1 of 54

Citizen Proposal

Suggestions for Urban Air Quality Management: Delhi-NCR

A Multi-Sectoral Approach

The Air Collective -Bharat Project

PRESENTED BY

Shivani Thakur @urjacity

SUBMITTED BY

2 of 54

Air Collective Mission:

To transition Delhi-NCR from reactive, emergency-based "shutdowns" to a proactive, engineered urban ecosystem.

By integrating Clean Technologies, Nature-Based Solutions (NBS) with Citizen-Led Data Networks, we create a self-regulating city that breathes.

3 of 54

Air Collective: Pilot Proposals

1. Black Carbon Mitigation: Targeted technical interventions (improved chimneys, Genset and transport retrofits) to reduce soot emissions in high-impact industries and locations.

2. RWA Waste-to-Resource Models: Decentralized wet-waste composting and zero-waste-to-landfill systems for housing societies to eliminate municipal transport emissions and fire risks.

3.Visual Pollution Literacy: Installing "Air-Flags," educational murals, and real-time health-impact displays in public squares and schools to drive mass behavioral change.

4.Farm Waste to Coal: Deployment of scalable bio-char/pelletization units to convert agricultural residue into industrial-grade fuel, resolving operational issues on fast track.

4 of 54

Air Collective: Pilot Proposals

5. Citizen Sensors Networks: Deployment of a high-density "mesh" of low-cost, IoT-enabled sensors to provide real-time, street-level air quality data for precision local enforcement.

6. BIVS & Transit Greening: Implementing Building-Integrated Vegetated Systems and vertical forests on metro pillars and flyovers to trap dust and neutralize heat at the source.

7. "Model Breathable Ward" Pilot: A comprehensive, multi-sector demonstration in a high-exposure municipal zone to prove the combined ROI of all technical and behavioral interventions.

8. Regulated Carpooling: Launching a structured, high-occupancy vehicle-sharing system to reduce private vehicle load on congested transit corridors.

5 of 54

Transport and Mobility

6 of 54

Transport – Decarbonizing the Legacy Fleet

Main Suggestion: Implement a "Retrofit-First" Policy

(20% of the oldest trucks cause 80% of roadside PM2.5.)

      • RECD (Diesel Exhaust Filters): 95% PM reduction, 20x cheaper than scrappage. Standardize retrofit costs and vendors.

      • Entry Checks : Link FASTag systems with PUC and DPF checks to ensure compliance

      • Finance: Notify 30-40% government subsidy/ESG financing framework for transitioning

      • Active Traffic lights: Establish no-idling zones at traffic hotspots to decrease localized air pollution and build vigilant network for active smart traffic lights that works on traffic volumes sensors.

7 of 54

Transport – Halt the trains to Halt the pollution

THE "STRATEGIC STOP" SOLUTION

The Connectivity Paradox

The Gap: Electric trains like the Rajdhani bypass major hubs like Ghaziabad/Noida.

The Conflict: Passengers backtrack 20+ km via fossil-fuel cars to reach central Delhi terminals

​The Hidden Environmental Cost

​Carbon Load: Each car trip to the station adds ~3.4 kg of CO_2 to Delhi’s air.

​Urban Friction: Avoidable "first-mile" journeys worsen PM2.5 levels and city-center gridlock.

​The "Strategic Stop" Solution

​Satellite Access: A 2-minute stop at NCR hubs allows boarding closer to home.

​Filter Effect: Transforms suburban stations into intermodal filters, keeping cars off city roads.

​Impact: Scaling Net-Zero

​Direct Savings: Eliminates the highest-emitting leg of the journey before the train even departs.

​Smart Planning: Integrates Indian Railways into a modern, multi-nodal urban ecosystem

8 of 54

Shared Mobility: Carpool & Office Luxury Buses

The Barrier: Help removing Legal ambiguity to ineffective, unsafe carpooling.

The Fix:

      • Adopt the Maharashtra Model or Singapore Model—defining "Non-Commercial" cost-sharing.
      • Implementing "High Occupancy" parking benefits and carbon-credit monetization.
      • Implement employer-led programs to reduce traffic congestion.
      • Employer led carpool and buses: An incentive based initiative for the government employess.

Impact: Even a 10% shift from single-occupancy cars reduces peak-hour smog-forming NOx by 15%.

