Rolling-Contact Bearings
CHAPTER 11
Lecture slides · MECH 420
1
Chapter outline
Section | Topic | Book page |
11–1 | Bearing types | 576 |
11–2 | Bearing life | 579 |
11–3 | Bearing load life at rated reliability | 580 |
11–4 | Reliability versus life: the Weibull distribution | 582 |
11–5 | Relating load, life, and reliability | 583 |
11–6 | Combined radial and thrust loading | 585 |
11–7 | Variable loading | 590 |
11–8 | Selection of ball and cylindrical roller bearings | 593 |
2
11–1 Bearing types
Rolling-contact bearings carry a load between parts in relative rotation with very little friction; their most common job is supporting a rotating shaft.
Ball bearings
The rolling elements are balls, which touch the raceways at a point. They run at very high speeds, but for a given size they carry less load.
Roller bearings
The rolling elements are rollers, which touch the raceways along a line. The longer contact gives a higher load rating than a ball bearing of the same size, at the cost of more friction and a lower speed limit.
3
Nomenclature of a ball bearing
Every rolling bearing has four essential parts:
4
Ball bearings: Deep-groove
The most widely used type. Its simple construction makes it easy to maintain and tolerant of operating conditions. Besides radial load it takes thrust in both directions, and its low friction torque suits high speeds.
Property | Rating |
Radial | Moderate |
Axial | Moderate, both ways |
Speed | Very high |
Typical uses: electric motors, fans, small gearboxes.
Radial
Axial
Axial
5
Ball bearings: Angular-contact
The raceways meet the ball at a contact angle, so load passes from one ring to the other along an inclined line. This makes it suitable for combined loads with a large axial component.
Property | Rating |
Radial | Moderate |
Axial | High, one way |
Speed | High |
Typical uses: machine-tool spindles, pumps; usually in pairs.
Radial
Axial
one way only
6
Ball bearings: Self-aligning
Two rows of balls in a cage, a double-row inner raceway and one continuous spherical outer raceway. The inner ring and balls can tilt inside the outer ring, so it tolerates shaft deflection and shaft–housing misalignment. Best for radial load.
Property | Rating |
Radial | Moderate |
Axial | Light |
Misalignment | Large |
Typical uses: long or flexible shafts, agricultural and textile machinery.
Radial
Light axial
7
Ball bearings: Thrust
Two discs (washers) with raceways for the balls. Designed only for axial load in one direction, so it locates the shaft axially one way.
Property | Rating |
Radial | None |
Axial | Moderate, one way |
Speed | Low |
Typical uses: vertical shafts, turntables.
No radial load
Axial
one way only
8
Roller bearings: Cylindrical
Line contact between rollers and raceways spreads the contact stress, giving a very high radial load rating. Some designs also pass a limited axial load.
Property | Rating |
Radial | Very high |
Axial | None to limited |
Speed | High |
Typical uses: gearboxes, motors; the floating bearing of a shaft.
Heavy radial
No axial load
9
Roller bearings: Spherical
A robust, self-aligning design like the self-aligning ball bearing, but with barrel-shaped rollers instead of balls, so it carries more. Handles high radial and moderate axial loads and accommodates misalignment.
Property | Rating |
Radial | Very high |
Axial | Moderate, both ways |
Misalignment | Large |
Typical uses: heavy machinery, conveyors, vibrating screens.
Heavy radial
Axial
Axial
10
Roller bearings: Tapered
Conical rollers run between tapered inner and outer raceways. Because of the contact angle it carries high radial load plus axial load in one direction; two are often mounted as a pair to take thrust both ways.
Property | Rating |
Radial | High |
Axial | High, one way |
Speed | Moderate |
Typical uses: wheel hubs, gearbox shafts; in opposed pairs.
Heavy radial
Axial
one way only
11
Roller bearings: Needle
A cylindrical roller bearing with long, thin rollers (needles). High load rating for its size, radial load only. A good choice where radial space is tight.
Property | Rating |
Radial | High for its size |
Axial | None |
Speed | Moderate |
Typical uses: rocker arms, planet gears, universal joints.
Radial
No axial load
12
11–2 Bearing life: definitions
Life
The number of revolutions (or the hours at a given speed) a single bearing runs before it fails.
Rating life, L₁₀
The life that 90% of a group of bearings reach or exceed; i.e. the life at which 10% have failed. Also called the minimum life or L₁₀ life.
Median life
The life at which 50% of the bearings have failed, found over many groups. Sometimes called the average life. It is typically 4 to 5 times the L₁₀ life.
