capacity.

FY26 Budget started with preliminary deficit of $6.36M - typical is $1-2M.

As of Change Memo 2 – March 24 – this has been reduced to $2.29M through significant cuts to Town departments and use of $3.5M of reserve funds.

April 3 EPS budget proposal, if adopted, will allow Easton to balance the non-override budget – but all of this comes at a cost.

This budget will enact the largest cuts to Easton’s educational and public services since the 2008 recession.

6 of 35

The Non-Override Budget

Town department requests (+5.31%) were cut $784,244 to a total of $21.06M (1.6% above current year)

EPS budget request (+8.2%) proposes reductions of $2.36M to a total of $51.54M (+3.6% above current year)

The impact of these cuts are significant – with ≈50 FTE town/EPS positions eliminated (7% of FY25 budgeted workforce)

7 of 35

Cuts to Town Services in Non-Override FY26 Budget

EPD already spends -14% less per-resident than comparable communities.

Police Cuts in FY26

  • 2nd Police Officer Cut
    • Detective Division cut from 4 to 3.
    • Overnight Patrol cut from 5 to 4 minimum on shift.
    • Reduced proactive mental health supports for public.�

EFD already spends -5% less per-resident than comparable communities.

FIRE / EMS Cuts in FY26

  • 2 Firefighters Cut
    • 6 additional positions currently or soon to be vacant due to resignations & IOD (down 8 total FFs).
    • EFD will not be able to staff 3 stations.
    • Ability to staff 2 ambulances will be weakened.
      • Doing so will require significant overtime, including involuntary OT.
    • Reduced paramedicine program – fewer proactive services to cut down on 911s.

DPW already spends -20% less per-resident than comparable communities.

Public Works Cuts in FY26

  • 2 Public Works positions cut
    • Additional position current vacant.
    • Reduced road, building, field and park maintenance.
    • Elimination of planned Engineer to support residents / businesses through permitting.

Gen. Govt already spends -52% less per-resident than comparable communities.

HCS already spends -46% less per-resident than comparable communities.

General Govt. & Health and Community Services Cuts in FY26

  • 1 position cut from town hall (2nd already vacant)
    • Customer Service hours for collections cut in ½.
    • Reduced services to public, slower permitting.
  • Close Town Pool.
  • Reduced transportation services.

Per Mass. DOR - Neighboring towns with K-12 schools employ an average of 38 town/school employees per 1,000 residents. Even before these cuts – Easton employs -27% below that average at 28 town/school staff per 1,000 residents.

This is a high-level overview of cuts and impacts – please visit www.Easton.ma.us/fy26budget for detailed information.

8 of 35

The Road Here – Easton’s Budget Milestones over 20 Years

2005 – Voters approve OAHS & EMS debt exclusion.

2006 – Voters approve last operating override in Easton.

2008 – State Aid Cut – Town and School budgets cut.

2013 – Voters fund facilities repair/replace program.

2016 – Voters reject operating override.

2016 – Town adopts financial management policies – cuts reserve fund use & adopts austere operating budgets.

9 of 35

2017 – Voters approve feasibility to replace all �K-2 schools.

2019- Voters approve Blanche Ames debt exclusion.

2021 – Voters approve feasibility to replace Police, Fire, DPW facilities.

2023 – Voters approve debt exclusion to build new police, fire, and DPW facilities.

2024 – Unprecedented inflation for health insurance & fixed costs.

2024 – Voters approve FY25 budget & create PASE.

2025 – PASE recommends $7.override for FY26.

The Road Here – Easton’s Budget Milestones over 20 Years

CY21 – 23 operating position was stable, stabilization fund was growing, & reserve use in budget were some of the lowest in fifteen years.

10 of 35

To left: history of Easton’s preliminary budget deficits by fiscal year, the amount of reserves used as a % of total balanced budget in the same year, and with key milestones relating to overrides and debt exclusions.

