1 of 39

Unpacking the 2022

ELD Standards�

Karen Solis

Laura VanCamp

June 2022�

tinyurl.com/unpackingELD

Growing Success for MLs

2 of 39

Introductions…

2

Karen Solis, ESL Teacher, Trainer & Coach

karensolis.literacy@gmail.com

Laura VanCamp, ESL Teacher & Trainer

lauravancamp2020@gmail.com

NC DPI EL Support Team Members

#NCELD22

3 of 39

Webex Overview

3

4 of 39

4

Your Conference Notebook

5 of 39

Pulse Check!

5

How familiar are you with the new ELD Standards Framework?

0- Completely new to me!

1- I’ve heard it’s coming!

2-I’ve looked at it, but I haven’t dug into it!

3- I’m familiar with it!

4- I’ve attended other PD on the standards framework!

5- I eat, sleep, and breathe this standards framework!

6 of 39

Objectives

  • To become acquainted with the purpose, format, contents, and location of the ELD Unpacking Documents
  • To provide ideas for how to use the resource in support of implementation of the adopted NC ELD SCOS
  • To reflect on our own practices
  • To promote research-based, standards-aligned practices
  • To create an artifact that will promote future application of this material

6

7 of 39

7

Introducing the

ELD Unpacking Document

To become acquainted with the purpose, format, contents, and location of the ELD Unpacking Document

8 of 39

Purpose of the Documents

  • Deepen the understanding of the NC ELD Standards
  • Show how content and language can be learned together.
  • Increase student achievement by providing access to rich, standards-based, grade-level content

8

9 of 39

Contents of the Documents

The Unpacking Documents include:

  • ELD Standards & Language Expectations
  • Clarifications
  • Unpacked language functions
  • "In the Classroom'' ideas
  • Sample language objectives

9

10 of 39

ELD Standards Framework

Adapted WIDA English Language Development Standards Framework, 2020 Edition ©

11 of 39

Format of Language Expectations

11

ELD Standard 2: Language for Language Arts Multilingual learners communicate information, ideas, and concepts necessary for academic success in the content area of Language Arts.

ELD-LA.6-8.Narrate.Interpretive Interpret language arts narratives by:

● Identifying a theme or central idea that develops over the course of a text

● Analyzing how character attributes and actions develop in relation to events or dialogue

● Evaluating impact of specific word choices about meaning and tone

Language Expectation

Grade-level Cluster

Key Language Use

Mode of Communication

12 of 39

Key Language Uses

12

WIDA English Language Development Standards Framework, 2020 Edition ©

  • Narrate: language to convey real or imaginary experiences through stories and histories (e.g., instruct, entertain, teach, or support argumentation)

  • Inform: language to provide factual information (e.g., define, describe, compare, contrast, organize, etc.)

  • Explain: language to give an account for how things work or why things happen (e.g., substantiate the inner workings of natural, man-made, and social phenomena)

  • Argue: language to justify claims using evidence and reasoning. (e.g., defend an idea, change another’s point of view)

13 of 39

Unpacking in the ELD Hub

13

14 of 39

Let’s Take a Tour!

14

15 of 39

Strategy #1: Number the Skills

15

Language Expectation

ELD-SC.2-3.Explain.Expressive Construct scientific explanations that:

● Describe observations and/or data about a phenomenon

Skills

In the Classroom

Clarification: Students describe data from observations about a phenomenon.

Unpacked Language Functions:

● Define terms: observations, data, phenomenon

● Describe observations about a phenomenon

● Describe data about a phenomenon

Students explore sound with a partner by taking turns and charting

whether a vocal sound is high or low (pitch) and loud or soft (volume).

Students then use “sound” vocabulary to explain to the partner that

sound waves are collected by the outer ear, vibrate in the eardrum,

cause the tiny bones in the middle ear to vibrate, and then move through

the bones in the inner ear where sounds are understood by the brain.

Students may draw a labeled diagram of the ear as well.

Sample Language Objective: Students will be able to describe data from

observations about a phenomenon by charting pitch and volume of vocal

sounds, drawing a labeled diagram of the ear, as well as explaining to

their partners how the sound moves through the ear and is understood

by the brain.

tinyurl.com/unpackingELD

1

2

3

16 of 39

Your Turn!

16

Language Expectation

ELD-SS.1.Argue.Interpretive Interpret social studies arguments by:

● Identifying topic

Skills

In the Classroom

Clarification: Students identify the topic of a social studies argument.

Unpacked Language Functions:

● Define terms: topics

● Identify topic of a social studies argument

The teacher shows students a picture of cars in long lines waiting for a

turn to pump gasoline. Using the picture and guided by the teacher,

students follow a See, Think, Wonder routine. Students name things

they see, as the teacher scribes on chart paper. Small groups then think

about how that shows the topic of limited resources and the demand for

that resource. Students then generate possible titles for a social studies

argument related to limited resources and scarcity e.g., How Panic

Buying Creates Scarcity). The teacher records the students’ responses

on the chart paper. After the discussion, the class votes on a topic title

for the argument regarding limited resources and scarcity. Students add

to the Wonder column in a subsequent activity.