13
11–3 Load rating definitions
Catalog load rating, C₁₀: the constant radial load under which 10% of a group fail at the manufacturer’s rating life.
Depends on type, geometry, manufacturing accuracy and material.
If the manufacturer’s rating life is 10⁶ revolutions, the catalog load rating is often called the Basic Dynamic Load Rating, or sometimes just the Basic Load Rating. The radial load needed to cause failure at such a low life would be unrealistically high, so the Basic Load Rating is a reference value, not an actual load to be achieved by a bearing.
Static load rating, C₀: the load causing permanent deformation of a raceway or rolling element, measured with the bearing not rotating.
Used to check against permanent deformation, and to combine radial and thrust loads into an equivalent load.
Equivalent radial load, Fₑ: the constant, stationary radial load which, with the inner ring rotating, gives the same life as the actual loads and rotation conditions.
14
Load–life relationship (1)
Groups of nominally identical bearings are run to the failure criterion at several loads. On log–log axes, load against life falls close to a straight line, which a regression fit expresses as
(11–1)
F = radial load (constant for each test group); L = life in revolutions, at which 10% of the group has failed.
A point on the line: the rating life L₁₀ and the catalog load rating C₁₀.
Figure 11–4 Typical bearing load–life log–log curve.
15
Catalog data for ball bearings (Table 11–2)
Single-row 02-series deep-groove and angular-contact ball bearings. Shoulder diameters dₛ, dₕ in mm; load ratings in kN.
Table 11–2 Dimensions and Load Ratings for Single-Row 02-Series Deep-Groove and Angular-Contact Ball Bearings
16
Why is C₁₀ larger than C₀?
The two ratings describe different kinds of failure, so neither is bounded by the other.
C₀
Static load rating: a deformation limit
Bearing not rotating
C₁₀
Dynamic load rating: a fatigue reference
Bearing rotating
In design, real loads sit far below both: use C₁₀ in Eq. (11–3) or (11–9) to check fatigue life, and check peak or shock loads against C₀ so the raceways never brinell. For some roller bearings, C₀ is close to or even above C₁₀.
17
Catalog data for cylindrical roller bearings (Table 11–3)
02-series and 03-series; load ratings in kN.
Table 11–3 Dimensions and Basic Load Ratings for Cylindrical Roller Bearings
18
Load–life relationship (2)
Writing Eq. (11–1) for two load–life conditions:
(11–2)
Let condition 1 be the catalog rating conditions (subscript R) and condition 2 the desired design conditions (subscript D):
(a)
L is in revolutions. For a life ℒ in hours at a speed n in rev/min, with 60 min/h, L = 60ℒn, so
19
Load–life relationship (3)
Solving (a) for
gives the catalog load rating:
(11–3)
•
The design load
and design life
are given by the problem.
•
The rated life
is set by the bearing manufacturer; many catalogs use
= 10⁶ rev.
•
The resulting C₁₀ is what you look up in the catalog.
A convenient dimensionless multiple of rating life is
20
Example 11–1
A bearing maker (SKF*) rates its bearings at 10⁶ revolutions. The application needs a life of 5000 h at 1725 rev/min under 400 lbf, at 90% reliability. What catalog rating should you look for?
Note: the bearing type is not given. Assume a ball bearing (a = 3), since ball bearings are SKF’s most popular product.
* SKF = Svenska Kullagerfabriken (Swedish Ball Bearing Factory), a Swedish bearing manufacturer founded in Gothenburg in 1907.
21
Example 11–1
A bearing maker (SKF*) rates its bearings at 10⁶ revolutions. The application needs a life of 5000 h at 1725 rev/min under 400 lbf, at 90% reliability. What catalog rating should you look for?
Solution
Rating life:
Eq. (11–3), a = 3:
* SKF = Svenska Kullagerfabriken (Swedish Ball Bearing Factory), a Swedish bearing manufacturer founded in Gothenburg in 1907.
22
11–4 Reliability versus life: the Weibull distribution
At constant load, bearing lives are skewed to the right, which the Weibull distribution fits well. With the dimensionless life x = L/L₁₀, the reliability is
(11–4)
23
11–5 Relating load, life, and reliability (1)
Figure 11–5 Constant reliability contours. Point A represents the catalog rating C₁₀ at x = L/L₁₀ = 1. Point B is on the target reliability design line RD, with a load of C₁₀. Point D is a point on the desired reliability contour exhibiting the design life xD = LD/L₁₀ at the design load FD.
A: catalog data, at C₁₀ and x₁₀ = 1, on the R = 0.90 line.
D: design data, at FD and xD, on the R = RD line.
