1 of 24

Virtual TPP Consensus Meeting

Date

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

2 of 24

Ground Rules

​

Please write your name, organization, and country in the chat to introduce yourself

​

​

Feel free to use the chat or “raise your hand” by clicking “Reactions” in Zoom when you have something you would like to contribute

​

We will be monitoring and calling on individuals whose hands are raised

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Please remain muted when you are not speaking and keep your video OFF due to bandwidth constraints

​

This session is being recorded.

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

3 of 24

  • Introduction (5 min)
  • Summary review (10 min)
  • Priority requirements (60 min)
  • Other requirements (10 min)
  • Next steps (5 min)

​

SAMPLE Agenda

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

4 of 24

Introduction

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

5 of 24

Newborn Target Product Profiles

TPPs are available as a public good on the UNICEF website here

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

6 of 24

Webinar Kick-Off

    • Host virtual webinar (Sep XX) featuring leading global experts to discuss the challenges with existing technologies and opportunities for innovation

2

TPP Survey

  • Distribute survey to key stakeholders to determine alignment on the minimal and optimal characteristics (Sep XX – Oct XX)
  • Agreement scored on a Likert scale

3

Consensus Meeting

  • If consensus is not achieved in the survey, hold virtual

consensus meeting to discuss characteristics with <75% agreement (Nov XX)

  • Publish TPP (Early 2022)

4

Delphi-like process to focus the dialogue

TPP Draft Development

    • Review stakeholder needs and challenges along with current and emerging products
    • Develop draft TPP with input from global experts to define the minimal and optimal characteristics

1

We are here

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

7 of 24

  • This presentation is a distilled compilation of your ideas

​

  • TPP: what, not how

​

  • Capture key comments, concepts, perspectives rather than wordsmithing

​

  • May not get 100% agreement – that’s fine

​

  • “Getting stuck” as an end point in the discussion presents a research opportunity

​

  • Chat and email me – will try to highlight all perspectives in the final report

​

​

​

Framing the discussion

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

8 of 24

Industry: how hard is it to do? vs. Clinicians: how important is it?

Hard to do

Easy to do

Not important

Very important

*How much is good enough?

**Is there another way?

***What are the cost drivers?

Framework for consideration

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

9 of 24

Total number of characteristics in survey XX

  • Number with over 75% agreement XX
  • Number with 50% - 75% agreement X (X Optimal, X Minimal)
  • Number with below 50% agreement X (X Minimal)

​

​

Overview of characteristics

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

10 of 24

Characteristics

Optimal

Minimal

In the survey, a list of performance and operational characteristics were outlined. The optimal and minimal characteristics define a range. 

Serves as the IDEAL target for the characteristic

Refers to the lowest acceptable target

Developers would ideally aim to develop their solutions to meet the ‘optimal’ characteristic in all cases. The timeline of development envisioned is 4 years. 

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

11 of 24

Summary Review

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

12 of 24

Completed Survey – XX respondents

​

Product Developer / Industry�(XX)

Technician�(XX)

Clinician / Health Professional (XX)

Other�(XX)

Respondent type

Percentage

Clinician / Health Professional (XX)

72%

Product Developer / Industry (XX)

14%

Technician (XX)

6%

Other (XX)

8%

Participants - Description

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

13 of 24

Country Primarily Work

Respondents

Percentage

Argentina

XX

8%

Brazil

XX

6%

Colombia

XX

3%

Ghana

XX

3%

India

XX

8%

Iran

XX

3%

Kenya

XX

3%

Mexico

XX

6%

Mongolia

XX

3%

N/A

XX

3%

Nigeria

XX

25%

Panama

XX

3%

Rwanda

XX

3%

Spain

XX

3%

Sri Lanka

XX

8%

United Kingdom

XX

6%

United States of America

XX

8%

Participants - Demographics

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

14 of 24

​

Characteristic

Characteristic 

Optimal

(% agree)

Optimal

(n)

Minimal

(% agree)

Minimal

(n)

1

Scope

Example

100%

n=35

91%

n=34

2

Scope

Example

100%

n=35

91%

n=34

3

Scope

Example

94%

n=35

91%

n=35

4

Scope

Example

97%

n=35

91%

n=34

5

Safety and Standards

Example

93%

n=27

93%

n=27

6

Safety and Standards

Example

97%

n=30

87%

n=30

7

Technical

Example

97%

n=30

81%

n=27

8

Technical

Example

100%

n=24

83%

n=23

9

Technical

Example

97%

n=30

80%

n=30

10

Technical

Example

91%

n=22

90%

n=20

11

Technical

Example

90%

n=21

89%

n=18

12

Technical

Example

93%

n=30

77%

n=30

13

Technical

Example

67%

n=33

71%

n=31

14

Technical

Example

94%

n=32

74%

n=31

15

Technical

Example

97%

n=29

89%

n=28

16

Technical

Example

94%

n=34

53%

n=34

17

Technical

Example

100%

n=33

45%

n=31

18

Technical

Example

97%

n=31

94%

n=31

19

Technical

Example

97%

n=34

91%

n=34

20

Technical

Example

97%

n=31

97%

n=31

21

Technical

Example

100%

n=30

38%

n=32

22

Technical

Example

82%

n=34

94%

n=35

Less than 50% agreement

Key:

50-74% agreement

Summary

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

15 of 24

Priority Requirements

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

16 of 24

​

Optimal

Agree

Minimal

Agree

All

Example text

67%

Example text

​

71%

Excl. industry

71%

78%

​

​

​

​

​

Recommendation

Example text

​

Example text

​

Key considerations

Overarching theme #1:

  • “Quotes from survey”
  • “Quotes from survey”

Overarching theme #2:

  • “Quotes from survey”
  • “Quotes from survey”

Characteristic #1

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

17 of 24

Characteristic #2

​

Optimal

Agree

Minimal

Agree

All

Example text

91%

Example text

50%

Excl. industry

96%

50%

​

​

​

​

​

Recommendation

​

​

Example text

​

Key considerations

Overarching theme #1:

  • “Quotes from survey”
  • “Quotes from survey”

Overarching theme #2:

  • “Quotes from survey”
  • “Quotes from survey”

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

18 of 24

Characteristic #3

​

Optimal

Agree

Minimal

Agree

All

Example text

89%

Example text

71%

Excl. industry

96%

67%

​

​

​

​

​

Recommendation

​

​

Example text

​

Key considerations

Overarching theme #1:

  • “Quotes from survey”
  • “Quotes from survey”

Overarching theme #2:

  • “Quotes from survey”
  • “Quotes from survey”

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

19 of 24

  • Will a device which fulfils the minimum requirements be of value compared with XX?
  • What do you consider to be the Gold Standard?

Discussion Items

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

20 of 24

  • Placeholder

Research Questions

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

21 of 24

Next Steps

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

22 of 24

Contributor Recognition

If you would like your name included in the final TPP report as a contributor, please complete the “Permission to Include Name and Institution” form and send to XX.

Please complete the “Declaration of Interest” form and send to XX.

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

23 of 24

Next Steps

​

Publish TPP

Early 2022

​

After the consensus meeting, will compile findings into a final report and will ultimately publish on XX website (aiming for XX 2022)

​

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby

24 of 24

Thank you

Sample template slides prepared by Becca Kirby