1 of 23

2022 CIS 9390�Navigating the Job Market

Junyoung Park

2 of 23

My Job Search Results

  • 70 applications
  • 11 first-round interviews
    • October 2021 – February 2022
    • 2 R1 universities, 4 R2 universities
  • 5 campus visit invitations (2 virtual)
  • 2.5 oral offers
  • Final decision: Auburn University

3 of 23

Things to Prepare

My Timeline

Ideal Timeline

Proposal defense

November 11, 2021

~ April 2021

(before August for Teaching Fellowship)

Job package

  • CV
  • cover letter
  • research statement
  • teaching portfolio
  • Job paper + sample papers
  • diversity statement
  • website + linkedin

September 2021

~ June 2021

  • Reference letters

September 2021

~ June 2021

Job paper & job talk slides

November 2021

~ August 2021

4 of 23

Before Entering Job Market (~April)

  • Research
    • Published/R&R/submitted papers
      • Top R1 : Top journals
      • R1 – R2 : ABS category 3 journals
    • Dissertation (completion and quality)
    • Job market paper
  • Teaching
    • Teaching evaluations
    • Teaching awards (should teach 2+ courses in a year)
  • Service
    • Peer reviews
    • AIS Doctoral Student College
    • Robinson PhD Fellows
    • Volunteering at conferences

5 of 23

Job Package (~June)

  • CV
  • Cover letter
  • Research statement
    • Overarching research interests and goals
    • Key points for each research project (motivation/method/findings+contribution)
    • If possible, future plans for research
  • Teaching portfolio
    • Teaching philosophy
    • Course list and Teaching evaluations
    • Interested courses (based on experience and expertise)
  • Job market paper + sample research

6 of 23

Job Package (cont’d)

  • 3 recommendation letters
    • Discuss with your dissertation chair early
    • Contact early
  • Diversity statement
  • Website + LinkedIn
    • They check your online presence.

7 of 23

Job Application (June~)

  • Websites:
  • Subscribe to get daily email notifications

  • For each school, create a folder and put all materials for that school

8 of 23

Some Opportunities

Research and Networking

    • AOM CTO Doctoral Consortium
    • AMCIS Doctoral Consortium
    • ICIS Doctoral Consortium

Job Applications and Interviews

    • AMCIS Career Connect (August)
    • CIST (October)
    • INFORMS (October)
    • ICIS Career Connect (December)

Funding

    • GSU Dissertation Grant

9 of 23

List of Job Postings

10 of 23

List of Job Applications

11 of 23

List of Job Applications �(Shared with advisors)

12 of 23

1st-Round Interviews (August – March)

  • Usually via Zoom or during conferences such as AMCIS, INFORMS, CIST, ICIS
  • Ask who will interview you and learn about them
  • Think about your unique contribution in research and teaching - in relation to job requirements
  • Present yourself as a colleague, not a student
  • Send thank you notes the same day – customize your message

13 of 23

1st-Round Interviews Preparation

  • Research
    • Progress of your dissertation and other research �(can you graduate and do research)
    • Fit between your research interests+methodologies and job requirements
    • Prospect of your research (can you get tenure)
  • Teaching
    • Courses you have taught
    • Courses you are interested/able to teach – check their programs
    • Teaching philosophy and experiences
    • Projects, assignments, textbooks, software
    • Diversity (how to serve underrepresented student body)

14 of 23

Interviews – Sample Questions

  • General questions:
    • Tell us about yourself
    • Why us? - Research fit, teaching interests, strategic initiatives, programs, area…
    • What are you looking for in a school?
    • Where do you see yourself in 5 years?
    • If we hired you, 5 years later, why would we be satisfied?
    • How will you treat diversity? (diversity as a force for mutual learning)
    • What questions do you have for us? – culture, nature of programs, teaching load,…)
    • What is your timeline (do you have other offers)?

15 of 23

Interviews – Sample Questions (cont’d)

  • Research:
    • Tell us about your dissertation
    • Where are you in the dissertation process (can you graduate)?
    • Tell us about your other research
      • Follow-ups on details about your research (context, methodology, variables, findings, …)
    • what are the status of your research projects?
    • What are the theoretical contributions of your dissertation?
    • With whom do you want to collaborate?
    • What are your strengths/weaknesses in research?
    • Future research?

16 of 23

Interviews – Sample Questions (cont’d)

  • Teaching:
    • What can you teach?
    • What have you taught? What is this course like?
    • What are your strengths/weaknesses in teaching?
    • what's one takeaway you want to instill students in your course?
    • if one of your students are very motivated and engaging, but does poorly, what would you do to that student?
    • How does your research help your teaching?
    • how would you balance your teaching and research?
    • how do you approach different levels/modes of teaching? (undergrad/grad/executive, online/hybrid/offline)
    • How will you treat academic integrity? (if some incidents happen such as students cheating, how will you proceed?)
    • how do you currently include strategies to ensure the success of underserved students in your classroom practice?

17 of 23

2nd-Round Interviews (Campus Visits, October - March)

  • You will meet:
    • Faculty members (in your department or college)
    • Department chair, Dean, Associate Dean
  • Agenda:
    • Research presentation – 45-90 mins
    • Teaching demonstration (usually for teaching schools) �- 45-60 mins
    • Meetings with faculty (individual or team)
    • Breakfast/lunch/dinner with faculty
    • Administrations
  • Be prepared for surprises (e.g., little flexibility in setting up dates, changes of schedules…)
  • Send thank-you notes

18 of 23

2nd-Round Interviews (cont’d)

  • Job talk
    • Make it complete as much as possible
    • Practice (with advisors and fellow students)!
    • Make connections to the department
    • Have a note and pen: document all feedback
    • Remember who participated

19 of 23

Sample Campus Visit Schedule

  • Typically, two-days with most “formal” agenda on 2nd date
  • Interview starts when you land!
  • Prepare many questions for the department!!

  • Suit & Tie
  • Do not check your bags.
  • Bring water, energy bars, and umbrella.
  • You might need to drive from the airport

20 of 23

Offers

  • Typically, search committee chair or department chair will call you for an offer
    • Thank them first and ask for decision time.
    • Get information on terms (base salary, summer support, teaching load, tenure, service, moving support, research funds, conference travels, leave, spousal programs…)
    • Contact your advisors immediately for negotiation and decision
  • Take your time to think while contacting other schools you are waiting for
  • When rejecting an offer, do it ASAP (with email+phone)

21 of 23

Some Thoughts

  • Communicate very often with your advisors.
  • Do regular exercise.
  • Think of this as a learning process.�(scholars, schools, fields, yourself…)
  • Seek help. Support each other.
  • Review each interview.
  • Expect a lot of uncertainties and surprises.

22 of 23

Useful Resources

Job search process

    • Professor Is In: The Essential Guide to Turning Your Ph.D. into a Job (Karen Kelsky)
    • The Academic Job Search Handbook (Julia Miller Vick, Jennifer S. Furlong, Rosanne Lurie)�

Institutions

Journals

Locations

    • NerdWallet’s cost of living calculator

23 of 23

References

  • Materials from and communications with former graduates �(e.g., Zhitao, Amrita, Mahesh, Xiaocong, Yukun, Hyoungyong, Christine…)

  • Do reach out to us!