1 of 22

2 of 22

Welcome!

So excited that you’re interested in the policy comp!!! :)

Please fill out the interest form!

3 of 22

About Us

  • Veda Subiah
    • BISF Co-Director of Policy Competition
    • Will Rice College
    • vs67@rice.edu
  • Sarah Vu
    • BISF Co-Director of Policy Competition
    • Brown College
    • swv1@rice.edu

4 of 22

About the Competition

AI Policy

5 of 22

About the Competition

Important Dates:

March 1 - Proposal submissions due

March 15 - Finalists notified of selection

March 20 - Deadline for selected finalists to confirm attendance

April 9 - Deadline for submitting powerpoints for presentations

April 18 - BISF Undergraduate Public Policy Competition

6 of 22

About the Competition

Participants can choose from one of five prompts:

  1. Data Misuse in AI Systems
  2. Environmental Responsibility in AI Development
  3. AI-Driven Job Displacement
  4. Underrepresentation in Biomedical Data
  5. Choose your own topic

7 of 22

About the Competition

Data Misuse in AI Systems

In recent years, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has reshaped how personal data is collected, analyzed, and reused, heightening long-standing privacy risks. In 2024 alone, AI-related privacy and security incidents rose by 56.4%, with 233 reported cases. As large language models and generative systems expand in capability, they can memorize or reveal personal information, facilitate targeted spear-phishing and voice-cloning scams, and repurpose user data such as resumes, photographs, or location histories for training without consent. These developments compound existing harms, including biased hiring tools and facial-recognition systems linked to false arrests, while unclear collection practices leave individuals with little control over how their information is used. Given these concerns, propose a U.S. policy initiative that regulates the use of personal data in AI systems, establishes legislative oversight across the training-data supply chain, and strengthens requirements for consent.

8 of 22

About the Competition

Environmental Responsibility in AI Development

From predictive models that forecast extreme weather to satellite systems that monitor deforestation and emissions, Artificial Intelligence (AI) is becoming a critical tool in global efforts towards climate adaptation and mitigation. Yet, the massive computing power required to train a single large AI model produces over 626,000 pounds of CO2 equivalent. As a result, the carbon footprint involved in the creation and maintenance of these models risks intensifying the very problems they seek to solve. Moreover, building these technologies often necessitates minerals like cobalt, lithium and tantalum. Extracting these resources comes at a significant environmental cost and can harm nearby communities–especially in low-income countries that have the greatest need for AI-driven climate solutions but the least access to them. Given these concerns, propose a U.S. policy initiative that regulates the environmental impact of AI development and encourages sustainable sourcing of critical minerals to reduce ecological harm, protect vulnerable communities, and promote responsible innovation in climate-focused AI technologies.

9 of 22

About the Competition

AI-Driven Job Displacement

In recent years, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has accelerated the rate of job displacement across the U.S. Between 2023 and 2024 alone, major technology companies including Google, Microsoft, and Duolingo announced thousands of layoffs explicitly tied to AI implementation, while companies like UPS and IBM have publicly committed to reducing or freezing hiring in roles being automated by AI systems. AI is rapidly outperforming human workers in industries such as data analysis, customer support, education, media, and tech as it can streamline scheduling, data processing, and quality control. Displaced workers often face a sudden loss in income, gaps in employer-based healthcare, limited access to retraining opportunities, and prolonged difficulty finding a job in the same field. Thus, considering that over 800 million jobs could be affected by 2030, propose a U.S. policy initiative at mitigating AI-driven job displacement that expands unemployment support, strengthens social safety nets, and invests in workforce transition programs.

