1 of 16

Battle of the Batteries

Bela Cortwright, Chris Linthacum, Lu Zheyu, and Aitan Haoyang Wu

2 of 16

Background

  • Battery packs are ubiquitous
  • Little information exists on performance
  • Evaluate different capacities and phone performance

3 of 16

Hypothesis

  • There is no correlation between charging speed and power bank capacity
  • There will be a difference in charging speed between the Google and Xiaomi phones

4 of 16

Literature Review

  • Study focused on how temperature affects battery performance

​

  • Minimal research pertaining to our specific topic

Source: Research on Modeling of Internal Resistance Characteristics of Li-ion Batteries

5 of 16

Input Variables & Levels

  • Power bank capacity
    • 5,000 mAh
    • 10,000 mAh
    • 20,000 mAh
  • Type of phone
    • Google Pixel 3XL
    • Xiaomi RedMi K20

Source: Verizon

Source: Android Police

6 of 16

Response Variables

  • Charging rate
    • Amount charged (mAh) /

time (min)

    • From 30% to 60%
  • Measurement
    • App called AccuBattery
    • Documented mAh and time on an Excel spreadsheet

Source: Accubattery

7 of 16

Control Variables

  • Power delivery method
    • Same USB-C cable
  • Same charging starting and ending point
    • 30%-60%
  • Environment
    • Same temperature (about 20° C)
  • Power banks were fully charged

8 of 16

Experimental Design

  • Used JMP to randomize order
  • 3 samples for each treatment
  • Two-way ANOVA

​

Google Pixel 3XL

Xiaomi RedMi K20

5,000 mAh

A1

B1

10,000 mAh

A2

B2

20,000 mAh

A3

B3

9 of 16

Experimental setup

  • Drain phone to 30%
  • Charge power bank fully
  • Plug in phone
  • Do not use phone
  • Unplug once at 60%
  • Document data from AccuBattery App

10 of 16

Two-Way ANOVA Table

Source

D.F.

Sum of Squares

Mean Squares

F Ratio

Prob > F

Type of Phone

1

86.667

86.667

90.440

~0

Capacity of

Power Bank

2

128.140

64.075

66.865

~0

Interaction

2

18.509

9.254

9.657

0.003167

Error

12

11.499

0.9583

​

​

C. Total

17

244.825

​

​

​

11 of 16

Interaction Plot

12 of 16

Analysis of Model

13 of 16

Assumption Analysis

Independence

Constant Variance

14 of 16

Assumption Analysis

Normality

15 of 16

Interaction between two Variables

  • Both power bank size and phone type affect charging rate
  • If given more time, we would like to:
    • Perform a greater number of samples
    • Test additional models of phones
    • Use new power banks

​

16 of 16

Questions?