1 of 15

The Todmorden Report

A report into the implementation of devolution within MHoC

2 of 15

Contents

A guide to this document

(3) Foreword

(4) Road map

(5) The stages process

(6) Moderation

(7) Regional elections

(7) Parties and other candidates

(8) Northern Ireland Assembly

(9) Scottish Parliament

(10) National Assembly for Wales

(11) Regional English Assemblies

(12) London Assembly

(13) Contributors

(14) Supporters

3 of 15

Foreword

From /u/TheQuipton, Speaker of the House of Commons.

It has been said time and time again that Devolution is the next big leap forward for our simulation, and that is an opinion that I truly believe. Rather selfishly, I want the wheels to start on the implementation of devolution to start under my speakership and will be doing everything I can over the coming weeks and months to see that is the case.

​

In a broader context, reports such as these are exactly what I want to encourage during my time as Speaker of the Model House of Commons. Likeminded individuals coming together to work on a superb, detailed and wideranging report into how they feel we should implement devolution. I made it quite clear in my manifesto for speaker there is a distinct contrast between the implementation of the committees system and the proposed implementation of devolution. Neither, in my opinion, were poorly planned and neither were or will be poorly implemented, but the difference between the two - which ultimately caused the committees system to fail and on the other hand I believe will cause the devolution addition to pass - is the community will to implement such a thing. At this moment in time, especially from the many deputy speaker manifestos and general questions that I have recieved, it is clear that the main thing the community wants to see at this stage in terms of new developments is devolution and thus as long as we take the correct steps, planning and maintain the level of will for devolution to succeed - it will.

​

This report is the first real milestone on this journey, and many of the ideas and proposals are very similar to how I envision devolution being implemented, from the theory of midterms to the general long term trend stages of the implementation process. Of course, this is a long term plan and many of the ideas in here will not take shape for years if at all, but it provides an optimistic vision for our future which, if successful, leaves us with tons of potential to diversify our roles.

​

Over the next few weeks ago, my speakership will begin our work on planning the implementation of devolution, involving all those who worked on this wonderful report as well as any other members of the community that would like to get involved. It was a pleasure to read and have input on this report and I hope that you all enjoy reading and gain the same buzz from these bright ideas as I do.

​

4 of 15

Road Map

A visual series of maps to showcase the stages of devolution within MHoC.

Stage 0

Stage 3

Stage 1

Stage 9

Stage 2

Stage 16

5 of 15

The Stages Process

How do we implement devolution on MHoC

The Expansion of MHoC

​

The stages system enables a gradual introduction of devolution to MHoC ensuring that MHoC will only expand when it has the capacity to expand. It is essential to devolution within MHoC. The stage system will create a road map for MHoC to develop over the next few years.

​

Transitions

​

Initially during stage 1, only the Northern Ireland Assembly is implemented starting off with 5 members. Stormont shall be used to trial devolution in an area where there are both complex issues and a good standard of activity and enthusiasm. During stage 2 both the Scottish Parliament (13) and the Welsh Assembly (5) is introduced to MHoC. Then at stage 3 then North England Assembly (7) and the South England Assembly (11) is introduced. At stage 9 the South England Assembly splits into the London Assembly (18), the South West Assembly (12) and the South East Assembly (16). At this point the Midlands Assembly (10) splits off from the North Assembly (15) which continues until stage 15. During stage 15, the North Assembly (29) splits into the North East Assembly (5), the North West Assembly (13) and the Yorkshire and the Humber Assembly (11). The East of England Assembly (7) splits off from the South East Assembly (24). The Midlands Assembly (19) splits into the East Midlands Assembly (8) and the West Midlands Assembly (11). By stage 20 the size of the assemblies are as follows: Northern Ireland (10), Scotland (26), Wales (10), North East (8), North West (25), Yorkshire and the Humber (21), East Midlands (8), West Midlands (11), East of England (7), London (35), South East (32), South West (23).

​

Adapting the Stages Process

​

The stages process can be adapted to suit the needs of the moderators by inserting the values of the votes for each region in the end column, labelled ‘End Values’, and the total number of votes cast at an election for each region in another column, labelled ‘Votes Cast’’. The forumals should then adjust the sheet to work everything out.

​

Link to Full Spreadsheet

​

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1iW0pz3kpT3YM47p3v3j_6_w6niTbPpx56_cpOvb6NNg/edit?usp=sharing

​

6 of 15

Moderation

The Running of the Devolved Assemblies

Presiding Officers/Speakers

​

Each Devolved Assembly should have a Presiding Officer/Speaker, who shall be responsible for the day to day running of the Assembly, such as posting Bills, Motions, and Counting Votes. They shall not be responsible for any Meta affairs of the Assembly, such as seats or elections. As a result of these Presiding Officers/Speakers not having any Meta authority, they shall not be expected to relinquish party membership upon their election as a Presiding Officer/Speaker, although they may decide to do so, similar to how the role of Lord Speaker functioned before it was incorporated into the Triumvirate.

