RISK�MANAGEMENT�PROCESS
WEEK 2
From Identification to Risk Response
Assessment • Measurement • Control • Reporting • Response
Ronald Rulindo, PhD • Nur Dhani, PhD
WEEK 2
Week 2 Learning Journey
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
02
01
IDENTIFY
What can happen?
→
02
ASSESS
How likely and severe?
→
03
CONTROL
How do we prevent or reduce it?
→
04
REPORT
How do we communicate and evaluate?
→
05
RESPOND
What should management do?
01
Risk Identification
Start with objectives, then systematically identify challenges and unexpected events.
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
03
SECTION 1
Risk Identification: Start With the Objective
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
04
Define the target first. Risk only has meaning in relation to an objective.
Identify challenges that may prevent the objective from being achieved.
List unexpected events from rare to frequent.
Scan market, legal, social, political and environmental influences.
Use the risk framework: source → factor → event → exposure / impact.
02
Risk Assessment & Measurement
Evaluate the possibility and impact of unexpected events that may prevent objectives from being achieved.
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
05
SECTION 2
Risk Assessment Is a Systematic Process
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
06
Risk assessment identifies and evaluates the possibility of unexpected events that could prevent achievement of objectives.
EARLY STAGE
More generalist and qualitative when data are limited.
MATURING
Data accumulate and assessment becomes more structured.
ADVANCED
More quantitative analysis supported by data and information systems.
Good assessment depends on sufficient data and adequate information systems.
SECTION 2
Qualitative vs Quantitative Assessment
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
07
QUALITATIVE
Categorizes or ranks potential risks using nominal or ordinal scales. Useful when data are limited, but external validation is important to reduce management bias.
QUANTITATIVE
Uses benchmarking, probabilistic and non-probabilistic models as internal and external loss-event data become available. Supports indicators, trend analysis and faster response.
The methods are complementary — not mutually exclusive.
SECTION 2
Risk Assessment Can Be Applied Across the Organization
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
08
Strategic
Operational
Compliance
Internal Audit
Financial Statement
Fraud
Market
Credit
Customer
Supply Chain
Product
Security
IT
Project
The assessment lens changes with the objective, owner and type of exposure.
SECTION 2
Who Typically Owns Which Assessment?
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
09
Strategic
Senior management
Mission and strategic objectives
Operational
Business + independent risk function
People, process, systems, external events
Compliance
Compliance function
Laws, regulations, policies, ethics and contracts
Market
Market risk specialists
Rates, currency, options and commodities
Credit
Credit risk specialists
Borrower / counterparty ability to meet obligations
IT / Security
IT risk and information security
Systems, access, data protection and cyber risk
SECTION 2
Techniques for Risk Assessment
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
10
Brainstorming
Checklist
Scenario Analysis
Business Impact Analysis
Cost / Benefit Analysis
Root Cause Analysis
Cause & Consequence
Probability Matrix
Bow Tie Analysis
Fault Tree Analysis
Choose the technique based on the decision you need to make — not because the tool looks sophisticated.
SECTION 2
Root Cause Analysis: Look Behind the Risk Event
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
11
RISK EVENT
Source 1
Source 2
Source 3
Source 4
Source 5
Factor A
Factor B
Factor C
Factor D
Factor E
Factor F
The visible event is usually the end of a chain of sources and contributing factors.
SECTION 2
Root Cause Example: Land Acquisition Delayed
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
12
PENGADAAN LAHAN TERHAMBAT
Regulation
Bureaucratic process�Land law constraints
Court Process
Slow execution letter�High legal cost
Local Govt.
Political factors�Coordination issues
Land Owner / Broker
Price too high�Long process
Land Officer
Limited tools�Low communication / training
Root cause analysis helps management intervene before the risk event repeats.
SECTION 2
Qualitative Risk Measurement: Risk Matrix
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
13
Impact ↑
Likelihood →
LIKELIHOOD
How likely is the event?
IMPACT
How severe is the consequence?
Risk priority emerges from the combination of likelihood and impact.
SECTION 2
Likelihood Criteria — 5-Level Scale
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
14
1
Sangat Rendah
Never / very rarely known to occur
2
Rendah
Rare; may occur randomly or within a longer interval
3
Sedang
Moderate possibility; could recur
4
Tinggi
High probability; known to occur frequently
5
Sangat Tinggi
Very high / near certain; daily or within less than one month
SECTION 2
Impact Criteria — 5-Level Scale
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
15
1
Sangat Rendah
Very low effect on strategy, operations and stakeholders
2
Rendah
Low effect on strategy, operations and stakeholders
3
Sedang
Moderate effect on strategy, operations and stakeholders
4
Tinggi
High effect on strategy, operations and stakeholders
5
Sangat Tinggi
Very high effect on strategy, operations and stakeholders
SECTION 2
Quantitative Risk Measurement
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
16
Distribution Analysis
Frequency
Standard / Semi-Standard Deviation
Probability of Occurrence
Value at Risk
Volatility / Beta
Coefficient of Variation
RAROC
Credit Rating
Gap Analysis
Stress Testing
As data quality improves, risk measurement can become more granular and decision-oriented.
