1 of 106

Jenn Guerrero

SCOE Multilingual Learner Specialist

Region 1 Title III EL Specialist

Lauren Ridgway

SCOE ELA/ELD Coordinator

Multilingual Learner Collaborative

May 18, 2023

bit.ly/ELC2223

2 of 106

3 of 106

What is energizing you these days?

What is challenging you these days?

4 of 106

Today

bit.ly/ELC2223

  • Focus on Instruction
    • Designated ELD: Putting it all together

  • Professional learning opportunities

  • Miscellaneous goodies

Break Time

  • Narrowing Down to Find Common Ground: Shared Agreements for Effective Literacy Instruction in California

  • FPM: Reflections from the field

  • Updates

  • Closure

5 of 106

Focus on Instruction

Designated ELD:

Putting it All Together

6 of 106

7 of 106

The CA EL Roadmap

Adopted in 2017, this policy sets a vision and mission for our schools and was developed as an aspirational statement for what should be in place for California’s

1.2 million English learners.

8 of 106

  1. Assets-Oriented and Needs-Responsive Schools

  • Intellectual Quality of Instruction & Meaningful Access

  • System Conditions that Support Effectiveness

  • Alignment and Articulation Within & Across Systems

9 of 106

Principle #2

Delves into the heart of what is taught and how the teaching and learning of content and language are structured.

10 of 106

“More than pretty words on a page...”

11 of 106

EL Roadmap

Teacher Toolkits

EL Roadmap Admin Toolkits

12 of 106

Designed to support administrators as they take up the challenge of leading and supporting the implementation of the EL Roadmap policy.

The CA EL Roadmap Implementation Guide and Toolkit for Administrators

13 of 106

Volume 1

Leading Implementation

Volume 2

Creating Assets Oriented & Student Responsive Schools

Volume 3

Ensuring the Intellectual Quality of Instructional and Meaningful Access for ELs

Volume 4

System Conditions for Implementation

Volume 5

Aligning & Articulating Practices Across the Systems

14 of 106

September

September

Foundational Understandings:

Implications of Second Language Development for Classroom Practice

15 of 106

September

December

Powerful Learning Experiences:The way humans deeply learn a language is by actively using it in multiple ways.

Sentence Expansion using Phrases

16 of 106

September

March

What to look for

in Designated ELD:

Observation Tool

17 of 106

Today

Putting It All Together

18 of 106

19 of 106

Diving deeper into dELD

  • Pick your focus
  • Explore with your table group
  • Synthesize your learning
  • Share out

20 of 106

Pick your focus (2 minutes)

  • Scan Volume 3 of the EL Roadmap Admin Toolkit.
    • Hint: the table of contents is a great place to start!
  • What do you want to explore today?
  • Be ready to settle on a topic with your table group.

bit.ly/ELC2223

21 of 106

Pick your focus (3 minutes)

  • With your table group, settle on a focus for your exploration.

22 of 106

Exploration time (30 minutes)

  • Dig into resources that apply to your focus area.
    • Quiet reading room: Oak Room
  • Decide on a way to synthesize your learning.
  • Create something together to represent your new thinking, understanding, questions, next steps, etc.

23 of 106

Synthesize your learning

Create something together to represent your new thinking, understanding, questions, next steps, etc.

    • Poster
    • Video
    • Slide show
    • Adobe Spark
    • Canva
    • Song
    • Dance
    • Poem

24 of 106

Share out (10 minutes)

  • Pair up with one other group.
  • One group shares out their product.
  • The other group listens to ask questions and/or provide feedback.
    • I’m curious to know more about…?
    • I’m intrigued by…
    • I wonder…
  • Switch roles!

25 of 106

Improving Education for Multilingual and English Learner Students:

Research to Practice

26 of 106

Professional Learning Opportunities

27 of 106

The AIM Institute:

Affirming Instruction for Multilingual Learners

Designed to deepen participants’ understanding of

  • the California ELD Standards
  • designated and integrated ELD instruction
  • the Summative ELPAC exam

Participants will learn how to

  • use these elements to design meaningful instructional sequences and create educational spaces that lift up the promise, power, and genius of multilingual learners.

September 28th and 29th at SCOE

28 of 106

The AIM Institute:

Affirming Instruction for Multilingual Learners

Educators from Sonoma County districts that receive Title III funds are eligible to attend this professional learning series at no cost, which includes registration fees and sub costs. To ensure that all districts have the opportunity to register at least two people, registration will be divided up into two windows:

Registration Round 1 (window open from May 10 - August 25)

  • Sonoma County districts who receive Title III funds may register up to TWO educators. Registration fees and sub costs will be covered for both registrants.
  • Districts who would like to send more than two people may register additional educators in Round 2.