​

The Presiding Officers/Speakers shall be elected each term by a vote of the AMs for the Assembly in Question, which shall be expected to be done in a Non-Partisan manner. Only AMs for the Assembly in Question may put themselves forward for the role. This vote should also use the Alternative Vote method of voting.

​

Deputy Presiding Officers/Deputy Speakers

​

The Presiding Officer/Speaker of the Assembly shall be able to appoint any number of Deputy Presiding Officers/Deputy Speakers to help the Presiding Officer/Speaker fulfil his duties. Like with their Commons and Lords counterparts, they shall not relinquish party membership or any other roles they would have in /r/MHOC or the Devolved Assembly. In addition, the Presiding Officer/Speaker may delegate specific roles to Deputy Presiding Officers/Deputy Speakers, such as the running of spreadsheets. In order to ensure that these Deputy Presiding Officers/Deputy Speakers have the support of the Assembly

7 of 15

Regional Elections

Introducing Mid-terms to /r/MHoC

Parties and other Candidates

Understanding regional parties and the electoral system: Single Transferable Vote +.

An Overview

​

This report recommends that the regional elections shall occur mid-term (3 months after/before a general election). This helps retain newer members who have been unable to get elected and it causes less chaos than it would if it was happening during the General Election. They electoral system shall use STV+ which constituency and then regional seats, the latter of which works like National MP seats do. The advisable ratio of constituency seats to regional seats is 4:1. All regional elections shall occur at once and the primary voting thread shall be placed on /r/MHoC where it is accessible to everyone. The elections shall be similar to the Model EU elections as there will be no advertising and the election shall be shorter than a General Election. Elections shall use the same voting booth that is currently in use in /r/MHoC.

​

Counting Votes

​

The /r/MHoC Moderators shall count the votes and shall control the election.

Implications for Parties

​

This report recommends that regional seats are elected through closed-lists after they have been allocated as a result of an election. It also recommends that parties shall be able to set up regional versions of their party (e.g. Welsh Labour instead of Labour) but they shall be restricted from operating entirely different non-affiliated parties. The exception shall be permitted in Northern Ireland where many large British parties do not contest elections there (e.g. Alliance, not the Liberal Democrats). The Moderators shall decide whether a regional party is permitted.

​

Implications for Independents

​

Independents shall be able to stand in constituency seats and shall also be eligible for regional seats if, whilst unlikely, they have enough votes to win a regional seat. Independent groupings should follow the same rules as the ones set concerning Independent groupings on /r/MHoC. This report advises giving regional party status to some independent groupings.

8 of 15

Northern Ireland Assembly

Crossing the Community Divide

An Overview

Northern Ireland’s political system is vastly different to the rest of the country. This has been the case since the very beginning with partition. Even prior to the Troubles, Northern Ireland had its own devolved legislature in Belfast since 1921. This was suspended throughout the 20th century, and rarely properly represented the full population. However the new Assembly emerged from the Troubles and the GFA with a more representative system, and one which both sides of the ongoing debate on the constitutional status of the six-counties was satisfied with.

​

This unique politics cannot be properly represented only in Westminster, and must have its own legislature to govern it. Furthermore there are many problems which Northern Ireland has which simply are not going to be covered in the House of Commons, and this extends far beyond simply questions of constitution, or the legacy of the horrors which the country has faced.

​

Powers, Elections and the Executive

The powers of the Assembly are outlined in the Northern Ireland Act 1998, as well as the Northern Ireland Act 2006. These powers should similarly be devolved to the Northern Ireland Assembly in /r/mhoc.

​

The structure of the Assembly and the governance of the Executive however will not work in the same way as irl, but instead the system agreed to in the 2015 cross party talks in MHoC will be used.

​

The STV system will be used in elections to determine the MLAs, from the various constituencies. There should be a few additional ‘national’ seats as well to make the system more preportional.

9 of 15

Scottish Parliament

Serving Scotland’s Interests.

An Overview

​

The Scottish Parliament shall be the national devolved parliament of Scotland based at Holyrood in the nation's capital, Edinburgh. The members of the Parliament will be known as Members of the Scottish Parliament (MSP’s) who will be elected from multi-member constituencies and eventually also a national list (in the same way as the House of Commons), after expansion.