SECTION 2
Match the Measurement Technique to the Risk
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
17
Credit
Credit rating, CreditMetrics
Market
Value at Risk, stress testing
Equity Investment
Scenario analysis, credit rating
Rate of Return
Gap analysis, duration analysis
Operational
Frequency, loss severity, VaR
Strategic / Technology
Scenario analysis
Shariah Non-Compliance
Frequency, regression, scenario analysis
Fiduciary
Frequency analysis
03
Risk Prevention & Mitigation
Controls can reduce the probability of a risk event or reduce its impact after it occurs.
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
18
SECTION 3
Brake vs Seat Belt: Prevention vs Mitigation
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
19
BRAKE
SEAT�BELT
RISK PREVENTION
Reduce the probability that the unwanted event occurs.
RISK MITIGATION
Reduce the damage if the event does occur.
Good control systems usually need both.
SECTION 3
Where Controls Act in the Risk Chain
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
20
SOURCE / FACTORS
RISK EVENT
IMPACT
PREVENTION CONTROLS
Act on causes and factors to lower likelihood.
MITIGATION CONTROLS
Act on consequences to reduce severity.
SECTION 3
Existing Control Effectiveness
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
21
1
Not Available
Control does not exist
2
Not Effective
Available but inadequate / barely functioning
3
Less Effective
Does not function according to design
4
Partly Effective
Functions as designed with reasonably satisfactory results
5
Effective
Functions as designed with optimal results
04
Risk Reporting & Evaluation
Turn risk information into prioritization, decisions and corrective action.
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
22
SECTION 4
Risk Reporting: From Identification to Evaluation
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
23
IDENTIFICATION
Risk event • type • frequency • severity • cause • impact
→
ANALYSIS
Control applied • likelihood • impact • control effectiveness • inherent risk
→
EVALUATION
Risk priority • opportunity / reward • risk acceptance
Reporting is useful only when it leads to a decision or corrective action.
05
Risk Response Strategies
Select a response based on risk level, reward and the organization's risk appetite.
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
24
SECTION 5
Risk Response Matrix
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
25
Impact ↑
Likelihood →
ACCEPT
REDUCE / SHARE
AVOID
ACCEPT
Low likelihood and low impact.
REDUCE / SHARE
Middle-zone risks requiring controls or transfer.
AVOID
High likelihood and high impact.
SECTION 5
Risk Appetite: Avoid the Two Extremes
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
26
RASH — RISK LOVING
Opportunity: lack of planning.�Hazard: inadequate precautions.�Result: harm and loss.
RISK NEUTRAL
Proper risk assessment and management.�Result: risks controlled and success maximized.
TIMID — RISK AVERSE
Opportunity: failure to innovate.�Hazard: excessive caution.�Result: inactivity and lost opportunities.
Risk appetite is not about eliminating risk. It is about taking the right risk for the right reward.
SECTION 5
Risk–Reward Positioning
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
27
CAUTIOUS
VIGOROUS
TIMID
RASH
HIGH REWARD
LOW REWARD
LOW RISK
HIGH RISK
SECTION 5
Risk–Reward Changes Across the Business Life Cycle
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
28
STARTUP
High risk�Low reward
GROWING
High risk�High reward
MATURE
Low risk�High reward
DECLINING
Low risk�Low reward
The appropriate risk posture changes as the organization evolves.
PRACTICE
Exercise: Root Cause Analysis of a Shariah Incident
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
29
DAGING BABI JATUH / TERKONTAMINASI
Employee
Training is rare
Vehicle Condition
Security checks are rare
Road Condition
Damaged road
Route Choice
Poor route selection
Schedule
Too tight
Discuss: which controls are preventive, which are mitigative, and what residual risk remains?
WRAP-UP
Week 2 Key Takeaways
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
30
1.
Risk identification starts from objectives and a clear risk framework.
2.
Risk assessment evolves from qualitative to more quantitative as data mature.
3.
Likelihood and impact provide a practical basis for prioritization.
4.
Prevention reduces probability; mitigation reduces consequences.
5.
Control effectiveness determines how much risk remains.
6.
Risk response should balance risk, reward and risk appetite.
WEEK 2 COMPLETE
Good risk management turns uncertainty into structured decisions.
IDENTIFY → ASSESS → CONTROL → REPORT → RESPOND
Ronald Rulindo, PhD • Nur Dhani, PhD
MANAJEMEN RISIKO PERBANKAN ISLAM
31