1 of 48

This is Our Shot! �Evaluating and Reducing Vaccine Related Errors in Outpatient Care Clinics

Hope Vertrice Askew, Pharm.D.

PGY-1 Health System Pharmacy Administration & Leadership Resident

Parkland Health

Dallas, TX

May 4th, 2022

2 of 48

Financial Relationship Disclosure

No relevant financial relationships have been established in the past 24 months with ineligible companies in accordance with the Standards for Integrity and Independence.

1

3 of 48

Learning Objectives – Pharmacist

2

Evaluate current advisory and governmental guidelines regarding appropriateness of immunization administration

Identify the key steps associated with vaccine administration

Describe the challenges of vaccine administration that lead to errors

Analyze immunization related errors that occurred within a single health system’s low-income urban outpatient care clinics

Discuss various ways to reduce vaccine related errors

4 of 48

Learning Objectives – Pharmacy Technicians

3

Discuss current advisory and governmental guidelines regarding appropriateness of immunization administration

Describe the key steps associated with vaccine administration

Describe the challenges of vaccine administration that lead to errors

Identify immunization related errors that occurred within a single health system’s low-income urban outpatient care clinics

Discuss various ways to reduce vaccine related errors

5 of 48

Background

  • The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) and the Center of Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) have published official recommendations regarding routine vaccinations for various age groups

​

  • Where a consistent trend of reports regarding improper vaccine administrations have been identified at Parkland Health

​

  • Emphasizing the need for improvements in immunizer education, optimization of the electric health record, and advancement in various safety warnings/precautions associated with the administration of vaccinations

​

  • Reducing vaccine related safety events should be included in the strategic plan for all companies involved in direct patient care

4

6 of 48

CDC’s Best Practice Guidelines for Immunizations

5

An error can occur at any step

Transportation and Storage

Review Immunization History

Assess Need for Immunization

Screen for Contraindications and Precautions

Educate the Patient

Prepare the Vaccine(s)

Administer the Vaccine(s)

Document the Vaccination(s)

Kroger A, Bahta L, Hunter P. General Best Practice Guidelines for Immunization.

Let us pay particular attention to the administration step, and how it can impact all the other steps

7 of 48

The 7 Rights of Vaccination Administration

#1 The Right Patient

    • Confirm 2 patient identifiers
    • Ensure screening for contraindications and precautions

6

Wexler D. Technically speaking: Know the "7 rights" of vaccine administration.

#2 The Right Time

    • In accordance with CDC’s immunization schedule recommendations

#3 The Right Vaccine (and diluent)

    • Double check the vaccine product to the patient
    • Check the vial 3x’s for correct product
    • Check expiration date of vaccine & diluent before preparing/administering

#4 The Right Dosage

    • Pediatric dosing vs. adult dosing

#5 The Right Route, Needle and Technique

    • Deviations can reduce vaccine efficacy or increase local adverse reactions

#6 The Right Injection Site

    • Administering vaccine into the wrong site (ie, IM instead of subcutaneously)

#7 The Right Documentation

    • follow federal law and fully document each immunization in your patient’s chart
    • Provide patient an immunization record
    • Submit vaccine information to appropriate state or local immunization information system

8 of 48

​

​

7

In which setting are vaccine related errors most commonly reported?

Community Pharmacies

Hospital Inpatient Care

Physician Offices

Outpatient / Public Health Clinics

2%

3%

31%

54%

Institute for Safe Medication Practices. ISMP National Vaccine Errors Reporting Program 2017 Analysis (Part I): vaccine errors continue with little change

Active Learning

9 of 48

What happens when things go wrong?

  • Vaccine related events most commonly occur (~72%) in non-pediatric outpatient settings
    • Where, 89% of all vaccine errors reached the patient

​

  • The top 5 most common vaccine related errors are:
    • Wrong Vaccine (23%), Wrong Dose (19%), Expired Vaccine/Contaminated (19%), Wrong Age (17%), Wrong time/interval (8%)

​

  • 61% of all errors involve medical assistants, RN’s, and LVN’s
    • 8% Physicians; 5% Nurse Practitioners; 2% Pharmacist

​

  • Individual vaccine error rates are dependent on how common that vaccine is used in that setting and patient population
    • Example: increased error rate of Hepatitis A and HPV vaccines in public health immunization clinics compared to inpatient care

​

​

​

8

2-year summary of the ISMP National Vaccine Errors Reporting Program (Part I). Institute For Safe Medication Practices.

Institute for Safe Medication Practices. ISMP National Vaccine Errors Reporting Program 2017 Analysis (Part I): vaccine errors continue with little change

10 of 48

While none of the reported errors caused immediate harm to the patient...