Sample Language Objective: Students will be able to identify the topic of

a social studies argument, writing a title with generalized nouns in small

groups and supported by a picture and See, Think, Wonder routine.

1. Read the standard, skills, classroom scenario and objective.

2. Highlight what skills and how many skills should be taught.

3. Figure out how you will determine mastery or measure student understanding for the skills you’ve identified.

17 of 39

Strategy #2: The Best Fit

17

Language Expectation

ELD-SS.4-5.Explain.Interpretive Interpret social studies explanations by:

● Determining different opinions in sources for answering compelling and supporting questions about phenomena or events

Skills

In the Classroom

Clarification: Students identify various opinions expressed in a variety of sources for answering compelling and supporting questions about phenomena or events.

Unpacked Language Functions:

  • Define terms: opinions, compelling questions, supporting questions, phenomena
  • Determine different opinions in sources for answering compelling questions about phenomena or events
  • Determine different opinions in sources for answering

supporting questions about phenomena or events

Students listen to a read aloud of three different sources regarding the decline of the furniture industry in North Carolina: 1) A newspaper article on furniture plant closings 2) A letter to the editor from an

unemployed furniture worker 3) An online interview with a legislator serving the area with closed-down furniture plants. Students listen in order to answer the compelling question: What factors led to the decline of the furniture industry in North Carolina? The teacher guides the class in identifying the opinion in the newspaper article, using the document camera and highlighting while thinking-aloud. Students form small groups and identify opinions in either the letter to the editor or the online interview, highlighting sentences that support opinions, and referring to the anchor chart as needed.

I wonder…

I notice…

  • What do you notice?
  • What do you wonder?

18 of 39

Strategy #2: The Best Fit

18

Language Expectation

ELD-SS.4-5.Explain.Interpretive Interpret social studies explanations by:

● Determining different opinions in sources for answering compelling and supporting questions about phenomena or events

Skills

In the Classroom

Clarification: Students identify various opinions expressed in a variety of sources for answering compelling and supporting questions about phenomena or events.

Unpacked Language Functions:

  • Define terms: opinions, compelling questions, supporting questions, phenomena
  • Determine different opinions in sources for answering compelling questions about phenomena or events
  • Determine different opinions in sources for answering

supporting questions about phenomena or events

Students listen to a read aloud of three different sources regarding the decline of the furniture industry in North Carolina: 1) A newspaper article on furniture plant closings 2) A letter to the editor from an

unemployed furniture worker 3) An online interview with a legislator serving the area with closed-down furniture plants. Students listen in order to answer the compelling question: What factors led to the decline of the furniture industry in North Carolina? The teacher guides the class in identifying the opinion in the newspaper article, using the document camera and highlighting while thinking-aloud. Students form small groups and identify opinions in either the letter to the editor or the online interview, highlighting sentences that support opinions, and referring to the anchor chart as needed.

I wonder…

I notice…

1. Look deeply at the “In the Classroom” idea.

2. Where does it fit: introduction, direct instruction/modeling, guided practice, independent practice or closure?

3. What instruction might need to happen before or after it?

19 of 39

Your Turn!

19

Language Expectation

ELD-SI.4-12.Argue

● Generate questions about different perspectives

Skills

In the Classroom

Clarification: Students identify various opinions expressed in a variety of sources for answering compelling and supporting questions about phenomena or events.

Unpacked Language Functions:

  • Define terms: opinions, compelling questions, supporting questions, phenomena
  • Determine different opinions in sources for answering compelling questions about phenomena or events
  • Determine different opinions in sources for answering supporting questions about phenomena or events

Students brainstorm a class list of different perspectives on a particular

topic. After brainstorming, students choose two of these perspectives to

explore, developing questions about them. Students develop questions

like: “I understand the perspective of _____, have we considered...?;”

“How is _____ different from...?”; “What would it look like if...”; “How

did ____ decide...?”

1. Look deeply at the “In the Classroom” idea.

2. Where does it fit: introduction, direct instruction/modeling, guided practice, independent practice or closure?

3. What instruction might need to happen before or after it?

20 of 39

Modes of Communication

20

ELD Standard 4: Language for Science Multilingual learners communicate information, ideas, and concepts necessary for academic success in the content area of Science.

ELD-SC.K.Inform.Interpretive Interpret scientific informational texts by:

● Determining what text is about

● Defining or classifying a concept or entity

ELD-SC.K.Inform.Expressive Construct scientific informational texts that:

● Introduce others to a topic or entity

● Provide details about an entity

ELD-SC.K.Explain.Interpretive Interpret scientific explanations by:

● Defining investigable questions or simple design problems based on observations and data about a phenomenon

● Using information from observations to find patterns and to explain how or why a phenomenon occurs

ELD-SC.K.Explain.Expressive Construct scientific explanations that:

● Describe information from observations about a phenomenon

● Relate how a series of events causes something to happen

● Compare multiple solutions to a problem

21 of 39

Strategy #3: Interpretive & Expressive Objectives: Compare & Contrast

21

Interpretive

Expressive

ELD-LA.4-5.Argue.Interpretive Interpret language arts arguments by:

  • Identifying main ideas
  • Analyzing points of view about the same event or topic
  • Evaluating how details, reasons, and evidence support particular points in a text

ELD-LA.4-5.Argue.Expressive Construct language arts arguments that:

  • Introduce and develop a topic clearly; state an opinion
  • Support opinions with reasons and information
  • Use a formal style
  • Logically connect opinions to appropriate evidence, facts, and details; offer a concluding statement or section

What kinds of verbs are used in the interpretive objectives?

