Budget Management
and Workforce Incentivization
Strategic Retirement Support Plan
Short Term and Long Run Solutions
We present an optimized strategy for the SSA
Retirement Support to achieve budget neutrality and better target groups in need with what they need most.
Team 1: Christina Xie, Cici Xu, Katie Guo, Lola Jiang
Executive Summary
Our Client:
The Social Security Administration, with its OASDI (Old Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance) program manages the Trust Fund and provides benefits payments to qualified retired workers and their family members.
#
Source:
Situation
Complications
Solutions
Questions
Recommendations
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
Situation & Complications
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
Aging population mounts retirement benefits expenses,
causing short-term deficits & long-term insolvency.
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Starting 2021, the program is having annual budget deficit, and is expected to go bankrupt in 2034.
By 2060, Americans ≥ 65 years old will more than Double
with Nearly ¼ population ≥ 65.
2095 OASDI Present Value: $-22,742 Billions
2034: 22% Less of scheduled payment
2095: 26% Less of scheduled payment
Source 1: PRB Analysis of data from U.S. Census Bureau Source 2: Social Security Administration Agency Report Fiscal Year 2021
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
Questions & Solution
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
How do we make the program
“stable & healthy”?
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Stable
Maintain Budget Neutral/Surplus
Healthy
Target Groups of people more in need of benefits
(Provide people with what they need the most)
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
How to achieve Budget Neutral/Surplus ?
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Cash Payment
Other Payments with lower Cost
⬆Income
Total Payroll Tax Income
Trust Fund Interests
Retirement Benefits �(82.5%)
⬇Cost
OASDI
Budget
Average Tax Payment
# Workforce
# Beneficiaries
Average Benefits Payment
Principal
Rate of Return
Administration Cost�(1.2%)
Disabled Benefits�(11.7%)
Workforce Participation Rate
Population aged 16-65
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
How to achieve Budget Neutral/Surplus ?
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Cash Payment
Other Payments with lower Cost
Feasibility
Total Payroll Tax Income
Trust Fund Interests
Retirement Benefits �(82.5%)
Financially
Sustainable
Achieve 8GW
with Financial & Environmental sustainability
Average Tax Payment
# Workforce
# Beneficiaries
Average Benefits Payment
Principal
Rate of Return
Administration Cost�(1.2%)
Disabled Benefits�(11.7%)
Workforce Participation Rate
Population aged 16-65
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
How to achieve Budget Neutral/Surplus ?
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Achieve 8GW
with Financial & Environmental sustainability
Feasibility
win rate
Competition Level
Financial Sustainability
Construction Cost Reduction
Capital Cost Reduction
Environmental
Sustainability
Environmental
Sustainability
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
Portfolio Diversification
Increase Trust Fund Investment Return Rate
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Source 1: The Trustees Report 2015-2021, Source2: GPIF Annual Report Fiscal Year 2021
Source 3 CPP Investment 2021 Fiscal Year Report Source 4: ATO Group Annual Report 2015-2021
Diversify the Trust Fund’s Portfolio from Treasury Securities solely to include Equities, Credits, etc.
Japan GP Fund ARR�5.42%
over 7 years.
USA Trust Fund ARR
2.35%
over 7 years.
Canada CPP Fund ARR
20.3%
over 7 years.
Denmark ATP Fund ARR
23%
over 7 years.
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
Retirement Benefits Redistribution
Cut Cost while Improve Beneficiary Targeting
Black Women benefit from Retirement Benefits more than others do
Increase benefit payment for Black Women by decreasing benefit payments to others
(Instead of using universal benefit payment scale based on income)
#
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Source : CBPP analysis of data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s March 2021 Current Population Survey
Mary Smith, 65 years old
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
Retirement Benefits Revamp
Cut Cost while providing people with What They Need
Substitute Cash Benefit Payment with Life Necessity Benefit Payment we procured with lower cost.
#
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Retired People
Procurement
Donations
Food
Rescue
Purchase Larger Amount at Lower cost
Life
Necessity Bank
Trust Fund
Cash Payment
Necessities
Necessities
Approximately
Zero Cost
Delivery
Delivery
Deliver Larger Amount at Lower Cost
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
Retirement Benefits Revamp
Cut Cost while providing people with What They Need
The Life Necessity Bank is justified by “Calfresh”’s past success in providing people with low-cost food and delivery services (in collaboration with Food Banks).
#
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Source 1: SLO Food Bank Cash to Buy Food - CalFresh and Other Benefits
Food Delivery from Farm to Food Bank and to the community
Food Rescue and donations consist of 47% of food source
Donation
Food Rescue
“I get to a point where we have about a week or more left in the month, but no more money to buy food. Thanks for free delivery services of Calfresh”
–David, Recipient
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
However, Life necessities including food & transportation consists a huge part of retired life expense, changing cash payment into life necessities payment won’t decrease their retired life quality significantly .
Some might argue that older people might not be willing to substitute cash payment with life necessities
#
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
Workforce Incentivization�Increase the Workforce Participation Rate
#
Source 1: Social Security Office of Policy Source2 : Social Security Administration Fast Facts & Figures About Social Security, 2022
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
Increase the early Eligibility Age for Social Security Benefits from age 62 to age 65 | |
Benefits | Limitations |
Lessen the stress on the budget in the short-term �Ensure people would receive higher benefit amounts once fully retire | Hurt individuals that need to retire early from physically demanding jobs �Potential protest from the society |
Require Retired Workers’ Spouses to participate in part-time jobs to receive Benefit Payments | |
Benefits | Limitations |
Cut 12% of the Retirement Benefit Payments Expense Incentivize Spouses’ participation in the Workforce | Too heavy workload on the spouse Potential protest from the society |
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
Final Recommendations
#
Situation
Complications
Question
Solution
Recommendation
⬆️ Investment Return Rate
Portfolio Diversification
⬇️ Payment Expense ⬆️ Beneficiary Targeting
Benefit Redistribution
⬇️Payment Expense ⬆️ Provide Needing Goods
Benefit Revamp
⬆️ Labor Participation Rate
Workforce Incentivization
Deloitte Case Competition Group 1
Budget Management
and Workforce Incentivization
Thank you for your time!
Short Term and Long Run Solutions
Team 1: Christina Xie, Cici Xu, Katie Guo, Lola Jiang