While you wait,
please create a name tent
HB Poster
9th grade LS Teacher
The Inference Strategy
University of Kansas- Center for Research on Learning
Nanette Fritschmann, Ph.D.
Jean B. Schumaker, Ph.D.
Donald D. Deshler, Ph.D.
Jane.Hines@FDLRSAction.org
Melissa.Mulock@FDLRSAction.org
The Florida Diagnostic and Learning Resources System is a discretionary project funded by the Florida Department of Education, Bureau of Exceptional Student Education, under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Improvement Act, Part B.
�
Group Norms
Refocus signal
Stretch beyond your current comfort zone
Ask clarifying questions
Engage fully
Use resources to advance learning
Be solution oriented
Use Person First Language
Learning Strategies
Content Enhancement Routines
+
Goal and Rationale
Today’s Learning Goal
Participants will learn to use the INFER Steps to identify and answer different types of questions typically asked about a reading passage and, with fidelity, to teach the Inference Strategy to their learners.
Rationale
Students often do not know how to successfully find clues to answer questions or make inferences during the reading process. These skills are critical for success on high-stakes reading comprehension tests; success on these tests opens the door for future opportunities.
Performance Scale
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
I can identify students who struggle with answering inferential questions and need a strategy to help them with this skill. | I can list and explain the 4 different types of questions used to assess understanding of text. | I can analyze student work for question type, supporting text evidence, and the correct answers to determine student mastery and provide feedback. | I can explain how the Inference Strategy is taught, differentiating between “stages” and “lessons” and have adequate knowledge to begin teaching the strategy to my students. | I have collected and reported student outcome data that shows I can implement the Inference Strategy with fidelity to improve student performance. |
Inside your name tent
Thinking about the Inference Strategy, what is your personal learning goal for the day?
Jot down your personal learning goal inside your name tent.
The Inference Strategy
University of Kansas- Center for Research on Learning
Nanette Fritschmann, Ph.D.
Jean B. Schumaker, Ph.D.
Donald D. Deshler, Ph.D.
Did you know…
Did you know…
Did you know…
Did you know…
Did you know…
Although the literacy rate in America is 99%, only 79% have a literacy skill level of 2 or higher, according to PIAAC (Program for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies). In practice, this means around 21% have difficulty completing “tasks that require comparing and contrasting information, paraphrasing, or making low-level inferences.”
So…How do we close the gap?
Engaging
Literature
Goals
Habits of Learning
Powerful
Strategies
Validated
Instructional
Principles
Inference Strategy Overview
Demand
Answer inferential questions
Purpose
Give students a systematic process to answer inferential questions
Inference Strategy Overview
Steps of the Strategy require the student to:
The Inference Strategy
Interact with the questions and the passage
Note what you know
Find the clues
Explore any supporting details
Return to the question
will teach students to…..
Results for the Criterion-based
Comprehension Tests
Results on the GRADE™: Grade-level Scores
Group Reading Assessment and Diagnostic Evaluation
Grade-Level Test Scores
Before Instruction | 32% |
After Instruction | 83% |
Given what you know about the Inference Strategy so far, does it meet your personal learning goal or do you need to revise your learning goal for today?
Review
The Manual and Student Materials
Brief Walk Through the Instructor’s Manual�
Registration Form
Copyright on back of title page
Introduction pages 1-10
Results you can expect (fidelity is critical!)