  • Recent debt exclusions stem back to a 2013 vote to fund a facilities repair program.
  • Notion that the votes to advance Public Safety / Works (fall of 2021 & 2023) occurred while Town operating budget indicated an override was imminent is not accurate.
  • In fact – the fiscal years during which Town leadership sought (and received) voter approval to advance that project (FY22 and FY24) were some of the most stable operating budgets in 15 years.
    • FY22 (year of the feasibility vote) had the lowest use of reserves as a % of operating in 16 years.
    • FY24 (year of the debt exclusion vote) had the 5th lowest use of reserves as a % of operating revenue of 16 years.
    • Both years had preliminary budget deficits below the 5- and 10-year averages,
    • Both years had reserve use below the 5- and 10-year averages.
  • The deficit then grew rapidly in FY25 & 26 due to unprecedented growth to health insurance and other fixed costs. Not because of a debt exclusion.

11 of 35

DID EASTON DO ANYTHING TO TRY TO CLOSE THE GAP?

  • Easton has fought hard – successfully – to delay the arrival of a year like this as long as possible.

  • We’ve saved or avoided millions in expenses by:
    • regionalizing services,
    • consolidating departments and in-housing SPED and other services,
    • reforming health insurance,
    • solar generation and grant funded efficiency projects

12 of 35

DID EASTON DO ANYTHING TO TRY TO CLOSE THE GAP?

  • Improved Revenue:
    • Millions in New Growth via sewer construction and zoning reform.
    • Local receipt growth (meals tax, building permits).
  • Reducing reliance on reserves:
    • Conservative operating budgets
    • Declining % of budget funded by reserves.
  • This approach served us well for nearly 20 years!.

13 of 35

Preparing for the Rain – Stabilization Funds and Fortifying Easton’s Financial Position

  • While gradual progress was being made, Easton fortified its financial position to prepare for eventual downturn.

  • Allows us to tap substantial amount of stabilization fund in FY26.

  • Regrettably, this is enough to mitigate the cuts in FY26 – but not prevent them outright.

  • Had Easton not built reserves, cuts to departments would be substantially worse today.

What has Easton done to strengthen financial position?

    • Quadrupled stabilization fund balance from $1.59M in 2016 to $7.03M, its highest balance ever.
    • Easton’s reserve fund ratio doubled from below 5% to 10% - the highest in real dollar and percentage terms in at least 20 years.
    • Leveraged mitigation funds & state grants to complete three sewer districts which contributed to FY25’s New Growth surpassing $1.5M.
    • Commercial, Industrial and Personal Property (CIP) have contributed significantly to Easton’s New Growth – despite 88% of Easton’s property value being residential – 32% of all New Growth since 2021 has come from CIP.
    • Easton’s average annual tax bill increase this decade (FY16-25) of 3.5% is below the Massachusetts average annual tax bill increase of 4%.
    • Easton’s average tax bill rank among 351 MA communities has dropped from 65th in 2021 to 79th today – the lowest it has been since 2006.
    • Easton’s FY25 residential tax rate of $12.48/$1,000 is lowest since 2009.
    • Easton’s income growth has been strong - the average single family tax bill as a percentage of per capita income in FY25 (13.5%) is the lowest it has been as far back as the Department of Revenue keeps such data (2007).

14 of 35

Key Takeaways on FY25 & 26 Budget Posture

  • Revenue growth available for department budgets next year is ≈$4.13M
    • More than half of this is $2.37M in Stabilization Fund use (reserves)
  • Fixed cost growth consumed 36% of new revenue in FY25.
  • Fixed cost growth will consume HALF of new revenue in FY26.

  • Revenue is insufficient due to minimum state aid and 19 years w/o override.

  • Expense capacity is insufficient due to fixed cost inflation – NOT from Town or School departments “overspending” or “taking” at the expense of the other.

FY26 Fixed cost increase ($2M) is more than EPS increase ($1.8M) and dwarfs increase to all Town Departments (332K).

