1 of 34

​

Employee Ownership Trusts: a new era in British employee ownership.

​

Andrew Pendleton

Prof. of Employee Ownership and Reward, UNSW

&

Andrew Robinson

Prof. of Accounting and Performance. University of Leeds, UK

​

​

Presentation to Mid-year Fellows’ Workshop in Honor of Louis O.Kelso, Rutgers University, 14th January 2023

​

Supported by Dr Jessica Yustantio, UNSW

Acknowledgements to Graeme Nuttall OBE and Nigel Mason 1959-2021

​

2 of 34

The EOT model: exponential growth

3 of 34

Average number of employees = 120 (median = 36). Estimate of total employee numbers = @125,000

4 of 34

Why are Employee Ownership Trusts (EOT) interesting?

  • In just 8 years (created in 2014) EOTs have become the dominant form of employee ownership in Britain. Nearly all EO conversions now take EOT form.
  • The number of employee-owned firms in Britain has increased at least five-fold in this time.
  • Numbers of conversions increasing each year
  • Other countries interested in the EOT form: US, Australia etc.

​

​

​

The EOT has been a great success story for employee ownership

5 of 34

Why are Employee Ownership Trusts (EOT) interesting?

  • Economic perspectives suggest few EO firms because of high barriers to EO
    • Ecological argument -inefficient (Jensen & Meckling, 1979; Furobotn)
    • Employees unwilling to assume additional risk-bearing + wealth/liquidity constraints
    • Coordination barriers inhibit EO in other than simplest firms (Hansmann, 2000).
    • Rarity generates conversion costs (Ben-ner, 1988) – information, expertise, cost of capital (Putterman, 1982)

​

​

The EOT sidesteps these barriers

6 of 34

Agenda

  • What the EOT looks like & some examples
  • Why the EOT has been so successful in terms of conversion numbers
  • Employee participation in profits and governance

​

Data sources

  • Annual population counts of all UK employee-owned firms (excluding co-ops with < 5 employees)
  • Employee Ownership 20/20 Survey. EOT n = 210 (@ one-third of all EOTs in mid-2021)
  • Previous EO survey in 2015 and data from mid-1990s

​

7 of 34

What is an Employee Ownership Trust (EOT)?

  • Created in 2014 in the UK, arising out of the Nuttall Review of Employee Ownership.
  • Involves majority ownership passing to a trust collectively holding ownership for the benefit of ALL employees. Employees thereby become indirect owners of their employer.
  • Based on the long-standing John Lewis and Arup models
  • Highly effective exit route for business owners wishing to exit without the company passing to a third party.

​

8 of 34

The EOT model in Britain: taxation regime

  • Involves majority ownership/control of ordinary shares of a trading company passing to an EOT trust collectively holding ownership for the benefit of ALL employees (subject to any eligibility terms for new employees) (apart from 5%+ shareholders)
  • Vendor receives Capital Gains Tax (CGT) exemption in the year majority ownership sold to trust (CGT for higher rate tax payers on non-residential assets is 20%, reducing to 10% with Business Asset Disposal Relief on first £1million, reducing to 0% in case of sale to EOT).
  • Any element of gift (ie. sale below fair market value) does not count towards Inheritance Tax thresholds for vendor or beneficiaries
  • Employees can receive annual bonuses up to £3,600 pa free of Income Tax on equal terms (equal, pay, hours worked, tenure)

​

​

9 of 34

The EOT model in Britain: the EOT Trust

  • An EOT is a special form of Employee Benefit Trust
  • EOT usually established as a trust company (most often a company limited by guarantee)
    • To minimise personal liability
    • To facilitate change of individual trustees
  • After the tax year in which owner receives CGT relief, the EOT becomes tax liable where a Disqualifying Event occurs (e.g. sale of the company).
  • Offshore trusts currently possible but may change.
  • Existing Employee Benefit Trusts can be deemed as EOTs if behave as EOT
  • ‘Paritarian trust’ recommended by some: to protect both exiting owner and employee interests

​

​

The regulatory regime for EOTs is designed to encourage long-term employee ownership

10 of 34

The EOT model: how the conversion works

​

​

Bank

​

​

Employee

Ownership

Trust

​

​

​

Owner

Profits

Shares

Payment

Loan

Payment

Dividends, gifts or loans

Profit share

​

​

​

Employees

The company

11 of 34

Comparison to other forms of EO - ESOPs

EOTs have similar trust structure and process of becoming employee-owned to US ESOPs but one big difference:

​

EOTs do not distribute shares from trust to individuals.