Registration Round 2 (window open from August 26 - September 19)

  • Registration opens for educators in all districts within and outside of Sonoma County. Registration fees and sub costs will only be covered for Sonoma County districts that receive Title III funds.
  • Educators who are outside of Sonoma County must pay a $250 registration fee and any associated sub costs.

29 of 106

Introduction to the Science of Reading Series

Every child has the right to read. How can we leverage years of scientific research to ensure that our instructional practices best meet the needs of the students in our classrooms?

Registration will be available on the SCOE website beginning on August 1st.

Grades TK-3

  • October 12, 19, and 26
  • 4:30-6:30pm

Grades 4-12

  • November 1 and 15
  • 4:30-6:30pm

NEW!

30 of 106

Family and Community Liaison Collaborative

Sessions will include professional learning focused on topics relevant to their role, exploration of resources they can bring back to families, and time to learn from and connect with colleagues from across the county and beyond.

9:00am- 12:00pm

  • Thursday, September 14th
  • Tuesday, December 19th
  • Thursday, February 8th (informal meet up at the Parent Institute)
  • Thursday, April 18th

Registration will open in June

31 of 106

Keynote presenters, participate in Q&A sessions with the California Department of Education, and receive valuable updates on California's assessments.

Attendees will have the opportunity to customize their learning experience by selecting from over 80 sessions presented by educators from across California.

32 of 106

Miscellaneous Goodies

33 of 106

34 of 106

35 of 106

A sampling

  • Asset-based Content and Language Instruction for Multilingual Learners in the Secondary Grades Institute

  • Developing and Strengthening Programs and Services to Meet the Needs of LTELs

  • English Learner Roadmap 101 for school board members

  • Integrated and Designated ELD Strand for Secondary Teachers

  • Leading School Improvement with English learners at the Heart: The English Learner Roadmap for Administrators Strand of Five Modules

  • Meeting the Unique Needs of Newcomers in the Classroom

Microsites

36 of 106

An online hub for research-based key principles, instructional strategies, and associated, free, practical, and easy-to-use resources that are geared towards educators who teach PreK-3rd Multilingual Learners.

New section added: Additional ELD Strategies

  • PreK- TK
  • Grades 1-2
  • Grades 2-3

37 of 106

38 of 106

Break Time

39 of 106

40 of 106

Narrowing Down to Find Common Ground

Shared Agreements for Effective Literacy Instruction in California

41 of 106

Every child has the right to read.

Because reading is a civil right.

42 of 106

43 of 106

44 of 106

Educational leaders at all levels and in all settings have a responsibility to put aside personal philosophies and build bridges between the science of reading and the classroom.

Nancy Hennessy, The Reading Comprehension Blueprint

45 of 106

“The ultimate aim of this collective work is that each student has adequate and equitable opportunities for success in school and beyond.”

46 of 106

California has policies and resources that are:

  • grounded in the ELA/ELD Standards
  • operationalized in the ELA/ELD Framework
  • codified in the California Comprehensive State Literacy Plan

AND…

Details and nuances are needed to promote clarity that can be felt at the ground level in schools, where it matters most.

Page 3

47 of 106

Elsa Cárdenas-Hagan

University of Houston

Lori DePole

Decoding Dyslexia CA

Maya Goodall

Lexia English

Martha Hernandez

Californians Together

Young-Suk Kim

University of California, Irvine

Magaly Lavadenz

Center for Equity for English Learners (CEEL)

Martha I. Martinez

Sobrato Early Academic Language (SEAL)

Gisela O’Brien

Center for Equity for English Learners (CEEL)

Laurie Olsen

Sobrato Early Academic Language (SEAL)

Megan Potente

Decoding Dyslexia CA

Pamela Spycher

WestEd

Becky Sullivan

Sacramento County Office of Education

Kareem Weaver

Full and Complete Reading is a Universal Mandate (FULCRUM)

Maryanne Wolf

University of California, Los Angeles

48 of 106

Step 1: Interviews

Step 2: Focus Groups

Step 3: The Convening

49 of 106

  1. Literacy and ML & EL students
  2. Early screening and assessment
  3. Foundational skills

50 of 106

Read the handout

  • What stands out to you?

  • What questions do you have?

51 of 106

  • Elementary educators
  • Secondary educators
  • TOSAs/Coaches
  • Site administrators
  • District administrators

  • What stands out to you?

  • What questions do you have?

Find Your People

52 of 106

“So, in working with English learners, it’s critical that we recognize that these children come to school with years of having built language in their home languages. The degree to which we leverage that linguistic resource and build upon it to engage them in literacy and learning a new language is a major factor in their educational success.”

Patricia Montes Pate, SEAL Early Learning Program Manager

53 of 106

Understand deeply.

Explain simply.

54 of 106

Federal Program Monitoring 2022-2023

Reflections from the Field

55 of 106

  • School districts, direct-funded charter schools, and county offices may be chosen for a review by the state.

