DISTRICT 50
Chief Judge�Orientation
2026 Fall Contests
Fair contests • Consistent process • Confident decisions
Ram Venkat, DTM • District 50 Chief Judge 2026–2027
01 • THE CHIEF JUDGE ROLE
What Does a Chief Judge Do?
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
2
01
Referee the contest
Protect the integrity of the contest and ensure the process is fair and consistent.
02
Lead the judging team
Select, brief, coordinate and support judges, timers and ballot counters.
03
Stay neutral
Do not coach, influence or discuss judging decisions during the contest.
04
Manage issues
Recognize procedural issues, protests and technical problems and route them appropriately.
05
Protect confidentiality
Keep ballots, rankings and judging discussions private.
06
Own the process
Make sure the contest is ready, the count is verified and results are communicated correctly.
02 • BEFORE THE CONTEST
Chief Judge Preparation – Week Before Contest
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
3
01
Review the contest
Know the applicable rules (pages 21-23 in the rule book)
02
Check eligibility
Collect Judges Eligibility forms.
03
Confirm the team
Choose your Judges, Confirm Tiebreaking judge (choose your senior most Judge)
04
Briefings
Schedule and complete Judges Briefings (or emails) Participate in Timer and ballot counter briefings. (Briefing links in reference slide)
05
Communication methods
Set up the communication plan: Set up group text for judges and private text for ballots.
06
Be aware of logistics
Have the program, correct ballots, contest timing and links for ballots and timer sheets
03 • JUDGE BRIEFING
Judge Briefing
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
4
01
RE-ITERATE ROLE & MINDSET
Judge the speech—not the speaker. Use the ballot criteria, not personal preferences.
02
SHARE BALLOT AND CONTEST DAY LOGISTICS
Review the ballot, scoring categories, ranking requirements and ballot submission process. Share Timer sheets with Timers – Provide Instructions
03
PROTESTS & CONFIDENTIALITY
Explain what may be protested, how to raise concerns, and the need to keep judging private.
04 • CONTEST DAY
Chief Judge Prep - Contest Day
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
5
01
Set up a group text
Create a group text with the judges before the contest starts.
02
Check in judges
Check off each judge as they arrive / log in.
03
Re-iterate communication
Remind everyone to communicate via the group text for judge-team messages & private text for ballots.
04
Confirm materials
Make sure everyone has the correct ballot, program and timing information.
05
Final readiness check
Confirm judges, timer(s), ballot counters and communication channels are ready.
05 • DURING THE CONTEST
Chief Judge during Contest
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
6
01
Observe
Watch the process without becoming part of the judging.
02
Protect neutrality
Keep judges and contestants from unnecessary interaction during the contest.
03
Watch procedure
Be alert to issues that affect contest administration—not speech quality.
04
Handle interruptions
Coordinate with the Contest Chair when a procedural or technical issue occurs.
05
Stay available
Keep communication open with the judging team without influencing their decisions.
06
Do not interfere
Let judges judge. Your job is to protect the process.
06 • RULES & DECISIONS
Protests — Chief Judge Process
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
7
01
Receive
A protest may be lodged with the Chief Judge or Contest Chair before adjournment. ONLY THE JUDGES AND CONTESTANTS ARE ALLOWED TO PROTEST.
02
Identify
Determine whether the concern involves an eligibility, originality or reference issue.
03
Follow procedure
For an originality or reference protest, involve the judges and give the contestant an opportunity to respond. Poll judges and let the majority vote decide.
04
Decide
Follow the applicable decision process, communicate the outcome appropriately and protect confidentiality. Decisions are final.
06 • RULES & DECISIONS
What Is NOT a Protest?
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
8
01
Personal preference
“I didn't like the speech.”
02
Opinion
“I disagree with the contestant's opinion.”
03
Accuracy
Speech is inaccurate or controversial.
04
Style & Visuals
A speaking style or accent. Poor video quality
05
Judging criteria
Poor organization, delivery or audience engagement.
06
Who should win
A belief that another contestant deserved to win.
07 • BALLOT COUNTING
Ballot Counting — The Chief Judge Workflow
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
9
01
Collect ballots & Timer sheets via text
Once ALL ballots and timer sheets are received inform the SSAA to move you and ballot counters to the breakout room.
02
Check
Check ballots and timer sheets before accepting the results.
03
Count & verify
Count rankings carefully, resolve discrepancies and independently verify the result. Use ballot counting tool.
04
Finalize
Confirm the final ranking with ballot counters before results are communicated to the Contest Chair (call them into the breakout room)
08 • RESULTS & DE -BRIEFING
Closing the Contest
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
10
01
CONFIRM
Double-check the final results before releasing them to contest chair
02
COMMUNICATE
Give the Contest Chair the confirmed results through the agreed process.
03
ADJOURN
Protect confidentiality and close the judging team when the process is complete.
04
DEBRIEF
Debrief with Area Director, Division Director and Contest Chair after adjournment
04
DOCUMENT
Email District Chief Judge
09 • SCENARIOS
Chief Judge Scenario Lab — Part 1
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
11
01
Same-club conflict
A judge realizes during the contest that they are in the same club as a contestant. What should the Chief Judge do?
02
Reference
03
Technical failure
A contestant loses audio or video during an online speech. Who acts first, and what should the Chief Judge coordinate?
04
No citation for a passage
Judge raised a protest - the contestant uses 10% of the speech from another source but gives no attribution whatsoever
A contestant refers to a speaker who has not spoken yet. What do you do?
09 • SCENARIOS
Chief Judge Scenario Lab — Part 2
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION
12
01
Ballots disagree
Two ballot counters report different totals. What is your next step?
02
Invalid ballot
A judge submits a ballot with an incomplete or invalid ranking. How should the issue be handled?
03
Contestant complaint
A contestant challenges a judging decision. What is the Chief Judge's role?
04
Late discovery
A potential eligibility issue is discovered just before results are announced. What should happen first?
05
Confidentiality
A judge asks how another judge ranked a contestant. What do you say?
06
Unexpected interruption
A speaker loses audio during the speech. What do you do?
Chief Judge References
DISTRICT 50
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • JUDGES’ TRAINING
06
toastmasters.org/resources/2025-2026-speech-contest-rulebook
02 Judges Eligibility form (Use this form or use the fillable pdf online)
d50tm.org/pq/contests/
https://content.toastmasters.org/image/upload/1189A-online-speech-contest-judges-guide-and-ballot-ff.pdf
https://content.toastmasters.org/image/upload/1188-international-tiebreaking-ballot-ff.pdf
Chief Judge References – Continued
DISTRICT 50
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • JUDGES’ TRAINING
06
https://content.toastmasters.org/image/upload/1175-time-record-sheet-ff.pdf
https://toastmastersonlinespeechballotcount.vercel.app/
https://content.toastmasters.org/image/upload/1182-notification-contest-winner-ff.pdf
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1lZoFfPTIU2heJUwS5ZcL4s_Yg9bvE5l-/view?usp=drive_link
08 Results form
https://content.toastmasters.org/image/upload/1168-results-form.pdf
Pages 21-23 Online Contest
DISTRICT 50
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • JUDGES’ TRAINING
06
Pages 21-23 Online Contest
DISTRICT 50
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • JUDGES’ TRAINING
06
DISTRICT 50
Thank you for�being a Chief Judge.
Fair contests depend on confident, prepared Chief Judges.
Ram Venkat, DTM
District 50 Chief Judge — 2026–2027
chiefjudge@d50tm.org
(949) 413-8278
DISTRICT 50 • FALL 2026 • CHIEF JUDGE ORIENTATION