California’s New Alternative Pathway to a High School Diploma for Students with Significant Cognitive Disabilities
https://bit.ly/CAIncludesAltPathway
New California
Alternative Pathway to a High School
Diploma for Students with Significant Cognitive Disabilities
https://bit.ly/CAIncludesAltPathway
FB: CA Includes
@CAIncludes
2
Accessibility Features
These features are embedded throughout today’s session to increase accessibility of the material for all participants. Please don’t hesitate to ask for additional accommodations, if needed.
3
Toolkit Resources
LEA and Family Guide to the CA Alt Pathway to a HS Diploma for Students with Significant Cognitive Disabilities
Quick Reference: Pathways to a Diploma for Students with Disabilities
4
Who’s in the room?
Q&A
You can also use the virtual parking lot to post questions.
Presume Competence
Welcoming/Inclusion Ritual
Go back in time and reflect on your own high school experience and what graduating meant to you and your family.
9
CONSIDER FOR A MOMENT
In groups of 2-3, spend 3 minutes discussing your thoughts.
A High School Diploma Helps Eliminate Barriers to Employment
Mythbusting
Myth: Students with Extensive Support Needs (ESN) don’t need a diploma, a certificate of completion is adequate.
Truth: 90% of employers prefer to hire youth with a diploma, and 66% of jobs require a diploma
Myth: Students with ESN don’t need a diploma because they will only be able to find work as volunteers and supported vocational environments that do not require a diploma.
Truth: While many students with ESN may go on to have supported employment, assuming a diploma isn’t a necessary goal limits access to later employment opportunities the student could have otherwise been eligible for.
A High School Diploma Helps Eliminate Barriers to Employment and Post-Secondary Education
Diploma is a Ticket!
90% of employers prefer to hire youth with a diploma
66% of jobs require a diploma
Every student with a disability should have an opportunity to earn a high school diploma that allows them to pursue any postsecondary college, training, or employment options they choose.
Lack of a Diploma Should Not be a Barrier!
14
Most jobs available to youth who lack a diploma
Existing Diploma Pathways Defined in CA Ed Code 51225.3
Courses | State | CTE Pathway | A-G Courses |
English | 3 | 3 | 4 |
Math | 2 | 2 | 3 |
Science | 2 | 2 | 2 |
Social Science | 3 | 2 | 2 |
Visual Perform. Art | 1 | --- | 1 |
Foreign Language | --- | 2 | |
Career Tech. Ed. | 2 | 1 | |
PE | 2 | 2 | --- |
Total | 13 | 13 | 15 |
| | Plus Local Graduation Requirements | |
Some student groups have already been granted statutory exemption from local requirements that go beyond state minimum course requirements for graduation. They include:
✦Foster Youth ✦Members of Military Families ✦Homeless Youth
✦English Language Learner ✦Adjudicated Youth ✦Alternative Ed. Participant
15
Three Things�
Unveiling the Past: Historical Insights into High School Educational Outcomes for Students with Significant Cognitive Disabilities
Recent Reports and Court Rulings
Reinforcing that ALL Students Have a Right to Learn Academic Standards at Grade-Level with Peers Regardless of Academic Level/Performance
18
Important Questions for Consideration:
19
Unveiling the Past: Historical Insights into High School Educational Outcomes for Students with Significant Cognitive Disabilities
�Recent Reports and Court Rulings Reinforce that ALL Students Have a Right to Learn Academic Standards at Grade-Level with Peers Regardless of Academic Level/Performance�
Important Questions for Consideration:
Supreme Court Ruling: Endrew F. v Douglas County School District Re-1 12/17
D.R. v. Redondo Beach Unified School District (9th Cir. 2022)
Researched Benefits of Post-Secondary Experience for Students with Significant Cognitive Disabilities
22
ESSA includes provisions that will help to ensure success for students and schools. Below are just a few. The law:
Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) Provision Highlights for ALL Learners
Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA)
California is utilizing the provision under ESSA that allows states to offer a pathway to graduation for students with significant cognitive disabilities using alternate achievement standards.
