1 of 46

Rich Create Tasks

&

Extended Discussion

11th June 2024

2 of 46

3 of 46

4 of 46

Learn | Ako

“Access and engage with existing (own and others) knowledge.”

Create | Hanga

“Combine existing knowledge with original ideas in new and imaginative ways to create a new outcome.”

Share | Tohatoha

“Connecting and collaborating with others. Building new knowledge.”

Our Pedagogy

Last time …

5 of 46

Let’s Dive in …

Rich Create Tasks

6 of 46

Learners Create to:

  • Engage
  • Apply their understanding
  • Exercise choice
  • Collaborate with peers
  • Make connections with learning intention

Teachers Empower learners:

Through

  • Choice
  • Information l Knowledge
  • Developing skills
  • Building capacity
  • Scaffolding

7 of 46

Practise

Engaging

Key ComP

What is a

Rich Create Experience?

Fun

Extending

Agency

Create tasks can be fun activities or use cool apps, but need to extend learning, not just be busy, fun work.

Create tasks should engage the individual and should build on their preferred learning style.

In create, students should be practising the skills and knowledge from Learn.

The create tasks extends the learning experience.

Don’t forget about these. Consider how your task builds on these skills/values too.

In create, students should have empowerment to choose.

8 of 46

9 of 46

10 of 46

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes in their paper reading books.

Students design a cart to transport the school’s iPads around the classes. In teams they create drawings in Explain Everything, then build a prototype.

Having read the book Black Beauty, we identify words to describe the setting and use CANVA to create a presentation about them and then record audio talking about the presentation and the words & phrases that have inspired it.

Read a book and create a presentation to record predictions and responses and share with class/teacher so that classmates can comment.

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes and highlight directly in the book. They then make digital flashcards of ideas that they have highlighted and email.

Students use cameras to take photos of squares and rectangles around the school. They then record a video of themselves explaining how to calculate area of the shapes.

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes in their paper notebook.

Conduct research online about drought conditions around the world. Using a design tool like Canva, they then create a flyer about ways to save water in the home and school.

Conduct a survey of students about their favorite school lunch choices. Use graphing software to create a bar graph to display the data.

I can add two groups of materials together to find how many there are by counting them all. Students collaboratively create a video with voiceover to teach other students.

Use a leveled math game on a computer to practice single digit multiplication.

Teacher to have set up a google doc with text (variety of sentence openings and closing) and the coordinating conjunctions in shapes. Students to drag the ‘FANBOY’ words that match the sentences.

Watch the short movie - Dust Bunnies, and create your own dust bunny. Record yourself talking about the choices the brown dust bunnies made.

Students use a PDF/Google Slide version of their maths textbook and work through the fraction problems 1-20 on page 12.

Group 1

Substitution

Augmentation

Modifcation

Redefinition

11 of 46

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes in their paper reading books.

Students design a cart to transport the school’s iPads around the classes. In teams they create drawings in Explain Everything, then build a prototype.

Having read the book Black Beauty, we identify words to describe the setting and use CANVA to create a presentation about them and then record audio talking about the presentation and the words & phrases that have inspired it.

Read a book and create a presentation to record predictions and responses and share with class/teacher so that classmates can comment.

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes and highlight directly in the book. They then make digital flashcards of ideas that they have highlighted and email.

Students use cameras to take photos of squares and rectangles around the school. They then record a video of themselves explaining how to calculate area of the shapes.

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes in their paper notebook.

Conduct research online about drought conditions around the world. Using a design tool like Canva, they then create a flyer about ways to save water in the home and school.

Conduct a survey of students about their favorite school lunch choices. Use graphing software to create a bar graph to display the data.

I can add two groups of materials together to find how many there are by counting them all. Students collaboratively create a video with voiceover to teach other students.

Use a leveled math game on a computer to practice single digit multiplication.

Teacher to have set up a google doc with text (variety of sentence openings and closing) and the coordinating conjunctions in shapes. Students to drag the ‘FANBOY’ words that match the sentences.

Watch the short movie - Dust Bunnies, and create your own dust bunny. Record yourself talking about the choices the brown dust bunnies made.

Students use a PDF/Google Slide version of their maths textbook and work through the fraction problems 1-20 on page 12.

