Brought to you by:
With contributions from:
John Perryman, Charles Cappell,
Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP)
Our current system, the history of how we got here, and how to move forward
Racial Inequities
in U.S. Healthcare:
This presentation is meant for educational purposes.
ISPC is a 501(c)3 organization and, as such, does not endorse or oppose any candidates for public office.
Our Current
System
How Did
We Get Here?
Single Payer for Healthcare
Equity
Our Current System
Our current system doesn't work!
All compounded by racial inequities
Deferring Care Due to Cost
Percent of adult ages 19-64 who reported any of the following cost-related access problems:
More bad news…
Different insurers reimburse at different levels
Meanwhile, community and public hospitals have far more uninsured and Medicaid patients.
Hospital try to optimize their 'payer mix' by looking for ways to attract wealthier, private insurance patients.
Hospital Hierarchy
Hospital Cost Per Day
Community and Rural Hospitals are Closing
*This is not a complete list of hospital closures in IL
Mercy Hospital, Chicago, 2021
St Mary’s Hospital, Streator, 2015
St Elizabeth’s, Belleville, 2015
Kenneth Hall, East St Louis, 2011
Jackson Park Hospital, Chicago, 2019
MetroSouth, Blue Island, 2019
Franciscan, Chicago Heights, 2018
Silver Cross, Joliet, 2012
closed its labor & delivery unit
40% of patients on Medicaid
moved 5 miles west to wealthier Olympia Fields
moved 3 miles N to wealthier city New Lenox
moved 7 miles NE to wealthier city O’Fallon
served the uninsured
(4x more than the ntnl avg)
INFANT MORTALITY
PREVENTABLE MORTALITY
LIFE EXPECTANCY
32nd
26th
31st
U.S. Rankings:
The Ultimate Sacrifice:
Excess Deaths Due to Lack of Insurance
Excess deaths in 2022 totaled 34,527
Four more stops on the blue line and life expectancy plummets
-David Ansell
Months of Adult Black Lives Lost as Compared to Whites
Medical prevention and treatment would help 86% of the difference in life expectancy
African Americans ages 18-49 are 2x as likely to die from heart disease than Whites.
African Americans ages 35-64 years are 50% more likely to have high blood pressure than Whites.
The life expectancy of Black Americans is 4 years lower than White Americans
Black Men spend MORE on Health care than other groups
Non-Hispanic Black individuals experienced more than 2-fold
higher cumulative lifetime healthcare expenses compared with individuals of other racial and ethnic groups
American Journal of Preventive Cardiology,Volume 14, 2023
How Did We Get Here?
Under slavery, healthcare was all about maximizing profits for slave owners
Medical Racism in America Goes Back to Our Beginnings
Gordon, 1863
After Slavery Came...
poverty
lack of education
poor work conditions
increased incarceration
segregation
disease
Higher rates of poverty, illiteracy, and low baseline health lead to...
MEDICAL ABUSE
Black people were used for medical teaching & research without consent
Medical Experimentation
Dr. Marion Sims
Tuskegee Experiment
Forced Sterilization
Many states passed sterilization & eugenics laws in the early 1900s, which allowed physicians to sterilize people (without knowledge of consent) deemed unfit to reproduce
MISSISSIPPI “APPENDECTOMIES”
60% of Black women in Sunflower County were sterilized without consent
NATIVE AMERICAN WOMEN
At least 24% of all Native American women sterilized in the 1970s
Hospitals: 1800s-1930s:
Hospitals were mostly private, non-profit
Hospitals were mostly private, non-profit
An ambivalence from white leaders on providing care
Hospitals: 1800s-1930s:
First federal healthcare program: Freedmen’s Bureau
Hospitals were mostly private, non-profit
An ambivalence from white leaders on providing care
Hospitals: 1800s-1930s:
Medical racism is the systematic and widespread racism against people of color within the medical system.