​

The operational structure of the Scottish Parliament

​

The person who will be responsible for the day-to-day running of the parliament will be known as the Presiding Officer. The Presiding Officer is elected at the start of every parliament and whenever the previous one resigns, by convention, the position is rotated between the parliaments major parties (LD-SNP-Con-SNP-Lab) and if one party has a majority government (even more unlikely here) they should nominate a presiding officer. One deputy presiding officer will also be elected in the same manner, and will have the same duties as deputy speakers. Any MSP may nominate for either of the positions despite the conventions above and these are the only secret ballots in the parliament. The presiding officer may vote only to break a tie.

The presiding officer will have the authority over the smooth running of the simulation but will be unable to on their own organise elections (except that of a new (deputy) presiding officer) so general and by elections will be organised in conjunction with the triumvirate. The presiding officer will also have no power to enact expansion of the parliament although it is recommended that they are involved in any such discussions.

Powers of the Scottish Parliament.

A good place to start regarding the powers of the parliament would be the real life Scotland Act 1998 or the Scotland Bill (2016) passed by parliament, although care should be taken to ensure that the simulation overall is still relevant to Scotland.

The First Minister will be made a member of the Privy Council and may appoint a cabinet from the governing party or coalition who will face Scottish Ministers Questions. Due to the small size (at least initially) of the parliament, it is suggested that despite a strong committee stage in real life, the three readings and a vote system is used.

​

​

​

10 of 15

National Assembly for Wales

A Government for the people of Wales.

An Overview

Wales is a nation rich in diversity and long held culture. The south is an area of expertise in industry, it has large multicultural cities and has excellent universities. Meanwhile the rural areas of Wales hold deep traditions and vastly different cultures in many ways. Wales has its own language, which needs cherishing and protecting.

These complex issues and this balancing act can only be provided by a Welsh Assembly, this is why this Report strongly supports an Assembly for Wales. This is why devolution for Wales is at Step 2 of our ‘Road Map’.

​

How will the Welsh Assembly operate?

The Welsh Assembly shall be the national devolved legislature of Wales based in Cardiff Bay in Cardiff. The members of the Assembly will be known as Welsh Assembly Members (AM’s) who will be elected from multi-member constituencies and eventually also a national list (in the same way as the House of Commons), after expansion.

​

The person who will be responsible for the day-to-day running of the Assembly will be known as the Presiding Officer. The Presiding Officer is elected at the start of every Assembly and whenever the previous one resigns, all parties may nominate a presiding officer, the nominee with the largest number of votes shall become the Presiding Officer (The system shall be STV). One deputy presiding officer will also be elected in the same manner, and will have the same duties as deputy speakers. Any AM’s may nominate for either of the positions despite the conventions above and these are the only secret ballots in the Assembly. The presiding officer may vote only to break a tie.

The presiding officer will have the authority over the smooth running of the simulation but will be unable to on their own organise elections (except that of a new (deputy) presiding officer) so general and by elections will be organised in conjunction with the triumvirate. The presiding officer will also have no power to enact expansion of the Assembly although it is recommended that they are involved in any such discussions.

What will the powers of the Welsh Assembly be?

The WAG (Welsh Assembly Government) shall have the powers outlined in the Welsh Assembly Bill 2016 (by AlexWagbo and Dynamic_12), these include limited control over: Agriculture, Archeological Remains, Arts and Crafts, Economic regeneration and development, Education, Environmental Protection, Food and Food Products, Local Government, Sport and Recreational Activities, Tourism, Town and Country Planning and the Welsh Language.

The First Minister will be made a member of the Privy Council and may appoint a cabinet from the governing party or coalition who will face Welsh Ministers Questions Due to the small size (at least initially) of the Assembly, it is suggested that despite a strong committee stage in real life, the three readings and a vote system is used.

​

​

11 of 15

Regional English Assemblies

Devolving power to England’s diverse regions.

An Overview

England is an extremely diverse country with varying social-economic climates across this green and pleasant land. It contains a mixture of scenic countryside where agriculture and leisure industries are common as well as high-tech industry and large commerical spaces within busy cities. England requires regional assemblies because the needs of London is very different to the needs of the North East, devolving power would make Britain a more prosperous country. These complex issues and this balancing act can only be provided by a Regional English Assemblies, this is why this Report strongly supports an Regional English Assemblies.

​

How will the Regional Assemblies operate?

The Regional Assemblies shall be the regional devolved legislatures of the regions of England based in major cities such as Manchester. The members of Assemblies will be known as Regional Assembly Members (RAM’s) who will be elected from multi-member constituencies and eventually also a national list (in the same way as the House of Commons), after expansion.

​

The person who will be responsible for the day-to-day running of the Assembly will be known as the Presiding Officer. The Presiding Officer is elected at the start of every Assembly and whenever the previous one resigns, all parties may nominate a presiding officer, the nominee with the largest number of votes shall become the Presiding Officer (The system shall be STV). One deputy presiding officer may also be elected in the same manner depending on each assembly’s size, and will have the same duties as deputy speakers. Any RAM’s may nominate for either of the positions despite the conventions above and these are the only secret ballots in the Assemblies. The presiding officer may vote only to break a tie.