10 of 22

About the Competition

Underrepresentation in Biomedical Data

Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly used in healthcare to support diagnostics, treatment planning, and public health decision-making. However, many AI algorithms are trained on datasets that underrepresent historically marginalized populations, creating foundational biases that affect model performance across diverse patient groups. For example, convolutional neural networks trained on predominantly white patient skin images have been shown to misclassify lesions in Black patients, contributing to disparities in melanoma outcomes. These challenges are compounded by inconsistent data standards, incomplete metadata, and limited interoperability across health systems. Given these limitations, propose a U.S. policy initiative that establishes national standards for inclusive health data, improves metadata collection, and ensures that AI algorithms are trained and evaluated on these representative datasets.

11 of 22

About the Competition

Choose your own topic. Either:

  1. Choose a specific policy that is currently in place, identify problems with this policy, and recommend a new course of action (reject the policy, change the policy, or adopt a new policy), or
  2. Argue for an adoption of a policy that would help address a specific problem in the realm of United States AI policy at the state or national level. Identify and respond to potential criticisms of the new policy.

12 of 22

What if I have never written a policy proposal or done anything with policy?

  • That’s ok! SERIOUSLY. ITS OKAY :)
  • As long as you are passionate about A.I. policy in the U.S. and have some ideas on how to change or contribute to that kind of policy.
  • And if you have any questions, feel free to ask us or any of the other BISF officers!

13 of 22

Components of a Good Policy Proposal

(Also in the Rulebook on the BISF website, but we’ll quickly go over it today)

At minimum you should have:

  • Brief abstract
  • Relevant background info about subtopic
  • Statement of current policy and why it is inadequate (or beneficial)
  • Statement of at least two policy options, with a brief summary of the benefits and drawbacks presented by each option
  • Recommendation for specific course of action
  • Explanation of why this policy is the preferable alternative, reinforced by evidence and strong argumentation that addresses possible counterarguments
  • Bibliography

14 of 22

What You’ll Be Evaluated On

  • Background (10%)
  • Proposal (20%)
  • Justification (30%)
  • Feasibility and Specificity (15%)
  • Evidence (25%)

15 of 22

Paper Formatting

  • All papers should be formatted according to the following criteria:
  • 2,000-4,000 words (excluding citations and graphics/appendix)
  • Times New Roman, 12 pt font
  • Double-spaced
  • Page number centered in footer
  • Standard 1 inch margins on all sides of page
  • Consistent formatting for subsection titles (letters, numerals, etc.)

16 of 22

Paper Formatting

  • Page 1: Cover Page displaying entrant’s
  • Name
  • University Attended, Expected Year of Graduation
  • Title of Policy Paper
  • Page 2:
  • Title of Policy Paper
  • Abstract (250-350 words)
  • Page 3... : Body of Paper
  • Last Pages: Bibliography
  • Citations: APA, Chicago/Turabian, MLA, and Harvard Styles will be accepted
  • Footnotes: Times New Roman, 10 pt font, single-spaced

17 of 22

Resources Available to You

  • Competition Website
    • Sample papers of past winners in past RJPP
    • This presentation
    • Rulebook
    • Important dates
  • Rulebook
    • Has pretty much everything
    • Section V: Paper Evaluation Overview
    • Section X: Overview of Presentation Evaluation
  • Us/BISF officers!

18 of 22

Office Hours

  • Fall:
    • Sarah & Veda: Tuesdays 11:00 am - 12:00 pm
    • Sarah: Mondays 3:00 pm - 4:00 pm
    • Veda: Fridays 12:00 pm - 1:00 pm
  • Spring:
    • Sarah: Tuesdays and Thursdays 9:00 a, - 10:00 am
    • Veda: TBD

19 of 22

Prizes!

Bragging rights ofc

Top 3 finalists (1st, 2nd, 3rd place) will have their papers published in The Rice Journal of Public Policy

1st Place: $1,000

2nd Place: $750

3rd Place: $500

20 of 22

Any questions?

21 of 22

Fill out this interest form if you would like to be updated on news/info for the competition:

22 of 22

Thank you for coming, and good luck on your proposals!

Feel free to email us if you want to contact us after this info session! We’ll also be hosting related events and office hours in the future!