Racism in our society makes Black people less healthy
Biases held by healthcare workers negatively affect the people of color in their care
Disparities in health coverage by race make it more difficult for Black people to find care
1930s & 1940s:
1930s
1930s & 1940s:
1940s
1930s
Passage of Medicare
1964
Passage of Medicare
1965
1964
mandatory insurance
Allowed doctors in the South to discriminate & refuse to care for black people
This provision was lobbied into the bill by the Democratic South
Why is this significant?
Medicare Part A
Medicare Part B
voluntary insurance
Allowed states to establish discriminatory eligibility requirements & determine where benefits offices were located
This provision was lobbied into the bill by the Democratic South
Why is this significant?
Medicare
Medicaid
State administered
Federally administered
Which leads to our current system...
In the meantime...
Our current system...
60% of those uninsured are people of color
Black maternal mortality 3x greater than white maternal mortality
Native Americans live 5.5 years less
Why hasn’t the system changed?
Millions of Dollars Go Towards
Healthcare Lobbying Every Year
Spending of Leading Lobbying Industries in U.S., 2022
The healthcare industry as a whole spent over
$660 million
on lobbying in 2022
This is fear-mongering.
And it is unfounded.
Healthcare providers don’t want to determine who has documentation and who doesn’t.
They just want to provide care.
Single Payer for Healthcare Equity
How It Works
What is Single Payer?
Benefits of Single Payer (SP)
Lower healthcare costs!
More effective in negotiations
Government accountability
More equitable care
Healthcare not tied to employment
Better equipped to improve public health outcomes
Improve provider financial stability
No medical bankruptcies
Transparency
Lifts the burden from employers & local municipalities
Freedom to get care
What Can Single Payer Do?
It can:
It can't:
Universal Healthcare Means
Racial Disparities Nearly Disappear
People of Color are more likely to be uninsured or underinsured than White people.
People of Color are more likely to die from preventable and treatable illnesses.
Fewer healthcare facilities; existing facilities are under-resourced and in danger of closing
Racism is embedded in our healthcare delivery system
How Can Single Payer Address Some Key Problems at the Intersection of Health and Race?
Medicare for All
Public option plans are not universal and may still leave millions without coverage.
They do nothing to help people with expensive, low-quality private insurance that discourages the use of care.
Medicare for All provides comprehensive, life-long coverage for everyone, regardless of income, age, or employment.
Patients get the care they need without premiums, copays, or deductibles.
People of Color are more likely to be uninsured or underinsured than White people.
Public Option
Many public option proposals require expensive copays and deductibles, which prevent patients from seeking timely care for health problems. A public option would do nothing to help those on high-cost, low-quality private or employer health plans that discourage care.
Medicare for All allows everyone to get the care they need when they need it, by providing lifelong coverage for all medically necessary care, including preventive and primary care, prenatal and maternal care, dental, mental health, prescriptions, and long-term care.
Medicare for All
People of Color are more likely to die from preventable and treatable illnesses.
Public Option
Public option plans do nothing to equalize funding or direct resources to underfunded facilities.
Many patients in low-income communities would still be uninsured, leaving hospitals and clinics to provide uncompensated care.
Since Medicare for All covers everyone, providers and hospitals are compensated equally for patient care.
Medicare for All funds hospitals through global budgets based on community needs — not profits.
Fewer healthcare facilities; existing facilities are under-resourced and in danger of closing
Medicare for All
Public Option
A public option leaves our fragmented health system in place.
It provides no resources to research or combat racial bias in the funding and delivery of care.
A publicly funded health system can invest in better research and data collection on racial inequity and provide training and education for health professionals to combat racial bias.
Racism is embedded in our healthcare delivery system
Medicare for All
Public Option
The establishment of Medicare and Medicaid in 1965, in conjunction with the Civil Rights Act of 1964, was transformative in desegregating the nation’s health care system for patients and providers, and in improving access to care.
What could Medicare for All do to improve the racial health inequities of today?
Thank You!