  • The program instrument is used by CDE to determine if the requirements of the program are being met.

  • At the end of each review, the state completes a report that details any findings of non-compliance and informs the entity being reviewed how to correct the findings.

  • CDE considers program size, fiscal analysis, level of support, and compliance history to select LEAs for review. The criteria may be adjusted based on the data available.

FPM Basics

56 of 106

EL Program Instrument for Federal Program Monitoring (FPM)

Used by CDE during an FPM to determine if the requirements of the program are being met.

57 of 106

English Learner Program Instrument

EL 01

English Learner Advisory Committee (ELAC)

EL 02

District English Learners Advisory Committee (DELAC)

EL 03

EL Identification and Assessment

EL 04

Implement, Monitor & Revise Title III Plan

EL 05

EL Program Inclusion in the SPSA

EL 06

Title III Inventory

EL 07

Supplement, Not Supplant with Title III

EL 08

Time and Effort Requirements (Title I & III)

EL 09

Evaluation of Title III- Funded Services and Programs

EL 10

Reclassification

EL 11

Teacher EL Authorization

EL 12

Professional Development Specific to ELs

EL 13

Language Acquisition Program Options and Parent Choice

EL 14

ELD

EL 15

Access to Standard Instructional Program

58 of 106

Sonoma County On-Site

FPM Reviews in 2022-2023

  • Bellevue
  • Cloverdale
  • Cotati Rohnert Park
  • Petaluma
  • Roseland
  • Santa Rosa Elementary
  • Sonoma Valley
  • Windsor

59 of 106

Share with us your reflections on the process

  • Preparation
  • Mindset
  • Site visits
  • Uploading materials
  • Working with the reviewer

60 of 106

Moving Forward

  • As a result of the FPM process, what areas of focus have emerged for your system?

  • How are you using FPM as leverage in your system?

61 of 106

Updates...

62 of 106

ML Collaborative

63 of 106

New Resource

64 of 106

Resources for Parents

of Multilingual Students

Resources include

  • Survey, Assessments, Programs, & Reclassification

  • How To... For Parents of Multilingual Students

  • And more!

65 of 106

Long Term English Learners

66 of 106

Long Term English Learner

Community of Practice

  • Bakersfield City School District (Kern County)
  • Coachella Valley Unified School District (Riverside County)
  • Compton Unified School District (Los Angeles County)
  • Elk Grove Unified School District (Sacramento County)
  • Escondido Union High School District (San Diego County)
  • Salinas Union High School District (Monterey County)

67 of 106

  • Over two years, CoP participants will
    • Collect and analyze qualitative and quantitative data to better understand students identified as LTELs and design supports around their specific needs. This work will include expanding definitions of data
      • LTEL course taking
      • A–G completion
      • shadowing
      • observations
      • etc.

  • Dr. Laurie Olsen, author of Reparable Harm: Fulfilling the Unkept Promise of Educational Opportunity for California’s Long Term English Learners, will contribute to the CoP planning and will document the CoP’s learnings, process, and recommendations following the conclusion of the CoP.

  • Goal: What is learned can be replicated.

68 of 106

Observation Protocol for

Teachers of English Learners (OPTEL)

69 of 106

1. Overall Performance Level of 4 on the

Summative ELPAC

2. Teacher evaluation

3. Parent opinion and consultation

4. Comparison of student performance in basic skills against basic skills of English proficient students of the same age (SBAC, etc.)

CA Reclassification Criteria

70 of 106

Observation Protocol for Teachers of English Learners (OPTEL)

  • The OPTEL is an observation protocol designed to support educators in monitoring and evaluating academic language use of EL students

  • Successful implementation of the OPTEL will help move California closer to statewide standardization of reclassification criteria

71 of 106

The OPTEL Timeline

March 31, 2023

Field testing concluded

May 30, 2023

Convening of the OPTEL Advisory Committee

September 2023

Validation report submitted to the CDE

November 2023

Presentation to the State Board of Education for approval

December 2023

OPTEL guidance, parent information tools, and resources completed

72 of 106

Summative ELPAC

Student Score Reports (SSR)

73 of 106

2022–23 ELPAC Student Score Reports (SSR)

  • New for this year, scores will be released daily as they are processed.

  • Grades 3 through 12 were scheduled to be released the week of May 8th

  • Grades kindergarten through grade 2 will be released in late May or early June.

  • The Summative Alternate ELPAC SSRs are expected to be available in late July/early August.

74 of 106

2022–23 ELPAC Student Score Reports (SSR)

The timeline to provide the required SSRs to parents is as follows:

  • SSRs received by an LEA during their 2022–23 instructional year, must be provided to parents within 30 calendar days from receipt.