15 of 35

Current Expense Posture Staffing

  • Recent cost inflation is not caused by overspending on operations or over-hiring.
  • Total per-resident spend is -17% below MA average.
    • Easton is lowest among our 8 comparable communities; 2nd lowest among our surrounding communities.
  • Easton has fewer staff across the board (police, fire, DPW) including school and town government leadership.
  • It was true in 2017’s operational audit, true for the 2020 Budget Subcommittee and true with PASE’s review today.

Massachusetts Dept. of Rev. data on staff levels show…

  • Among neighbor towns with K-12 School Systems, Easton has the FEWEST staff per 1,000 residents.
  • Easton/EPS total staff of 28 per thousand residents is 27% below the neighbor average of 38 per thousand.
  • Were Town / EPS to staff at average rate, we’d need to hire an additional 258 employees.
  • The expense growth that is straining the budget is inflation of fixed costs.

16 of 35

The Data Shows that Easton & EPS:

  • Spends fewer dollars per resident and pupil than most neighbors and peer agencies

  • Staffs fewer personnel

  • Did not overspend itself into this challenge

  • Cannot cut its way to improved services

So why would we ever need an override?

17 of 35

DEFICIT DRIVER 1 OF 2�FY26 INSURANCES, PENSION ASSESSMENTS AND REGIONAL ASSESSMENTS

1 of 2 major causes of the FY26 deficit is the explosion in fixed operating costs – specifically health insurance, property insurance, pension assessments and regional school assessments.

Fixed Cost

FY24 Budget

FY25 Budget

FY26 Change 2

2 Year Increase

2 Year % Increase

Employee and Retiree Health Insurance

$9.5M

$10.3M

$11.44M

$1.9M

20%

Retirement Assessment (Pension)

$5.75M

$6.1M

$6.66M

$0.9M

16%

Prop, Casualty and Liability Insurance

$1.24M

$1.32M

$1.45M

$0.21M

17%

Regional School Assessments

$1.38M

$1.69M

$1.94M

$0.56M

41%

Subtotal

$17.87M

$19.41M

$21.49M

$3.6M

20%

For perspective:

  • 2-year health care increases = previous 10 years combined
  • 2-year health care increases = more $$ than total increase to Police in 10 years

Compare Fixed Cost Growth - $3.6M in 2 years time to:

  • FY26 Tax Revenue* (biggest revenue bucket) is forecast to increase $2.6M
  • FY26 State Aid Revenue (2nd largest source) – forecast to increase $361,111.
  • FY26 all Town Department Increase - $332K (1.6%)

* doesn’t include exempt revenue which cannot be used for operating budget

18 of 35

DEFICIT DRIVER 1 OF 2 �HEALTH INSURANCE

  • GIC plans in FY26 range from “low” of 10.5% to high of 17.2% over FY25.
  • On heels of 10% increase in FY25, this is catastrophic.
  • Town has taken numerous steps to mitigate this disastrous increase:
    • Adoption of future retiree healthcare contribution changes by the Select Board
    • Convening the Insurance Advisory Committee
    • Development of Annual Required Contribution Policy
    • Expanding the Town’s annual insurance incentive and opt-out programs

What Has Changed with Insurance Costs?

FY14-24 Av. Annual Increase – 3%

FY24 Increase – 3.9%

FY25 & 26 Cumulative Increase – 20%

19 of 35

DEFICIT DRIVER �2 OF 2 ��20 YEARS OF MINIMAL STATE AID FUNDING

  • The 2nd major cause of the FY26 deficit is Easton’s 20-year history of underfunded state aid.
  • Had Easton’s FY08 State Aid simply grown at the rate of inflation – FY25 would’ve seen ≈ $17 million instead of the actual net receipt of $12.9.

20 of 35

Deficit Driver 2 of 2 �What Does Minimum State Aid Look Like?

  • Receiving only minimum aid - $30 / per student new revenue per year – means EPS receives ≈$100,000 new state aid per year.
    • That is equal to 0.2% of the EPS annual budget.
  • Since 2010 – Chapter 70 State Aid to EPS has funded only 7.5 cents of every new dollar of budget capacity.
  • During those years, State Aid went from 31% of EPS budget to only 22% today.
  • Local funds have made up difference and done so with no override.

