Replacing the Whole Barrel: �An Overview of Sustainable and Renewable�Biofuels and the Emerging Bioeconomy��For Parul University Presentation�January 9, 2024��Joanne Ivancic, Executive Director for Advanced Biofuels USA�
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
1
Advanced Biofuels: A Truly Sustainable Renewable Future
Advocates for the adoption of advanced biofuels as an
solution.
Advanced Biofuels USA
501(c)3 Nonprofit Educational Organization
Founded April 2008
Frederick, MD
Website:
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
2
Advanced Biofuels USA Home Page www.AdvancedBiofuelsUSA.org
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
3
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
4
Before we start:��What do you think of when you hear �“bioenergy”?
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
5
Does it include energy for transportation?
What do you think of when you hear �“biofuel”?
Your answer might depend on where you live.
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
6
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels?
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
9
What are they?
What are they used for?
How are they made?
Why are they important?
Jobs/Careers throughout
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels?
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
10
What are they?
What are they used for?
How are they made?
Why are they important?
Jobs/Careers throughout
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels?
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
11
What are they?
What are they used for?
How are they made?
Why are they important?
�Some Considerations:�� -Low-cost feedstock� -Low nutrient inputs� -Don’t harm environment� -Conversion processes are energy and water efficient� -Equal or better performance than fossil fuels�
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
12
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels?
Ethanol is a biofuel, �not the only biofuel. ��Biodiesel�Renewable Diesel�Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF)�Bio-isobutanol�Renewable Natural Gas�rDME, Bio-CNG, Bio-LNG, Bio-PNG�Drop-in hydrocarbons�Marine/Maritime Fuel and more
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
13
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels?
Corn-based ethanol, sugarcane ethanol�(nearly 200 proof moonshine or 100% ethanol) ��One of the few currently commercially available biofuels you can buy for vehicles today. Blends of 10%, 15%, 30%, 85% ��Replaces MTBE, provides octane.
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
14
“First Generation” Biofuel
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels??
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
15
What are they?
What are they used for?
How are they made?
Why are they important?
The Citröen Rosalie
Ford Model T
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?�Yesterday: Early Automobiles
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
17
18
If you have a flex fuel vehicle (FFV), you can use gasoline with blends up to 85% ethanol.
Look for the logo, check your owner’s manual or look at the info on the driver’s side door.
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?� Today Flex Fuel Vehicles
If you have a diesel engine, you might see a decal that indicates it was built to use up to 20% biodiesel, B20
Or, you can retrofit older cars to use E85
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF)
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
20
Fueling Trains with Biodiesel and Renewable Diesel
From Diesel Technology Forum: LA’s Metrolink and Bay Area’s Capitol Corridor Commuter Rail Service Both Invest in New Advanced Diesel Engines Powered with 100% Renewable Diesel
18 new trains for regional passenger rail services in Groningen and Friesland, the Netherlands will be powered by biodiesel.
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
Fueling Buses with Renewable Natural Gas (RNG)
21
Buses with Biodiesel, Renewable Diesel and Hydrogen
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
What Are Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
What Are Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
Fueling Trucks with Renewable Natural Gas, Biodiesel and Renewable Diesel
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
23
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
24
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
Heating oil
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
25
What Are Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
Ethanol Cook Stoves
Project Gaia:
Nigeria
Ethiopia
Haiti
Brazil
Tanzania
KOKO’s “ATM” Dispensers
Kenya
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
26
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
27
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?�Today
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
28
Plans for 100% sustainable, renewable by 2026
(Formulas 2,3,4 also use renewables)
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
29
What Are Renewable Fuels Used For? Today
What Will Sustainable Renewable Fuels Be Used For?� Tomorrow
Fuels for high performance vehicles, E85 retrofit
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
30
Hydrogen or Ethanol for Fuel Cells
E30 Sweet Spot
What Will Sustainable Renewable Fuels Used For?�Tomorrow
Copyright 2024 Advanced Biofuels USA
31
Ford Escape Hybrid E85
Toyota’s 100% ethanol plug in hybrid prototype introduced in India, August 2023
What Will Sustainable Renewable Fuels Be Used For? Tomorrow
Rocket Fuel
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
32
Missile Fuel: DARPA High Density JP-10 (BR-1)
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels?
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
33
How are they made?