This state-defined alternate diploma pathway must meet three requirements:
24
Impetus of the Alt Pathway
Budget Act of 2020, Senate Bill 74 established a workgroup (2020-2021)
Workgroup Convening
25
Historical Context: Establishment of a Workgroup
The Alternate Pathways to a High School Diploma (Alt Pathways) Workgroup was established in California as authorized by the Budget Act of 2020, Senate Bill 74. It operated from December 2020 to July 2021 with the purpose of making recommendations to various educational bodies in the state, including the California State Legislature, State Board of Education, Department of Education, and Department of Finance. The primary focus was on examining and creating pathways to a high school diploma for students with disabilities, especially those with significant cognitive disabilities.
The workgroup's motivation stemmed from the fact that students with disabilities, as identified through California's accountability system, had the lowest high school graduation rates compared to other student groups. The legislation charged the workgroup with several key tasks:
26
Historical Context Cont.
The workgroup aimed to ensure that all students with disabilities, including students with significant cognitive disabilities, have the opportunity to earn a high school diploma.
The workgroup emphasized the principles of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), which call for equal opportunities for students with disabilities to earn a high school diploma and pursue postsecondary education or employment. Historically, students with significant cognitive disabilities receive a high school certificate of completion instead of a diploma, which limited access to postsecondary opportunities and competitive employment.
27
Workgroup Recommendations
The workgroup's overall aim was to ensure that students with disabilities have equal access to educational opportunities and the chance to earn a high school diploma that prepares them for postsecondary success.
28
Which Students are Not Currently Receiving Diplomas in California?
Group 1: Students with significant cognitive disabilities who take the California Alternate Assessments (CAAs) throughout their education. These students who receive special education and related services, typically require extensive support, including direct individualized instruction and significant academic support to achieve measurable gains in their grade-level standards.
Group 2: This generalized group of students, who receive special education and related services, likely need a moderate level or more specialized support through individualized academic instruction and accommodations to meet grade-level standard expectations. They might require both specialized academic instruction or small group instruction, or additional time to master the content standards of a specific grade-level or course. They reported that some students in this group may struggle to master all of the required content in the traditional time allotted but might be able to achieve proficiency if allowed more time (For example, multiple semesters at a slower pace), and intensive support to fully access and learn the content. In such a scenario, these students may benefit from the opportunity to earn a high school diploma based on the state minimum requirements for graduation without having to meet additional local requirements.
29
California Alternative Pathway to a High School Diploma for Students with Significant Cognitive Disabilities
New California Education Code 51255.31
(a) (1) Notwithstanding any other law, a local educational agency shall exempt an individual with exceptional needs who satisfies the eligibility criteria described in subdivision (b) from all courses and other requirements adopted by the governing board or governing body of the local educational agency that are additional to the statewide course requirements specified in Section 51225.3 and shall award the pupil a diploma of graduation from high school, as described in Section 7801(23)(A)(ii)(I)(bb) of Title 20 of the United States Code.
(2) In accordance with Section 300.102(a)(3) of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, the award of a diploma of graduation from high school pursuant to this subdivision does not change a local educational agency’s obligation to provide a free appropriate public education until 22 years of age, or otherwise constitute a change in placement.
(b) An individual with exceptional needs, who entered ninth grade in the 2022–23 school year or later, shall be eligible for the exemption and award described in subdivision (a) if their individualized education program provides for all of the following:
(1) The pupil’s individualized education program team has deemed the pupil eligible to take the state alternate assessments as described in subdivision (k) of Section 60640.
(2) The pupil is required to complete state standards aligned coursework to meet the statewide course requirements specified in Section 51225.3.
(c) An individual with exceptional needs who meets the criteria for the alternative diploma pathway pursuant to this section shall be eligible to participate in any graduation ceremony and any school activity related to graduation with their grade-level peers with and without disabilities. Participation in graduation activities that are subject to this section shall not be construed as termination of the provision of free appropriate public education, consistent with Section 300.102(a)(3)(ii) of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, unless the individualized education program team, which includes the parent and pupil, as defined in Sections 300.320 and 300.321 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, has determined the pupil has completed their high school experience.