9 of 54

Reclaiming the Street: Walkability & E-Cycling

      • Infrastructure as Behavior Nudge: Building wide, shaded footpaths and dedicated cycling tracks to make "walking the last kilometer" the easiest choice.

      • No encroachment lanes: Create a dedicated space for street vendors and make a citizen vigilant network for no encrochment lanes.

      • E-Cycling Integration: Promote e-bike sharing or bike on rent at all Metro stations. (Bengaluru model)

The Scientific Rationale: Every 1 km shifted from a motor vehicle to a cycle prevents 150g of CO_2 and associated PM2.5 emissions.

10 of 54

Revolutionizing Urban Logistics & Last-Mile Mobility

      • Diesel-to-Electric Retrofit Kits: Instead of scrappag, certifying modular kits to convert existing delivery vans from diesel to electric. Saving from giving economic shock to small logistics players.

      • Battery Swapping Infrastructure: A network of swapping stations to eliminate "range anxiety" and maximize "uptime" for gig workers.

      • Multi-Modal Feeder Systems: Utilize Rail/Metro freight for bulk transit to the city fringe, and creating strategic stops at NCR like Mumbai locals for passengers.

Ensuring no trucks or polluting buses enter Delhi/NCR region- Rigid Checks

11 of 54

Waste and Dust

12 of 54

Construction Dust – From Fragmentation to Precision Control

      • Regulatory Guardrails: Mandatory Site Registration: Every active construction site (residential or commercial) must be registered on a central dashboard.

      • Compliance-Linked Approvals: Building "Permit to Work" should be contingent on a verified Dust Management Plan.

      • Adopting C40 Clean Construction Standards: Shifting to low-carbon, low-dust materials and prioritizing Demolition Waste as a circular resource rather than a pollutant.

13 of 54

Construction Dust – From Fragmentation to Precision Control

      • Rent Auto-Trigger Fogging: Sensors that automatically activate misting systems the moment PM10 levels exceed a set threshold—removing human discretion.

      • Traffic Light Scoring: A public Green/Orange/Red site scoring system. High-performing (Green) sites receive fast-tracked clearances for future projects & possibly, preferential rates from vendors.

14 of 54

Urban Dust & Waste – The "Soil Shield" Strategy

Main Suggestion: Waste-to-Mulch for Dust Suppression to reduce PM 10.

      • The Fix: Urban Mulching—using shredded dry leaves and decentralized compost to cover all bare medians and parks. Add Bio-Enzymes or Dust Binders to the water tankers used for sprinkling.

      • Improve soil structure and water‑holding capacity in parks, medians, lake edges, roadsides green zones, reclaimed dumps and C&D buffer belts.

      • We propose Pilot: Establish a 2km "Model Clean Corridor" using soil polymers, biodegradable air towers and automated misting.

15 of 54

Urban Waste – Fix Open Burning

Addressing the Source: Open Burning Prevention

      • The Toxicity Fact: Open burning of municipal solid waste (MSW) is a leading source of dioxins, furans, and black carbon, which are far more carcinogenic than road dust.

      • NGO-Led Monitoring: "Hotspot Mapping" system where citizen volunteers use a mobile app to report neighborhood burning in real-time, triggering immediate municipal response, automated challans to property owner and vehicle number challans based on image captured, instead of delayed complaints.

16 of 54

Urban Waste Decentralized Management 1

Ward-Level Composting: Instead of transporting wet waste 30km to a landfill (emitting transport CO2), we advocate for Decentralized Aerobic Composting within colony parks or community centers.

Entrepreneurial Opportunity: We suggest a "Carbon Credit" model for housing societies that achieve Zero-Waste-to-Landfill status.

E-Waste Recovery: Formalize the "Kabadi" network through an entrepreneur-led platform to ensure toxic heavy metals, plastic and recyclables do not form general waste fires.

17 of 54

Urban Waste Decentralized Management 2

Automated Segregation: We propose automated, segregation-first waste management systems with sealed underground conveyance in new high-density developments. This intervention directly lowers PM2.5, NOₓ, and road dust emissions, while improving urban hygiene and operational efficiency.

Incentivized Segregation App: For existing neighborhoods, our entrepreneur collective proposes a QR-coded Bin System. Households that achieve 100% segregation (Wet/Dry/Hazardous) receive "Green Credits" redeemable for utility bill discounts.

