The Arizona STEM Acceleration Project
Elephant Toothpaste Reaction Rate Laboratory
Elephant Toothpaste Reaction Rate Laboratory
A 10-12 grade STEM lesson
Author
Janet Anderson
Date
01/30/2024
Notes for teachers
This activity is best done as a culmination activity toward the end of your instruction on reaction rates. Students should have a foundational understanding of factors that affect reaction rates before they begin.
Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) is a reactive molecule that readily decomposes into water (H2O) and oxygen:�� 2H2O2 --> 2H2O + O2(g)�� In this demonstration, sodium iodide catalyzes the decomposition so that it proceeds much more rapidly than normal. The dishwashing detergent captures the oxygen that is released, making foam. Food coloring can color the film of the bubbles so that you get colored foam. In addition to being a nice example of a decomposition reaction and a catalyzed reaction, the elephant toothpaste reaction is exothermic, so heat is produced.
List of Materials
Standards
Arizona State Standard
HS.P1U1.3 Ask questions, plan, and carry out investigations to explore the cause and effect relationship between reaction rate
factors.
Science and Engineering Practices
Planning and carry out investigations
Obtaining, evaluating and communicating
evidence
Disciplinary Core Ideas
All matter in the Universe is made of very small particles.
Standards
Cross Cutting Concept
Causes and effect
Next Generation Science Standards
HS-PS1-5.
Apply scientific principles and evidence to provide an explanation about the effects of changing the temperature or concentration of the reacting particles on the rate at which a reaction occurs.
Objectives:
1.Study chemical changes how hydrogen peroxide changes into oxygen and water vapors.
2. Consider how concentration and the presence of a catalyst affect the reaction rate.
3. Design and conduct a scientific investigation.
Agenda
Duration : one hour to an hour and a half (depending on whether you want to do post lab as homework)
Prelab: 15 minutes to review key concepts, definitions and safety concerns
Laboratory: 35 minutes to complete the detailed procedures
Graphing: 10 minutes for students to use graphing software to complete and attach graphs to laboratory report
Post lab: 30 minutes to complete
conclusion questions
Intro/Driving Question/Opening
Driving Question
To determine the effect of reactant concentration and addition of a catalyst on the rate of a chemical reaction.
Background information: The reaction you will be completing today is the decomposition reaction: 2 H2O2 → 2 H2O + 1 O2.
The addition of dish soap is used to trap the O2 and create the foam.
Review Prelab, definitions and safety concerns before beginning the laboratory activity
Hands-on Activity Instructions
Addition of a Catalyst
Assessment
Component of the Lab Report | Point Value | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
Introduction (Asking Questions) | | Unable to complete with support given | Extra support needed | Some support needed | Minimal support needed | Students ask specific questions. Students’ questions are scientific and testable. (i.e., answerable through gathering quantitative or qualitative evidence about the natural world to determine relationship between variables.) |
Investigation (Planning an Investigation) | | Unable to complete with support given | Extra support needed | Some support needed | Minimal support needed | Students design and conduct investigations that will gather relevant data to answer the empirical question. Students make decisions about experimental variables, controls, and investigational methods (e.g., number of trials) that will produce accurate and reliable data. |
Investigation (Carrying out an Investigation) | | Unable to complete with support given | Extra support needed | Some support needed | Minimal support needed | Students carry out investigations with replicable procedures, using appropriate tools, trials, and safety procedures. The student takes full and relevant data/observations, and when possible manipulates variables to ensure the most valid investigation possible. |
Analysis and Conclusion (Obtaining, Evaluating, and Communicating Information) | | Unable to complete with support given | Extra support needed | Some support needed | Minimal support needed | Students read and evaluate text from multiple resources to independently obtain scientific information. Students produce scientific writing, or presentations that accurately communicate these ideas, using evidence and rationale for the implications. Students consider the validity and reliability of claims, methods, and designs, verifying the data when possible. |
Total Score | | Notes: | ||||
Differentiation
Circulating as groups work on their data collection and analysis of their results will allow the teacher to provide additional assistance to groups that may need it. This might include inspecting tables to make sure data quality will yield good results and that students have any necessary support while working through graphing operations in the chosen application
For issues that perplex multiple groups, a whole-class discussion can help, especially if suggestions for solutions come from the other groups in the classroom instead of the teacher.
Remediation
Extension/Enrichment
Groups that complete their analysis quickly can be enlisted to assist those that might be struggling, especially with the nuts and bolts of collecting and analyzing data. Teaching others is always the best way to become expert in something new.
If time and materials all student can try the experiment with differently-shaped containers. What happens if you use a bottle with a narrower or wider neck, or a cylindrical drinking glass with no neck?