(d) For purposes of this section, “local educational agency” includes a school district, county office of education, charter school, or state special school. (Amended by Stats. 2023, Ch. 194, Sec. 17. (SB 141) Effective September 13, 2023.)
31
Summary of Education Code 51255.31
Students with exceptional needs, who entered ninth grade in the 2022–23 school year or later, attending a school district, county office of education, charter school, or state special school can graduate from high school through a newly defined diploma pathway by meeting the following criteria as referenced in the student’s individualized education program:
LEAs must exempt students who meet the above criteria from all local coursework and other requirements that are in addition to statewide coursework requirements, as defined in EC 51225.31. For information on the statewide course requirements, please visit the CDE website: https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/gs/hs/hsgrmin.asp. Additional information on Individualized Education Program (IEP) team guidance for participation in the California Alternate Assessment may also be found on the CDE website: https://www.cde.ca.gov/ta/tg/ca/caaiepteamrev.asp.
Through the completion of the statewide coursework requirements, the LEA must award the qualifying student a diploma of graduation from high school. Through this newly defined diploma pathway, the qualifying student may participate in any graduation ceremony and any school activity related to graduation in which a student of similar age would be eligible to participate. The award of the diploma of graduation via the alternative pathway under EC 51225.31 does not change or terminate an LEA’s obligation to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to an eligible special education student. This is consistent with Section 7801(23)(A)(ii)(I)(bb) of Title 20 of the United States Code and Section 300.102(a)(3) of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
32
Existing Diploma Pathways Defined in Ed Code 51225.3
Courses | State | CTE Pathway | A-G Courses | Alt-Pathway |
English | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 |
Math | 2 | 2 | 3 | 2 |
Science | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 |
Social Science | 3 | 2 | 2 | 3 |
Visual Perform. Art | 1 | --- | 1 | 1 |
Foreign Language | --- | 2 | ||
Career Tech. Ed. | 2 | 1 | ||
PE | 2 | 2 | --- | 2 |
Total | 13 | 13 | 15 | 13 |
| | Plus Local Graduation Requirements | | |
51225.31
Some student groups have already been granted statutory exemption from local requirements that go beyond state minimum course requirements for graduation.
Students with significant cognitive disabilities have now been granted this exemption and may earn a diploma under the new Alternative Pathway to a high school diploma.
33
34
ESSA Flexibilities to Allow the use of Alternate Achievement Standards
4. A State may adopt alternate academic achievement standards and aligned alternate assessments for students with the most significant cognitive disabilities, as permitted under section 1111(b)(1)(E) of the ESEA.
Alternate academic achievement standards must be aligned with the State’s challenging academic content standards, promote access to the general education curriculum, and reflect professional judgment as to the highest possible standards achievable by such students. (ESEA sections 1111(b)(1)(E), 1111(b)(2)(D); 34 C.F.R. §§ 200.2(b)(3)(ii)(B)(2), 200.6(c)-(d)).
A Note on Modification…
ESSA requires that all students have access to the “State’s challenging academic content standards”. Therefore, the common core state standards are not to be modified.
Alternative Pathway - Who is eligible?
(b) An individual with exceptional needs, who entered ninth grade in the 2022–23 school year or later, shall be eligible for the exemption and award described in subdivision (a) if their individualized education program provides for all of the following:
(1) The pupil’s individualized education program team has deemed the pupil eligible to take the state alternate assessments as described in subdivision (k) of Section 60640.
(2) The pupil is required to complete state standards aligned coursework to meet the statewide course requirements specified in Section 51225.3.
36
Alternative Pathway Requirements Defined
…a local educational agency shall exempt an individual with exceptional needs who satisfies the eligibility criteria described in subdivision (b) from all courses and other requirements adopted by the governing board or governing body of the local educational agency that are additional to the statewide course requirements specified in Section 51225.3 and shall award the pupil a diploma of graduation from high school, as described in Section 7801(23)(A)(ii)(I)(bb) of Title 20 of the United States Code.
The alternative pathway provides a provision where students do not need to meet additional LEA adopted requirements for a diploma, such as A-G requirements, requiring students only meet CA State graduation requirements regardless of the LEAs’ policy.
