1 of 17

Systematic Review Incubator

Laurel Scheinfeld, Evidence Synthesis Lead, MSLIS, AHIP-D

Lara Nicosia, Health Sciences Librarian, MSLIS, MA, AHIP-M

From Research Question to Submission-Ready Review

2 of 17

Who We Are

  • Health Sciences Librarian since 2026
  • Awarded MLA SRSS Level 1 June 2026
  • Liaison to the Renaissance School of Medicine
  • 16+ years of experience in academic librarianship
  • Evidence Synthesis Lead September 2026
  • Awarded MLA SRSS Level 1 May 2023, Level 2 April 2024
  • Collaborated on my first review in 2018/2019
  • Health Sciences Librarian since 2012

2

Lara Nicosia

Health Sciences Librarian

lara.nicosia@stonybrook.edu

Laurel Scheinfeld

Evidence Synthesis Lead

laurel.scheinfeld@stonybrook.edu

3 of 17

What is Evidence Synthesis?

"Evidence synthesis is a broad term referring to different types of reviews that systematically compile and analyze information from multiple documents such as studies or reports on a similar topic to develop an overall understanding of the results."

3

4 of 17

The Evidence Synthesis Process

  • Protocol / Review Design�Define the research question, eligibility criteria, outcomes, analysis plan, and ideally register the protocol
  • Search�Run database and supplementary searches and deduplicate records
  • Title/Abstract Screening�Screen records against eligibility criteria
  • Full-Text Screening�Retrieve and assess potentially eligible studies; document exclusion reasons
  • Data Extraction�Extract study characteristics, outcomes, effect estimates, and other required data
  • Risk of Bias (Systematic Reviews only)�Assess methodological quality/bias using an appropriate tool.
  • Evidence Synthesis / Meta-Analysis�Combine results statistically when appropriate; otherwise perform narrative or other synthesis
  • Reporting�Create tables/figures, and report results

4

5 of 17

Common Approaches to Evidence Synthesis

Systematic Review

  • Addresses a focused research question
  • Typically takes 12+ months to complete
  • Uses a comprehensive, systematic search strategy
  • Applies predefined eligibility criteria to select studies
  • Assesses risk of bias in included studies
  • Synthesizes findings, with meta-analysis when appropriate

Scoping Review

  • Addresses a broad research question
  • Typically takes 12+ months to complete
  • Uses a comprehensive, systematic search strategy
  • Maps available evidence and identifies research gaps
  • Risk of bias assessment is typically not required

5

6 of 17

Common Approaches to Evidence Synthesis

Meta-Analysis

  • Addresses a focused research question
  • Statistically combines results from multiple studies
  • Produces a pooled estimate of effect
  • Assesses variation (heterogeneity) across studies
  • Typically conducted as part of a systematic review
  • Timeline depends on the review; the statistical analysis itself may take weeks to months

Umbrella Review

  • Addresses a broad or focused research question
  • Typically takes 12+ months to complete
  • Uses a comprehensive, systematic search strategy
  • Includes systematic reviews and meta-analyses
  • Assesses the quality of included reviews
  • Synthesizes evidence across multiple reviews

6

7 of 17

Common Approaches to Evidence Synthesis

Rapid Review

  • Addresses a focused research question
  • Typically takes a few weeks to 6 months
  • Uses streamlined systematic review methods to accelerate the process
  • May limit databases, search dates, languages, or screening procedures
  • Typically includes risk of bias assessment
  • Designed to provide timely evidence for decision-making

7

8 of 17

What is the Incubator?