The designer goes from D to A by way of B.
24
Relating load, life, and reliability (2)
Fig. 11–5: D → B along the design line, B → A at load C₁₀.
25
Relating load, life, and reliability (2)
1. Along the constant-reliability line BD:
2. B is on the R =
line, so at load C₁₀, Eq. (11–4) gives
Solving for
3. Putting
into the BD relation:
4. With
= C₁₀ and an application factor
(11–9)
For
= 0.90 the denominator is one and (11–9) becomes (11–3).
Fig. 11–5: D → B along the design line, B → A at load C₁₀.
= application factor
A factor of safety that increases the design load to account for overload, dynamic loading, and uncertainty.
Typical values: Table 11–5 (slide 36).
26
Weibull parameters
Table 11–6 Typical Weibull Parameters for Two Manufacturers
27
Relating load, life, and reliability (4)
(11–9)
For easier calculator entry, note that
pf = probability of failure
so Eq. (11–9) is approximately
(11–10)
28
Example 11–3
Ball bearing; design load 413 lbf with application factor 1.2; shaft speed 300 rev/min; life 30 kh at reliability 0.99. Find the C₁₀ to look for in a deep-groove catalog rated at 10⁶ revolutions, with Weibull parameters x₀ = 0.02, (θ − x₀) = 4.439, b = 1.483.
29
Example 11–3
Ball bearing; design load 413 lbf with application factor 1.2; shaft speed 300 rev/min; life 30 kh at reliability 0.99. Find the C₁₀ to look for in a deep-groove catalog rated at 10⁶ revolutions, with Weibull parameters x₀ = 0.02, (θ − x₀) = 4.439, b = 1.483.
Solution
The design life is 540 rating lives. For a ball bearing a = 3, and Eq. (11–10) gives
Answer: C₁₀ ≥ 6696 lbf
30
Combined reliability of multiple bearings
When several bearings work together, on a shaft or in a gearbox, the overall reliability is the product of the individual reliabilities. For two bearings A and B:
31
11–6 Combined radial and thrust loading (1)
A ball bearing carrying both a thrust load Fₐ and a radial load Fᵣ is treated through an equivalent radial load Fₑ that does the same damage.
Tests give a plot of Fₑ/(VFᵣ) against Fₐ/(VFᵣ).
V is a rotation factor for the different ball kinematics when the outer ring, rather than the inner ring, rotates:
Figure 11–6
32
Combined radial and thrust loading (2)
Two straight lines approximate the data:
(11–11a)
(11–11b)
X is the intercept and Y the slope: Fₑ equals Fᵣ while Fₐ/Fᵣ is small, and starts to grow once Fₐ/Fᵣ passes e.
Written as one equation:
(11–12)
X and Y depend on the geometry and construction of the particular bearing.
Figure 11–6
33
Equivalent radial load factors for ball bearings
Table 11–1 Equivalent Radial Load Factors for Ball Bearings
X, Y for a given bearing come from its catalog; Table 11–1 gives typical values.
X and Y depend on e, and e depends on Fₐ/C₀.
C₀ is the basic static load rating, listed in the catalog.
* Use 0.014 if Fₐ/C₀ < 0.014. Columns headed ≤ e or > e refer to Fₐ/(VFᵣ).
34
Bearing-life recommendations (Table 11–4)
Table 11–4 Bearing-Life Recommendations for Various Classes of Machinery
35
Recommended load-application factors (Table 11–5)
Table 11–5 Load-Application Factors
36
Example 11–4
An SKF 6210 angular-contact ball bearing carries Fₐ = 400 lbf and Fᵣ = 500 lbf with the outer ring stationary; C₀ = 4450 lbf and C₁₀ = 7900 lbf. Estimate the ℒ life at 720 rev/min.
37
Example 11–4 (1)
An SKF 6210 angular-contact ball bearing carries Fₐ = 400 lbf and Fᵣ = 500 lbf with the outer ring stationary; C₀ = 4450 lbf and C₁₀ = 7900 lbf. Estimate the ℒ₁₀ life at 720 rev/min.
