1 of 20

Changes In Benthic Communities Along A Presumed Pollution Gradient In Vancouver Harbour

Kehinde Olajide, Paul Olatunji, and Mujeeb Balogun

2 of 20

Summary

  • Introduction
  • PICES intervention
  • Objectives
  • Study area
  • Methodology
  • Sampling method
  • AMBI
  • Result and Discussion
  • Conclusion
  • Observations and Recommendations

3 of 20

Introduction

  • The late 1800s saw the beginning of shipping and industry in Vancouver Harbour.
  • Petroleum refineries, shipyards, chlorine plant, seafood processing plants, fuel loading docks, and marinas were among the other industries that sprung up along the shoreline around 1900.
  • The residual contamination of the industries may still be present at the harbour even though some are no longer active. (Levings et al., 2004).

4 of 20

Introduction Cont’d

Pollution source and disturbance in the harbour

  • In 1999, around 8 million tonnes of ballast water were released into the harbour.
  • Harbour shoreline modification for dock construction together with other activities.
  • Burrard Inlet has around 36 allowed discharges (municipal and industrial effluent) and 32 unauthorised combined sewer overflows (CSOs) to the marine environment (Levings and Samis, 2001a).

5 of 20

PICES intervention

  • The North Pacific Marine Science Organization  (PICES) Practical Workshop in1999 considered these different research area;

​

    • A wide range of data was collected, including
    • benthic invertebrate and fish community structure,
    • evaluation of fish health using biological markers and exposure data,
    • evaluation of contaminant exposure in intertidal invertebrates,
    • imposex in gastropods, and
    • information about natural toxins produced by algae.

6 of 20

Objectives

  • To establish the pollution gradient in Vancouver harbour by examining the benthic communities of the harbour using AMBI and M-AMBI

​

  • To compare and contrast the ecological quality derived from AMBI with other methods used by the PICES

7 of 20

Study area

  • Sediment, benthos, and intertidal invertebrates were collected from seven sites in Vancouver Harbour.
  • The port is made up of four bodies of water:
    • the Outer Burrard Inlet or English Bay,
    • the Inner Burrard Inlet,
    • the Port Moody Arm, and
    • the Indian Arm.
  • Except for a far field reference all of the PICES sampling stations were located on the water bodies.

Levings et al., 2011b

8 of 20

Methodology

  • In the reviewed paper, the stations were grouped and analysed using
    • ANOVA,
    • Abundance–Biomass Comparisons (ABC) and related statistics,
    • cluster analysis,
    • multidimensional scaling, and
    • the BIOENV procedure. (Je et al., 2004)

​

​

  • Two stations (B-41B and B-38) were positioned in the Inner Harbour (Port Moody Arm), three in the Central Harbour (B-48, B-11B, and B-3A), one in the Outer Harbour (B-49), and the reference one in Howe Sound near Gibsons (B-50).

9 of 20

Sampling method

  • A van Veen grab (0.1 m2) was used to take five samples of at least 5 L volume from each location (making 5 replicates for each station).
  • Each grab sample was poured into a clean plastic container before being sieved using a 0.5 mm mesh screen.
  • The residual fauna on the sieve was fixed with a 10% formalin solution that had been neutralised by seawater.
  • The fauna was classified into major taxonomic groups and identified to the presumed species level as much as possible in the laboratory.
  • A total of 171 identifiable species and 3,348 individuals from eight phyla were discovered.

​

10 of 20

AMBI

  • AMBI was downloaded and installed from https://ambi.azti.es/
  • The data was extracted from Je and Belan (2001) and computed in an excel format
  • AMBI was used to analysed the abundance data in the excel sheet and biotic indices were generated for each station.