  • Six-month, project-based cohort, with the option to continue for an additional six months to support project completion (Begins January 2027)
  • Monthly cohort sessions led by librarians with expertise in evidence synthesis
  • Participants enter with a review idea and develop their project throughout the program
  • Instruction is timed to each stage of the review process
  • Sessions combine instruction, discussion, feedback, and project work
  • Participants complete substantial project work between sessions
  • Goal: Move each project toward a submission-ready evidence synthesis manuscript

8

9 of 17

Why Participate

  • Turn your review idea into a completed evidence synthesis project and manuscript
  • Receive structure, guidance, and accountability to keep your project on track within a realistic timeframe
  • Learn and apply established methods for conducting evidence synthesis
  • Participate in a community of researchers and benefit from peer support
  • Work toward a rigorous, submission-ready manuscript aligned with appropriate methodological and PRISMA reporting guidelines

9

10 of 17

Deliverables

At the end of five months, you will have…

  • A registered protocol (e.g., PROSPERO, Open Science Framework)
  • An archived search strategy on searchRxiv

At the end of one year, you will have…

  • A completed evidence synthesis project (e.g., scoping review, systematic review)
  • One dissemination product:
    • A submission-ready manuscript following applicable PRISMA reporting guidelines, OR
    • An academic poster presenting the methodology and findings

10

11 of 17

Program Details

11

Month 1 (January)

Define the review

Evidence synthesis fundamentals; refine topic and research question; identify seed articles and existing reviews; build review team; select methodological guidance; brainstorm key terms

Month 2 (February)

Develop the protocol

Establish inclusion/exclusion criteria; identify databases and gray literature sources; plan screening and co-screeners; begin search strategy; draft protocol; introduce data extraction/charting

Month 3 (March)

Build the search

Develop comprehensive PubMed strategy using MeSH, keywords, and Boolean operators; translate across databases; document for reproducibility; begin manuscript "Introduction" section

Month 4 (April)

Peer review and finalize search

PRESS/peer review of search strategies; incorporate feedback; finalize protocol and searches; register protocol (OSF); archive search strategy (searchRxiv); draft manuscript "Methods" section

Month 5 (May)

Search and screen

Run final searches; set up Covidence; import and deduplicate results; begin title/abstract screening and conflict resolution; determine data to extract

12 of 17

Program Details

12

Months 6-8

(June–August)

Screen, write and progress

Dedicated screening and writing time; individual project check-ins; troubleshoot screening questions and conflicts; address project-specific challenges; catch up as needed; complete title/abstract screening; continue manuscript development; register protocol (e.g., OSF)

13 of 17

Program Details

13

Month 9 (September)

Retrieve and screen

Locate and manage full-text articles; conduct full-text screening; document exclusion reasons; complete citation and gray literature searching; import and screen additional records; resolve screening conflicts

Month 10 (October)

Extract and organize

Create and pilot a Covidence extraction template; apply PRISMA guidance; complete data extraction/charting; organize findings for synthesis; begin drafting "Results" section

Month 11 (November)

Synthesize and interpret

Examine examples of well-written scoping reviews; synthesize and interpret findings; complete evidence synthesis; draft "Results" and "Discussion" sections; update PRISMA flow diagram; continue manuscript revision

Month 12 (December)

Prepare and disseminate

Select an appropriate journal; identify and avoid questionable journals; prepare for manuscript submission and peer review; complete PRISMA checklist; finalize manuscript or prepare an academic poster/presentation

14 of 17

Badges and Certificates

Digital Badges

  • Earned as participants complete key milestones throughout the program
  • Recognize evidence synthesis skills and accomplishments
  • Issued through Brightspace
  • Can be shared as digital credentials, including on professional profiles such as LinkedIn

Certificates of Achievement

  • Awarded at major program milestones
  • 6-Month Certificate: Completion at the foundational phase
  • 12-Month Certificate: Completion of the full evidence synthesis program
  • Recognizes sustained participation and completion of program requirements

14

15 of 17

Application Requirements

  • Program is open to:
    • Undergraduate juniors and seniors
    • Graduate students
    • Professional students
    • Residents and fellows
    • Faculty and clinicians
    • Staff
  • Students are required to submit a letter of support from a faculty mentor or faculty co-author
  • Application will be emailed to all registered participants

15

  • Deadline:�November 13, 2026
  • Notice of Acceptance:�December 1, 2026
  • Program runs:
    • January – May 2027
    • September – December 2027

16 of 17

Share Your

Thoughts!

17 of 17

Thank You!!!

Laurel Scheinfeld, MSLIS, AHIP-D

laurel.scheinfeld@stonybrook.edu

Lara Nicosia, MSLIS, MA, AHIP-M

lara.nicosia@stonybrook.edu