1 of 28

The Third Century Project

First United Methodist Church

of Ann Arbor

November 8, 2026

2 of 28

What we hope you leave with today

  • A shared understanding of where we are today and how we are moving forward so that future congregant engagement can be as productive as possible.

​

  • The scope of the Bonner Advisory Group Team work.

​

  • Sense of excitement for the opportunities ahead.

​

​

​

3 of 28

Generations of ministry

1827 — Methodist Society organized

1940 — Three churches before the current building was dedicated

1950s — Education wing added

1981 — Memorial Garden dedicated

Each generation adapted buildings & property to the ministry needs of its time.

Circa 1870

4 of 28

Adaptation continues

2000–06 — Major renovations to west entry, social hall, sanctuary

2020-26 — Livestreaming; Green Wood Sanctuary renovation; new playground; A/V upgrades; income from rentals (kitchen, parking)

2026 — Bonner Advisory Group team engaged

5 of 28

FUMC AA & Wesley today

1.77 acres downtown - intersection of U of M & city

47,305 square feet of building - equal to 21+ single family homes

1,100 square feet in the Memorial Garden - over 500 internments

6 of 28

Why this work began

  • Strategic planning since ‘19 confirms desire to remain downtown
  • Our ministries have changing needs
  • Attendance and membership have declined.
  • Congregational giving is not a resilient

long-term model.

  • An aging campus needs ongoing care

and investment.

​

​

7 of 28

What we’ve heard we need in our space…

  • Community building/building community
  • Inviting entrances
  • Welcoming & flexible spaces
  • Right-sized for congregational participation
  • Safety & security
  • Outdoor space
  • Practical parking
  • Energy efficiency
  • Financial stability

​

8 of 28

The stewardship question

  • FUMC has been operating at a deficit
  • The endowment has been helpful but it’s not a solution
  • Our 47,000 sq. ft. building is big and beautiful; maintenance and upgrades will be expensive for future generations
  • FUMC is financially stable today; the future is

uncertain

  • Our mission, ministry and maintenance

budgets are limited by congregational giving

9 of 28

Building on generations of care

Our building remains in service because generations of Trustees and members have cared for it.

​

We have a new opportunity to create more intentional spaces and greater financial resilience

10 of 28

How we arrived here

2023: Wesley identified a vision for a living, learning,

and worshiping community in a new space.

2024-2025: The FUMC taskforce consulted legal, housing,

development, and finance experts.

2026: FUMC reached our limits; hired experts to evaluate property development potential and help define FUMC needs.

​

​

​

2019-2022: FUMC strategic planning and visioning work

11 of 28

Bonner Advisory Group assignment

  • Engage the congregation and study building needs.
  • Help identify what is desirable and profitable for a developer.
  • Analyze financial benefits & tradeoffs to the church.
  • Prepare a developer request for proposals.

​

​

​

Bonner provides independent professional help. The church decides.

12 of 28

The next stage

  • Shared knowledge baseline - what we are doing now
  • Congregation and user group participation starts today
  • Scenario review and trade-off discussions
  • Recommendations and formal decisions

​

Conversations will focus on priorities, concerns, and tradeoffs.

13 of 28

Unknowns

  • Whether redevelopment proceeds
  • Which existing structures remain
  • Future uses, density, parking, and phasing
  • Financial structure, developer, timing,

and final approval

​

14 of 28

Today’s invitation

As we enter the process be open, curious and committed to learning. We hope you will share openly and with care for the generations that will follow us.

15 of 28

First United Methodist

hurch of Ann Arbor

2

A PLACE TO THRIVE

16 of 28

The project team

One Team. Assembled with your needs in mind.

BONNER ADVISORY GROUP

Lead Consultant

Luke Bonner, CEO

26 years SE Michigan economic development experience with over 300 projects and $15B+ in Michigan investment. Focus on community engagement, incentive procurement, real estate advisory and developer negotiations.

Deep local market relationships.

Recently completed a real estate development feasibility study for City of Riverview.

GRITTER REAL ESTATE SERVICES

Real Estate & Entitlements

Tom Gritter, Founder

22 years in site planning, brokerage, real estate development, and project management.

Directly comparable experience guiding faith-based institutions through facilities strategy and redevelopment, including multiple Ann Arbor organizations (Ann Arbor Christian School, Grace Churches).

HOBBS+BLACK ARCHITECTS

Architecture & Site Evaluation

Megan Hon, Senior Associate

Hobbs+Black Architects is a full-service architecture and planning firm headquartered in Ann Arbor, MI with over 60 years of experience and 80+ professionals across five Michigan offices and Phoenix.

Has an extensive portfolio of Ann Arbor projects, including church facilities, student housing, and complex mixed-use developments.

17 of 28

Lead profile: Luke Bonner

Luke Bonner, CEO

Bonner Advisory Group

Luke Bonner, CEO, has 25 years of economic development experience in the public and private sectors. Over that time, he has supported over 300 corporate projects in which the companies have committed to nearly 15,000 jobs and over $5 billion in new investment in Michigan communities. Luke has authored over 40 tax increment finance and development plans that brought public financing to private development projects. Luke has successfully negotiated economic incentives for the likes of Amazon, Penske Logistics, Huntington National Bank, AJG Aerospace, and Shyft Group. Luke has also successfully managed pre-development approvals for Core Spaces, REDICO, Landmark Real Estate, and Beztak, for multi-story mixed use real estate developments in Ann Arbor, MI.

Luke is an Intermittent Lecturer at the University of Michigan teaching a graduate course in Real Estate Development Public Private Partnerships. Luke was a four-year letter winner for the University of Michigan Baseball team, winning two Big Ten championships and graduating with a degree in Psychology. After graduating, Luke played minor league baseball with the Cleveland Indians, and eventually returned to receive a Masters in Liberal Studies and Public Administration from Eastern Michigan University.

