1 of 26

2008 Financial Crisis

TEAM 18:

DEXTER LONGLEY

ALLAN LAO

SYLVIA GONG

JACK MURRAY

AVIKUMAR PATEL

2 of 26

Introduction to the Crisis

3 of 26

Important Concepts

  • Leverage
    • Borrowing money to increase the increase impact of investment.
  • Hedge Fund
    • Funds set aside for high risk investment. Use leverage to maximise returns.
  • Mortgage
    • A loan given to homeowners using the house as collateral.
    • Prime Mortgage
      • A mortgage given to applicants who are likely to not default.
    • Sub-Prime Mortgage
      • A mortgage given to less responsible applicants, higher risk of default.
  • Collateralized Debt Obligations
    • The tiers of Mortgage Related Securities sold to investors
  • Credit Default Swap
    • Insurance designed to make CDOs safer.

4 of 26

Major Players

​

  • Lehman Brothers
    • 4th largest investment bank.
    • Acquired mortgage lenders in 2004
      • Includes several subprime lenders.
    • Stock fall dramatically when 2007 credit crisis erupts.
    • Bankruptcy in September 2008
  • Bear-Stearns
    • Large investment bank
    • Collapsed at the start of the Crisis
      • Result of overleveraging in CDO investments.
    • Purchased by JPMorgan

5 of 26

Major Players

  • Government Sponsored Enterprises (GSE)
    • Fannie Mae (FNMA)
      • Federal National Mortgage Association
      • Created 1938 ( Entered Public Sector 1968)
    • Freddie Mac (FHLMC)
      • Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp
      • Created 1970
    • Created a secondary market for Mortgages
    • Borrow Money at lower interest rates.
    • Allow lower income citizens to purchase houses.
    • Losses due to market collapse were pushed onto the taxpayers.

6 of 26

What happened in 2008?

  • January: Countrywide Financial Corp. bought by Bank of America
  • March: Bear Stearns declares bankruptcy, bought by JPMorgan Chase
  • September
    • U.S. Department of Treasury seizes control of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac
    • Merrill Lynch bought by Bank of America
    • Lehmann Brothers files for bankruptcy
    • American International Group gets government bailout
    • Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley become bank holding companies
    • Washington Mutual Bank closed by federal regulators

7 of 26

What happened in 2008?

  • Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP)
    • $700 billion fund for buying mortgage-based securities
    • Changed to helping banks that held the securities
      • Government owned stakes in private banks
    • Ford, Chrysler, and General Motors request for loans
  • End of 2008: unemployment and recession

​

8 of 26

Subprime Loans

THE IDEAL LOAN FOR THE NON-IDEAL CANDIDATE...

​

9 of 26

Results of Subprime Lending

​

  1. Provide money to be circulated in the economy
    1. Banks were issuing loans out to “subprime” candidates
    2. Growth of “Housing Bubble”
    3. Previous year success led to even riskier business tactics
    4. Leverage
  2. Fail obligations for consumers to repay loans
    • Burst of “Housing Bubble”
    • Lost in Mortgage backed securities
  3. Lehmann Brother were the largest victim of U.S. subprime mortgage during financial crisis.
    • Collapse of housing market

​

10 of 26

Was Subprime Lending ethical?

Applied Ethical Theory: Kantianism

​

1st Formulation: “What is always good without qualification?” (Quinn, 68).

​

  • Subprime loans were issues on the basis that they would be paid back from goodwill.

​

  • Were subprime loans false promises?

​

2nd formulation: using borrowers as a means to fuel mortgage backed securities, also known as Collateralized Debt Obligations, means to an end.

11 of 26

Was Subprime Lending ethical? Part II

Applied Ethical Theory: Rule Utilitarianism

Benefits:

  1. made housing affordable
  2. increases property value of houses

Harm:

  1. Collapse 4th largest lender in US
  2. borrower owed more than what their house was worth.

​

The long term harm outweighed the short term benefit to society.

12 of 26

SECE Code of Ethics

​

1.04 “Disclose actual/potential dangers”

Subprime lending is risky for a reason. Do not expect ideal results from non-ideal sources.

​

2.04 “Ensure documents are approved”

Credit history, credit reports, and financial documentations are all documents that can ensure that loans will be paid back on time. The reliance on “good will,” is not enough to secure repayments for a loan.

13 of 26

BMES Code of Ethics

​

Professional Obligations:

  1. Use their knowledge, skills, and abilities to enhance the safety, health, and welfare of the public.
  2. the overconfidence that the lenders had in the subprime borrowers head to collapse of the financial institution.
  3. Strive by action, example, and influence to increase the competence, prestige, and honor.
  4. For a company to be in existence since 1850, a lot of generation has dedicated their lives to the company. Follow by example set by the predecessors and do not gamble the reputation of the company.