-The Illinois Single Payer Coalition
ilsinglepayer.org
info@ilsinglepayer.org
Sources
Alker, J. (November 2018). New report shows progress on children’s health coverage reversed course. Georgetown
University HealthPolicy Institute, Center for Children and Families. Retrieved from https://ccf.georgetown.edu/2018/11/28/new-report-shows-progress-on-childrens-health-coverage-reversed-course/
Ansell, D. (2017). Death gap: How inequality kills. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
healthcare-providers-impact-provider-reimbursement-overall-cost-care-treatment-decisions/
Bell, K. (Jun 2011). Only East St Louis hospital with emergency room closes. St Louis Post-Dispatch. Retrieved fromhttps://www.stltoday.com/news/local/illinois/only-east-st-louis-hospital-with-emergency- room-closes/article_02ffd19b-e542-59cf-aff9-efecad98a79e.html
Bosworth, A., Sheingold, S., Finegold, K., De Law, N., & Sommers, B. D. (2022, September 30). Price Increases for Prescription Drugs, 2016 -2022. HHS. Retrieved December 2022, from https://aspe.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/documents/d850985c20de42de984942c2d8e24341/price-tracking-brief.pdf
Buffie, N. (Feb 6, 2017). Overhead costs for private health insurance keep rising, even as costs fall for other types ofinsurance. Center for Economic and Policy Research. Retrieved from http://cepr.net/blogs/cepr-blog/overhead-costs-for-private-health-insurance-keep-rising-even-as-costs-fall-for-other-types-of-insurance
ClearHealthCosts. Retrieved February 25, 2019 from clearhealthcosts.com.
Sources, Continued
Cohen, J. (September 2018). The curious case of Gleevec pricing. Forbes. Retrieved fromhttps://www.forbes.com/sites/joshuacohen/2018/09/12/the-curious-case-of-gleevec-pricing/#331d985254a3
Collins, S.R., Gunja, M.Z., & Doty, M.M. (October 2017). Commonwealth Fund. How well does insurancecoverage protect consumers from health care costs? Retrieved from https://www.commonwealthfund.org/sites/default/files/documents/ media_files_publications_issue_brief_2017_oct_collins_underinsured_biennial_ib.pdf
Collins, S. R., Haynes, L. A., & Masitha, R. (2022, September 29). The state of U.S. Health Insurance in 2022. State of U.S. Health Insurance in 2022: Biennial Survey | Commonwealth Fund. Retrieved December 2022, from https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/issue-briefs/2022/sep/state-us-health-insurance-2022-biennial-survey
Collins, S. R., Radley, D. C., & Baumgartner, J. C. (2022, January 12). State trends in employer premiums and deductibles, 2010–2020. Commonwealth Fund. Retrieved January 2023, from https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2022/jan/state-trends-employer-premiums-deductibles-2010-2020
Commonwealth Fund. (February 2019). Health insurance coverage eight years after the ACA: Fewer uninsured Americans andshorter coverage gaps, but more underinsured. Retrieved from https://www.commonwealthfund.org/sites/default/files/2019-02/Collins_hlt_ins_coverage_8_years_after_ACA_2018_biennial_survey_sb.pdf
Congress.gov, Medicare for All Act of 2019, HR. 1384, 116 Cong. (2019).
Congress.gov, Medicare for All Act of 2019, S. 1129, 116 Cong. (2019).