Group 2

Substitution

Augmentation

Modifcation

Redefinition

12 of 46

Students design a cart to transport the school’s iPads around the classes. In teams they create drawings in Explain Everything, then build a prototype.

Having read the book Black Beauty, we identify words to describe the setting and use CANVA to create a presentation about them and then record audio talking about the presentation and the words & phrases that have inspired it.

Read a book and create a presentation to record predictions and responses and share with class/teacher so that classmates can comment.

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes and highlight directly in the book. They then make digital flashcards of ideas that they have highlighted and email.

Students use cameras to take photos of squares and rectangles around the school. They then record a video of themselves explaining how to calculate area of the shapes.

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes in their paper notebook.

Conduct research online about drought conditions around the world. Using a design tool like Canva, they then create a flyer about ways to save water in the home and school.

Conduct a survey of students about their favorite school lunch choices. Use graphing software to create a bar graph to display the data.

I can add two groups of materials together to find how many there are by counting them all. Students collaboratively create a video with voiceover to teach other students.

Use a leveled math game on a computer to practice single digit multiplication.

Teacher to have set up a google doc with text (variety of sentence openings and closing) and the coordinating conjunctions in shapes. Students to drag the ‘FANBOY’ words that match the sentences.

Watch the short movie - Dust Bunnies, and create your own dust bunny. Record yourself talking about the choices the brown dust bunnies made.

Students use a PDF/Google Slide version of their maths textbook and work through the fraction problems 1-20 on page 12.

Group 3

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes in their paper reading books.

Substitution

Augmentation

Modifcation

Redefinition

13 of 46

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes in their paper reading books.

Students design a cart to transport the school’s iPads around the classes. In teams they create drawings in Explain Everything, then build a prototype.

Having read the book Black Beauty, we identify words to describe the setting and use CANVA to create a presentation about them and then record audio talking about the presentation and the words & phrases that have inspired it.

Read a book and create a presentation to record predictions and responses and share with class/teacher so that classmates can comment.

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes and highlight directly in the book. They then make digital flashcards of ideas that they have highlighted and email.

Students use cameras to take photos of squares and rectangles around the school. They then record a video of themselves explaining how to calculate area of the shapes.

Students read a digital textbook in class and take notes in their paper notebook.

Conduct research online about drought conditions around the world. Using a design tool like Canva, they then create a flyer about ways to save water in the home and school.

Conduct a survey of students about their favorite school lunch choices. Use graphing software to create a bar graph to display the data.

I can add two groups of materials together to find how many there are by counting them all. Students collaboratively create a video with voiceover to teach other students.

Use a leveled math game on a computer to practice single digit multiplication.

Teacher to have set up a google doc with text (variety of sentence openings and closing) and the coordinating conjunctions in shapes. Students to drag the ‘FANBOY’ words that match the sentences.

Watch the short movie - Dust Bunnies, and create your own dust bunny. Record yourself talking about the choices the brown dust bunnies made.

Students use a PDF/Google Slide version of their maths textbook and work through the fraction problems 1-20 on page 12.

Group 4

Substitution

Augmentation

Modifcation

Redefinition

14 of 46

Group 1

Names:

Curriculum Strand:

Core Learning Concept:

Year Level:

Substitution Task

Augmentation Task

Modification Task

Redefinition Task

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

15 of 46

Group 2

Names:

Curriculum Strand:

Core Learning Concept:

Year Level:

Substitution Task

Augmentation Task

Modification Task

Redefinition Task

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

16 of 46

Group 3

Names:

Curriculum Strand:

Core Learning Concept:

Year Level:

Substitution Task

Augmentation Task

Modification Task

Redefinition Task

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

17 of 46

Group 4

Names:

Curriculum Strand:

Core Learning Concept:

Year Level:

Substitution Task

Augmentation Task

Modification Task

Redefinition Task

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

Learn/Ako:

Create/Hanga:

Share/Tohatoha:

18 of 46

Let’s Dive in …

Extended Discussion

19 of 46

Why teach learners to have discussions?

Classroom Discussion

A form of instruction in which students are invited to speak about the topic at hand. It involves much more than a teacher asking a class a question, then another, etc., but involves students discussing with each other, often prompted from an open and not closed set of questions.