18 of 54

Industry Emission

19 of 54

Industry & Power – Precision Emission Control

Zero-Tolerance Enforcement (Immediate)

      • Mandatory APCD Deployment: Strict enforcement of ESPs (Electrostatic Precipitators), RCP, scrubbers, and Air Pollution Control Devices (APCDs) in all smoke emitting plants and connected to central controlling platform, accessible to public.

      • Biomass Co-firing Mandates: Implement the 5–10% biomass co-firing rule immediately to reduce coal dependency.

      • Technical Capacity Building: Launching ecosystem-wide workshops via CII, NTPC, and the IIT network to train plant operators on emission-reduction optimization.

20 of 54

Industry & Power – Policy Watch

The Retrofit Revolution

      • Industrial Retrofit Innovations: Allowing innovations to pilot with real project, moving beyond basic filters to low-NOx burners.

      • Fast-Track Innovation: Creating a "Green Channel" for fast-tracking regulatory approvals for Clean-Tech Startups providing proven retrofit solutions.

      • Citizen reporting : Promote Infrastructure for citizens to raise their observation of chimneys soot and make companies mention their compliances in ESG/CPCB reports.

21 of 54

Industry & Power – Transition Support

The "Clean Vendor" List: Publishing a government-validated list of technology vendors to prevent MSMEs from being cheated by sub-standard equipment.

Accountability: Permanent closure of chronic violators who fail to meet emission benchmarks after three warnings.

22 of 54

Brick Kilns – From "Zig-Zag" to Zero-Emission

      • The Ask: Provide interest-subsidized loans for kiln owners to upgrade technology rather than just imposing fines.

      • Immediate Enforcement: As per the SC ruling, mandate and verify the transition from FCBTK (Fixed Bull’s Trench Kilns) to Zig-Zag Technology, which reduces coal consumption by 20% and PM emissions by 70%.

      • Fly-Ash Integration: Mandate the use of fly-ash (from power plants) in brick manufacturing to reduce topsoil excavation.

      • Induced Draft Fans: Introduce VFD-controlled fans to optimize combustion and prevent "Black Smoke" episodes.

      • Structural Shift: Transition to Autoclaved Aerated Concrete (AAC) blocks and "Green Bricks" that don't require firing.

23 of 54

Industrial Stack Monitoring – Targeting toxicity in air

Main Suggestion: Real-time AI-Visual Enforcement.

The Problem: Visible "Black Smoke" represents a complete failure of ESP/Scrubber systems.

The Fix: Deploy AI-Stack Cameras and low-cost Black Carbon sensors on chimneys and truck traffic signals.

Enforcement: A Whistleblower portal managed by NGOs to provide real-time evidence to CAQM.

Citizen led Truck number reporting for vehicle pollution violators, and send challan at home.

24 of 54

Nature-Based Solutions

25 of 54

Nature-Based Solutions (NBS) – The Biological Shield

Building-Integrated Vegetated Systems (BIVS)

Green Roofs & Facades: Utilizing the "Opportunity" of unused rooftop space (identified via GEE mapping) to install modular greening.

Green ribbons: Transform transit metro into active biological filters that utilize metro pillars, flyover embankments, and highway medians to intercept vehicular toxins and neutralize urban heat.

26 of 54

Nature-Based Solutions (NBS) – The Biological Shield

The Science: BIVS act as a Physical Filter, trapping PM2.5 on leaf surfaces, and a Thermal Buffer, reducing roof surface temperatures by up to 20°C. This lowers the "Convection Effect" that keeps dust suspended in the air.

One-Time "Seed Grant": A direct municipal grant (e.g., ₹50,000 to ₹2,00,000) for societies to transition from "dumping waste" to "composting waste," which pays for itself by reducing municipal transport costs and compost used for BIVS implementation reducing cost on building owners.

27 of 54

Nature-Based Solutions (NBS) – Using Law

Integrate BIVS into building bylaws: Offer floor-area ratio (FAR) incentives for "Greening Compliance”.

Low-Interest Green Loans: Partner with banks to classify BIVS as Essential Climate Infrastructure, allowing homeowners and MSMEs to access priority-sector lending at reduced rates.