Solution
V = 1 and Fₐ/C₀ = 400/4450 = 0.090. Interpolate for e in Table 11–1:
Fₐ/C₀ | e |
0.084 | 0.28 |
0.090 | e |
0.110 | 0.30 |
so e = 0.285
38
Example 11–4 (2)
Fₐ/(VFᵣ) = 400/[(1)500] = 0.8 > 0.285, so interpolate for Y₂:
Fₐ/C₀ | Y₂ |
0.084 | 1.55 |
0.090 | Y₂ |
0.110 | 1.45 |
so Y₂ = 1.527
From Eq. (11–12):
With
= ℒ₁₀ and
= Fₑ, Eq. (11–3) solved for ℒ₁₀:
39
11–8 Selection of ball and cylindrical roller bearings
Example 11–7 (1)
The second shaft of a 25-hp parallel-shaft foundry crane reducer carries a helical gear of 8.08-in pitch diameter. The gear force components act at A (Fig. 11–12); the simple-support reactions at C and D are shown in the figure. C gets a ball bearing that takes the thrust; D gets a cylindrical roller bearing. Life goal 10 kh; the four bearings of the reducer (both shafts) together must have reliability ≥ 0.96, Weibull parameters x₀ = 0.02, (θ − x₀) = 4.439, b = 1.483 (as in Example 11–3); application factor 1.2.
(a) Select the roller bearing at D.
(b) Select the angular-contact ball bearing at C; the inner ring rotates.
Note: power to speed (Eq. 3–42, U.S. units): H = Tn / 63 025, where H is the power in hp, T the torque on the shaft in lbf·in, and n the speed in rev/min.
Assumption: equal reliability for all four bearings of the reducer.
Fig. 11–12 (redrawn), forces in lbf
40
Example 11–7 (3)
Solution
Torque and speed at rated power (Eq. 3–42):
Radial bearing loads:
Equal reliability for the four bearings:
Dimensionless design life:
41
Example 11–7 (4)
(a) Eq. (11–10) with the Weibull parameters of Example 11–3, af = 1.2 and a = 10/3 for the roller bearing at D:
No thrust here, so the choice is direct: a 02-25 mm or a 03-25 mm cylindrical roller bearing from Table 11–3.
Answer
42
Example 11–7 (5)
(b) The ball bearing at C has a thrust component, so selection is iterative. Assuming Fₐ/(VFᵣ) > e:
43
Example 11–7 (6)
First approximation, the middle entry of Table 11–1: X₂ = 0.56, Y₂ = 1.63. Eq. (11–12) with V = 1:
Eq. (11–10) with a = 3:
Table 11–2: angular-contact 02-60 mm, C₁₀ = 55.9 kN, C₀ = 35.5 kN.
44
Example 11–7 (7)
Step 4, with Fₐ in kN:
which gives e ≈ 0.24 from Table 11–1. Fₐ/(VFᵣ) = 344/[(1)464.4] = 0.74 > 0.24, so interpolate for Y₂:
Fₐ/C₀ | Y₂ |
0.042 | 1.85 |
0.043 | Y₂ |
0.056 | 1.71 |
so Y₂ = 1.84
45
Example 11–7 (8)
Eq. (11–12):
Only Fₑ changed, so
Table 11–2: angular-contact 02-65 mm, C₁₀ = 63.7 kN, C₀ = 41.5 kN. Again:
so e ≈ 0.23; Fₐ/(VFᵣ) = 0.74 > 0.23. Interpolating, Y₂ between 1.99 (0.028) and 1.85 (0.042) gives Y₂ = 1.90.
46
Example 11–7 (9)
Eq. (11–12):
Only Fₑ changed, so
Table 11–2 still gives the angular-contact 02-65 mm, so the iteration has converged.
Answer: 02-65 mm angular-contact ball bearing
47
Problem 11–37
A worm shaft transmits 1.2 hp at 500 rev/min; the static force analysis is shown below. Bearing A is an angular-contact ball bearing from Table 11–2 that takes the 555-lbf thrust. Bearing B takes radial load only: an 02-series cylindrical roller bearing from Table 11–3. Use af = 1.2, a life of 30 kh, a combined reliability of 0.99 and manufacturer 2 Weibull data (Table 11–6). Specify both bearings.
Take R = 1 for bearing B and R = 0.99 for bearing A.
48
Solution: bearing B (straight roller)
The smallest bearing in Table 11–3 is rated 16.8 kN, so choose the 02-25 mm straight cylindrical roller bearing.
49
Solution: bearing A (angular-contact ball)
Middle entry of Table 11–1: X₂ = 0.56, Y₂ = 1.63.
Select 02-85 mm angular-contact: C₁₀ = 90.4 kN, C₀ = 63.0 kN.
interpolating: X₂ = 0.56, Y₂ = 1.88
50
Solution: bearing A (continued)
Trial 2: try the 02-90 mm angular-contact ball bearing, C₁₀ = 106 kN, C₀ = 73.5 kN.
Table 11–1, interpolating: X₂ = 0.56, Y₂ = 1.93
Select an 02-90 mm angular-contact ball bearing.
51