21 of 35

What Is Going on in Massachusetts?

  • This is not an “Easton problem”
  • Exploding insurance/fixed costs, expiring federal funds, and minimum state education funding are coming to a head throughout the state.
  • From FY14-23: 287 overrides sought statewide.
    • Average of 28 attempts / year out of 351 cities and towns.
  • FY24 – 62 attempts.
  • FY25 thru 12/31/24 – 46 attempts.

Among the 10 MA towns with most similar tax profile– Easton has gone the 2nd longest (19 years) without an override.

22 of 35

DRAFT�FY26 OVERRIDE BUDGET RECOMMENDATIONS

Visit www.Easton.ma.us/override for all information.

23 of 35

DRAFT OVERRIDE RECOMMENDATION

  • Basis of Recommendations:
    • PASE Community Compact and Recommended $7.3M override
    • FY26 change memo #2 dated March 24th
    • Draft EPS FY26 budget presented on April 3rd
  • Pending FY26 Items that will likely shift final figures:
    • Property/liability insurance
    • Snow & ice
    • House version of FY26 MA budget
  • Estimated additional tax impact:

24 of 35

1. ELIMINATION OF ONE-TIME RESERVE FUNDS USED IN NON-OVERRIDE BUDGET�$3,522,648

  • Non-override budget uses $3.5 million in reserves
    • Weakens long-term financial position
    • Creates fiscal cliff in FY27
    • Additional town / school budget cuts needed in FY27 if override does not pass
  • Impact on Town and School Budgets if reserve use is not eliminated from budget:
    • $3.1M in budget cuts meant ≈50 positions cut in FY26 non-override budget
    • $3.5M of reserves in FY26 = even more cuts in FY27
    • Public and educational services will continue to decline
  • Benefits of Removing Reserves as a funding source:
    • More stable financial position
    • Increased cash capital for school technology, roads, parks, emergency equipment
    • First budget since 2006 without structural revenue gap
    • Enhance longevity of the FY26 override
    • Protect against future economic downturns or state/federal funding instability

25 of 35

2. RESTORATION OF CUTS TO EASTON PUBLIC SCHOOLS��$2,060,000�

  • Restoration of $2,060,000 in cuts
    • 90% of the proposed $2,228,422 reduction in non-override budget will be restored.

  • Total EPS FY26 budget increase with Override
    • $3,850,940 increase
    • 7.74% over FY25

26 of 35

EPS OVERRIDE PRIORITY RESTORATIONS / NEEDS

  • Restoration of positions and programs
  • Classroom and Specialist Teacher(s) - reduce class sizes (elementary first)
  • Course Offering(s) - reinstate selected electives
  • Student Support Staff - Ie: para, nurse, etc. staff
  • Student Programming - Ie: Sheep Pasture, Summer instruction, etc.
  • Emerging or Unexpected Needs - Ie: ML, Special Ed, Kindergarten, transportation, data, etc.
  • Facilities - Loss of Capital Funds option

27 of 35

IMPORTANT NOTES:��EPS BUDGET�

  • Override amount will not be enough to fund all reduced/eliminated positions

  • Most of the reduced/eliminated positions (26.81 of 44.81) were vacated by retirement, resignation, etc.

  • Many positions will remain unfilled due to enrollment or student interest (ie: one or more electives)
  • As noted, emerging or urgent needs will be data based and may affect final budget allocations