Bulk Procurement Programs: The Municipal Corporation can aggregate demand to lower the cost of native plants, specialized growth media, and automated irrigation kits for citizens

28 of 54

Nature-Based Solutions (NBS) – Using Law

The "Rent-to-Rebate" Link: The government can offer a Construction Cess Rebate to developers who can prove (via geo-tagged photos/sensors) that they maintained a 30% green shield coverage throughout the construction period.

Instant Habitability: New buildings often remain "concrete deserts" for 2–3 years while permanent trees grow. We suggest a mandate for temporary Rented Greenery (potted shrubs, vertical walls) in common areas as a condition for the Occupancy Certificate (OC).

We can help to measure the Dust Capture Efficiency of different plant species to provide a "Certified Species List" for rental contracts.

29 of 54

Behaviour as Infrastructure :

Not just awareness

30 of 54

Pollution Literacy

The Suggestion: Compliment "Awareness Campaigns" with "Behavioral Systems" that reduce the cost of governance.

Human Capital as a "Force Multiplier" for Enforcement

Treat a literate citizenry as a decentralized Monitoring Grid. When residents understand the "Chemistry of Pollution," they move from passive observers to active enforcers of "No-Idling" zones and "Zero-Burning" protocols.

Mural Behaviour Science: Use photo-catalytic paint (which absorbs NOx) for school, metros and public places murals that explain the "Carbon Cycle" or "Dust Suppression." The wall itself becomes both a filter and a textbook.

31 of 54

The "Impact Leaderboard" (RWA Solution-Tracking)

Instead of displaying discouraging "Pollution Points," the RWA Scoreboard focuses on Positive Contribution Metrics. This shifts the focus from the problem to the collective agency of the residents.

Positive Metric Display: Societies are ranked on a "Green Participation Index" (GPI)

Friction-Free "Safety-First" Carpool Zones

To maximize carpool adoption, the physical infrastructure must address the primary psychological barrier: Trust and Safety.

like Gender-Specific Highlights: The "Pink Zone" (All-Women Hub): Dedicated, well-lit sections of the Green-Pool Zone for women-only carpools.

32 of 54

Pollution APP

A single app for every Indian for everything related to ‘Pollution’, similar to, or re-purposing the ‘Aarogya Setu App for COVID’ for ‘Pollution Awareness & Prevention’

The Vision: Single platform to drive awareness, behavior changes and incentivize actions which benefit the environment & prevent its degradation

Repurpose the pandemic’s digital infrastructure for tackling pollution.

Strategic Nudges: Linking localized sensor data to respiratory health alerts for vulnerable groups & creating incentives for making right environmental choices.

33 of 54

Integrate Social Proof

Social Proof Scoreboards: Public leaderboards at metro stations for wards- low emission compliance, no-burning approach and green adoptions

Gamified version for schools/colleges; incentives (eg tax rebates) for adults

Integrate an AI reporting interface into the PAVAN Digital Ecosystem (CAQM’s 2026 analytical platform).

Automated validation, geotagging, clustering to prioritize enforcement in high-density hotspots

Promote Work from Village culture.

34 of 54

WFV: Empowering Villages, Protecting NCR

​Commute Deletion: Removes thousands of cars from NCR roads, instantly cutting PM_{2.5} and NO_2 levels.

​Rural Brain Gain: Brings global expertise to villages, mentoring local youth and fueling "Digital Village" growth.

​Cooling the City: Reduces the "Urban Heat Island" effect by lowering energy demand for massive IT park ACs.

​Circular Economy: Directs urban salaries into rural markets, incentivizing green land use over industrial sprawl.

Workfromvillage.com

35 of 54

Capacity Building

36 of 54

1. The "Green Intern" & Expert Surge Adoption of Green Interns: Embed specialized environmental graduates into the CAQM (Commission for Air Quality Management) and CPCB (Central Pollution Control Board).

These interns act as "Technical Liaisons," assisting senior officials with data processing and real-time monitoring of the pilot projects.

2. Specialized Contractual Staff: Hire contractual subject-matter experts (Environmental Engineers, Data Scientists, and Behavioral Psychologists) to manage specific "Collective" initiatives.

37 of 54

3. Solving the "TIDCO Problem" (Inter-Departmental Friction)

The Problem: Innovation often dies in the "no-man's land" between departments

The Solution: Create an "Integrated Air Cell" that sits above individual departments. This body has the mandate to override "siloed" objections that stall cross-sector pilots like construction violation, BIVS or broken footpaths.