Feedstock
Logistics
Technology
Agriculture�Forestry�Aquaculture � �The Foundations�of the Bioeconomy� �Along with Waste Management�for the Circular Economy�
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
34
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
35
Carbon Cycle
Examples of Potential Feedstocks or Energy Crops
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
36
36
Examples of crops/plants which are used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
37
Soybeans, Corn, Rice, Wheat
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
38
38
AGRICULTURAL RESIDUES
Corn Stover, Corn Cobs
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
39
Grain Sorghum
Milo
Forage Sorghum
Sweet Sorghum
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
40
40
Sunflower or
Jerusalem Artichoke
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
41
Canola/Rapeseed
Carinata
Camelina
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
42
42
Arundo or Giant Reed
And many others
Miscanthus
Grasses
Phragmites
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
43
Switchgrass
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Energy Tobacco
Tyton Bioenergy Systems
Ready to Harvest, Danville, VA
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
44
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
45
Sugar Cane
Sugar Cane Bagasse
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
46
Sugar Beet/Sugar Beet Pulp
Energy Beets
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
47
Cassava
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
48
Jatropha
Moringa
Pongamia
Castor Bean
Jojoba
Croton
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
50
Cashew Apple
Agave
Cactus,
Nopales
Date Palm Pits/Seeds, Waste
Sisal Bole
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
51
51
Kenaf
Hemp and Cannabis Residues
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
52
52
Nut Shells
Cotton Seed and Hulls
Rice Hulls, Husk
Rice or Wheat Straw
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
53
53
Woody Biomass
Forest Waste and Residues
Sawdust
Examples of potential crops/plants which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
54
54
Short Rotation Coppice Willow
Poplar
Examples of potential feedstock which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
55
55
Duckweed/Lemna
Algae
Cyanobacteria
Seaweed
Kelp
Duckweed/Lemna
Examples of potential feedstock which can be used for production of renewable fuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
56
56
Sorted Municipal Solid Waste or Food Waste
Flue Gas
Brewers and Distillers Waste
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
57
Used Cooking Oils
Fats
Grease
Examples of potential feedstock which can be used for production of biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
58
Landfill Gas or Biogas from Animal or Food Processing Waste
Examples of potential feedstock which can be used for production of biofuels
Renewable Fuels and Chemicals, �Not Just Bio-Based -- Recycling Carbon
59
LanzaTech
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
60
Water for Renewable Hydrogen
Examples of potential feedstock which can be used for production of renewable fuels
Renewable Hydrogen plus Carbon Dioxide to Methanol or Methane
Power to Fuel
Not Just Renewable Fuels --�Co-Products!
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
61
Celtic Renewables
Raisinor/U.C.V.A Distillery
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
62
Feedstock Sustainability Criteria
Edible oil crops
Edible Sugars
1st gen-crop based
Advanced and waste
waste and residue lipids
purposely grown energy plants
Agricultural residues
Oil trees on degraded land
Rotational Cover Crops
Oil cover crops
Cellulosic Cover Crops
Forestry Residues
Wood Processing Waste
Municipal solid waste
Recycled Carbon
Non-biomass based
Reusable plastic waste
Industrial waste gas
CO2 from direct air capture (DAC)
CO2 from point source capture (CCS)
Other (e.g. gas from steel production)
Focus of analysis
Palm
Soybean
Other (incl. sunflower, rapeseed/canola)
Sugar Cane
Maize
Other
Used cooking oil (industrial or private sources)
Animal waste fat (tallow)
Other (incl. tall oil, technical corn oil, fish oil, POME, PFAD)
Jatropha, pongamia
Camelina, carineta, pennycress
Miscanthus, switchgrass, reed canary grass
Rice Straw
Sugarcane bagasse
Other (incl. corn stover, cereal residues)
Feedstock type
Feedstock Category
Feedstock
Substantial GHG savings potential
No fundamental sustainability concerns
Satisfied
Potentially Satisfied
Not Satisfied
A Few Types of Jobs Available in Renewable Fuels Feedstock Development and Production
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
63
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels?
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
64
How are they made?
Feedstock
Logistics
Technology
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
65
Logistics: Harvest, Storage, Transport
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
66
Logistics: Harvest, Storage, Transport
67
67
Logistics: Harvest, Storage, Transport
Logistics: Harvest, Storage, Transport
Storage of co-product, carbon dioxide (CO2), for carbon sequestration
Graphic from Rocky Mountain Coal Mining Institute
http://www.rmcmi.org/education/carbon-capture-storage#.X-zZi9hKhPY
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
68
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels?
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
69
How are they made?
Feedstock
Logistics
Technology
Recycling Carbon ��Why is the sustainable renewable fuel industry concerned about capturing CO2 and CH4? Consider this reason:�
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
Processes
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
71
Biochemical
Thermochemical/Catalysis
Overcoming the �Technical Roadblocks to Low-Cost Advanced Biofuel Production
-- Make all components of biomass available for biofuel and co-product production (Use the appropriate parts of specific plants)
-- Improve the efficiency of biomass to biofuel conversion (Do it faster, cheaper, sustainably)
-- Minimize the cost of biomass transportation (Move more for less)
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
72
72
“Why aren’t we there yet?”� Biomass Recalcitrance
(“You can make anything you want from lignin except money”)
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
73
Making Plant Biomass �Available for Biofuel Production �Biomass Recalcitrance
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
74
Making Plant Biomass �Available for Biofuel Production �Sugar Availability in Plant Cell Walls
This is the “woody” material that gives trees great tensile strength
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
75
75
Making Plant Biomass �Available for Biofuel Production �Overcoming Biomass Recalcitrance
Researchers are pursuing at least four different approaches to overcome biomass recalcitrance
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
76
76
Making Plant Biomass �Available for Biofuel Production �Overcoming Biomass Recalcitrance
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
77
77
Making Plant Biomass �Available for Biofuel Production �Overcoming Biomass Recalcitrance
Discover enzymes that will “deconstruct” cell wall matrices
Examples: Leaf Cutter Ants, Termites, Horse or Panda Feces, sea hare slugs.