18 of 28

Lead profile: Tom Gritter

Tom Gritter, Founder

Gritter Real Estate Services

Tom Gritter, Founder and Managing Partner has over 22 years of real estate brokerage, development and business advisory experience across the hospitality, multifamily and commercial real estate industries. Tom began his career at Victor International, a luxury land development company specializing in resort development. At Victor Tom worked primarily on Bay Harbor, the ULI Award Winning 1,100-acre luxury resort developed on a brownfield site in northern Michigan and Oil Nut Bay, a 600-acre resort development on Virgin Gorda in the British Virgin Islands.

After Victor, Tom had a ten-year career at McKinley Companies, a full-service real estate investment company in Ann Arbor, MI. Tom led McKinley’s commercial division, managing a portfolio of owned and fee-managed office and retail assets across the country. Tom subsequently performed all ground up and redevelopment multifamily and commercial projects in Michigan and Florida. Tom then joined Wickfield Properties where he was the president of the firm responsible for the company’s operations before he founded Gritter Real Estate Services where he focuses on brokerage, development and incentives.

Tom excels at forming and leading teams to desired outcomes. Tom was a 4-year letterwinner for the University of Michigan Soccer Team, leading the team to the NCAA Elite 8. Tom graduated with high distinction with a BBA from the Ross School of Business at the University of Michigan where Tom now is an Intermittent Lecturer teaching real estate classes for both undergraduate and graduate students.

19 of 28

Lead profile: Megan Hon

Megan Hon, LEED AP

Hobbs+Black Architects

Megan Hon, Senior Associate, has 20 years of experience leading and managing the design of highly impactful projects throughout the Detroit market. Her work spans mixed-use, multifamily, hospitality, food & beverage, corporate workplace, healthcare, retail, and government and institutional projects. Recent work includes Huntington Bank Tower and the BESA Restaurant on Woodward Avenue, and she has been heavily involved in the redevelopment and master planning of the Joe Louis Arena site in downtown Detroit, the first phase of which is under construction.

For FUMC, Megan leads architecture and site evaluation for Hobbs+Black, a firm with an extensive Ann Arbor portfolio that includes church facilities, student housing, and complex mixed-use developments. Her experience in master planning and mixed-use redevelopment helps test how a downtown campus can support both ministry and new development. Megan holds Bachelor degrees in Architecture and Interior Architecture from Lawrence Technological University (2008), is NCIDQ certified and a LEED Accredited Professional, and has been with Hobbs+Black since 2023.

20 of 28

Lead profile: Daniel Clawson

Daniel Clawson

Senior Planner, Hobbs+Black

Daniel Clawson, Senior Retail Planner, translates project design, planning, and interior design into a comprehensive set of contract documents for construction, and coordinates all engineering disciplines for consistency with the design and completeness. Daniel has extensive experience planning retail lifestyle centers and mixed-use developments. He holds a Bachelor of Science in Architecture and Urban Planning from Lawrence Technological University (2013).

Relevant retail and mixed-use experience

Stonebriar Centre: Mall expansion and redevelopment design, interior refresh, food court design

Shopville Le Gru: Phased roof-off renovation, skylight design, new GLA and circulation

Boulevard Berlin: Interior refresh, popup retail design

Southwest Plaza: Interior design and redevelopment, entry design

Beachwood Place: Interior refresh, entry design, exterior lifestyle space design

Pioneer Place: Food court design, redevelopment concepts, new circulation pathways

21 of 28

SITE ADJACENCIES

22 of 28

MARKET OPPORTUNITY - SUMMARY

Market Research

  • UM enrollment is growing: 39,993 to 53,488 students over 20 years (+33.7%); a 70,000 target is reported but unconfirmed
  • Housing supply is catching up: 7,500 beds arrive fall 2026–2028; student housing developers are more selective
  • Hotel rates favor luxury: $241 per night vs. $161 in Ann Arbor and $137 statewide; 71% full in September
  • Downtown can support more: a full-service hotel with 225+ rooms and 50,000 sq. ft. of event space

Active 55+ senior housing

Residential use beyond student housing; demand is not yet sized in these slides

Event space

50,000 sq. ft. paired with 225+ hotel rooms; the quality space to meet demand is missing today

Mixed use

Hotel, event space and housing combined on one site, shaped by flexibility and partnerships

These uses are starting points; the final program will reflect approved developer proposal.

​

23 of 28

SPACE ALLOCATION

EFFICIENCIES

PROGRAMMING

PARTNERSHIPS

FLEXIBILITY

A PLACE TO THRIVE - LAND USE

24 of 28

A PLACE TO THRIVE - LAND USE

25 of 28

First United Methodist Church of Ann Arbor

5

ST. AUSTIN CATHOLIC PARISH AUSTIN, TEXAS

A PLACE TO THRIVE - CASE STUDIES

26 of 28

CENTRAL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH ARLINGTON, VA

A PLACE TO THRIVE - CASE STUDIES

27 of 28

From today to the developer RFP

1

Nov 8

Congregational Level-Set Meeting

2

Nov / Dec

Focus Group / Congregant Meetings

3

Nov / Dec

Developer / 3rd Party Continued Research Discussions

4

Jan / Feb

Refined Site Analyses

5

1Q / 2Q

Congregational Meeting

6

2Q / 3Q

Developer RFP

28 of 28

  • Q&A today
  • Project website will be posted next week
  • Questions/thoughts? email to facilities@fumc-a2.org
  • Third Century Coffee Chats with John & Laura
  • Sunday, November 15th after church and before Harvest Dinner
  • Sunday, December 6 after church in Social Hall
  • More to be announced

Continue learning and sharing