1 of 20

Show Pride in Your Work

Joanne Carroll

November 2026

2 of 20

What we’ll cover. . .

  • Things to look for in your work�
  • How to scale it up�
  • Your evaluation

​

3 of 20

Why Me?

Carving Experience

​

1966-1968 - College

​

1993 - 2026 SCVC Club

​

2022 – 2026 Lincoln Hills Woodcarvers

​

Expert Class in CCG Judging

​

Teach-Mentor at club only

​

Judging Experience

​

1995 to 1999

Apprentice, Provisional

​

1999 - Certified judge

​

2003 - 2013 Chief Judge – Northern CA Region

​

Currently – Certified Judge

​

​

​

Pyrography Experience

​

Burning 2014 – 2026

​

Teaching 2018 – 2026

​

4 of 20

Things To Look For in Your Work

5 of 20

Things to look for in your work

Utilization of wood as the medium

  • Color
  • Surface quality
  • Lamination
  • Texture
  • Grain
  • Tool Marks

​

​

Artistry

Sycamore

6 of 20

Things to look for in your work

3 Dimensional Features

  • Form
    • Shape - geometric or expressive
    • Surface curvature or flatness
    • Treatment of intersections

​

  • Light and shadow
    • Modeling shadows

​

  • Relief Depth Perception
    • Retinal image (foreshortening, realistic, perspective)
    • Gradients (tonal contrast, faceting, curvature, focus, density, detailing)
    • Local depth cues (interposition, familiar size, shadows, positioning, dimensions of size)

​

Artistry

7 of 20

Things to look for in your work

Artistry

Correctness

Realistic

The carving is of an existing thing, true to life and nature in terms of shape, proportion, pose, and color?

The habitat should be consistent with the workmanship of the figure.

​

Stylized

The shape is intentionally altered but is still a recognized subject. There should be a purpose to the alteration as a means of “saying something” about the subject. The carving technique may be detailed or not; the distortion of the form is the stylization “statement” – merely omitting detail is lazy realism.

​

Non-Representational

There is no recognizable form. Focus is on the relationship between positive (The physical objects of the carving) and the negative (The area in and around the physical objects) space. Important:

  • choice of woods, textures, colors, grain or “figure” as they relate to the composition.
  • Physical and compositional “balance” are of prime importance, as they are critical to the quality of the final composition.

8 of 20

Things to look for in your work

Composition

  • Mobility
    • Relation to axis of reference (Lines of Rhythm)
    • The illusion of motion
  • Unity
    • Coordination of Mass (no divided interest)
    • Mounting - Base or Frame
  • Contrasts
    • Mass vs. voids (worked vs. natural)
    • Light vs. shadow (active vs. passive)
    • Smooth vs. textures
  • Balance
    • Bilateral symmetry (equivalents not equality)
    • Unequal Mass (support of figure)
  • Center of Interest
    • Specific Object (expression)
    • Focal point - explicit or implied

​

​

Artistry

9 of 20

Things to look for in your work

Artistry

Artistic Impact

  • Overall effect (boldness in tackling problems)
  • Does the piece make a statement (imaginative interpretation)
  • Sentiment (your subjective feelings)
  • Narration (would I like to own this piece, sell it or give it as a gift?)

10 of 20

Things to look for in your work

Degree of Difficulty (10 points)

  • Complexity of Design
  • Made from single piece
  • Pierced vs. closed
  • Thin regions
  • Carving difficulty of the wood
  • Quality of details (especially regions difficult to reach)

​

Technical Attributes

11 of 20

Things to look for in your work

Technical Skill (10 points)

  • Execution of details
  • Texturing
  • Clean cuts
  • Proper Undercutting
  • Quality of cross grain carving
  • If laminated - Quality of joint

​

Technical Attributes

12 of 20

Things to look for in your work

Care in execution (10 points)

  • Surface preparation
  • All parts equally caved
  • Quality of details
  • How realistic are features
  • Corners sharp or rounded by improper sanding

​

Finish (10 points)

  • Application
  • Correct Choice - Colors must enhance the effect
  • Visibility of Grain - Colors must not mask carving/ p
  • yrography errors
  • Painted Carvings - Quality of Painting Techniques

​

Technical Attributes

13 of 20

How to Scale it Up!

14 of 20

How To Scale It Up

Is the pattern Correct?

​

Really scrutinize your pattern and make changes BEFORE proceeding.

​

This is a beautiful picture but there are some anatomical issues with the bear.

​

Can you see them?

Pattern

15 of 20

How To Scale It Up

Make a statement

Illusion of motion

Focal point - explicit or implied

16 of 20

How To Scale It Up

NEEDS GOOD AND BAD EXAMPLES

Expression

By Vic Hood

Balance - Symmetry

17 of 20

How To Scale It Up

Use Textures

​

​

NEEDS GOOD AND BAD EXAMPLES

Move It Up to Another Dimension

18 of 20

Your Evaluation

Carving Name:

 

Artistry

 

 

  1. Utilization of wood as the medium

10

 

  1. Three-Dimensional Features

10

 

  1. Correctness

10

 

  1. Composition

10

 

  1. Artistic Impact

10

 

Total Artistry

50

 

 

 

 

Carving Skill

 

 

  1. Degree of Difficulty

10

 

  1. Technical Skill

10

 

  1. Care in execution

10

 

  1. Finish

10

 

  1. Overall Level of Craftsmanship

10

 

Total Carving Skills

50

 

 

 

 

TOTAL SCORE

100

 

 

 

 

COMMENTS:

 

 

Using the handout – ‘Carving Attributes Job Aide’

​

Look at your Carving/Pyrography and determine what score you would give yourself.

19 of 20

How are the Ribbons Awarded?

3 judges judge every piece

1st, 2nd and 3rd are chosen for each Class

1st, 2nd and 3rd are chosen for each Category

There is a cumulative score for Carving Skill

There is a cumulative score for Artistry

The Total Score is what determines a 1st (225-300), 2nd (168-224), 3rd (138-167)

20 of 20

Thanks for letting me a part of your program.