THE NEUROPLATFORM : TOWARDS A COMPREHENSIVE MECHANISTIC QUANTITATIVE SYSTEMS PHARMACOLOGY MODEL OF ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE FOR SUPPORTING DRUG DISCOVERY AND DEVELOPMENT
Hugo Geerts
Certara
Alzheimer’s Disease : The Problem
Treatment Options
-tacrine (1992)
-donepezil (2000)
-galantamine* (2000)
-rivastigmine (2000)
-memantine (2004)
…
>200 trial failures
…
Courtesy of R. Tanzi
2
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
From Molecular Biomarkers to Clinical Function in AD
3
Clinical
Scales
Synapse
EEG,
BOLDfMRI
Network
Gene-gene
coregulated
Causal networks
ADAS-Cog
CDR-SOB
Clinical Biomarkers
Functional Biomarkers
Neuro-Fibrillary Tangles
Amyloid plaques
Microglia
3
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Outline
4
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Computational Neuroscience:�How can we maximize drug effects on symptoms? ��
Simulating Neuronal Network Activity as Proxy for Functional Outcomes
5
Simulating Neuronal Circuits in a Biophysically Realistic Way
Brain regions are represented by synaptically coupled biophysical models of neurons
Both imaging studies (BOLDfMRI) and icEEG) and interventional studies (rTMS) suggest neuronal firing drives domain-specific clinical outcomes.
In Silico Biosciences
Applying Hodgkin-Huxley equations to predict firing dynamics in specific neuronal networks that drive clinical outcomes
6
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
INTERMEZZO 1 : NEURON MODEL EQUATION
7
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Raster diagram readout
A) Model Neurons
B) Microcircuits
C) Full Circuit
The nuclei (thalamus, cortex, basal ganglia) are synaptically interconnected with known anatomy to form the full model.
Synaptic strengths are adjusted so that the spontaneous spiking activity is consistent with electrophysiological data in the literature.
This state of the model represents the “healthy” case.
8
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Introducing drug exposure and target engagement
A) Model Neurons
B) Microcircuits
C) Full Circuit
D) Drug Pharmacology & Target Engagement
The effects of neuromodulators (dopamine, serotonin, etc) are added to the model by computing the activation of receptors with a receptor competition model.
E) Physiological coupling
9
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Defining Pathology and Circuit Emergent Properties
A) Model Neurons
B) Microcircuits
C) Full Circuit
F) Pathology
E) Receptor activation
G) In Silico Biomarker
AD Disease Pathology is introduced using imaging and postmortem data. (1) APOE genotype dependent Synapse loss, (2) Neuronal cell loss and (3) cholinergic state changes
Working Memory span depends on pathology and pharmacological intervention.
D) Drug Pharmacology & Target Engagement
Amyloid pathology affects NMDA, AMPA and GABA leading to hyperactivity
Tau pathology affects Na+ and K+ channels
10
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Calibration with Clinical Data
A) Model Neurons
B) Microcircuits
C) Full Circuit
F) Pathology
E) Receptor activation
G) In Silico Biomarker
Calibrate using published clinical trials
Adjust coupling parameters on receptor effects to best match linear causal relationship with simulated historical clinical trials.
D) Drug Pharmacology & Target Engagement
11
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Amyloid Aggregation Model��
Simulating Effect of anti-amyloid antibodies on biomarkers and cognition
12
Mechanistic Physiology-Based PharmacoKinetic Model
Chang et al. 2019. J.Pharmacokinet. Pharmacodyn.
Amyloid Aggregation QSP Platform
APOE
degradation
Monomer
Monomer
Oligomeric
ProtoFibril
ProtoFibril
Oligomeric
Fragmentation
Elongation
Nucleation
Breakdown
kf
kb
Microglia clearance
Plaques
Plaques
SUVR imaging
X
X
Sec nucleation
(DAM)
synthesis
Shorter Aβ40
Longer Aβ42
Based on microscopic kinetic equations (Knowles group -Oxford)
SUVR = Standard Uptake Value Ratio
CSF Ab42
Plasma Ab42
Plasma Ab40
Drug Exposure from PBPK
Geerts CPT : PSP ;12(4):444-461 (2023)
14
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
INTERMEZZO 2 : AMYLOID AGGREGATION MODEL EQUATION
trimer gaining monomer
Loss of monomer from pentamer
tetramer losing monomer to trimer
pentamer gaining monomer
trimer gaining monomer on plaque
Tetramer losing monomer on plaque
tetramer cleared by microglia
a(j) bound by antibody
tetramer moving to perivascular space
v
tetramer
15
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Model Can Reproduce Observed Change in Biomarkers
TRAILBLAZER
GRADUATE
16
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
QSP Model Predicts Different Biomarker Profile of Lecanemab
Adu
Gan
Leca
Lecanemab has the biggest effect on protofibrils
Plaques
Leca
Adu
Gan
No real difference with aducanumab & gantenerumab
17
© Copyright 2022 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
QSP Model Predicts Differentiation on Side-Effect of ARIA-E
Perivascular QSP Model
Adu
Leca
Time-to-event modeling
18
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Plasma-tau Change is Driven by Soluble Ab42 species
Plaques
R2=0.05
Protofibrils*
R2=0.62
Oligomers*
R2=0.56
Monomers*
R2=0.39
Aggregation
Multiple Regression
R2=0.69
32 observations
7 antibodies
19