Data USA. City median income data retrieved 8/3/2019 from https://datausa.io/
Sources, Continued
Friedman, G. (2012). Funding a national single payer system. Dollars and Sense. Retrieved fromhttp://www.pnhp.org/sites/default/files/docs/2012/Dollars%20and%20Sense.pdf
Friedman, G. (2013). Funding HR 676: The Expanded and Improved Medicare for All Act: How we can afford a national single-payerhealth plan. Retrieved from Physicians for National Health Program website:http://www.pnhp.org/sites/default/files/Funding%20HR%20676_Friedman_7.31.13.pdf
Galewitz, P. (May 2015). Hospitals pack up in poor areas, move to wealthier ones. Kaiser Health News. Retrieved fromhttps://money.cnn.com/2015/04/20/news/economy/hospitals-relocating/index.html
GBD 2015 Healthcare Access and Quality Collaborators. (2017). Healthcare access and quality index based on mortality from causesamenable to personal health care in 195 countries and territories,
1990-2015: A novel analysis from the Global Burden of Disease Study 2015. The Lancet, 390(10091), 231-266. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(17)30818-8
Global, regional, and national levels of maternal mortality, 1990-2015: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of DiseaseStudy 2015. (2016). The Lancet, 388, 1775-1812. Retrieved from http://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lancet/PIIS0140-6736(16)31470-2.pdf
Goudie, C., Markoff, B., Tressell, C., & Weidner, R. (2020, October 21). Mercy Hospital's slated closure among wave of medical centers vanishing from Chicago area. ABC7 Chicago. Retrieved December 2022, from https://abc7chicago.com/hospitals-closing-mercy-hospital-chicago-urban/7202136/
Greenspan, A. (2005). Video retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DNCZHAQnfGU
Health Care Cost Institute and International Federation of Health Plans. (2022, July). International Health Cost Comparison Report. Health Cost Institute. Retrieved December 2022, from https://healthcostinstitute.org/images/pdfs/international_health_cost_comparison_report_2022.pdf
Sources, Continued
Henry J Kaiser Foundation. (Dec 2018). Key facts about the uninsured population. Retrieved from https://www.kff.org/uninsured/fact-sheet/key-facts-about-the-uninsured-population/
Himmelstein, D., Thorne, D., Warren, E., & Woolhandler, S. (2009). Medical bankruptcy in the United States, 2007: Results ofa national study. The American Journal of Medicine, 122, 741-746. doi:10.1016/j.amjmed.2009.04.012
Himmelstein, et al. (March 2019). Medical bankruptcy: Still common despite the Affordable Care Act. American Journal of Public Health,109(3), 431-433. doi 10.2105/AJPH.2018.304901.
Illinois Department of Healthcare and Family Services. MedicaidManaged Care in Illinois Frequently Asked Questions. Retrievedfrom https://www.illinois.gov/hfs/MedicalClients/ManagedCare/Pages/ManagedCareFAQ.aspx
Illinois Hospital Report Card. Illinois Department of Public Health. Metrosouth Medical Center. Retrieved 8/3/2019 fromhttp://www.healthcarereportcard.illinois.gov/hospitals/view/101212
Ingram, J. (Aug 2007). East Boogie may lose its only hospital. The St Louis American. Retrieved fromhttp://www.stlamerican.com/news/columnists/james_ingram/east-boogie-may-lose-its-only- hospital/article_95af0c32-f697-515d-b6d4-76df8d1e0e87.html
International Federation of Health Plans. 2015 comparative price report: Variation in medical and hospital prices by country. Receivedupon email request from admin@ifhp.com on 6 Mar 2019.
Sources, Continued
KFF. (2022, August 22). Total Medicaid spending. KFF. Retrieved January 2023, from https://www.kff.org/medicaid/state-indicator/total-medicaid-spending/?currentTimeframe=0&sortModel=%7B%22colId%22%3A%22Location%22%2C%22sort%22%3A%22asc%22%7D
KFF. (2022, October 27). Premiums and worker contributions among workers covered by employer-sponsored coverage. KFF. Retrieved January 2023, from https://www.kff.org/interactive/premiums-and-worker-contributions-among-workers-covered-by-employer-sponsored-coverage/
KFF. (2022, September 16). Average annual deductible per enrolled employee in employer-based health insurance for single and Family Coverage. KFF. Retrieved January 2023, from https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/average-annual-deductible-per-enrolled-employee-in-employer-based-health-insurance-for-single-and-family-coverage/?activeTab=graph¤tTimeframe=0&startTimeframe=8&selectedRows=%7B%22wrapups%22%3A%7B%22united-states%22%3A%7B%7D%7D%7D&sortModel=%7B%22colId%22%3A%22Location%22%2C%22sort%22%3A%22asc%22%7D
Mitchell, William, L. Randall Wray, and Watts, Martin, Macroeconomics, 2019, MacMillan
Moran, T. (July 2018). St James hospital slated to close soon. Patch. Retrieved 8/3/2019 from https://patch.com/illinois/chicagoheights/st-james-hospital-slated-close-soon
National Research Council and Institute of Medicine. (2013). U.S. health in international perspective: Shorter lives, poorer health.The National Academies Press: Washington DC. Retrieved from https://www.nesri.org/sites/default/files/US_Health_in_International_Perspective.pdf
Sources, Continued
Nolte, E. & McKee, M. (Jan/Feb 2008). Measuring the health of nations: Updating an earlier analysis. Health Affairs, 27(1), 58-71.doi:10.1377/hlthaff.27.1.58.