37
Alternative Pathway: FAPE Requirement
(2) In accordance with Section 300.102(a)(3) of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, the award of a diploma of graduation from high school pursuant to this subdivision does not change a local educational agency’s obligation to provide a free appropriate public education until 22 years of age, or otherwise constitute a change in placement.
The LEA is still responsible for FAPE until the student is 22 years of age. This is a course of study, and does not end student’s eligibility for services. Students can earn their diploma and continue to receive services through the LEA until 22 years of age, or until the IEP team determines they have met their individual educational goals.
38
Alternative Pathway - Specific Course Requirements
https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/gs/hs/hsgrmin.asp
Unless otherwise specified, each course shall have a duration of one school year:
39
Alternative Pathway - Specific Requirements
https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/gs/hs/hsgrmin.asp
One semester of Ethnic Studies, commencing with pupils graduating in the 2029–30 school year (a course based on the model curriculum developed pursuant to Section 51226.7; an existing ethnic studies course; an ethnic studies course taught as part of a course that has been approved as meeting the A–G requirements; or a locally developed ethnic studies course approved by the governing board of the school district or charter school).
40
Complete State Standards Aligned Courses
Develop strategies to align instructional goals with state standards
CA Common Core State Standards
41
Core Content Connectors (CCCs) identify the most salient grade-level, core academic content in ELA and Mathematics found in both the Common Core State Standards. CCCs illustrate the necessary knowledge and skills in order to reach the learning targets within the CCSS, focus on the core content, knowledge and skills needed at each grade to promote success at the next, and identify priorities in each content area to guide the instruction for students in this population and for the alternate assessment.
CCCs in Mathematics:
Data Analysis, Probability, and Statistics 1
Data Analysis, Probability, and Statistics 2
Patterns, Relations, and Functions 1
Patterns, Relations, and Functions 2
CCCs in English Language Arts:
Core Content Connectors (CCCs)
How to Create Course of Study
Questions for the IEP Team to Consider:
Does the course of study reflect student interests, post-secondary goals?�When do we give the diploma?
Course | Grade 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | Post 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
English | | | | | | | | |
Math | | | | | | | | |
Science | | | | | | | | |
Social Science | | | | | | | | |
Elective | | | | | | | | |
PE | | | | | | | | |
44
Sample Course of Study
EC 51225.3 | 9th Grade | 10th Grade | 11th Grade | 12th Grade |
3 - English Courses | English 9 with modifications | English 10 with modifications | English 11 with modifications | English 12 w/mods or GE Elective |
2 Math incl. Algebra unless waived | CT or SAI IM1 Foundations | CT or SAI IM1 A/B (year 1 of a 2 year course) | CT or SAI IM1 C/D (year 2 of a 2 year course) | Fundamental Math 12 or Math for Life |
2 Science Courses: incl. biology and physical science | CT Biology or Ag Bio | CT Phys Science or Ag Env. Science | Alt Science in Everyday Life or “elective” | Career Awareness & Exploration |
3 - Social Studies Courses | Independent Living Skills I & Health | CT World History | CT US History | CT Government & Economics |
1 - Elective from VPA, World Language and/or CTE | General Education Elective | General Education Elective | Independent Living Skills II | Vocational Skills or Job Shadow |
EC Section 51241: (2) Courses in PE | Physical Education or APE | Physical Education or APE | Communication & Social Skills or GE Elective | Communication & Social Skills or GE Elective |
This example highlights a course of study that utilizes existing courses already available and adapting them to meet the unique needs of students.
New courses would not be created in separate settings, and do not require new curriculum adoptions. This model utilizes staffing to co-teach or provide consultation with GE teachers to create participation support plans for individual student needs.