Why teach learners to have discussions?

Your thoughts here:

20 of 46

What is Extended Discussion?

First 32 sec

21 of 46

What is Extended Discussion?

An extended discussion involves a conversation between at least three learners, without the teacher needing to contribute in between. The teacher may begin the conversation and then learners carry it on.

22 of 46

Questioning and Discussion in Observations

Why is questioning having a limited impact on extended discussion?

23 of 46

Questioning and Discussion in Observations

Why is questioning having a limited impact on extended discussion?

4/18

1/5

24 of 46

Extended Discussion and Structured Literacy

Extended Discussion is an important part of the Reading Rope. Where does it fit?

25 of 46

Every Opportunity Taken

26 of 46

Step 1: Building a Strong Foundation for Discussion

  • Whanaungatanga
  • Discussion Scaffold
  • Thought provoking questions/statements
  • Timetable: Plan for Ambitious Outcomes
  • Outcomes for Learners: Reflection

Differentiation of discussion foundations: taking context into account

  • Culturally responsive
  • Age of learners
  • Department or subject specificity
  • Local curriculum

27 of 46

Note: Purposeful development involves building on each phase and happens over time.

What would a classroom culture of quality discussion look like?

Participation phase

Opportunity phase

Quality Phase

Planning for Quality Extended Discussion

28 of 46

Independent Collaborative Reasoning

Over time, we want to build learners’ independence about ways they can effectively lead, and contribute to, any discussion.

Initiate,

Build

Clarify

Fact check

Critically evaluate

Initiate,

Build

Clarify

Fact check

Critically evaluate

Initiate,

Build

Clarify

Fact check

Critically evaluate

29 of 46

What Are Ground Rules for Talk?

Learning intention(s)

To learn the 6 important ground rules for talk and use them to have learning discussions in reading.

Success criteria

We will know we are successful when we can:

  • Remember the 6 ground rules for talk
  • Give reasons why the ground rules are important for learning through talking
  • Use the ground rules to have a learning conversation in reading

Ground

Rules

For

Talk

30 of 46

Why Should We Use Ground Rules for Talk?

  • Actively listen and don’t talk when others are talking
  • Respectfully take part by giving ideas with reasons and evidence
  • Ask questions to increase understanding
  • Make sure everyone has a chance to take part
  • Stick to the topic
  • Try to look at both sides of the issue. We learn from each other.

Make a copy of these ground rules for talk. With a buddy discuss and record at least one reason why the rule is important for learning through talking.

What do you think Dee Jaye?

I think ….

Ground Rules for Talk Posters

  • Thanks to Angela Jones @ SHS

31 of 46

Teacher’s Role

  • Initially launch the discussion through the provocation: A person can be brave even if they are scared
  • Use selective, probing questions (includes playing ‘Devil’s Advocate’!)
  • Direct probes towards the more contentious aspects of the provocation
  • Redirect when the discussion is getting off track (or ground rules breached).
  • Encourage learners to engage with each other (rather than you)

32 of 46

Using Discussion Roles

“Now we know how things turned out for Matiu: He didn’t even weigh enough to do the bungy jump in the end!

Let’s go back to what it means to be brave and whether, at the end, we think Matiu was brave. Our definition of brave was “a person who is strong or courageous”.

Let’s have a discussion about this because right through the story there is evidence Matiu was afraid. Can you be strong and afraid? I’m going to be the initiator and I want you to use your builder skills to help us think together about this. Here is the provocation (make visible)....

Who wants to kick us off?

Example of setting expectations for learners:

33 of 46

For example: “Let’s use our collaborative reasoning to have an extended discussion… I want you to use our ground rules for talk…we will review how well we reasoned together at the end”

  • Girls are treated differently in the text compared with boys? Why? Is that fair?
  • I would not like the main character as a friend. I don’t think they can be trusted. Do you agree or disagree with me? What do you think….?
  • The author has chosen to keep this information from us… Do you think that was a good strategy? Why/why not?
  • “People who have read this book think Mr Piggy is a misogynist … do you agree? What is a misogynist..?”

Make sure to give learners a discussion signal: “I want us to…”

“...practice our ground rules for discussion….”