28 of 35

3. RESTORATION OF CUTS TO TOWN DEPARTMENTS��$727,352

  • Restoration of $727,352 in cuts
    • 89% of cuts to Town Department level service requests restored
  • Total Town Depts FY26 budget increase with Override
    • $1,059,701 increase
    • 5.11% over FY25
  • Gen Govt.
    • 1 cut position restored, partial expenses restored.
    • $48,407 in cuts will not be restored
  • Health & Comm. Services
    • Restoration of $40,229 in cuts to HCS
    • Town Pool can reopen in summer 2026
    • Transportation services maintained
  • Public Works
    • 1 of 2 positions cut restored,
    • Cut salary funds re-directed to capital R&M funding
    • Not sufficient for needs – but step in right direction of recurring operating expense for R&M
  • Police
    • 2 positions cut restored
    • Maintain existing detective division, overnight patrol staffing, and community resource officer / mental health liaison co-response capacities.
  • Fire / EMS
    • 2 cut positions restored
    • Ability to hire / fill the growing vacancies – resignations due to instability mean EFD will enter FY26 non-override down 8 firefighters (20% of department).
    • Maintain existing ambulance response (2 available)

29 of 35

4. INCREASE TAX ABATEMENTS & EXEMPTIONS:�SENIORS, VETERANS & INDIVIDUALS W/ DISABILITIES��$150,000

  • Increase annual allowance for abatements and exemptions by $150,000 (up 30% from FY26 request) to:
    • Potentially double the tax breaks on most existing statutory exemptions – index veterans abatements to increase w/ inflation
    • Enhance capacity for forthcoming FY26-28 local Circuit Breaker program passed with the muni building project
  • PASE Community Compact
    • Acceptance of various state options to increase tax exemptions in Easton are included on Town Meeting Warrant (Article 3)
    • Contingent on the override passing
  • Coupled with county ARPA award for Tax Aid Committee and SERVES – would bring Easton’s annual financial assistance in FY26 to ≈$900,000 – 1,000,000

30 of 35

5. RESTORATION OF CUTS TO INSURANCE BUDGET��$40,000

  • Restoration of Town’s Contribution to OPEB Trust Fund
    • Recurring contribution to the fund
  • Increase allowance for health insurance from expected job restorations
  • Pending finalization of property, casualty, and liability insurance
  • Resolution by April 29th
    • Will lead to adjustments to amount or necessity of override funding of this item.

31 of 35

6. CREATION OF OVERRIDE STABILIZATION FUND��$800,000

  • PASE recommendation:
    • $7.3 million override,
    • $800,000 in efficiencies / cuts
  • Purpose of Override Stabilization Fund
    • Diverts $800,000 into fund to offset future wages and insurance costs- largest cost drivers in the budget
    • Fund can only be appropriated by voters at Town Meeting
  • Necessity of Override Stabilization Fund
    • Override positions Easton to be more sustainable
    • 4% annual budget caps on Town and School operations
    • But as PASE analysis showed – will be struggle to maintain services without reducing budgets by FY2028 – should NOT allocate out all $7.3M to operating spending in year one (FY26)
    • Recommend $800,000 to this fund to extend the benefit of the override consistent with PASE Compact.

32 of 35

DRAFT PENDING FINALIZATION BY APRIL 29, 2025

33 of 35

Important Resources to Stay Informed

  • SIGN UP FOR THE TOWN’S WEEKLY NEWSLETTER – www.Easton.ma.us/towncrier

  • Visit www.Easton.ma.us/override for all information relating to the budget choices voters have this spring.
  • If you are joining discussion for 1st time – please read the Promoting A Sustainable Easton Frequently Asked Questionswww.Easton.ma.us/paseFAQ

34 of 35

Key Dates for the Community

LEARN & ENGAGE

  • April 29, 6:30PM, OAHS Auditorium – FY26 Final Budget Hearing �Select Board & Finance Committee
    • Balanced budget (reserves & cuts) and override budget will be presented and recommendations voted by elected leadership
  • May 7, 6:00 PM, OAHS Atrium/Auditorium - Final PASE Open House
    • PASE presentation
    • Q&A with PASE and town/school

COMMUNITY VOTES

  • May 19, 7:00 PM, OAHS Auditorium – Annual Town Meeting
    • Vote 1 of 2 to Pass / Reject Override
  • June 10, 7AM-8PM, OAHS – Special Town Election: Override
    • Vote 2 of 2 to Pass / Reject Override

35 of 35

Thank You