45
Sample Course of Study
EC 51225.3 | 9th Grade | 10th Grade | 11th Grade | 12th Grade |
3 - English Courses | Fundamental English 9 | Fundamental English 10 | Fundamental English 11 | Fundamental English 12 or “elective” |
2 Math incl. Algebra unless waived | Math 1 or Algebra | Math 2 | Fundamental Math 11 or Consumer Math | Fundamental Math 12 or Math for Life |
2 Science Courses: incl. biology and physical science | Fundamental Biology | Fundamental Physical Science | Alt Science in Everyday Life or “elective” | Career Awareness & Exploration |
3 - Social Studies Courses | Life Skills & Health | Geography/World History and Current Events HS | Alt US History | US Government & Economics or Elective |
1 - Elective from VPA, World Language and/or CTE | General Education Elective | Independent Living Skills I | Independent Living Skills II | Vocational Skills or Job Shadow |
EC Section 51241: (2) Courses in PE | Physical Education or APE | Physical Education or APE | Communication & Social Skills or “elective” | Communication & Social Skills or “elective” |
This example highlights a course of study that utilizes existing SDI courses but also includes the possibility of creating of new SDI courses and curriculum to meet standards aligned requirement.
This model utilizes staffing for providing instruction in all content areas to provide access to all CA diploma requirements.
46
Sample Course of Study
EC 51225.3 | 9th Grade | 10th Grade | 11th Grade | 12th Grade |
3 - English Courses | Fundamental English 9 | Fundamental English 10 | Fundamental English 11 | Fundamental English 12 or “elective” |
2 Math incl. Algebra unless waived | CT or SAI IM1 Foundations | CT or SAI IM1 A/B (year 1 of a 2 year course) | CT or SAI IM1 C/D (year 2 of a 2 year course) | Fundamental Math 12 or Math for Life |
2 Science Courses: incl. biology and physical science | CT Biology or Ag Bio | CT Phys Science or Ag Env. Science | Alt Science in Everyday Life or “elective” | Career Awareness & Exploration |
3 - Social Studies Courses | Life Skills & Health | CT World History | Alt US History | CT Government & Economics |
1 - Elective from VPA, World Language and/or CTE | General Education Elective | Independent Living Skills I | Independent Living Skills II | Vocational Skills or Job Shadow |
EC Section 51241: (2) Courses in PE | Physical Education or APE | Physical Education or APE | Communication & Social Skills or “elective” | Communication & Social Skills or “elective” |
This example highlights a hybrid course of study which utilizes current SDI courses already standards aligned, and existing GE courses with the support of co-teaching and/or modifications.
This model utilizes staffing for providing instruction in SDI courses, consulting with GE teachers in creation of participation support plans, and CoTeaching.
47
Three Things�
Algebra Requirement
Students with IEPs have to meet the Algebra I graduation requirement. In order to earn a high school diploma, students receiving special education services are required to pass a course or combination of courses based on Algebra I content standards.
The Algebra I content standards are the same for all students; however, some students receiving special education services may require accommodations or modifications to instruction. The individualized education program (IEP) team determines the type of instruction appropriate for each student. For students whose IEP team has determined they are pursuing an alternative diploma pathway as described in 51225.31, they are still required to pass coursework for Algebra I coursework aligned to the state standards.
49
Algebra Waiver Explained
Under California Education Code (EC) Section 56101, the governing board of a district or county office of education or a Special Education Local Plan Area may request the State Board of Education (SBE) to grant a waiver for individual students from all or part of the Algebra graduation requirement.
There is a specific process in place which must be followed in order for students to access this waiver.
Questions:
Waiver Office waiver@cde.ca.gov
916-319-0824
https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/gs/hs/algebrafaq.asp
50
Aligning Systems
Aligning School Systems
Adding this alternative pathway may require that the schools’ SIS and Master Schedules to be updated to reflect the new pathway requirements.
LEAs may consider how report cards and transcripts currently note that the student accessed a non-A-G or college bound curriculum, and use that to guide this new pathway process.
Course descriptions and course catalogues may need to be updated to reflect changes to meet the alt-pathway requirements including standards alignment and progression towards a high school diploma. (see resources for examples of best practice)
Aligning School Systems
53
Exit Criteria & Tracking
LEAs will need to track each students’ progress towards meeting the alternative pathway to a diploma requirements.
In some instances, this may need to be done “manually” if the SIS is not set up to align to the specific alternative pathway diploma requirements.
Exit Criteria & Tracking: Counselor Role
Secondary counselors, working with IEP teams, will be responsible for tracking progress towards the Alt Pathway, ensuring alignment with record keeping on the transcript, and communicating progress to the SIS.