Improper or missed vaccinations may have a detrimental effect on individual and public health. Leading to:

disease outbreaks

loss of herd immunity

costly overvaccination/re-vaccination, and consumer skepticism of vaccination

11 of 48

So, How Does Parkland Compare?

12 of 48

11

This means we have ~2 safety posts reported monthly

13 of 48

12

Patient Demographics

14 of 48

13

15 of 48

14

16 of 48

15

17 of 48

16

Comparing the Rate of Vaccine Related Errors Amongst Different Providers

18 of 48

Our Identified Challenges

19 of 48

Informatic and Electronic Health Record Challenges

18

According to the Care Gaps, COVID-19 vaccination is not needed

What does health maintenance, say?

20 of 48

Informatic and Electronic Health Record Challenges (continued)

19

According to the Immunization Tab,

the patient is in fact, due for their 2nd COVID-19 dose!

(>21 days since 1st dose)

Inconsistent reporting of vaccine information can lead to misinformation if the immunizer is not diligent on screening the patient for appropriateness prior to administration!

21 of 48

Informatic and Electronic Health Record Challenges (continued)

20

No alert to the person ordering and/or verifying that there is a contraindication for use (like typically received with medication orders)

22 of 48

21

*No alert auto populates if wrong dose or site of administration is chosen

Upon documentation of the ordered vaccine’s administration…

23 of 48

Current Vaccine Related Warnings and Alerts

22

If placing a duplicate order that has not been administered yet

​

​

If placing a duplicate order that has already been administered the SAME day as the new (duplicate) order

24 of 48

In An Ideal Patient and Medication Safety World

23

Ability for immunizations to appear on the MAR in Outpatient Epic Hyperspace.

​

Would allow for alerts (too soon to give, duplicate therapy, contraindications, etc.) to auto-populate upon entering order, verifying order, and scanning vial

25 of 48

A 52-year-old female presents to the family medicine clinic for a routine checkup. You overhear her nurse instructing their tech to obtain a COVID-19 vaccine from the medication room. So, she can administer it per patient request. You remember seeing this patient in diabetes clinic last week where you recall the patient showing you her vaccination card that had no outstanding doses needed. What should NOT be done next?

  1. No further investigation, administer the dose per patient request (risk vs. benefit)
  2. Verbally verify with the patient if she has her vaccination card with her and administer only if it is the appropriate timing per recommendations
  3. If the patient does not have her vaccination card, attempt to reconcile the patient's immunizations within the Immunization Tab in Epic to confirm patients' vaccination history
  4. Do not administer the vaccination and defer to when the patient is able to provide their vaccination card/history
  5. Update the immunization tab with the dates you remember seeing on the patient's card so there is no further confusion at future visits

​

24

Learning Assessment

26 of 48

Parkland’s Most Common Immunization Related Errors

25

Storage

Review Immunization History

Assess Need for Immunization

Screen for Contraindications and Precautions

Educate the Patient

Prepare the Vaccine(s)

Administer the Vaccine(s)

Document the Vaccination(s)

27 of 48

#1 – Preparation Errors

  • Preparing multiple vaccines for different patients at the same time 🡪 confusing which vaccine was prepared for which patient

​

  • Lack of knowledge and/or ability to seek help from a quick reference source on how to properly prepare the vaccine (correct diluent, needle, dose etc.)

​

  • Drawing up (and administering) the wrong dose and/or via the wrong route

26

28 of 48

#1 – Preparation Errors

27

29 of 48

#2 – Assessing the Need for Immunization

  • Not consulting The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) and the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommendations and guidelines regarding routine vaccine schedule and proper timing of vaccine

​

  • Not confirming the patients identify prior to administering (language barrier and similar sounding names are common)

​

  • Lack of verification of contraindications prior to administration

​

  • Vaccines are NOT able to be recognized in EPIC as a medication. Unable to display on the patients MAR, no pt specific warnings can auto generate

​

  • Standing delegating order 🡪 no double verification of the “7 rights”

​

​

​

​

​

28

30 of 48

#2 – Review of Immunization History (continued)

  • Clicking into the immunization tab, requires 2-3 extra clicks outside of the normal nursing navigator

​

  • Unfamiliarity with administering vaccines, lack in general knowledge of ambulatory nursing workflow, and/or distraction upon review

​

  • Listening to the patient when they deny or condone that they have received a vaccine without double checking the immunization tab or reconciling the patient's vaccinations

​

  • Placing the order or seeing in previous provider’s note the desire to administer a vaccine, but fails to review immunization history of patient prior to administration

29

31 of 48

30

#2 – Assessing the Need for Immunization

32 of 48

31

#2 – Assessing Appropriateness of the Immunization

33 of 48

#3 – Administration Errors

  • Standing delegating order 🡪 no double verification of the “7 rights” or approval my patients' primary provider prior to administration

​

  • Improperly administering a vaccine via the wrong route or administering diluent/air with no vaccine

​

  • Lack of following current procedures for after administration of vaccines, leading to falls and adverse events.