​

​

As a result, EOTs

  • Are administratively less complex than ESOPs
  • Do not have to re-purchase shares from departing employees
  • But do not give the full benefits of direct ownership (but tax-efficient bonus means can get financial pay-off + in principle possible to operate an individual ESO scheme alongside EOT)

Hence growing interest in EOTs as an alternative to ESOPs

12 of 34

Changing character of EO in Britain

​

Insert direct, indirect, hybrid fro Niels presentation

Form of employee ownership

2020 2015 mid-1990s

Trust only (no direct ownership)

83 35 11

Trust (EBT or EOT) present

92 66 84

Hybrid direct and trust ownership

9 31 73

Direct ownership present

17 65 89

Direct ownership only

8 34 16

 

 

Shift to indirect ownership as a result of the growth of the EOT

13 of 34

Levels of employee ownership

​

EOT legislation requires that 50%+ be passed to EOT. Most EOT firms do more than this

​

​

​

​

​

n = 210

​

​

​

​

Ownership (%)

Mean

Median

Mode

EOT Trust

85

100

100

EOT Trust + other forms of EO (ie. direct share ownership)

87

100

100

EOT Trust + other ‘insiders’

99

100

100

In 76% of cases owners sell out entirely

14 of 34

EOT examples: Richer Sounds

​

​

505 employees

£211 million turnover, 2020

  • Hi-fi retailer
  • Founded 1978, 51 stores
  • Founder Julian Richer passed 60% of his ownership to EOT in 2019
  • Retained 40%
  • Colleague Forum established
  • Policy of no zero hours contracts, pay Real Living Wage, high emphasis on training

Information is from company web-site

15 of 34

EOT examples: GoApe

​

​

​

@1000 employees

£20 million turnover, 2020

  • Founded 2002
  • Operates 35 tree-top adventure sites in the UK, 16 in USA
  • 90% to EOT in late 2021. Founders retain 10% (want to continue involvement but not control)
  • Previously explored selling to external investors but fears that would ‘cherry-pick’ key sites and break-up the business, selling some bits on
  • Formed employee council

​

​

Information is from company web-site

16 of 34

And one that got away…

Founded 1879

383 employees

Turnover £88 million (18 months to 2021)

Blackwell Booksellers

​

Owners and management had long term plans to sell to EOT. Fell through in early 2022.

​

Acquired by Waterstones (UK book chain), March 2022, itself owned by US-based Elliott Investment Management (who also acquired Barnes and Noble in 2019).

17 of 34

Circumstances of conversion to EOT

​

​

​

​

​

​

Overlap between business success and sharing ownership

Source: White Rose Employee Ownership Survey 2020. N= 199

Reason

Percentage of firms

Business succession

75

Share ownership with employees

31

Rescue failing company

1

Transaction usually initiated by exiting owners

18 of 34

Reasons for becoming employee-owned using EOT?

​

​

Reason

Strongly agree/agree (%)

Long term stability for the company

92

To share rewards with employees

91

Tax efficient for previous owners

82

The socially responsible thing to do

74

Keep company and jobs local

65

Could not find another buyer

17

Source: White Rose Employee Ownership Survey 2020. N= 193

19 of 34

Alternatives to employee ownership

​

​

Alternatives

Percentage of cases (%)

Trade sale

61

Sale to private equity

21

Management buy-out (MBO)

37

Close down company

11

Break-up of company

1

Employee ownership only alternative considered

24

Source: White Rose Employee Ownership Survey 2020. N= 193

20 of 34

Surmounting obstacles to EO conversion: ecological

Firms with EOTs are on the whole good performers

​

​

​

​

​

​

Subjective evaluation of survey respondents. N = 180

​

​

Profitability

Productivity

A lot below average

2

1

Below average

9

7

About average

36

36

Above average

40

44

A lot above average

13

13

21 of 34

Surmounting obstacles to EO conversion: co-ordination

Coordinating employee preferences and/or subscriptions not an important issue:

  • Owners initiate and guide the EO transaction
  • Employees often have a limited role in the transaction

​

22 of 34

Involvement in design of EO arrangements

​

​

​

​

​

​

Forming an EOT is generally a process initiated and guided by exiting owners

Actors

Mean score on influence scale (1-5)

Exiting owners

4.72

Other directors/senior managers

3.93

EO Advisors

4.01

Employees

2.59

23 of 34

Employee involvement in the sale process

​

​

Source: White Rose Employee Ownership Survey 2020. N= 193

When were employees informed

Percentage of firms

At the start of the process

31

Part way through the process

22

Towards the end of the process

26

When the company become employee-owned

15

After the company became employee-owned

5

24 of 34

Surmounting obstacles to EO conversion: risk-bearing

Indirect employee ownership.