Secondary counselors will need training from LEAs on coursework that meets the Alt Pathway requirements, including in both specialized settings as well as general education settings.
55
Does the document signify: | High School Diploma | Transcript |
The student has completed a specific course of study | Yes | Yes |
The specific coursework a student completed? | No | Yes |
Grades or Achievement Levels a student achieved? | No | Yes |
The student has a disability or any exceptional learning needs? | No | No |
The high school diploma document should be the same for all graduates.
Note the pathway in the transcript.
It documents the availability of FAPE to 22.
Documents: Diploma & Transcript
56
Student Exit Category Code | Student Exit Category Name | School Completion Status | School Completion Status Name | First Academic Year Effective | Last Academic Year Effective |
E230 | Completer Exit | 100 | Graduated, Standard HS Diploma | 1990-1991 | NA |
E230 | Completer Exit | 102 | Pathway Diploma for Students with Disabilities | 2022-2023 | NA |
E230 | Completer Exit | 120 | Student with disabilities certificate of completion | 1990-1991 | NA |
57
Suggested Next Steps
58
Transcending Compliance
How will you move forward to ensure that we provide access to the Alt Pathway to transcend compliance?
Optimistic Close
Q&A
Please share your feedback with us so we can make any necessary adjustments to ensure we are meeting the needs of our attendees.
FB: CA Includes
@CAIncludes
https://bit.ly/CAIncludesFeedback
62
Resources
Family Guide to the Alt Pathway to a HS Diploma for Students with Cognitive Disabilities
LEA Guide to the Alt Pathway to a HS Diploma for Students with Cognitive Disabilities
CAST (UDL)
F3 Law News Update
Supporting Inclusive Practices
SWIFT Education Center
TIES Center
Resources - California Alternative Assessments
https://www.cde.ca.gov/ta/tg/ca/documents/caaelafactsheet.pdf
CDE CAA information
https://www.cde.ca.gov/ta/tg/ca/altassessment.asp
Alternative Assessment IEP Team Guidance
https://www.cde.ca.gov/ta/tg/ca/caaiepteamrev.asp
IEP Teams Resource Sheet
https://www.cde.ca.gov/ta/tg/sa/documents/iepedresource.pdf
64
Resources - CCSS Content Connectors
Link to CA Content Connectors in Reading, Writing and Math
https://www.cde.ca.gov/ta/tg/ca/altassessment.asp
Link to CA Content Connectors in Science
https://www.lbschools.net/Asset/Files/Research/State_Assessments/CAA-Science-Blueprints.pdf
State of WV Content Connectors
https://apps.sos.wv.gov/adlaw/csr/readfile.aspx?DocId=24512&Format=WORD
State of LA Content Connectors
https://www.louisianabelieves.com/resources/library/students-with-significant-cognitive-disabilities
Learning Maps: Essential Elements
chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/https://dynamiclearningmaps.org/sites/default/files/documents/ELA_EEs/DLM_Essential_Elements_ELA.pdf
65
Resources What to Teach & More
NCSC Wiki Curriculum Resources: What to Teach
https://wiki.ncscpartners.org/index.php/Curriculum_Resources
Extended Content Standards - UD for Learning and Students with Significant Cognitive Disabilities (YouTube Video)
Aligning Instruction to grade Level Standards for Students with Significant Cognitive Disabilities (TCOE YouTube Video)
Instruction of Grade-Aligned Content for Students with Cognitive Disabilities (PaTTANpod [S2E19] YouTube Video)
66
Resources - Waiving Algebra
CDE Waiver Process
https://www.cde.ca.gov/re/lr/wr/index.asp
CDE Specific Waivers
https://www.cde.ca.gov/re/lr/wr/specificwaiver.asp
Waiver attachments for Algebra
https://www.cde.ca.gov/re/lr/wr/specificwaiver.asp#Algebra1
Waiver FAQs
https://www.cde.ca.gov/re/lr/wr/faq.asp
Waiver Request Login Page
https://www2.cde.ca.gov/waiverweb/logon.aspx
67