1 of 46

Leading with Care: Prioritizing the �Health and Wellness of Music Educators

Dr. Danni Gilbert, The University of Minnesota

National Association for Music Education, Music Program Leaders Forum

January 24, 2024

2 of 46

Health and Wellness

3 of 46

Agenda

  • What’s the matter with teachers?
  • Why does this matter?
  • What can we do?
  • How can we also prioritize our own wellness as leaders?

4 of 46

5 of 46

What’s the matter with teachers?

  1. Compensation
  2. Safety

6 of 46

1. Compensation

  • Salary and benefits
  • Classroom resources
  • Human needs and dignity
  • Professional respect, feeling valued

7 of 46

Amy Poehler

“Punch fear in the face.”

8 of 46

Woodrow Wilson

“I not only use all the brains I have, but all the brains that I can borrow.”

9 of 46

Partner Discussion #1

  • How have concerns about compensation affected music educators in your setting?
    • Salary and benefits
    • Classroom resources
    • Human needs and dignity
    • Professional respect, feeling valued
  • What are some ideas for helping your teachers feel valued (treating your teachers like pro-athletes)?

10 of 46

2. Safety

  • Students
  • Staff
  • Parents
  • Community

11 of 46

Partner Discussion #2

  • How have concerns about safety affected music educators in your setting?
    • Students
    • Staff
    • Parents
    • Community
  • What are some ideas for helping your teachers feel safe on the job?

12 of 46

Why does this matter?

  1. Stress
  2. Distress
  3. Burnout

13 of 46

1. Stress

  • Physical symptoms

  • Psychological symptoms such as anxiety and depression

  • Reduced performance and productivity

14 of 46

2. Distress

  • Perception that situation is threatening, harmful, or a risk to wellbeing

  • Causes tension, nervousness, fatigue

15 of 46

3. Burnout

  • Outcome of prolonged or excessive stress

  • Emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, reduced personal accomplishment

16 of 46

3. Burnout

Symptoms =

    • Physical
    • Emotional
    • Behavioral

17 of 46

More pronounced for music teachers?

  • Music educators may experience greater symptoms of anxiety and depression than educators in other disciplines (Payne et al., 2020).

  • Lack of professional development in recognizing signs of stress and coping strategies for challenging situations (Gustems-Carnicer & Calderon, 2013).

18 of 46

More pronounced for music teachers?

19 of 46

Partner Discussion #3

  • How have concerns about stress, distress, and burnout affected music educators in your setting?

  • What are some ideas for helping your teachers reduce stressors?

20 of 46

What can we do?

  1. Know the job
  2. Create a safe space where teachers can ask for help
  3. Listen, recognize, and act proactively
  4. Advocate for policy based on what is applicable, practical
  5. Help ease burdens rather than add to them
    • Promote meaningful human connections
    • Encourage rest as part of the work
    • Develop and follow “SMART” self-care plans

21 of 46

1. Know the Job

  • Walk in their shoes?
  • Consider adjustments?
  • Schedule and logistics
  • Sufficient time to be human

22 of 46

Cultivate The Disney Experience

23 of 46

Transformation

  • What is your destination? Your end goal?
  • What is the current state of reality in your setting?
  • How can you use backwards planning to map out a path from the finish line to the starting line?
  • Positioning = advertising, selling your “product”
  • Reframing = providing a new context to break down negative associations

24 of 46

25 of 46

26 of 46

2. Create a safe space

Culture of the school district--be the administrator who helps teachers feel safe to ask for what they need.

27 of 46

Charles Schwab

“I have yet to find a man, however exalted his station, who did not do better work and put forth greater effort under a spirit of approval than under a spirit of criticism.”

28 of 46

3. Listen, recognize, and act proactively

29 of 46

4. Be an advocate

  • Look at comparable districts for salary and pay
  • Address teacher concerns regularly with school board, policy makers, PTA, local and state officials
  • Be informed so you can best inform

30 of 46

5. Ease burdens when possible

    • Promote meaningful human connections
    • Encourage rest as part of the work
    • Develop and follow “SMART” self-care plans

31 of 46

Meaningful human connections

  • Social support can mitigate symptoms of burnout

  • PLCs/PLNs where positive social interactions among colleagues are the goal

  • Mentoring partnerships

  • Inclusive work environments

32 of 46

Rest is part of the work

  • Non-negotiable plan periods

  • Time for bathroom breaks and rest built into school day

  • Adequate lunch breaks

  • Encourage sufficient personal time and sleep

33 of 46

Rest during work—�Code of Federal Regulations

  • 5–20-minute breaks improve efficiency
  • Breaks for meal periods are not worktime—they are rest periods. The employee must be completely relieved from duty for the purposes of eating regular meals.

34 of 46

“SMART” Self-Care Plans

  • S = specific

  • M = measurable

  • A = achievable

  • R = realistic

  • T = time-bound

35 of 46

Partner Discussion #4

What are some strategies you have used to:

  1. Know the job
  2. Create a safe space where teachers can ask for help
  3. Listen, recognize, and act proactively
  4. Advocate for policy based on what is applicable, practical
  5. Help ease burdens rather than add to them

36 of 46

How can we also prioritize our own wellness as leaders?�

  • Passion
  • Immersion
  • Enthusiasm

37 of 46

PASSION

  • We are not always passionate about teaching all the time…and that’s ok!
  • How can we intentionally find passion to bring to teaching role every day?
    • Content Passion (teaching music)
    • Professional Passion (What do you want to DO?)
      • Purpose
    • Personal Passion (What drives you as a PERSON?)

38 of 46

39 of 46

IMMERSION

= the ability to completely give yourself up to the moment and fully “be” engaged

40 of 46

41 of 46

ENTHUSIASM

  • Make a commitment to being “on”…while balancing adequate time for rest!
  • Deal with circumstances as you find them—don’t let factors outside your control affect your effort and enthusiasm.
  • How to light your fire:

1. “Act as if…” or shift your perspective to moving toward a positive outcome.

2. Change your focus to what empowers you.

3. Cultivate an attitude of gratitude.

4. Practice self-care.

42 of 46

43 of 46

CARLOS SANTANA

“There is nothing more contagious on this planet than enthusiasm. The songs become incidental. What people receive is your joy.”

44 of 46

Partner Discussion #5

  • What are examples of your:
    • Content passion (job assignment)
    • Professional passion (your purpose, your WHY)
    • Personal passion (what drives you as a human)
  • What are some ways that you can be fully immersed while removing distractions and worry?
  • Give some examples of times when you lost your enthusiasm. How did you overcome and refocus?

45 of 46

Thank you!

Dr. Danni Gilbert

Assistant Professor of

Instrumental Music Education

University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

gilbertd@umn.edu

46 of 46