Human Voice, Smart Tools:
AI Without Cheating
Essay writing seminar: Using the AI Tools with integrity
2
Goals (share these out loud)
Students will learn the principles of using AI tools in an ethical way that supports their authentic writing voice and expression, rather than replacing it.
Students will practice identifying scenarios where AI is used appropriately to enhance their writing process, versus scenarios where AI is used in a way that constitutes academic dishonesty.
Students will apply their understanding of ethical AI use by giving specific instructions to an AI tool to improve an existing paragraph they've written, and then revising the paragraph in their own words.
AI or Human?
Read Prompt
Read the prompt out loud: "Describe a challenge you've faced and how it changed you."
Read Paragraphs
Read two sample paragraphs - one written in an AI-style and one written in a human/teen-style.
Student Identification
Ask students to close their eyes and raise 1 finger for the AI-style paragraph, 2 fingers for the human/teen-style paragraph.
Discussion Prompts
Lead a discussion on which paragraph sounds more like a real teenager, which one a college admissions officer would prefer, and what the AI-style paragraph means for students' writing.
This opening activity gets students engaged and thinking about the differences between AI-generated and human-written content, setting the stage for the rest of the presentation.
4
Paragraph A (AI-style): “One of the biggest challenges I have faced in my life was adjusting to high school. At first, I felt overwhelmed by the workload and the expectations of my teachers. Over time, however, I learned to manage my time better and stay organized. This experience taught me the importance of responsibility, perseverance, and hard work. Now I feel more prepared for future challenges in college and beyond.”
Paragraph B (human/teen-style): “Freshman year almost broke me. I went from being the ‘smart kid’ in middle school to failing my first biology test. I remember staring at the 54% and trying not to cry on the bus ride home. After that, I started going to after-school tutoring and asking my teacher to re-explain things I pretended to understand in class. I still don’t love tests, but now when I see a bad grade, I don’t think ‘I’m dumb’—I think ‘Okay, what do I need to change?’”
AI or Human?
Discussion Prompts
“Which one sounds more like a real teenager? Why?”
“Which one do you think a college admissions officer would rather read?”
“If a bot can write something like Paragraph A, what does that mean for your writing? What still makes you valuable?”
What Is Ethical AI Use?
AI is a tool, like a calculator or spell-check. Ethical use means it helps you think better, not think for you.
What Is Ethical AI Use?
Ethical AI use = using AI to support your own ideas and effort, and being honest about how you used it.
Example (ethical): You ask AI: “Give me 10 topic ideas for a college essay based on these interests: dance, helping younger kids, and growing up in a big family.” You then choose a topic, outline your own story, and write the essay yourself.
What Is Ethical AI Use?
Cheating with AI = letting AI generate the main ideas, structure, and wording, then turning it in as if you wrote it.
Example (cheating): You paste your college prompt into AI: “Write a 650-word essay answering this.” You copy and paste the answer, change a sentence or two, and turn it in with your name.
9
Human Voice, Smart Tools: AI Without Cheating
If you copy-paste a whole AI essay and put your name on it, what's the real risk—for your grade, and also for your learning and your future?
Take 2–3 quick responses.
10
Human Voice, Smart Tools: AI Without Cheating
Three Big Principles (with examples)
1. Transparency – Be honest and follow your teacher’s or college’s rules.
Example: Your teacher says AI can only be used for brainstorming. You use it to generate possible essay topics, but you don’t let it draft the essay. If asked, you can clearly say: “I used AI to help me come up with ideas, but I wrote the essay myself.”
11
Human Voice, Smart Tools: AI Without Cheating
Three Big Principles (with examples)
2. Ownership – The core ideas, structure, and voice are still yours.
Example: AI suggests: “Add a specific moment where you realized you wanted to be a nurse.” You decide to write about the night you stayed at the hospital with your little brother, in your own words, using your memories.
12
Human Voice, Smart Tools: AI Without Cheating
Three Big Principles (with examples)
3. Documentation – Keep evidence of your process.
Example: You keep your rough draft, your AI chat (screenshots or saved text), and your revised draft. If anyone asks, you can show: “
Here’s what I wrote first, here’s what AI suggested, and here’s what I changed.”
13
Scenario Sorting
Step 1 - Hand out or display scenarios
Step 2 - Sort into Green / Yellow / Red
Students to sort the scenarios into three categories:
🟢 Green (OK - helpful support, still their own work)
🟡 Yellow (ask a teacher - gray area, depends on class rules)
🔴 Red (Not OK - cheating or dishonest)
Step 3 - Debrief
14
Sort into Green / Yellow / Red
15
Activity: Green / Yellow / Red: AI Use Scenario Sorting Small-Group Activity
Step 1
Scenario 1 “I ask AI to list 10 possible essay topics based on my interests in music, mentoring younger kids, and growing up in a single-parent home. I pick one idea and write the essay myself, using my own stories.”
Scenario 2 “I paste the entire essay prompt into AI, then copy the response word-for-word, change a few adjectives, and turn it in as my own work.”
Scenario 3 “I write a full rough draft of my essay. Then I paste a paragraph into AI and ask: ‘Can you show me 3 ways to make this clearer and fix grammar without changing my meaning?’ I use some of the suggestions but decide what to keep.”
Scenario 4 “I don’t have time to read an article for class, so I ask AI to summarize it. I copy the summary directly into my assignment and don’t mention that I didn’t read the original article.”
Scenario 5: “I’m stuck on a conclusion, so I ask AI: ‘What are some possible ways to end an essay about overcoming stage fright?’ I read the suggestions, then write my own ending in my own words.”
16
Step 3 – Debrief
Reflection Questions (whole group)
17
Practice: Improving Your Writing with AI
Students write a 5-7 sentence paragraph in response to a college essay prompt, using specific details, names, places, feelings, and small moments.
Prompt choice (pick one to read aloud):
Option A: “Why do you want to attend an HBCU or a college with a strong sense of community?”
Option B: “Describe a community that has shaped who you are.”
18
Practice: Improving Your Writing with AI
Students give a specific request to an AI tool, such as 'Point out 3 places I could add more detail' or 'Identify grammar/clarity issues, but don't rewrite the whole paragraph.'
Students then review the AI's suggestions and decide which ones to implement.
Example Prompt 1: “I wrote this paragraph for a college essay. Without rewriting it for me, point out 3 places where I could add more specific detail or clarify my thinking.”
Example Prompt 2: “Please identify grammar and clarity issues in this paragraph, but don’t rewrite it completely. Just tell me what to fix and why.”
Example Prompt 3 (for structure): “Based on this paragraph, suggest 2 ideas for what I could talk about in my next paragraph. Don’t write the new paragraph, just give me ideas.”
19
Practice: Improving Your Writing with AI
Exit Ticket: Reflecting on AI Use
Exit Ticket
Students describe one green way they plan to use AI on their next writing assignment and one red use of AI they commit to avoiding—and why.
Use AI ethically:
Leverage AI to enhance, not replace, your unique writing voice.
Use AI ethically:
Leverage AI to enhance, not replace, your unique writing voice.
Questions????