What makes for “good” feedback
Instructional Sequence
Stages of Instruction
Student Folder organization
Brief Walk Through the Instructor’s Manual�
Please Tab:
Evaluation Guidelines page 87
Progress Chart page 90
Guided Notes Answer Keys page 130
Answer Keys for Lesson Passages page 133
Answer Keys for Levels page 135
How the Strategy is Taught
Student Materials Book
Part I: Determining the student’s skills
Stage 1: Pretest BIG TAB page 11
Instructor’s Manual
Stage 1:Take a Pretest
Pretest Goals
Stage 1: Pretest
As you read pages 11-13
Pgs. 11-13
Pair Share
Student Outcome Data
small tabs
Lesson 2 passages*, page 4
Lesson 3 passages*, page 12
Lesson 4 passages*, page 20
Lesson 5 passages*, page 28
How the Strategy is Taught
Student Materials Book
Part II: Teach students to use the INFER Steps to answer questions
Stages 2 and 3: Describe and Model BIG TAB page 14
Instructor’s Manual
Lesson 2: Factual Questions, page 23
Lesson 3: Big Picture Questions, page 32
Lesson 4: Predicting Questions, page 43
Lesson 5: Clarifying Questions, page 51
small tabs
Lesson 1: Introduction to the Inference Strategy, page 14
*Lesson 2-5 Passages are written on a 3rd Grade level to promote learning the strategy and reduce or eliminate the cognitive load from reading
We will be stepping in and out of modeling lessons:
The Inference Strategy
Stages 2 & 3 Describe and Model�
Lesson 1: Introduction to the Inference Strategy
Pgs. 14-22
Lesson 1 Goals
“INFER” Means…
or guess based on
hints or facts
Grade Level Test Scores
That means you can
Use the inference strategy to do well on
Interact with the questions and the passage
Note what you know
Find the clues
look for clues to answer the questions
Explore any supporting details
look for more details
Return to the question
Steps for the Inference Strategy�
think about or work with the question
Interact with the questions and the passage
think about or work with the question
Note what you know
Find the clues
look for clues to answer the questions
Explore any supporting details
look for more details
Return to the question
Steps for the Inference Strategy�
figure out the type of question and write a code letter
2 Major Types of Questions
Factual Questions F
Require finding a fact in the information that you have
read
Think and Seek Questions
Require thinking & looking for clues in the passage
Interact with the questions and the passage
think about or work with the question
Note what you know
figure out the type of question and write a code letter
Find the clues
look for clues to answer the questions
Explore any supporting details
look for more details
Return to the question
Steps for the Inference Strategy�
look for clues to answer the questions
look for more details
answer the questions
Progress Chart for Stages �2 & 3
Think and respond
Think:
What are Factual Questions?
What are Think and Seek Questions?
Pair Share = 1 to 2 sentences
Stages 2 & 3 Describe and Model
Lesson 2: Factual Questions
Pgs. 23-31
Lesson 2 Goals
Interact with the questions and the passage
think about or work with the question
Note what you know
figure out the type of question and write a code letter
Find the clues
look for clues to answer the questions
Explore any supporting details
look for more details
Return to the question
Steps for the Inference Strategy�
look for clues to answer the questions
look for more details
answer the questions
Types of Questions
Factual Question
Think and Seek Question
Factual Questions-
Require finding a fact in the information that you have read.
F
Example Factual Questions
Characteristics of Good Answers
FRAME Review --- Tie-up loose ends
Model – Tornado Watch��Lesson 2, Passage 1
RallyCoach for Guided Practice
Stages 2 & 3 Describe and Model
Lesson 3-Big Picture Questions
Pgs. 32-42
Lesson 3 Goals
Big Picture Questions-
B
Example Big Picture Questions
Key Words in Big Picture Questions
Main Idea
Questions to ask myself:
Key Words in Big Picture Questions
Purpose
3 Purposes for Writing
Key Words in Big Picture Questions
Summary
Key Words in Big Picture Questions
Message
Key Words in Big Picture Questions
Theme
Key Words in Big Picture Questions
Setting
“Ship-Trap Island,”
a “moonless,” “dank,” “warm” “Caribbean night,” with air like “moist black velvet”
Key Words in Big Picture Questions
Tone:
FRAME Review --- Tie-up loose ends
Model – Secret Messages��Lesson 3, Passage 1
Review
Think about what you now know about factual and big picture questions.
Factual questions often start with:
Big Picture questions often ask about:
The Safe Zone of Modeling
Stages 2 & 3 Describe and Model
Lesson 4- Predicting Questions
Pgs. 43-50
Lesson 4 Goals
What does it mean to predict?
make a guess or forecast about what will happen in the future
Predicting questions ask you to forecast what will happen next or in the future based on what you just read.
There is a correct prediction or a correct answer to the question.