OECD Health Statistics 2018. Retrieved from stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=SHA
Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development. (n.d.). OECD Statistics. Retrieved December 2022, from https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx
Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP). The uninsured. Presentation retrieved from https://slideplayer.com/slide/15157733/
Posner, E. (Jun 2019). As black women face maternal health crisis, Jackson Park Hospital plans to shut down ob/gyn unit –and nurses are fighting back. Block Club Chicago. Retrieved from https://blockclubchicago.org/2019/06/24/as-black-women-face-maternal-health-crisis-jackson-park-hospital-plans-to-shut-down-its-ob-gyn-unit-and-nurses-are-fighting-back/
Schneider, E.C., Sarnak, D.O., Squires, D., Shah, A., & Doty, M.M. (2017). Mirror, Mirror 2017: International comparison reflects flawsand opportunities for better U.S. health care. The Commonwealth Fund. Retrieved fromhttps://www.commonwealthfund.org/sites/default/files/documents/ media_files_publications_fund_report_2017_jul_schneider_mirror_mirror_2017.pdf
Sources, Continued
Schneider, E. C. (2021, August). Mirror, Mirror 2021 — Reflecting Poorly: Health Care in the U.S. Compared to Other High-Income Countries. Commonwealth Fund. Retrieved January 2023, from https://www.commonwealthfund.org/
Shadac, State Health Compare. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. Retrieved fromhttp://statehealthcompare.shadac.org/map/103/medicaid-expenses-as-a-percent-of-state-budgets#a/24/140
Silverman, E. (October2016). Huge Valeant price hike on lead poisoning drug sparks anger. STAT. Retrieved fromhttps://www.statnews.com/pharmalot/2016/10/11/valeant-drug-prices-lead-poisoning/
Statistics Canada, Canadian Health Institute, and NCHS/CommerceDept. Chart adapted from PNHP presentation. Retrieved 27 May 2019from www.pnhp.org/slideshow/2012/PNHPShortSetWeisbartVersion.ppt
Sweich, P. (Oct 2015). Residents: Closing hospital ‘another nail in the coffin of Streator.’ Pantagraph. Retrieved fromhttp://www.ilsinglepayer.com/article/residents-closing-hospital-another-nail-coffin-streator
United States Government Accountability Office. (2011). Federal Reserve System: Opportunities exist to strengthenpolicies and processes for managing emergency assistance. Retrieved from https://www.gao.gov/new.items/d11696.pdf
Sources, Continued
Woolhandler, S. & Himmelstein, D. (September 2017). The relationship of health insurance and mortality: Is lack of insurance deadly?Annals of Internal Medicine, 167(6), 424-431. doi:10.7326/M17-1403
World Health Organization. Global Health Expenditures Database. Retrieved 2 March 2019 from http://apps.who.int/nha/database
Yee, M.K. Mount Sinai Medical Center’s Eleven West wing. The New York Times. Retrieved fromhttps://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/26/opinion/hospitals-red-blanket-problem.html
Zallman, L., Woolhandler, S., Touw, S., Himmelstein, D., & Finnegan, K. (2018). Immigrants pay more in private insurance premiums thanthey receive in benefits. Health Affairs, 37(10).