4. The "Living Laboratory" Sandbox

Hyper-Polluted Sandboxes: Identify the most contaminated zones, designate them as "Regulatory Sandboxes."

The Living Lab: In these zones, permit "Living Lab" status where new, unproven innovations (like experimental smog-absorbers or new bio-absorbers) can be tested in real-world conditions without the usual years procurement delay.

38 of 54

5. Establishing the "Trusted Provider" List

Removing the Distrust Barrier: The biggest hurdle for officials is the fear of "vendor failure."

The Validated List: The Collective (If needed) can provide a Pre-Validated Directory of Solution Providers. Each provider is vetted by the scientific wing of the Collective for performance and the NGO wing for community safety.

Assurance Framework: This "White-Labeling" by a trusted multi-stakeholder body reduces the perceived risk for officials and speeds up the tendering process.

39 of 54

Funding and

Carbon Market Participation

40 of 54

Mobilising CSR Capital for NCR Clean Air

A Scalable Financing Lever for CAQM

The Gap

• Delhi–NCR continues to face severe PM2.5 burden

• Public clean-air allocations remain limited

• India deploys ~₹30,000 crore annually under CSR (Companies Act 2013)

• Only ~6–7% currently flows to environment

Untapped financing potential exists within the CSR framework.

41 of 54

Delhi-NCR Clean Air & Climate Facility

Blended Capital Stack for Scalable Air Pollution & Climate Solutions (₹500 Crore Model)

Layer 1 – Catalytic Capital (CSR First-Loss) | ₹125 Cr

• Pilot deployment & viability gap funding

• MRV & monitoring infrastructure

• Technology validation & risk absorption

High Risk | Unlocks Lower Layers

Layer 2 – Performance Capital (Carbon + Impact Funds) | ₹175 Cr

• Industrial retrofits & diesel transition

• Methane capture & black carbon reduction

• Pay-for-performance model

Moderate Risk | Scales Verified Reductions

Layer 3 – Scale Capital (Green Bonds / Senior Debt) | ₹200 Cr (Expandable to ₹1,000+ Cr)

• EV bus fleets & electrification

• Waste & biomethanation plants

• Sewage & drainage infrastructure

Low Risk | Enables Infrastructure at Scale

3-Year Target Outcomes

• PM2.5 reduction across NCR hotspots

• 2–4 million tons CO₂e avoided

• 100,000+ diesel vehicles retrofitted

• 1,000+ MSMEs transitioned

• Methane capture from landfill clusters

• Verified black carbon reduction

Capital Logic: CSR absorbs early risk → Carbon monetizes performance → Green Bonds scale infrastructure

42 of 54

Funding & Corporate Participation

43 of 54

Mobilising CSR Capital for NCR Clean Air

A Scalable Financing Lever for CAQM

44 of 54

🟥 1️⃣ The Gap

• Delhi–NCR continues to face severe PM2.5 burden

• Public clean-air allocations remain limited

• India deploys ~₹30,000 crore annually under CSR (Companies Act 2013)

• Only ~6–7% currently flows to environment

Untapped financing potential exists within the CSR framework.

🟦 2️⃣ The Opportunity

Proposed structured CSR alignment:

• 10% baseline CSR → environment

• 30% CSR for high-impact sectors (construction, power, manufacturing, transport)

Potential unlock nationally:

→ ₹3,000–6,000+ crore annually

If even 10% directed to NCR:

→ ₹300–600 crore per year

🟩 3️⃣ What This Enables in NCR

Coordinated, measurable interventions:

✔ Mechanized road dust suppression

✔ Construction compliance tech

✔ Industrial emission retrofits

✔ Crop residue management deployment

✔ EV charging & fleet pilots

✔ Advanced monitoring & enforcement systems

Shift from fragmented CSR → systemic pollution reduction.

🟨 4️⃣ Role for CAQM

Under the mandate of the Commission for Air Quality Management:

• Define eligible clean-air project categories

• Create NCR Clean Air CSR Registry

• Standardize PM2.5 reduction metrics

• Publish annual impact dashboard

• Coordinate corporates, state govts & regulators

No new tax. No fiscal expansion.

Leverages existing legal framework.