Predicting Questions-
P
Example Predicting Questions
Key words in Predicting Questions:
Model – Packing Problem��Lesson 4, Passage 1
FRAME Review --- Tie-up loose ends
So what’s the importance of modeling?
Stages 2 & 3 Describe and Model
Lesson 5- Clarifying Questions
Pgs. 51-58
Lesson 5 Goals
Stages 2 & 3 Describe and Model
Partner A:
Be prepared to describe
Partner B:
Be prepared to model
Please take 12 minutes to read
Lesson 5, Clarifying Questions, pages 51-58
Lesson 5 Clarifying
10 minutes each
Materials needed for Partner A:
Cue Card handouts
Materials needed for Partners A and B:
Lesson 5, Passage 1 “Safety First”
FRAME Review --- Tie-up loose ends
Progress Chart for Stages �2 & 3
Lunchtime Options at FDLRS
Walkable options:
The Local
Ragazzi’s Pizza
Table service; ask for your check as soon as you get your food
Ollie’s Public House
Table service; be sure to let them know you’re on time schedule
Gabriel’s Sub Shop
Counter service
Cafe Linger
Order at counter
Dunkin Donuts, Domino’s, Papa John’s, Einsteins
Within a mile on Edgewater Drive
NORTH
Tornatore’s Cafe & Pizzeria
SOUTH
The Dog House
Eden’s Fresh Salads & Wraps
Blended Cafe
Tijuana Flats
Jersey Mike’s
Tropical Cafe
Publix
Infusion Tea
FRAME Review --- Tie-up loose ends
Extend your understanding:
Which question type do you anticipate being the most difficult for your students to master? How can you pre-correct to reduce or remove this barrier?
So what? is so important about kids learning to read the questions first and looking for key words to determine the type of question?
From what you have seen so far,
reflect on these Unit Questions:
Performance Scale
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
I can identify students who struggle with answering inferential questions and need a strategy to help them with this skill. | I can list and explain the 4 different types of questions used to assess understanding of text. | I can analyze student work for question type, supporting text evidence, and the correct answers to determine student mastery and provide feedback. | I can explain how the Inference Strategy is taught, differentiating between “stages” and “lessons” and have adequate knowledge to begin teaching the strategy to my students. | I have collected and reported student outcome data that shows I can implement the Inference Strategy with fidelity to improve student performance. |
How the Strategy is Taught
Part II: Teach students to use the INFER Steps to answer questions
Stage 4: Verbal Practice BIG TAB page 59
Instructor’s Manual
small tabs
Inference Strategy Verbal Practice Quiz, page 121
Inference Strategy Verbal Practice Checklist, page 122
Stage 4: Verbal Practice Activities
Practice so that students reach mastery of 100% on the written or verbal quiz.
Interact with the questions and the passage
Note what you know
Find the clues
look for clues to answer the questions
Explore any supporting details
look for more details
Return to the question
answer the question
Steps for the Inference Strategy�
Appendix A – Evaluation Guidelines pages 87-90
Scoring 3 things-
Score
small tab page 38
Passages* for Stages 5 and 6
How the Strategy is Taught
Student Materials Book
Part II: Teach students to use the INFER Steps to answer questions
Stage 5: Controlled Practice & Feedback BIG TAB page 66
Stage 6: Advanced Practice & Feedback BIG TAB page 73
Instructor’s Manual
*Passages are LEVELED from a 4th grade level to a 10th grade level
Stage 5-Controlled Practice and Feedback
Stage 6- Advanced Practice and Feedback
Progress Chart for Stages �5 & 6
How the Strategy is Taught
Student Materials Book
Part III: Determining the student’s Progress
Stage 7: Post test BIG TAB page 77
Instructor’s Manual
Goals of the Post test
Stage 7: Posttest
Passage of about 400 words at the student’s grade level with 5-6 corresponding inferential questions
If score is < 80% do additional Advanced Practice activities
If score is > 80% proceed to Stage 8: Generalization
Progress Chart for Stages �5 & 6
How the Strategy is Taught
Part IV: Ensuring Students Use the Strategy
Stage 8: Generalization BIG TAB page 80
Instructor’s Manual
Stage 8: Generalization
�
Discuss and prepare for application of the strategy in natural settings.