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
78
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
79
Praj 2nd Generation Ethanol and Bioplastics Work
Virent’s BioForming Platform
Recent announcement of working with Cargill to use dextrose from corn ethanol production as feedstock
https://advancedbiofuelsusa.info/cargill-virent-collaborate-on-biobased-fuels-and-chemicals/
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
82
Clariant ferments straw/stover/grasses/bagasse via enzymes and microorganisms to multiple products
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
84
Anaerobic Digester
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
86
Fermentation and Anaerobic Digestion as Integral Parts of Gevo’s
Net Zero 1 Biorefinery System
Anaerobic Digestion
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
87
Anaerobic Digestion
Hydrogen (Bio-Hydrogen), E-Fuels
Hydrogen (Bio-Hydrogen), E-Fuels: Cautions and Comparisons
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
89
Recycling Carbon
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
90
Synhelion uses RED II-certified CO2 and methane from biowaste as a carbon source to ensure clean production.
Process Path: Biomass-to-Fuels and Products
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
91
Graphic by Zina Deretsky, National Science Foundation
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
92
Recycling Carbon
Recycling Carbon
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
93
Anaerobic Digestion
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
94
Bright Renewables CO2 liquefaction plant is a prefab compact containerized technology
The facility consists of eight collector containers, with an annual capture capacity of 500 tons each. Iceland location; Swiss company
Co-product and/or Feedstock:
Carbon Capture and Storage or Use
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
95
Water for Renewable Hydrogen via Electrolysis
Examples of potential feedstock which can be used for production of renewable fuels
Renewable Hydrogen plus Captured Carbon Dioxide to Methanol
Power to Fuel
A Few Types of Jobs Available in Advanced Biofuels Production
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
96
What Are Sustainable Renewable Fuels?
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
97
How are they made?
What are they used for?
Why are they important?
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
98
What We Have
Why Replacing Fossil Fuel Is Important
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
99
What We Could Have
Why Replacing Fossil Fuel Is Important
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
100
Windmills and solar
can produce electricity
but cannot power jet airplanes.
Why Replacing Fossil Fuel Is Important
Virtually no oil is used to produce electricity in the US.
Before oil runs out, it becomes more difficult and dangerous to extract.
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
101
Why Replacing Fossil Fuel Is Important
Before oil runs out, it becomes more difficult and dangerous to extract.
102
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
Why Replacing Fossil Fuel Is Important
Waste Management,
Landfill Management
103
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
Why Replacing Fossil Fuel Is Important
Solutions to Problems
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
104
Why Replacing Fossil Fuel is Important
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
105
Zero Emissions Vehicle…?
GHG Emissions
GHG Emissions
Nuclear
Coal Mining
Natural Gas Fracking
Power Plant
Solar
Wind
Hydro
Rare Earth Metal Mining
Batteries
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
106
Zero Emissions Vehicle…?
GHG Emissions
GHG Emissions
Nuclear
Coal Mining
Natural Gas Fracking
Power Plant
Solar
Wind
Hydro
Rare Earth Metal Mining
Batteries
34%
20%
36%
0.33%
2.9%
1.35%
Captured methane: 0.3%
Solid Waste: 0.5%
Wood/Biomass: 0.17%
2019
Frederick, Maryland
A Few Types of Jobs in Communicating Importance of Advanced Biofuels
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
107
Barriers and Challenges�Not as easy as we hoped!
TECHNICAL CHALLENGES, Biomass Recalcitrance, Enzyme Recycling, …
FINANCING “New” & “Never Been Done Before” Technologies …
POLICY ISSUES / CONTROVERSIES: Feedstock Cost Reductions, Efficient Land Use, Sustainability
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
108
��
Advocates for the adoption of sustainable, renewable fuels as
solutions.
Advanced Biofuels USA
501(c)3 Nonprofit
Educational Organization
Founded April 2008
Website:
Frederick, MD
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
109
��
Joanne Ivancic, Executive Director
+1 301-644-1395
Advanced Biofuels USA
501(c)3 Nonprofit
Educational Organization
Founded April 2008
Website:
Frederick, MD
Copyright 2023 Advanced Biofuels USA
110
Advanced Biofuels
for a
Truly Sustainable
Renewable
Future