  • SSRs received by the LEA after the 2022–23 instructional year ends must be provided to parents within the first 15 workdays of the 2023–24 instructional year.

    • For the results being received in 2023-24 instructional year, LEAs can combine the release of their SSRs with the required Annual Title I parent notification letter which must be provided within the first 30 calendar days of the new school year to inform parents/guardians about EL programs and services.

75 of 106

Questions?

Thoughts?

76 of 106

Reclassification

77 of 106

What does it mean to be reclassified?

  • The reclassification process recognizes EL students’ well-developed abilities to read, write, speak, comprehend, and articulate in English across academic subject areas.

  • It also acknowledges EL students’ attainment of an English proficiency level that allows for full engagement in grade-level academic tasks and activities in a variety of content areas without the need for specialized ELD instruction.

78 of 106

1. Overall Performance Level of 4 on the Summative ELPAC

2. Teacher evaluation

3. Parent opinion and consultation

4. Comparison of student performance in basic skills against basic skills of English proficient students of the same age (SBAC, etc.)

CA Reclassification Criteria

79 of 106

Reclassification can take place at any time during the academic year, immediately upon the student meeting all the criteria.

80 of 106

Reclassification Using

Prior Year's ELPAC Results

  • If a student scored an Overall 4 on the 2021-22 Summative ELPAC LEAs can only use that score through May 31, 2023 for reclassification.

  • However, if the student does not meet all four reclassification criteria by May 15, 2023, the LEA should plan to test the student during the 2022-23 administration window which closes May 31,2023. This arbitrary deadline allows 2 weeks to process the change in ELAS in CALPADS or to assess the student on the Summative ELPAC.

81 of 106

Questions?

Thoughts?

82 of 106

Reclassification of Dually Identified English Learners

“An IEP team may recommend a dually identified student for reclassification if they determine that it is the student’s disability and not English language proficiency that is preventing them from achieving an ELPAC level 4 or Alt ELPAC level 3. The IEP team must be able to support their decision and demonstrate that all language development services have been provided.

This guidance is documented in the Practitioner Guide on page 396 of the PDF (376 of the print) and the ELPAC Information Guide on pages 52 and 55.”

83 of 106

Questions?

Thoughts?

84 of 106

ELPAC Participation Rates

85 of 106

“To ensure districts and schools are testing all of their current EL students, the CDE requires that they meet or exceed a participation rate of 95%* on the Summative ELPAC.”

*LEAs have a responsibility to administer the Summative ELPAC to 100% of their English Learners.

86 of 106

Districts and schools that do not meet the 95% participation rate on the Summative ELPAC will have an automatic “Low” Status applied to the English Learner Progress Indicator (ELPI) on the California School Dashboard.

87 of 106

  • California's accountability system is based on a multiple measures system that assesses how LEAs and schools are meeting the needs of their students.

  • Performance on these measures is reported through the California School Dashboard (Dashboard).

88 of 106

English Learner

Progress Indicator (ELPI)

Shows the percentage of current EL students making progress at a school or district towards English language proficiency or maintaining the highest performance level on the Summative ELPAC

89 of 106

90 of 106

91 of 106

92 of 106

Less than 35%

35% to less than 45%

45% to less than 55%

55% to less than 65%

65% or greater

ELPI Status Levels

93 of 106

Which students are included in the participation rate calculation?

94 of 106

95 of 106

Prior school year

2021- 2022

This school year 2022-2023

Next school year

2023- 2024

96 of 106

Using 2021–22 ELPAC Results for Reclassification

If a student is reclassified July 1, 2022 through May 31, 2023 using 2021-22 results, the student will count towards the 2022-23 reclassification rates in CALPADS and they will not be included in the 2022-23 ELPI (EL Progress Indicator) participation rate on the Dashboard because they disappear from the eligibility list for 2022-23.

97 of 106

Using 2022–23 ELPAC Results for Reclassification

If LEAs are using the 2022-23 Summative ELPAC results, LEAs can reclassify students upon release of the SSRs beginning in early May 2023 through June 30, 2023, which will count towards the 2022-23 reclassification rates in Data Quest and students will be counted in the 2022-23 ELPI (EL Progress Indicator) participation rate.

98 of 106

Questions?

Thoughts?

99 of 106

and….

100 of 106

101 of 106

Multilingual Learner Collaborative 2023-2024

Save the DATES!

  • Thursdays
    • September 7th
    • December 14th
    • February 29th
    • May 16th

Important Information

  • 23-24 registration is open! Register here!

  • Everyone will receive notifications for the EL News Page until August 31st.

  • After August 31st, you will not receive any notifications for the News Page unless you have registered for 23-24.

102 of 106

103 of 106

The ML Collaborative

104 of 106

Stay updated.

Stay connected.

Impact the lives

of multilingual learners.

105 of 106

106 of 106

Feedback, please?