1 of 10

APPRAISAL OF LAND WITH MINERAL RESOURCES

Author's project of Doctor of Sciences Vladimir Punko

58 rue Nicolas Meyers, L-4918 Bascharage, Luxembourg

+352 691722839 E-mail: рunko.lux&ukr.net +380 67 6889829 Viber&WhatsApp

The cost of 1 hectare of agricultural land in Europe

.

2 of 10

APPRAISAL OF LAND WITH MINERAL RESOURCES

Author's project of Doctor of Sciences Vladimir Punko

58 rue Nicolas Meyers, L-4918 Bascharage, Luxembourg

+352 691722839 E-mail: рunko.lux&ukr.net +380 67 6889829 Viber&WhatsApp

Updated: 12 April 2023 For Germany, the market price of sand is $116/ton.

WHOLESALE PRICE 110 - 112 $/ton Sand quartz dry coat 0.4-0.8 mm 0.8-1.2 mm 1.2-1.6 mm

The formula for assessing the value of land with mineral resources:

Add to the cadastral value of a piece of land the value of a mineral resource that is located in a given piece of land.

Thus, on April 12, 1 hectare of land with a conditional 1,000,000 tons of sand will cost

(if we evaluate a hectare of land in Poland)

116 x 1,000,000 + cadastral value = $116,009,699

.

3 of 10

APPRAISAL OF LAND WITH MINERAL RESOURCES

Author's project of Doctor of Sciences Vladimir Punko

58 rue Nicolas Meyers, L-4918 Bascharage, Luxembourg

+352 691722839 E-mail: рunko.lux&ukr.net +380 67 6889829 Viber&WhatsApp

The project is focused on:

owners and owners of land;

legal entities and individuals;

banks and insurance companies;

investment and financial structures;

private firms and government agencies;

ministries and departments of states, geological, mining and mining companies who are interested in increasing capitalization by identifying

– geological survey, prospecting and exploration in the depths mineral resources

and valuation of land with mineral resources.

4 of 10

APPRAISAL OF LAND WITH MINERAL RESOURCES� Author's project of Doctor of Sciences Vladimir Punko58 rue Nicolas Meyers, L-4918 Bascharage, Luxembourg� +352 691722839 E-mail: рunko.lux&ukr.net +380 67 6889829 Viber&WhatsApp�

  • The project is based on:

  • Copyright Punko V.P. for the investment geotoxicological register of mineral resources - Certificate No. 104036 of the Ukrainian Institute of Intellectual Property dated April 15, 2021

  • Glossary of the Investment Geotoxicological Register of Mineral Resource sunder the editorship of the International Auditor, Honorary scout of the subsoil, Honorary Geotoxicologist, Expert of Mineral Resources, ScD Punko V.P. - https://gplan.com.ua/hromadas/geogoliya

  • International Valuation Standards IGO 14 - Valuation of property in the mining industries dated January 31, 2020

  • United Nations Framework Classification for Fossil Energy and Mineral Resources, 2009
  • and United Nations Framework Classification of Resources – Update, 2019

  • International reporting system for mineral reserves of CRIRSCO series standards:
  • JORC CODE – 2012,
  • CIM DEFINITION STANDARDS - 2014,
  • SME Guide - 2017
  • PERC Reporting Standard – 2021
  • and other standards

5 of 10

APPRAISAL OF LAND WITH MINERAL RESOURCES� Author's project of Doctor of Sciences Vladimir Punko58 rue Nicolas Meyers, L-4918 Bascharage, Luxembourg� +352 691722839 E-mail: рunko.lux&ukr.net +380 67 6889829 Viber&WhatsApp�

Qualification of the author of the project

2023 March 31 - Doctor of Science in Geology and Mineralogy

No. 00101-2023 Ministry of Higher Education and Research - Government of the Grand Duke of Luxembourg