32

34 of 48

#3 – Administration Errors

33

35 of 48

Other Identified Problems: Storage & Documentation

  • Immunizers are not required to place the vaccine order prior to obtaining the vaccine from the medication room and/or administering the vaccine

​

  • Accidently confusing a vaccines with another, due to the ability to obtain any vial out of medication room/fridge and administering it prior to a second verification

​

  • Placing refrigerated vaccines in the freezer or at room temperature and vice versa

​

  • Administering expired vaccines/ diluents

​

  • Not required to document administration prior discharging patient and/or closing the visit

34

36 of 48

35

Other Identified Problems: Storage & Documentation

37 of 48

Let’s Discuss…

38 of 48

37

Active Learning

39 of 48

Current Interventions�An Interdisciplinary Team Effort

40 of 48

Designing and implementing ‘vaccine pocket cards’ that will be easily accessible (online and tangibly in-person) to nursing staff.

​

Will serve as a quick reference for immunizations that are commonly administered at Parkland Health.

39

We are actively partnering with nursing on

41 of 48

40

Vaccine Pocket Card Example:

42 of 48

We are actively partnering with nursing on

Optimization of the procedure utilized within the nursing workflow to:

    • ensure and emphasize a complete vaccine history is being obtain via the immunization information system (IIS), previous medical records, and personal vaccination records
    • consider the need for double verification prior to ordering and/or administration of vaccinations

41

43 of 48

Future Direction�An Interdisciplinary Team Effort

44 of 48

Adding a clickable link within the order and/or documentation screen that would be routed directly to lexicomp for the specific immunization ordered

43

In the pipeline: partnering with nursing and the

clinical informatics team on

Hepatitis A Vaccine – Lexicomp Link

Hepatitis A Vaccine – Lexicomp Link

45 of 48

Future Direction

  • To collaborate with Epic Hyperspace to design auto-populated alerts regarding inappropriate ordering/administration of vaccinations

​

  • To collaborate with Epic Hyperspace to allow for the incorporation of immunizations to be billed/designated as a medication instead of a procedure so it may show up on the patients MAR (allowing for alerts)

​

  • To partner with nursing education to aid in the development and integration of a new immunization training program into orientation and yearly education for all immunizers at Parkland Health
    • The new training will focus on appropriate vaccine timing, indications, and Parkland specific immunization workflow (how to confirm a patient’s immunization history)
    • Current training focuses on vaccine storage practices and non-specific parkland administration recommendations

44

46 of 48

Acknowledgements

  • Talemah Jones, MS, PharmD., Director Ambulatory Off-Campus Population Health
  • Carrie Berge, MS, PharmD., Vice President of Pharmacy Services
  • Rusty Appleberry-Recker, PharmD.; Director of Ambulatory Campus Specialty Services
  • Jacilyn McNulty, PharmD.; PGY-2 HSPAL Resident

45

47 of 48

Resources

  1. Kroger A, Bahta L, Hunter P. General Best Practice Guidelines for Immunization. Best Practices Guidance of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP). [www.cdc.gov/vaccines/hcp/acip-recs/general- recs/downloads/generalrecs.pdf].
  2. Wexler D. Technically speaking: Know the "7 rights" of vaccine administration. https://www.immunize.org/technically-speaking/20141101.asp. Published January 7, 2015.
  3. Confusion abounds! 2-year summary of the ISMP National Vaccine Errors Reporting Program (Part I). Institute For Safe Medication Practices. https://www.ismp.org/resources/confusion-abounds-2-year-summary-ismp-national-vaccine-errors-reporting-program-part-i?id=95. Published December 4, 2014.
  4. Institute for Safe Medication Practices. ISMP National Vaccine Errors Reporting Program 2017 Analysis (Part I): vaccine errors continue with little change. https://www.ismp.org/resources/ ismp-national-vaccine-errors-reporting-program2017-analysis-part-i-vaccine-errors. Published June 14, 2018.
  5. Immunization schedules. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/schedules/index.html. Published August 23, 2021.
  6. Sarah E. Brewer, Juliana Barnard, Jennifer Pyrzanowski, Sean T. O'Leary, Amanda F. Dempsey. Use of Electronic Health Records to Improve Maternal Vaccination. Women's Health Issues. Volume 29, Issue 4, 2019, Pages 341-348,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.whi.2019.04.017.

​

​

46

48 of 48

Questions?

Hope Vertrice Askew, Pharm.D.

PGY-1 Health System Pharmacy Administration & Leadership Resident

Parkland Health

Dallas, TX

​

hope.askew@phhs.org

​

​