Goals:
We’ll model
Virtues of Venom
Use response cards
Elaborate on the significance of applying the steps of INFER to more complex text or high stakes test practices.
How will you encourage generalization of this strategy with your students?
Fidelity & Master Teaching
Respond to the Unit Question:
Respond to the Unit Question:
4. What is your plan for implementing The Inference Strategy?
FID Timeline for Implementation
Access the FID
Post Organizer
Performance Scale
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
I can identify students who struggle with answering inferential questions and need a strategy to help them with this skill. | I can list and explain the 4 different types of questions used to assess understanding of text. | I can analyze student work for question type, supporting text evidence, and the correct answers to determine student mastery and provide feedback. | I can explain how the Inference Strategy is taught, differentiating between “stages” and “lessons” and have adequate knowledge to begin teaching the strategy to my students. | I have collected and reported student outcome data that shows I can implement the Inference Strategy with fidelity to improve student performance. |
Support
Let’s wrap it up
Overview of How the Inference Strategy is Taught
Part 1: Determining Student’s Skills
Stage 1: Pretest
Part II: Teaching Students to Use the
INFER Steps to Answer Questions
Stages 2 and 3: Describe and Model
Lesson 1: Introduction to the Inference Strategy
Lesson 2: Factual Questions
Lesson 3: Big Picture Questions
Lesson 4: Predicting Questions
Lesson 5: Clarifying Questions
Stage 4: Verbal Practice
Stage 5: Controlled Practice and Feedback
Stage 6: Advanced Practice and Feedback
Part III: Determining Student’s Progress
Stage 7: Posttest
Part IV: Ensuring Students Use the Strategy
Stage 8: Generalization
Student Materials Book
Passages 1-4, pages 4-11
Passages 1-4, pages 12-19
Passages 1-4, pages 20-27
Passages 1-4, pages 28-35
Levels 4-10, pages 38-93
Levels 4-10, pages 38-93
NAME
DATE
The Unit Organizer
NEW
UNIT
SELF-TEST
QUESTIONS
Expanded Unit Map
is about...
9
10
helping students learn how to make inferences from text and answer questions accurately
The Inference Strategy
By determining the level of skill through a
pretest
by providing
by
ensuring
by teaching students to
opportunities to practice with feedback
by determining
level of mastery with the INFER steps
the generalization process occurs by using a variety of texts and in various contexts
use the INFER steps with 80 % mastery
to measure
Skills of
answering Inferential questions
identify question types
80 % is mastery
and
in which
to
answer
think and seek questions
factual questions
clarifying
big picture
predicting
through
such as
that is
verbal practice
scaffolded lessons
and
TRAINER COPY
NAME
DATE
The Unit Organizer
NEW
UNIT
SELF-TEST
QUESTIONS
Expanded Unit Map
is about...
9
10
helping students learn how to make inferences from text and answer questions accurately
The Inference Strategy
By determining the level of skill through a
pretest
to measure
Skills of
answering Inferential questions
identify question types
80 % is mastery
and
in which
NAME
DATE
The Unit Organizer
NEW
UNIT
SELF-TEST
QUESTIONS
Expanded Unit Map
is about...
9
10
helping students learn how to make inferences from text and answer questions accurately
The Inference Strategy
by providing
by teaching students to
opportunities to practice with feedback
use the INFER steps with 80 % mastery
to
answer
think and seek questions
factual questions
clarifying
big picture
predicting
such as
that is
Corrective, positive, individual and timely
1. Why is the describe and model stages of each lesson necessary for student learning?
2. Explain the connection of formative assessment to practice and feedback.
NAME
DATE
The Unit Organizer
NEW
UNIT
SELF-TEST
QUESTIONS
Expanded Unit Map
is about...
9
10
helping students learn how to make inferences from text and answer questions accurately
The Inference Strategy
by
ensuring
by determining
level of mastery with the INFER steps
the generalization process occurs by using a variety of texts and in various contexts
through
scaffolded lessons
and
1. Why is it critical for students to know the steps of the strategy with fluency?
2. Elaborate on the significance of applying the steps of INFER to more complex text or high stakes test practices?
verbal practice