2022 September 8 – master No. 7-1/22/2438-2 Education and Youth Council, Estonia

2022 September 7 – Bachelor No. 7-1/22/2437-2 Education and Youth Council, Estonia

2022 August 31 – PhD No. 7-1/22/2312-2 Education and Youth Council, Estonia

2009 April 18 - expert in assessing the rights to objects and intellectual property of the State Property Fund of Ukraine

No. 203 Ukrainian commercial school

2003 April 15 – mineral resources expert

No. MP/01/2003 - Certification Center for Subsoil Use Objects of Ukraine of the State Geological Survey of Ukraine

2003 April 15 - Lead Auditor of Quality Management Systems, Environment, Health and Safety, Social Responsibility, Corporate Responsibility

No. CM/01/2003 - Certification Center for Subsoil Use Objects of Ukraine of the State Geological Survey of Ukraine

2001 May 10 - Lead Auditor of ISO 9000 Quality Management Systems with registration: IRCA – International Register of Certificated Auditors IQA – Governing Board of the Institute of Quality Assuarance IATCA – International Auditor and Training Certification Association

No. LA2/01/UA/209 BVQI – Bureau VERITAS Quality International

2000 December 11 - Lead Auditor of Environmental Management Systems with registration: IRCA – International Register of Certificated Auditors

№ ЕА/00/RU/282 BVQI – Bureau VERITAS Quality International

1999 December 20 - Doctor of Geological and Mineralogical Sciences

DGM No. 0239 - Higher Inter-Academic Attestation Commission of the Russian Federation

1997 June 13 - Candidate of Geological and Mineralogical sciences

CT No. 032404 - State Higher Attestation Committee of the Russian Federation

1987 June 30 - mining engineer - geologist, specialty: geological survey, prospecting and exploration of mineral deposits

PV No. 225204 – Leningrad Mining Institute, Russia

1979 February 28 - electrical technician, specializing in the construction and installation of power lines

BT No. 390041 - Dniester Energy College, Moldova

6 of 10

APPRAISAL OF LAND WITH MINERAL RESOURCES� Author's project of Doctor of Sciences Vladimir Punko�58 rue Nicolas Meyers, L-4918 Bascharage, Luxembourg� +352 691722839 E-mail: рunko.lux&ukr.net +380 67 6889829 Viber&WhatsApp�

Experience of the author of the project

2023 Member of the Supervisory Board UPSK - Ukrainian Fire Insurance Company(assessment of insurance risks: assessment of lands with mineral resources; geological mining, mining and processing companies; environmental), Ukraine, Kyiv

2021 – 2023 Expert on mineral resources of the Innovative and Financial Institute of Mineral Resources, Ukraine, Kyiv2019 - 2023Member of the Public Council of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine Committee on Social Policy and Protection of Veterans' Rights

2019 – 2023 Member of the working group on environmental impact assessment and strategic environmental assessment of the Verkhovna Rada Committee on Environmental Policy and Nature Management

2018 – 2023 Chairman of the Public Council on Mineral Resources of the KNOWLEDGE Society of Ukraine, Kyiv

2018-2020 Rector - Head of the Department of Geodesy, Land Management and Ecology - Professor - University of Advanced Technologies, Ukraine, Kyiv

2014-2017 Deputy General Director Black Sea State Regional Geological Enterprise, Ukraine, Odessa

2008-2013 Head of the Department of Environmental Standardization, Certification and Audit - Professor - Director of the Center for Environmental Management, Engineering and Registry State Ecological Academy of Postgraduate Education and Management of the Ministry of Environmental Protection of Ukraine

2005-2008 General Director of the Management Certification Center, Ukraine, Kyiv

2003-2005 Director of the Certification Center for Subsoil Use Objects of Ukraine

1992-2023 Mineral resource expert - head of the Geotoxicology department - director of the scientific and marketing company Bureau of Mineral Resources, Ukraine, Odessa

1992 Head of the Sea Ecology Department of the Odessa Regional State Administration, Ukraine, Odessa

1990-1991 Research Laboratory Engineer, Mechnikov Odessa State University, Ukriana, Odessa