11 of 20

AMBI Cont’d

  • Undisturbed communities: 0 to ≤1.2
  • Slightly disturbed: 1.2 to ≤3.3
  • Moderately disturbed: 3.3 to ≤5
  • Heavily disturbed: 5 to ≤6
  • Extremely disturbed: 6 to 7

(Borja et al., 2006)

Total changes made = 102

Not assigned = 28

No of changes (spelling, species, grouping) = 74

Group suggestions by AMBI was followed

12 of 20

AMBI result and Discussion

AMBI Biotic indices by stations

​

W statistics and SEP from the reviewed paper

13 of 20

LOCATION

STATIONS

SITE POLLUTION CLASSIFICATION

AMBI

DOMINATING ECOLOGICAL GROUP

Inner harbour

Station B 38

Moderately Disturbed

3.54

IV

Station B-41B

Slightly disturbed

2.19

II

Central harbour

Station B48

Slightly disturbed

2.52

III

Station 3A

Slightly disturbed

2.35

III

Station B11

Slightly disturbed

2.5

III

Outer harbour

Station B-49

Slightly disturbed

2.37

III

Reference station

Station B50

Slightly disturbed

1.77

III

14 of 20

AMBI Result and Discussion

  • AMBI indices showed that the community in station B-38 is in-between moderately and slightly disturbed. This correlates well with the report in the reviewed paper which indicate that station B-38 is severely disturbed.
  • However, station B-48 is not in the same group with B-38 as portrayed by W statistics and SEP but it fits well in the same group with B-49 in slightly disturbed category.
  • In AMBI, stations B-11B, B-3A, B-41B are in the same category of slightly disturbed which is the same as the one represented in the original work using W statistics and SEP
  • Station B-50 is in the category of slightly disturbed but tending to undisturbed which is similar to the one indicated using W statistics and SEP. This suggest that B-50 is the right reference station as proposed.

15 of 20

Result and Discussion

16 of 20

Comparison between M-AMBI & the reviewed paper

  • It is likely that the suite of stations sampled did not necessarily represent a continuum along a pollution gradient, and ecosystems in Thornbrough Channel supported different benthic communities because of natural factors not present at the other stations (e.g., coarser sediments).

​

  • Contaminants originates from the harbour are likely dispersed into the Strait of Georgia via a variety of oceanographic processes and the reference is not necessarily at the ‘‘low concentration’’ end of the gradient.

17 of 20

Conclusion

  • AMBI is an excellent and easy to use tool for assessing Ecological quality assessment using benthic communities data
  • With M-AMBI, we were able to establish the pollution gradient of Vancouver harbour with Station B-38 having the least ecological quality and the reference station, B-50 having the highest ecological quality status
  • Hence, it is evident that the result from AMBI tool is comparable to other ecological assessment tools when used appropriately.

​

18 of 20

Observations

  • Inconsistences in the data labelling
  • No reasons for some conclusions
  • Station B-41B being an outlier may probably be due to the hydrodynamics of the inner harbour
  • Problems with AMBI’s initialisation

​

Recommendation

  • There should be assurance of correct naming and grouping of the species in AMBI database to ensure increase in accuracy and efficiency of the biotic indices.
  • A new version with improved platform compatibility (Windows & Mac)

19 of 20

References

  • Borja, Á., Muxika, I., & Franco, J. (2006). Long-term recovery of soft-bottom benthos following urban and industrial sewage treatment in the Nervión estuary (southern Bay of Biscay). Marine Ecology Progress Series, 313, 43-55.
  • Je, J.G. and Belan, T. (2001). Tabulated data from benthic surveys (Table 53 - numerical data) in Stehr, C.M. and T. Horiguchi (Eds) Environmental Assessment of Vancouver Harbour, Data Report for the PICES Practical Workshop. PICES Scientific Report No. 16. 205 pp
  • Je, J. G., Belan, T., Levings, C., & Koo, B. J. (2004). Changes in benthic communities along a presumed pollution gradient in Vancouver Harbour. Marine Environmental Research, 57(1-2), 121-135.
  • Levings, C. D., Stein, J. E., Stehr, C. M., & Samis, S. C. (2004). Introduction to the PICES practical workshop: objectives, overview of the study area, and projects conducted by the participants. Marine environmental research, 57(1-2), 3-18.
  • Levings, C. D., & Samis, S. (2001a). Section II site description and oceanography. In Environmental assessment of Vancouver Harbour data report for the PICES practical workshop (p. 15).
  • Levings, C. D., Stehr, C. M., & Stein, J. E. (2001b) Section I Practical Workshop Description.

20 of 20

Thank you for listening

Any questions?