14 of 26

Credit Rating Companies’ Actions Evaluated

KANTIANISM AND VIRTUE ETHICS

15 of 26

Credit Rating Companies

  1. Credit rating companies are the entities that evaluate how reliable a security is
  2. Investors rely heavily on these ratings to inform their decisions on what to invest their money in (FCIR, pg. 27)
  3. Certain companies are reliant upon ratings to be able to invest in securities (FCIR, pg. 119)

16 of 26

The actions of the “Big 3”

  1. Gave mortgage related securities (MRS’s) AAA ratings when they knew that these MRS’s were made up of smaller securities that had lower ratings
  2. Justified this through credit enhancements
  3. Allowed people to have mortgages that wouldn’t normally have been able to get a mortgage; this allowed them to become homeowners
  4. Allowed people to have mortgages without considering what would happen if a large number of them defaulted
  5. Charged exorbitant fees to manipulate F-rated securities into AAA securities (FCIR, pg. 44). This is the specific action that will be analyzed.

17 of 26

Was It Ethical - Kantianism

  • 1st Formulation: If the credit companies gave every security a AAA rating because the company attached to it offered a bribe to them, many securities, reliable and risky, would have AAA ratings. This would undermine the credit rating system itself, and having a AAA rated security wouldn’t actually mean it was a safe investment. No one would trust the ratings, so the credit rating companies would stop receiving fees from companies that wanted a AAA rating; this would then cause them to go out of business, so by the first formulation their actions are self defeating.

18 of 26

Was it Ethical - Kantianism

  • 2nd Formulation: By the credit rating companies accepting fees to create false ratings they are using the investors trust in their ratings as a means to make more money. Investors rely heavily upon the ratings, so whatever information the credit rating companies give to investors, the investors trust it. The entities selling the mortgage backed securities understood this and decided to take advantage of it. The credit rating companies took advantage of this by accepting the bribes over and over again to rate more MBS’s AAA knowing that because of the investors trust, the investors would buy these securities, even though they were actually a risky investment. This is how the credit rating companies used the investors to make more money, so by the second formulation the credit rating companies action was unethical.

19 of 26

Was it Ethical - Virtue Ethics

  1. With respect to generosity as a virtue, the credit rating companies swung to the side of greed.
  2. These companies were not being selfless but selfish. They were only thinking about the well-being of their own company and not of the investors and people taking out mortgages.
  3. Overconfidence or arrogance was also an issue with the rating agencies because they thought that they could keep making these false ratings and have nothing negative happen to them or others involved.

20 of 26

Was It Ethical - IEEE Code of Ethics

3. to be honest and realistic in stating claims or estimates based on available data.

  • The banks made unreasonable statements that securities backed by subprime mortgages were worth a AAA rating.

4. to reject bribery in all its forms

  • The credit rating agencies took large “fees” to rate subprime mortgage backed securities as AAA.

21 of 26

Was it Ethical - PMI Code of Ethics

Honesty -

  • We do not engage in dishonest behaviour for personal gain
    • The credit rating agencies made particular ratings to increase their monetary gain

​

  • We provide accurate information in a timely manner
    • These agencies also deceived investors by saying that unreliable securities were as reliable as federal securities issued by the Federal Reserve

22 of 26

Post Financial Crisis

  • Stock prices rose during 2009-2010
  • After losses in 2008, some financial institutions, including Merrill, Goldman, and Citigroup returned to profitability in 2009
  • Many financial institutions bought back the stock they had sold to the government under TARP
  • In the end, the government made money on many of these transactions, selling the stock back at higher prices than it paid
    • A government audit of TARP in 2010 estimated that it will eventually cost taxpayers $40 billion, a small fraction of the $700 billion put into the program
  • However, high unemployment (about 10%) still persists

​

23 of 26

Conclusion & Lessons learned

  • Ethics cannot be separated from economics
    • Only one decision – no economic decisions or ethical decisions
    • Separation between economics and ethics is one of the ultimate cause of the crisis
  • Politics should be tightly linked with ethics

24 of 26

References

  • "The Financial Crisis of 2008: Year In Review 2008". Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopædia Britannica Online. Encyclopædia Britannica Inc., 2015. Web. 08 Oct. 2015 <http://www.britannica.com/topic/Financial-Crisis-of-2008-The-1484264>.
  • "Timeline: Key Events in Financial Crisis." USA Today. Gannett, 9 Sept. 2013. Web. 16 Oct. 2015. <http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2013/09/08/chronology-2008-financial-crisis-lehman/2779515/>.
  • "Case Study: The Collapse of Lehman Brothers." Investopedia. IAC, 30 Oct. 2008. Web. 15 Oct. 2015. <http://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/09/lehman-brothers-collapse.asp>.
  • "Dissecting The Bear Stearns Hedge Fund Collapse." Investopedia. IAC, 12 Aug. 2007. Web. 15 Oct. 2015. <http://www.investopedia.com/articles/07/bear-stearns-collapse.asp?rp=i>.
  • Jarvis, Jonathan. "The Crisis of Credit Visualized." The Crisis of Credit Visualized. Jonathan Jarvis, 22 Jan. 2011. Web. 15 Oct. 2015. <http://crisisofcredit.com/>.
  • “Crash Course” The Economist Newspaper. September 7, 2013. Web. 15 Oct. 2015 <http://www.economist.com/news/schoolsbrief/21584534-effects-financial-crisis-are-still-being-felt-five-years-article>

25 of 26

Questions?

26 of 26

Thank You!