1989-1992 Mineral Resources Expert - General Director of the Association of Science and Engineering of the Center for Economic, Scientific and Technical Activities and Social Initiatives of the USSR Academy of Sciences(ZENDISI at the Academy of Sciences of the USSR), Ukraine, Odessa

1987-1990 Geologist of the Black Sea Exploration Expedition of the Ministry of Geology of Ukraine, Odessa

1985-1987 Technician - Senior Technician - Marine Geological Parties of the All-Union Geological Institute (VSEGEI), Russia, Leningrad

1982-1984 Laboratory assistant at various laboratories of the Leningrad Mining Institute, Russia, Leningrad

1979-1981 Military topographer - armed forces of the USSR

1975-1979 Electrical technician - master of electrical work - enterprises: Kazakhstan, Ukraine, Russia

7 of 10

APPRAISAL OF LAND WITH MINERAL RESOURCES� Author's project of Doctor of Sciences Vladimir Punko58 rue Nicolas Meyers, L-4918 Bascharage, Luxembourg� +352 691722839 E-mail: рunko.lux&ukr.net +380 67 6889829 Viber&WhatsApp�

First step

Declaration of intent of the parties

The declaration of intent of the parties is necessary when forming the assessment of lands with mineral resources to take into account a number of factors related to different profiles (legal, geological, geotoxicological, economic, financial, logistical, and others).

The declaration of intent of the parties provides for the partners to agree on several projects, each of which has its own agreements, and the discussed projects are interconnected in an obvious way - this format is the basis for signing a declaration of intent of the parties.

The declaration of intent of the parties is the basis for setting up the procedure for assessing lands with mineral resources.

The declaration of intent of the parties provides for the appointment of authorized persons and their powers in matters of valuation of lands with mineral resources.

The declaration of intent of the parties provides for the language of business correspondence and execution of documents preceding the assessment of lands with mineral resources.

The declaration of intent of the parties is formed on a non-financial basis.

The declaration of intent of the parties determines the dates, places and forms of events that determine the assessment of lands with mineral resources.

8 of 10

APPRAISAL OF LAND WITH MINERAL RESOURCES� Author's project of Doctor of Sciences Vladimir Punko58 rue Nicolas Meyers, L-4918 Bascharage, Luxembourg� +352 691722839 E-mail: рunko.lux&ukr.net +380 67 6889829 Viber&WhatsApp�

Second step

– Formation of terms of reference according to the assessment

of lands with mineral resources

Determination of the list of mineral resources to be assessed.

Legal aspects

Determination of the geodetic boundaries of a selected piece of land to be assessed

Formation of a methodology for assessing land with mineral resources for a specific allocated area

Evaluation Priority Determination:

  • holding an auction for the sale of land with mineral resources,
  • risk insurance of land valuation with mineral resources,
  • other forms of evaluation

Coordination of performers of land assessment with mineral resources.

Approval of the list of procedures to be performed in the process of valuation of land with mineral resources

Other questions

9 of 10

APPRAISAL OF LAND WITH MINERAL RESOURCES� Author's project of Doctor of Sciences Vladimir Punko58 rue Nicolas Meyers, L-4918 Bascharage, Luxembourg� +352 691722839 E-mail: рunko.lux&ukr.net +380 67 6889829 Viber&WhatsApp�

Third step

Consulting

Fourth step

Audit of completed works on evaluation

of lands with mineral resources

Fifth step

Conducting an assessment

of land with mineral resources

10 of 10

APPRAISAL OF LAND WITH MINERAL RESOURCES� Author's project of Doctor of Sciences Vladimir Punko58 rue Nicolas Meyers, L-4918 Bascharage, Luxembourg� +352 691722839 E-mail: рunko.lux&ukr.net +380 67 6889829 Viber&WhatsApp�

Recommendations

Asset management –

lands with mineral resources