1 of 8

Name: Date: Class Period:

Nuclear Energy Policy Lesson

Question: What role should nuclear fission play in our future energy plans?:

Background

Climate Change Facts - Global Temperature - Earth Indicator (NASA)

The climate science data is clear: global temperature is rising and it is due to the increase in atmospheric greenhouse gases. Extracting and burning fossil fuels is a major source of heat trapping greenhouse gases. The global temperature is rising and it is due to human activity.

Slowing the trends of global warming relies on three fundamental actions: dramatically reducing the use of fossil fuels to cut greenhouse gas emission, removing carbon dioxide gas that is already in the atmosphere, and managing the amount of solar radiation that passes into our atmosphere.

Our most immediate climate action should be to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. How can we achieve a meaningful change in atmospheric GHG? What risks and benefits are associated with cutting fossil fuel use?

​

Role of The United Nations

The United Nations is active in addressing global warming and climate change. The UN established the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) in 1988. The IPCC is an independent body that assesses climate science data.

​

In 1995, the UN began sponsoring annual Conference of Parties (COP) meetings. Representatives from the UN, IPCC, and global governments meet to plan climate policy goals that aim to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, address global monetary needs, and resolve climate justice concerns.

​

In 2015, 197 countries signed the Paris Agreement, a pledge to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and limit the global temperature increase to 2 °C above pre industrial levels, by the year 2100. In 2018, the IPCC released a revised report lowering the global temperature increase from 2 °C to 1.5 °C. The 2 °C temperature limit was considered too risky for climate conditions and economic disruptions.

​

When nations meet at the COP conferences, they review progress from the previous year’s emission reduction pledges. Currently, nations are not on target to meet their 2100 climate emission reduction pledges. To follow the IPCC recommendations, nations will need to dramatically move away from using fossil fuels.

​

2 of 8

Assignment

You are an attendee at an upcoming COP conference. You work on a committee that focuses on nuclear energy. The question before your group is: Should nuclear fission technology be a part of our future energy policy? If so, to what extent should we expand or limit the use of nuclear power?

​

Start with researching fission technology. It’s a good idea to take notes on both the pros and cons of using fission technology. Being informed on both sides of the fission argument will help make your debates productive and more interesting. Suggested research sites are listed below along with a table to write down research notes.

Once you have completed your research, sort into two groups: For vs. Against, using fission as an energy resource. You can meet with other classmates who will argue the same side of the debate. Compare and share your notes to gather more information about your point of view.

Once your research notes are complete, organize into small hybrid groups to debate the opposing points of view. During the discussion, you can use your written notes to help prompt debate, but no electronic resources should be available.

Discuss the following questions in your hybrid groups:

  • Should nuclear fission technology be a part of our future energy policy?
  • Should we expand or limit our current use of nuclear power? If so, to what extent?

Your hybrid group discussions should also address the following questions:

  • What do we gain, or risk, by keeping fission technology as part of our energy planning?
  • Is fission technology essential given the expansion of wind, solar, hydroelectric, geothermal, and battery storage technologies?
  • How can we meet the projected increase in energy needs due to the expansion of AI?
  • Do the benefits of energy from fission technology outweigh the environmental and public health risks?
  • Can fission technology be effectively monitored in a way that does not threaten international political stability?

Your hybrid group is also responsible for outlining an energy policy that reflects the ideas and decisions made during your group discussion. Your policy solution may reject, limit, or expand the use of fission technology. Write a short statement that presents and explains your group’s fission energy plan. Add this statement to your assignment notes. Be prepared to explain your group policy decisions to the class.

Finally, take some time to reflect on your group discussion, compromise and resulting policy. You should consider the agreement made in your discussion group and any facts about fission technology that were most thought-provoking for you. Did the research and discussion support or change your point of view about using fission as an energy resource? Did your thinking change? Why or why not?

3 of 8

Resources

Below is a list of resources you can use to research the benefits and risks of using fission technology. Feel free to use resources beyond the ones provided for you. Be sure to include any new resource links with your assignment.

​

  1. Stanford University: Understand Energy Learning Hub
  2. Stanford University: Understand Nuclear Fission
  3. EnergySage: Nuclear Energy Pros and Cons
  4. EIA: nuclear power explained
  5. EIA: nuclear power and the environment
  6. EIA: Renewable energy explained
  7. Energy.gov: How does a nuclear reactor work?
  8. BBC Video: Inside a Nuclear Reactor Core (3.53 min)
  9. seeker video - how uranium becomes fuel (U-235 enrichment - 5.50 min)
  10. PBS news: How the next generation of nuclear reactors could be smaller, greener, and safer (2/2020)
  11. National Center for Biotechnology Information: Toxicological Profile for Uranium
  12. Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation -The Basics of Nuclear Weapons Fact Sheet
  13. Our World In Data - Nuclear Weapons Testing

4 of 8

Fission Pros

Fission Cons

  • ​
  • ​

Suggested topics: any definitions, history and general applications of fission technology, renewable energy and energy storage resources. Note the research resources you have used.

Research Notes

Name: Date: Class Period:

5 of 8

Policy Plan

Write your group energy plan statement here:

Name: Date: Class Period:

6 of 8

Reflection

Were there any facts about fission technology that were most thought provoking for you?

Did the research and discussion support or change your original point of view about using fission as an energy resource?

Explain how and why your ideas have changed or not changed.

Name: Date: Class Period:

7 of 8

Topic

Criteria

Points Earned

Research

  • Research includes discussion of: fission technology pros and/or cons
  • Research includes discussion of: renewable energy pros and/of cons
  • Notes clearly define argument to expand or limit future use of fission technology
  • Research is detailed and well sequenced
  • Resources are cited

​

Policy Agreement

  • State the energy plan that your group outlined.
  • Explain the reasoning behind the ideas that were included in your group’s final agreement.

​

Discussion Reflection

  • Comment on fission technology facts that were most thought provoking for you.
  • Explain how the research and discussion supported or changed your opinion of using fission technology?
  • Comments are clearly written

​

Comments & Total Points Earned

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Grading Form

8 of 8

Visit now for more FREE Resources!

​

​

www.subjecttoclimate.org