45 of 54

National Environment Fund

46 of 54

Why India Needs a National Environment Fund (NEF)

​Pooled CSR Impact: Aggregates private sector CSR funds to finance large-scale national projects (e.g., river rejuvenation or green corridors) that individual companies cannot manage alone.

​Public Participation: Creates a transparent, NDF-style channel for citizens to contribute micro-donations directly toward local pollution-fighting infrastructure and urban air quality.

​Funding Green Innovation: Acts as a catalytic capital source for Indian startups developing "high-risk, high-reward" technologies like carbon capture and waste-to-fuel systems.

​Emergency Response Readiness: Provides a dedicated financial reserve for rapid deployment during environmental crises, such as severe smog episodes or urgent ecosystem restoration.

47 of 54

Delhi NCR

Clean Air Carbon Market

�Turning Pollution Reduction into a Self-Financing Capital Engine

48 of 54

🛑 Capital Engine�- Quantify GHG + PM2.5 reductions → Issue DACC → Corporate ESG purchases → Clean Air Transition Fund�- Capital Potential (Phase 1):� • Participating corporates: 50–60� • Avg annual credit purchase: 30,000 tCO2e� • Price per tonne: ₹1,000� • Total capital mobilized: ₹900–1,500 crore/year��Proof It Works – Case Evidence:�• Mumbai Metro 2A & 7 → 85k tCO2e avoided, PAS 2060 → Urban projects measurable & verifiable�• Humbo Ethiopia → 29k tCO2e/year → High-integrity MRV attracts capital�

�🟩 Governance�- CAQM as registry & market regulator�- Independent MRV & 3rd-party audits�- Transparent pricing & digital tracking�- BRSR-aligned credits for top 1,000 corporates�- Prevent double counting & verify co-benefits��Outcome: High-trust, CAQM-backed urban carbon marketplace�

�🟧 Impact�Capital Deployment:�• Clean fuel & MSME transitions�• EV freight & public transport incentives�• Dust & construction mitigation�• Stubble & waste management��Co-Benefits:�• PM2.5 reduction & public health�• Climate mitigation (GHG reduction)�• Job creation & industrial modernization�

�🟥 Strategic Positioning�- Pollution epicenter → urgent PM2.5 reduction�- High corporate ESG → reliable demand�- CAQM mandate + state alignment�- Scalable pilot for national carbon/ESG framework��Outcome: Delhi = India’s first Air-Quality Linked Carbon Finance Hub�

Carbon markets work → Urban emission reductions measurable → High-integrity standards attract capital.�Delhi can mobilize ₹900–1,500 crore/year to reduce pollution & generate measurable health, climate, and economic benefits.

49 of 54

    • Mechanized road dust suppression
    • Construction compliance tech
    • Industrial emission retrofits
    • Crop residue management deployment
    • EV charging & fleet pilots
    • Diesel Retrofits to phase out use of diesel
    • Advanced monitoring & enforcement systems

Shift from fragmented CSR and ESG → systemic pollution reduction.

What This Enables in NCR:

Coordinated, measurable interventions

50 of 54

51 of 54

Under the mandate of the Commission for Air Quality Management:

    • Define eligible clean-air project categories
    • Create NCR Clean Air CSR and ESG Registry
    • Standardize PM2.5 reduction metrics industrywise
    • Incentivize Black carbon reduction
    • Publish annual impact dashboard
    • Positions NCR as India’s Clean Air Market Pilot zone and tradable in Carbon Market

No new tax. No fiscal expansion.

Leverages existing legal framework.

Leveraging CAQM Provisions:

52 of 54

The Air Collective: Contributors

53 of 54

Participants:

YourStory

Quick Ride Carpool/Bikepool

Urjacity

Vayufres

Saroja Earth

Oxyharvest

Share4earth

Green Saarthi

  • Agastya Hydrogen

Climate Culture

Sklara-Greentech Solutions

FuelFlip Energy

Newcycl

MahaGaonkar Charitable Trust

Hawa Badlo

Surya Enviro/ Waste

CommuniTREE

Advandes

Sidel Systems

Immpact

The Bharat Project :

200+ experts, practitioners, professionals;

600+ ideas

& Counting

54 of 54

Thank you !

These recommendations are

placed for CAQM review.

Air Collective: For Breathable Cities

We would welcome the opportunity for further discussion,

feedback and guidance