​

Employees do not bear financial risk of conversion or of ownership.

​

Conversions to date not cyclical (cp. Co-op literature) – exponential growth year by year.

25 of 34

Surmounting obstacles to EO conversion: conversion costs

  • Now widespread knowledge of EOT amongst professional advisers (driven by tax concessions?)
  • Mimetic spread via extensive commentary in trade press
  • Some ‘off the shelf’ documentation
  • Little dependence on external capital for conversion
  • Lower risk and uncertainty in the sale negotiation process

​

26 of 34

Insider transaction

Form of transaction financing

Percentage of EOT firms

External bank finance

11

Private equity

2

Deferred payment from company to owners

86

Employee contributions

1

.

N = 183

27 of 34

Sale price

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

.

Sale price

Percentage of cases

Market value

59

Discount on market value

32

Gift

2

Other

7

Average size of discount = 22%

​

​

Use of external sources of finance in only 13 % of cases.

28 of 34

Why do business owners like it?

​

  • Sale valuation and negotiation process has lower risk/uncertainty. Can create a market for the firm.
  • Maintains stability of the company
  • Facilitates gradual rather than cliff-edge exit (but does this mean departing owners retain undue influence?)
  • Tax concessions

29 of 34

Effective employee ownership?

Theory highlights rights to returns and control as integral to EO (Ben-Ner and Jones, 1995) and to ‘felt’ ownership (Pierce et al., 1981).

​

Returns

  • 57% of EOT firms awarded profit share in last year. 75% of pre-2020 EOTs.
  • Average of £2,818 per employee.
  • 56% of new EOTs anticipate giving profit share in first year.
  • Profit shares awarded on the basis of
    • Equally 55%
    • Linked to salary 40%
    • Linked to tenure 26%

​

N = 187

30 of 34

Effective employee ownership: control?

​

​

Governance mechanism

Percentage of EOTs

Worker directors

36

Employee council

17

Worker directors + employee council

16

Regular employee shareholder meetings

29

Employee trustees

77

Collective bargaining

1

Average number of governance mechanisms = 2

N = 187

98% of EOTs have at least one of these forms of governance

31 of 34

Composition of EOT trusts

​

0

1

2

2+

Exiting owners

54

30

13

3

Directors trading company

25

38

25

13

Employees

19

34

26

22

Independents

35

54

8

3

Mean number of trustees = 6 (median = 4). Average employee proportion of trust = 37% (median = 33%)

Number of trustees: percentage of cases with number shown

32 of 34

Governance: provision of information to all employees

​

At least annually

Several times a year

At least monthly

More than monthly

Financial performance

21

38

34

3

Investment plans

27

32

8

1

Board decisions

14

54

21

1

Staffing plans

19

48

18

2

We lack recent comparisons for non-EO organisations

In 85% of cases employees have some or a lot of say on introduction of new working methods

33 of 34

Limitations

  • Lack of information on comparator organizations
  • Difficult to secure financial information for most EOT organisations
  • Selection/response biases to survey requests
  • Single respondent per company
  • Difficult to identify nature, extent, and sources of variation amongst EOT firms, in particular what makes for a vibrant and effective employee ownership culture
  • Need measures of employee well-being and individual outcomes

34 of 34

Future research

  • Need employee level data to match to organisations to enable multi-level analysis. Do employees feel like owners? Are they satisfied with indirect ownership. (Have started to collect this data).
  • What are the ownership, governance, and management features of effective and vibrant EOT firms?
  • How does employee governance work in EOTs, and what forms give employees most say? Relationships between EOT trusts and other governance forms?
  • What benefits do EOTs deliver to their employees compared with other firms?
  • Nature and sources of variation amongst EOTs

​

A big agenda