“...use our Collaborative Reasoning…”

“...have a learning conversation…”

Participation: Use a Discussion Signal

34 of 46

  1. Stand in a circle,
  • When you catch ball say your first name
  • Reverse ball direction when everyone had a turn catching
  • When you catch ball EVERYONE repeats your first name
  • Reverse ball direction when everyone had a turn catching
  • When you catch ball say what you like doing in your spare time
  • Reverse ball direction when everyone had a turn catching
  • When you catch ball EVERYONE repeats what you like doing in your spare time

Developing Participation: Toss n’ Talk

35 of 46

Developing Participation: Talk Moves

36 of 46

Developing Participation: Talk Moves

37 of 46

Developing Participation: Talk Moves

38 of 46

Outcomes for Learners

At the end of the session, how might you ensure your learners have a chance to reflect:

Reflect on the discussion:

  • What parts of the discussion were easy?
  • Did everyone have a chance to contribute?
  • What could we change next time to make the discussion easier?

These reflections could then be shared on learner blogs.

Consider, how might you capture your discussion to reflect on, or to use as a

learning artifact?

39 of 46

Quality - Learner Reflection

The quality of learners’ contributions and reasoning can be built through opportunities to reflect. For example, using self- and group-assessment practices.

ORAL

A quick oral response:

“How well did you think our discussion went today? Did we get to think deeply about the issue? How? What could we do better? What goal should we set ourselves for next time?

WRITTEN

A ‘quick write’ template with prompts (or key words):

“In today’s discussion I had the role of …… The part I/we found easy was…. The part I/we found hard was …. Next time our I/we should aim to..

RATING TOOL

Reflection against a set of indicators:

“Give your group a rating of 1, 2 or 3 (1 - lowest and 3 - highest):

  • We used our ground rules for talk
  • We all took part
  • We disagreed respectfully

40 of 46

How Well Did Your Group Do?

Make a copy of the slide below to rate how well your group used the 6 ground rules for talk:

  • Give your group a score out of 3 for each ground rule (1= Needs Lots of work; 2=Needs some work 3=Did a Great job!!)
  • Post to your blog
  • Explain what your group needs to improve on and what you did well.
  • Choose someone from another reading group to read and comment on.

41 of 46

Raise Achievement

Acceleration

Effective Practice

What are you going to try in your class this term, based on what you have learned today?

Connected

Communities

42 of 46

Further Reading

43 of 46

Useful Links

44 of 46

Examples:

Reflect on: Which will provide a framework for -

  • ambitious learning outcomes
  • empowering learner contributions
  • a shared language
  • use in other contexts

Choosing a Framework

45 of 46

Collaborative Reasoning Model

This model follows 7 basic steps:

  1. After reading the group has a discussion. Ground rules are introduced/reviewed (see example below.)
  2. The teacher poses a central question / provocation (e.g. a dilemma faced by a character in the story).
  3. Students freely explain their positions on the question/provocation.
  4. They expand on their ideas, adding reasons and supporting evidence from the text and everyday experience.
  5. They challenge each other’s thinking and ways of reasoning.
  6. At the end of the discussion, a final poll is taken to see where everyone stands.
  7. Teacher and learners review the discussion and make suggestions on how to improve future discussions.

Ground rules for learners:

  • Stick to the topic.
  • Do not talk when others are talking
  • Try to look at both sides of the issue.
  • Make sure everyone has a chance to participate.
  • Respond to the idea and not to the person.

46 of 46

Differentiation of Discussion Model

Inexperienced discussers:

Assign roles to learners and resource with prompts / sentence stems:

    • Initiator (e.g. teacher prior to yielding responsibility to students)
    • Evidence (/fact) finder (and first responder)
    • Clarifier (e.g. of question/summariser/paraphraser)
    • Builder (e.g. to build on others contributions)
    • Critical Thinker (eg. provides a different perspective)

Reflect on discussion

Experienced discussers:

  • Freely explain their positions on the central question with turn taking (gradual release of scaffold).
  • They expand/build on ideas, adding reasons and supporting evidence from the text and everyday experience.
  • They challenge each other’s thinking and ways of reasoning.
  • At the end of the discussion, a final poll is taken to see where everyone stands.
  • Teacher and students review the discussion and make suggestions

on how to improve future discussions (alse see self-assessment slide 13)