Employee Ownership Trusts: a new era in British employee ownership.
Andrew Pendleton
Prof. of Employee Ownership and Reward, UNSW
&
Andrew Robinson
Prof. of Accounting and Performance. University of Leeds, UK
Presentation to Mid-year Fellows’ Workshop in Honor of Louis O.Kelso, Rutgers University, 14th January 2023
Supported by Dr Jessica Yustantio, UNSW
Acknowledgements to Graeme Nuttall OBE and Nigel Mason 1959-2021
The EOT model: exponential growth
Average number of employees = 120 (median = 36). Estimate of total employee numbers = @125,000
Why are Employee Ownership Trusts (EOT) interesting?
The EOT has been a great success story for employee ownership
Why are Employee Ownership Trusts (EOT) interesting?
The EOT sidesteps these barriers
Agenda
Data sources
What is an Employee Ownership Trust (EOT)?
The EOT model in Britain: taxation regime
The EOT model in Britain: the EOT Trust
The regulatory regime for EOTs is designed to encourage long-term employee ownership
The EOT model: how the conversion works
Bank
Employee
Ownership
Trust
Owner
Profits
Shares
Payment
Loan
Payment
Dividends, gifts or loans
Profit share
Employees
The company
Comparison to other forms of EO - ESOPs
EOTs have similar trust structure and process of becoming employee-owned to US ESOPs but one big difference:
EOTs do not distribute shares from trust to individuals.
As a result, EOTs
Hence growing interest in EOTs as an alternative to ESOPs
Changing character of EO in Britain
Insert direct, indirect, hybrid fro Niels presentation
Form of employee ownership | 2020 2015 mid-1990s |
Trust only (no direct ownership) | 83 35 11 |
Trust (EBT or EOT) present | 92 66 84 |
Hybrid direct and trust ownership | 9 31 73 |
Direct ownership present | 17 65 89 |
Direct ownership only | 8 34 16 |
|
|
Shift to indirect ownership as a result of the growth of the EOT
Levels of employee ownership
EOT legislation requires that 50%+ be passed to EOT. Most EOT firms do more than this
n = 210
Ownership (%) | Mean | Median | Mode |
EOT Trust | 85 | 100 | 100 |
EOT Trust + other forms of EO (ie. direct share ownership) | 87 | 100 | 100 |
EOT Trust + other ‘insiders’ | 99 | 100 | 100 |
In 76% of cases owners sell out entirely
EOT examples: Richer Sounds
505 employees
£211 million turnover, 2020
Information is from company web-site
EOT examples: GoApe
@1000 employees
£20 million turnover, 2020
Information is from company web-site
And one that got away…
Founded 1879
383 employees
Turnover £88 million (18 months to 2021)
Blackwell Booksellers
Owners and management had long term plans to sell to EOT. Fell through in early 2022.
Acquired by Waterstones (UK book chain), March 2022, itself owned by US-based Elliott Investment Management (who also acquired Barnes and Noble in 2019).
Circumstances of conversion to EOT
Overlap between business success and sharing ownership
Source: White Rose Employee Ownership Survey 2020. N= 199
Reason | Percentage of firms |
Business succession | 75 |
Share ownership with employees | 31 |
Rescue failing company | 1 |
Transaction usually initiated by exiting owners
Reasons for becoming employee-owned using EOT?
Reason | Strongly agree/agree (%) |
Long term stability for the company | 92 |
To share rewards with employees | 91 |
Tax efficient for previous owners | 82 |
The socially responsible thing to do | 74 |
Keep company and jobs local | 65 |
Could not find another buyer | 17 |
Source: White Rose Employee Ownership Survey 2020. N= 193
Alternatives to employee ownership
Alternatives | Percentage of cases (%) |
Trade sale | 61 |
Sale to private equity | 21 |
Management buy-out (MBO) | 37 |
Close down company | 11 |
Break-up of company | 1 |
Employee ownership only alternative considered | 24 |
Source: White Rose Employee Ownership Survey 2020. N= 193
Surmounting obstacles to EO conversion: ecological
Firms with EOTs are on the whole good performers
Subjective evaluation of survey respondents. N = 180
| Profitability | Productivity |
A lot below average | 2 | 1 |
Below average | 9 | 7 |
About average | 36 | 36 |
Above average | 40 | 44 |
A lot above average | 13 | 13 |
Surmounting obstacles to EO conversion: co-ordination
Coordinating employee preferences and/or subscriptions not an important issue:
Involvement in design of EO arrangements
Forming an EOT is generally a process initiated and guided by exiting owners
Actors | Mean score on influence scale (1-5) |
Exiting owners | 4.72 |
Other directors/senior managers | 3.93 |
EO Advisors | 4.01 |
Employees | 2.59 |
Employee involvement in the sale process
Source: White Rose Employee Ownership Survey 2020. N= 193
When were employees informed | Percentage of firms |
At the start of the process | 31 |
Part way through the process | 22 |
Towards the end of the process | 26 |
When the company become employee-owned | 15 |
After the company became employee-owned | 5 |
Surmounting obstacles to EO conversion: risk-bearing
Indirect employee ownership.
Employees do not bear financial risk of conversion or of ownership.
Conversions to date not cyclical (cp. Co-op literature) – exponential growth year by year.
Surmounting obstacles to EO conversion: conversion costs
Insider transaction
Form of transaction financing | Percentage of EOT firms |
External bank finance | 11 |
Private equity | 2 |
Deferred payment from company to owners | 86 |
Employee contributions | 1 |
.
N = 183
Sale price
.
Sale price | Percentage of cases |
Market value | 59 |
Discount on market value | 32 |
Gift | 2 |
Other | 7 |
Average size of discount = 22%
Use of external sources of finance in only 13 % of cases.
Why do business owners like it?
Effective employee ownership?
Theory highlights rights to returns and control as integral to EO (Ben-Ner and Jones, 1995) and to ‘felt’ ownership (Pierce et al., 1981).
Returns
N = 187
Effective employee ownership: control?
Governance mechanism | Percentage of EOTs |
Worker directors | 36 |
Employee council | 17 |
Worker directors + employee council | 16 |
Regular employee shareholder meetings | 29 |
Employee trustees | 77 |
Collective bargaining | 1 |
Average number of governance mechanisms = 2
N = 187
98% of EOTs have at least one of these forms of governance
Composition of EOT trusts
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 2+ |
Exiting owners | 54 | 30 | 13 | 3 |
Directors trading company | 25 | 38 | 25 | 13 |
Employees | 19 | 34 | 26 | 22 |
Independents | 35 | 54 | 8 | 3 |
Mean number of trustees = 6 (median = 4). Average employee proportion of trust = 37% (median = 33%)
Number of trustees: percentage of cases with number shown
Governance: provision of information to all employees
| At least annually | Several times a year | At least monthly | More than monthly |
Financial performance | 21 | 38 | 34 | 3 |
Investment plans | 27 | 32 | 8 | 1 |
Board decisions | 14 | 54 | 21 | 1 |
Staffing plans | 19 | 48 | 18 | 2 |
We lack recent comparisons for non-EO organisations
In 85% of cases employees have some or a lot of say on introduction of new working methods
Limitations
Future research
A big agenda