1 of 21

Aloof!� Black Divas of Refusal

Kwame Kruw Ocran

Breakin’ Black and Reachin’ Back Conference

English Student Association, CUNY Graduate Center

April MMXXII

2 of 21

The Matter of Veneration

There has been scholarship that explores the “historical and phenomenological effect of the black woman’s voice in performance”. Such work requires examination and critique.

​

This scholarship examines the phenomenon of sound, performance and intended effect. I extend analysis to venerate the subject, an active process of beatifying the subject with respect, honor, and reflection.

​

The black diva’s sound disrupts and dislocates fictions of self, narrative, and space. The diva’s sound forms an aesthetics of joy burdened by the circumstances that made the occasion of their singing entirely possible.

3 of 21

Black divas equipped themselves with a sense of refusal and aloofness to strategically posture themselves in conditions that suited their personal predilections best and considered their status as representatives of the Black community.

​

4 of 21

Lena Horne’s evolution as an aloof diva successfully saw the singer and actress escape classist thought of racial uplift to the full embracing of the totality of Black experience, and she was successful on the merits of her performative choice to withhold her interiority, and talents, from an oppressive gaze.

​

5 of 21

​

Jazz icon Billie Holiday refused the simultaneous logistical arrangements of racism and sexism with an aloofness to law and an unapologetically candid interiority.

Holiday’s refusal against government suppression contextualizes the antagonisms of future black insurgents after her death—namely, Angela Y. Davis, and the Black Panther Party.

Perhaps the ways in which the aloof diva enacted her own journey in refusing allowed for greater expression of Blackness untethered by the fetishization for White consumption. �

6 of 21

Scholars such as Angela Davis and Hazel Carby write about divas of “excess”, who may have performed as part of the blues tradition, using stage and songcraft to add political dimensions to musical performances. Blueswomen like Bessie Smith, Gertrude Ma Rainey, and Gladys Bentley put sexual politics to the fore in the lyrics of their music.

​

However, this work is devoted to divas of deficit, those who refused contemporary racial and sexual discourses in performance. These divas are named for employing the powers of subtraction, restraint, silence, withholding and detached vocalization to express deep dissatisfaction with the logistical arrangements concern race, sex, power, and privilege.

7 of 21

Shane Vogel, The Scene of Harlem Cabaret

Study of Lena Horne’s impersona demonstrates attention to detail and contains a genealogy of “women nightclub performers”.

​

According to Vogel, refusal is a strategic mode enacted by the diva to reject or critique the position she participates from.

​

Refusal can be discerned from Lena Horne’s straightforward delivery, and her detached stylization, from Eartha Kitt’s decision to keep her eyes closed for the majority of her performance, and from Diahann Carroll’s delicate phrasing and ability to blend her vocal performance well with Judy Garland’s.

​

​

​

8 of 21

Refusal

According to Vogel, refusal is a strategic mode enacted by the diva to reject or critique the position she participates from.

​

Refusal is discerned from Lena Horne’s straightforward delivery, and her detached stylization, and from Billie Holiday’s choice to perform “Strange Fruit” (1939) despite national and federal censorship efforts.

9 of 21

Aloofness

I assign to aloofness a pretense of nearly uppity disregard for varied and pernicious forms of oppression, a choice the diva elects to enact in the face of clamoring audiences.

​

Whether during live performances, or in film roles, the diva declares an autonomy as a kind of physical and psychic retraction, a cleaving from the demands of onlookers.

10 of 21

If refusal is a political stratagem, a radical stance that balks at hegemony and its complicit oppressions, then aloofness—in the diva’s distance, glamour, and performance—shields Black female interiority from performing Black pain for White audiences in each performance, maintaining a sense of dignity and self.

​

Aloofness creates a sense of unapproachability and unattainableness in the diva. Refusal, on the other hand, is the radical positionality and strategic mode that defies racial exoticization and fetishization.

11 of 21

The Divas’ Sounds

​

Rather than be given to vocal excess in the sexual self-determination of the full-voiced blueswoman, Horne’s performance of the task and the task alone with glamour and deflection left audiences craving more from her.

“the way she utilized her voice, tone, phrasing, timing, and intonation in the rendition of [“Strange Fruit”]. Through this performative presentation of the song, Holiday refused to simply reproduce the fictional lynching scene based on the dominant discourse of lynching to be consumed.” (Sakashita, 118)

​

12 of 21

Shane Vogel, The Scene of Harlem Cabaret

The Diva’s Impersona

Lena Horne

“Honey in the Honeycomb”

Honey in the Honeycomb

(1943)

13 of 21

Horne, like many of her contemporaries, were relegated to performing for whites in segregated audiences, and being in the vicinity of racial intimacies led her to perform as if she had “the air of a bashful volcano”.

​

She displays a seductive reserve, only to release and vocalize larger vocal moments at the conclusion of songs. Horne participates in a repertoire of reticence, controlled gestures, precise phrasings, and restrained physicality.

14 of 21

Shane Vogel, The Scene of Harlem Cabaret

A Diva’s Refusal

Eartha Kitt

“C’est Si Bon”

Live in Kaskade

(1962)

15 of 21

Shane Vogel, The Scene of Harlem Cabaret

Lady Day’s Refusal

Billie Holiday

“Strange Fruit”

Live from Cafe Society

(1939)

16 of 21

Aloof: Black Divas of Refusal

Study of Lena Horne’s aloof impersona (lack of persona) demonstrates attention to detail and contains a genealogy of “women nightclub performers”.

​

Study of Billie Holiday’s strategic refusal of simultaneous logistical arrangements of racism with an aloofness to law and candid interiority.

​

Interiority denotes the totality of one person’s expression, so the thesis venerates both divas as trailblazers who developed the representation of black female expression, with a versatility beyond maid-jezebel.

​

​

17 of 21

Aloof: Black Divas of Refusal

The first purpose is to elucidate and better understand the standpoint of Black female interiority with respect to Black representation in the modes of American media—namely film, television, and popular music.

​

The second is to honor Black female interiority as sacred and foundational to any perspective of liberatory impulse.

​

Certain Black female performers, starting with Lena Horne, contended with Black femininity in mass media in a way that suggests that they are entrusted—by custom or circumstance—with a responsibility to curate representations of themselves with dignity, aplomb, and glamour.

18 of 21

Aloof: Black Divas of Refusal

By interiority, I mean the internal combination of human faculties of expression, mental, sexual, spiritual, psychological or otherwise. Though everyone possesses interiority, it is a Black female interiority that persists despite the limiting gaze of largely White, male audiences.

​

In the face of oppression at the intersections of race, sex, and class, Black divas Lena Horne and Billie Holiday fashioned for themselves an armor of aloofness for the sake of self-preservation and a revolutionary form of representation of Black women.

19 of 21

Aloof: Black Divas of Refusal

By innovating new forms of being in Black female performance, certain performers were able to entertain a multiracial, multivalent audience—often by portraying simultaneous images of entertainment and a subversion of entrenched cultural norms.

​

Neither Mammy nor Mulatto would be suitable roles for these women.

​

​

20 of 21

Aloof: Black Divas of Refusal

An authentic Black female interiority afforded these performers the ability to project a glamour and grace while vying for the aims of Black insurgency in the years preceding the fever-pitch of the 1960s Civil Rights Movement.

By insurgent or insurgency, I mean to signify the movement’s efforts to radically transform the social order with respect to contemporary racial politics beyond a Jim Crow South and a complicit North.

“Aloof” desires to dwell upon and celebrate manifestations of power that hold themselves well, even in non-masculinist spaces.

​

21 of 21

Aloof: Black Divas of Refusal