What will the powers of the Regional Assemblies be?

The RAG (Regional Assembly Government) shall have the powers outlined in the English Regional Assemblies Act 2015, equal to that of the transformed London Assembly. This will include things such as Agriculture, tourism and Local Government.

​

The First Minister will be made a member of the Privy Council and may appoint a cabinet from the governing party or coalition who will face Ministers Questions Due to the small size (at least initially) of the Assembly, it is suggested that despite a strong committee stage in real life, the three readings and a vote system is used.

​

​

​

12 of 15

London Assembly

Mayor of London and reforming the London Assembly to encourage activity and legislation.

How will the London Assembly operate?

​

The London Assembly shall be formed as of stage 9. It shall consist of the North, Central and South London constituencies and shall begin with 17 members, increase to 15 members at stage 12, then increase further to 33 members by stage 19. The London Assembly shall use the same electoral system as every other regional assembly but shall also have a separate election for Mayor of London (which will be held at the same time as the London Assembly elections). The London Mayor shall be elected by the electorate using the Contingent Vote system as they do in real life. The London Assembly and Mayor of London’s powers are the exact same as they are in real-life. The Mayor of London shall be able to appoint a Deputy Mayor. The London Assembly shall elect a Chair who shall be the Head Moderator for the subreddit /r/ModelCityHall. The Chair shall be able to appoint two Deputy Chairs to assist with their duties, Deputy Chairs must pass a vote of confidence to be able to carry out their role. A leader of the Largest group, and Leader of the Opposition shall be nominated and then confirmed by the Chair. The Assembly shall be able to scrutinise the activities of the mayor and through a two-thirds majority reject the mayor’s annual budget and draft statutory strategies. The London Assembly is based in City Hall, London.

​

​

Reforming the London Assembly

​

This reports heavily advises that Assembly members are given powers equal to those granted to other English Regional Assemblies. This would involve passing the proposed English Regional Assembly Bill, to clarify the previous England Regional Assemblies Act. It would repeal the piece of aforementioned legislation which whilst adequate for simulating regional assemblies (it’s purpose), it is not adequate for forming active regional assemblies. The English Regional Assembly Bill will repeal both Greater London Authority Acts (1999 and 2007), in order for equal powers to be granted to Greater London. The First Minister shall have the unique title of Mayor of London and a regional government and opposition shall be able to be formed within the new London Assembly. Currently, if we replicated the Greater London Authority and the London Assembly as they operate in real life, the London Assembly would suffer from a lack of activity because Assembly Members would be unable to submit legislation.

​

​

13 of 15

Contributors

A list that includes anyone who contributed to The Todmorden Report.

/u/TheQuipton The Rt. Hon MP (Falklands) PC, Speaker of the House of Commons

/u/Duncs11 The Rt. Hon MP (English Borders) AL PC, Leader of the United Kingdom Independence Party, Prme Minister of the United Kingdom

/u/mg9500 The Rt. Hon MP (National) PC, Principal Speaker of the Green Party, Shadow Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government.

/u/YCymrobach The Rt. Hon MP (Wales) PC, Deputy Principal Speaker of the Green Party, Shadow Secretary of State for Wales.

/u/SPQR1776 The Rt Hon MP (Northern Ireland), MLA (Belfast West) PC, Deputy First Minister of Northern Ireland

​

​

In Memorandum

​

/u/dynamic_12 The Rt. Hon MP (Lesser Wessex) PC

14 of 15

Supporters

A list that includes anyone who supports the contents of The Todmorden Report.

/u/IndigoRolo The Rt Hon. MLA (Belfast South) PC, Leader of the Alliance Party of Northern Ireland

/u/BwinCymraeg The Rt Hon. MP (Wales) PC, Shadow Secretary of State for Scotland

/u/DF44 The Rt Hon. MP (Lancs., Mers. & Chesh.), Principal Speaker of the Green Party, Leader of the Opposition

/u/RavenGuardian17 The Rt Hon., Former Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs

/u/rexrex600 The Rt Hon. MP (N. London), Former Secretary of State for the Home Department

/u/Yoshi2010 The Rt Hon. MP (National), Deputy Principal Speaker of the Green Party

/u/ABlackwelly The Rt Hon. MP (High., Loth. & Tays.), Leader of the Scottish National Party

/u/DavidSwiftie13, The Hon. MP (Wales), Deputy Leader of Plaid Cymru

/u/StereotypicalLurker The Rt Hon. MP (National), Leader of the Northern Irish Greens, Shadow Secretary of State for Northern Ireland

15 of 15

The Todmorden Report

A report into the implementation of devolution within MHoC