What kinds of verbs are used in the expressive objectives?

How are they similar?

How are they different?

22 of 39

Your Turn!

22

Interpretive

Expressive

ELD-MA.6-8.Explain.Interpretive Interpret mathematical explanations by:

  • Identifying concept or entity
  • Analyzing possible ways to represent and solve a problem
  • Evaluating model and rationale for underlying relationships in selected problem-solving approach

ELD-MA.6-8.Explain.Expressive Construct mathematical explanations that:

  • Introduce concept or entity
  • Share solution with others
  • Describe data and/or problem-solving strategy
  • State reasoning used to generate solution

What kinds of verbs are used in the interpretive objectives?

What kinds of verbs are used in the expressive objectives?

How are they similar?

How are they different?

23 of 39

23

Unpacking the Artifact

Objective: To create an artifact that will promote future application of this material.

QR CODE

24 of 39

Time for a journey!

24

  1. Choose a grade cluster and language expectation.
  2. Join a Break Out room for your grade cluster.
  3. Together with your group, use one of the strategies for unpacking we shared and unpack your language expectation.

5-6 people per room

25 of 39

25

tinyurl.com/unpackingELD

26 of 39

26

27 of 39

Share with us!

What more did you learn about the language expectations?

What wows and wonders popped up for you?

27

28 of 39

Connections to

NC ML Intiatives

28

29 of 39

Best Practices Strategies

29

Lower the affective filter

acculturation

equity access

More Resources: EL Toolkit (OELA)

30 of 39

OCDE Project GLADStrategies

30

Listen & Sketch

Find a text and identify 6 stopping points

Fold white paper into 6 boxes

Read each section until the stopping point.

Ask students to sketch “the picture in their minds”

Learning Logs

Draw a simple T-chart

Text side: What’s something you learned from the text

You side: How does it connect to your life?

31 of 39

ExC-ELL Strategies

Expediting Comprehension for English Language Learners

31

Resources from Dr. Margarita Calderón’s ExC-ELL website

7 Step Vocabulary

Pre-Teach

  1. (T) says the word and students repeat it 3x
  2. (T) provides the word in context from the text
  3. (T) provides dictionary definition
  4. (T) provides student-friendly definition
  5. (T) highlights feature of the word
  6. (S) engage in one minute ping pong
  7. (T) shares how students will be accountable for the word

Reading

  • Teacher read alouds
  • Partner reads
  • Multiple reasons to go in text

Writing

  • Write Around
  • Cut and Grow
  • Tear Ups
  • RAFT

32 of 39

32

Feel Free to Share on GoOpen!

33 of 39

33

ELD Unpacking Document: Reflection

Objective: To reflect on our own practices

QR CODE

34 of 39

34

bit.ly/*******************

Reflect.

Think about your lessons and how you apply the standards.

In the chat, summarize your learning in three words.

35 of 39

Did we meet our objectives today?

  • To become acquainted with the purpose, format, contents, and location of the ELD Unpacking Document
  • To provide ideas for how to use the resource in support of implementation of the adopted NC ELD SCOS
  • To reflect on our own practices
  • To promote research-based, standards-aligned practices
  • To create an artifact that will promote future application of this material

35

bit.ly/*******************

36 of 39

Help Us Help You

We value your feedback!

36

Please complete our PD evaluation.

Thank you in advance for your feedback.

37 of 39

Office Hours

3:30pm - 4:30pm

37

tinyurl.com/unpackingELD

38 of 39

Karen Solis

karensolis.literacy@gmail.com

Laura Van Camp lauravancamp2020@gmail.com

39 of 39

39

EL Data and Title III Compliance

Susan Walz

ESL/Title III Consultant (EL Data Collection, Reporting, & PowerSchool)

susan.walz@dpi.nc.gov

Marshall Foster

ESL/Title III Consultant (EL Program Compliance)

marshall.foster@dpi.nc.gov

NCDPI ESL/Title III Team

EL Program Quality

Ivanna Mann Thrower Anderson

ESL/Title III Consultant (West)

ivanna.anderson@dpi.nc.gov

Xatli Stox

ESL/Title III Consultant (East)

xatli.stox@dpi.nc.gov

Administrative Support

Stacy Daniel, Ed.D.

Section Chief for ELA & Languages

stacy.daniel@dpi.nc.gov

Teresa Parker

Administrative Assistant for ELA & Languages

teresa.parker@dpi.nc.gov