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Addressing Treatment Challenges in Clinical Practice
Biomarker of reaching amyloid negativity
Maintenance Dosing
Restarting after ARIA-E interruption
Therapeutic Index in virtual patient trial
Geerts 2024, in press
20
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Soluble Abeta species affect excitation-inhibition balance in neuronal networks
Network performance
Network Performance
ADAS-Cog
Slope β
Time
Slope α
Slope α*
Aβ40
Aβ42
xo
Total Aβ
Glu Effect
α7 Nicotinic Effect
Aβ42 (y)
Aβ40 (x)
ΔT
ΔT
Aβ load
Geerts et al 2018, Geerts et al 2020
Can explain 3 different clinical observational datasets
Can explain clinical effect of BACE-inhibitors
Generate hypothesis for difference between EMERGE and ENGAGE outcome
Huijbers 2018 : Amyloid deposition is related to BOLD hyperactivity
Oligomeric Abeta increases excitability
Complex monomer Abeta effects
21
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
QSP Model of Amyloid-Tau Interaction
Z
v
Amyloid aggregation model
PFC microcolumn
Neuronal Activity
Intrasynaptic pTau217
v
Amyloid PET
Monomer dynamics
Oligomer dynamics
CSF/plasma pTau217& CSF tau dynamics
Firing activity
Control : Increased deposition
Increased Ab42 oligomer, increased firing
Aβ42 oligomers
Amyloid antibody : reduces Ab42 oligomer, reduced firing
v
Geerts 2023
Activity-dependent Tau secretion
22
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
CDR-SOB changes and changes in Ab42 species
Plaques*
R2=0.41
Protofibrils
R2=0.39
Oligomers
R2=0.35
Monomers*
R2=0.37
Aggregation
Multiple Regression
R2=0.50
34 observations
7 antibodies
23
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Cognition and Neuronal Firing Move in Opposite Direction
Human Encoding uses information bandwidth (Shannon entropy)
Outcome of Computational Neuroscience Platform
MCI and Early Prodromal AD show hyperactivity
Reduced Firing by Amyloid Antibodies
24
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
25
TAU QUANTITATIVE SYSTEMS PHARMACOLOGY MODEL
Tau diffusion, interaction with antibody and uptake
CSF | ISF | Neurons | 1 synaptic cleft | All synaptic clefts |
0.16 liter | 0.26 liter | 0.76 liter | 0.04 fL | 1.2 milliliter |
20nm
500 nm
26
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Gosuranemab : No Effect Despite CSF Target Engagement
Geerts 2022
27
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Spatial Monte-Carlo Simulation In Synapse Geometry
P. D’Alcre 2015
28
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Seed Internalised Fraction is Not Affected by Antibodies
Lack of sufficient Target Engagement can explain clinical trial failure of first-generation antibodies
8000mg semorinemab
No “bridges’
Bridges spaced 8nm
Bridges spaced 80nm
29
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
QSP Model for IntraNeuronal Tau processing
Dendritic Region
Compartments 0-9
Axonal Region
Compartments 11-20
Cell Soma
Compartment 10
Secretion
Active/Passive Anterograde Movement
Active/Passive Retrograde Movement
Active/Passive Anterograde Movement
Active/Passive Retrograde Movement
Uptake
Processes
- axonal transport
- oligomerization
- degradation
- secretion at synapse
30
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Virtual Twin Model�Towards Personalized Treatment
Individual Cognitive Trajectories in AD are Very, Very Noisy
ADNI Database
Variability due to
- comedication
- common genotype variants
- Abeta pathology
- Tau pathology
- Various comorbidities
32
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Comedications and Genotypes Affect Cognitive Trajectory
APOEXX
APOE4X
APOE44
MM
MV
VV
LL
Ls
ss
LL
Ls
ss
LL
Ls
ss
LL
Ls
ss
LL
Ls
ss
LL
Ls
ss
LL
Ls
ss
LL
Ls
ss
LL
Ls
ss
MM
MV
VV
MM
MV
VV
5-HTTLPR rs23351
COMTVal158Met
APOE
Progression Rate 7-fold difference
Baseline 14 point difference
On same background of amyloid tau pathology
Geerts 2021
Patients on benzodiazepines, antidepressants, cholinergics, antipsychotics
33
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Misfolded Tau affects K+ and Na+ channels
34
Ken Kosik lab
Li Gan
V337M
FTD mutation
Axon Initial
Segment
Axon 6x60 um
Cell
Soma
Dendritic Tuft
V337M Tau mutation hIPSC on Multi-electrode Arrays
Create NEURON Model
Identify changes leading to same phenotype
Tau affects K+ and AIS Na+ channels
34
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Using Virtual Twins for Personalized Medicine
Individual target exposure & engagement
Variables
- Comedications
- Genotypes
- Amyloid load
- Tau load
Clinical Trial
outcome
Virtual patient trial
Identical distribution
“Virtual twins”
QSP Virtual Trial
Outcome
Compare on per-patient basis
Novel treatment
Natural Trajectory
Placebo
Tau
β-amyloid
Hill 2019
Wang 2013
Stimulated
Pyramidal
cells
Unstimulated
Pyramidal
cells
Inter
neurons
Memory Span
35
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
Conclusion Neuroplatform Properties
36
© Copyright 2020 Certara, L.P. All rights reserved.
THE NEUROPLATFORM : TOWARDS A COMPREHENSIVE MECHANISTIC QUANTITATIVE SYSTEMS PHARMACOLOGY MODEL OF ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE FOR SUPPORTING DRUG DISCOVERY AND DEVELOPMENT
Mike Walker
Rachel Rose
Silke Bergeler
Shaina Short
Viji Chellia
Doug Chung
Maryam Khalifa
Athena Grant
Jamie Goff
Ivo Schuttel
Athan Spiros
Patrick Roberts