1 of 11

SEMM 1513�Introduction to Design

Concept Selection

2 of 11

Concept Selection

Concept generation phase develops a number of concepts.

Hence, the next step is to select the final concept to be further developed.

​

Problems

  • The criteria for selection may contradict to each other such as precision device may demand a higher cost in manufacturing process.

​

  • Each concept may have good and bad features within a single design, however a perfect final design is having good features.

​

​

​

3 of 11

Concept Selection: Matrix Selection

Component of Matrix Selection

  • Criteria & Weightage
  • Datum
  • Concept

​

The selection process will compare each criteria for each concept with datum.

4 of 11

Matrix Selection: Criteria and Weightage

Importance of criteria and weightage

Case 1

Performance : 1

Manufacturing: 0

Aesthetic: 0

The final product may perform very well, but may require very precision manufacturing process and looks ugly

Case 2

Performance : 0

Manufacturing: 1

Aesthetic: 0

The final product can be fabricated, but may not work and look ugly

Case 3

Performance : 0

Manufacturing: 0

Aesthetic: 1

The final product may look nice, but may not work and very expensive to fabricate.perform very well, but may be unable to be manufacture and ugly

Solution:

Performance : 0.6 or 60%

Manufacturing/production : 0.3 or 30%

Aesthetic : 0.1 or 10%

5 of 11

Matrix Selection: Criteria

Bad Criteria

Improved Criteria

Good Criteria

  • Easy to compare (No of steps taken)
  • Well understood by group
  • Specific item is compared.

6 of 11

Datum

One of the concept or similar product in market

​

For each criterion, the concept will be compared with the same of criterion of the datum.

​

​

Range of mark depends on type of selection matrix

​

  1. Screening (‘-’ , 0 , ‘+’) : worse, equal, better
  2. Scoring (-2, -1, 0, 1 ,2 ): worst, worse, equal, better , best

​

​

​

​

​

​

7 of 11

Screening and Scoring Matrix

Screening Matrix: when the number of concepts is larger than 6.

​

Scoring Matrix: when the number of concepts is equal or less than 6.

​

​

​

​

​

​

8 of 11

Meaning of total mark

Positive: the concept is better than the datum

​

Negative: the concept is worse than the datum

​

Highest mark amongst the concepts: the best concepts

​

Two concepts have equal mark: both concepts may have similar features which can be combined to develop a new concept

​

​

​

​

​

9 of 11

Reflection of final design

Based on the total mark: the concept with the highest mark will be selected as the final concept.

​

However, there is a number of criteria on the final concept that is marked as -2,-1,0,1.

​

To ensure better final design, the criteria that has been marked as -2, -1, 0, 1 should be reflected whether the mark can be improved to 2 if possible.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

10 of 11

Final Design

The final design can be

​

  • One of the proposed concepts with the modification during reflection of the final design

​

  • The integration of two or more proposed concepts.

11 of 11

Submission After Sem Break

Oral Presentation

  • Cover: Customer Need to Final Concept.
  • Every group must submit their video presentation via Youtube Channel
  • Duration: 20 min + 5 min (give brief of your final concept after reflection)

​

Minor Project

​

Submission Date: 7 May 2022, Saturday 11:59 pm

​