Why does school cost so much?
Smart shoppers compare costs.
Tim Shores · Leverett's representative on the Amherst-Pelham Regional School Committee
This presentation does not represent committee views or decisions. All errors are mine and mine alone.
1.4×
Leverett's income per capita, against Western MA's
Mass. Department of Revenue
1.6×
Leverett's property value per capita, against Western MA's
Mass. Department of Revenue
155%
Leverett's average tax bill, against inflation since 1992
Four Towns Fiscal Study Group
1%
FY28 limit on Lev budgets. After inflation:
Reduction of about −2%
Leverett Finance Committee guidance
Leverett Elementary: most of our budget growth per pupil is due to inflation and enrollment decline
2
Enrollment trend
+81%
Nominal dollars
+12%
Inflation-adjusted
−20%
Enrollment trend
Data: Massachusetts DESE, FY2005–FY2025, after inflation by the Northeast CPI · timshores.com/muni-spending
Amherst-Pelham Regional: more growth, greater decline
3
Enrollment trend
+128%
Nominal dollars
+41%
Inflation-adjusted
−39%
Enrollment trend
Data: Massachusetts DESE, FY2005–FY2025, after inflation by the Northeast CPI · timshores.com/muni-spending
Comparisons with districts & groups of similar size
4
Growth in spending per pupil after inflation, FY2005–FY2025
Data: Massachusetts DESE, FY2005–FY2025, after inflation by the Northeast CPI · timshores.com/muni-spending
5
1.8%
Western
1.8%
Central
1.9%
Northeast
1.6%
Metro West
1.6%
Boston area
1.9%
Southeast
Spending per pupil: yearly growth after inflation
Total, FY2005–FY2025
Change in students per district
+42%
+43%
+38%
+45%
+37%
+47%
Data: Massachusetts DESE, FY2005–FY2025, after inflation by the Northeast CPI · timshores.com/muni-spending
State aid can mitigate the risk of school cost growth …
Some groups have fallen behind
6
Gateway cities
Massachusetts
Rural schools
Leverett
Data: Massachusetts DESE, FY2005–FY2025, after inflation by the Northeast CPI · timshores.com/muni-spending
Chapter 70 assumes Leverett revenue grows ~3.9% a year
7
The municipal revenue growth factor: the state's yearly estimate of how fast a town's own revenue grows.
The more a town grows, the more Chapter 70 expects us to pay for schools.
Data: Massachusetts DESE, Chapter 70 formula, FY2007–FY2027 · timshores.com/muni-spending
In our four towns, growth is just housing
8
Residential share of the levy
88% Amherst
88% Leverett
93% Pelham
94% Shutesbury
30%
of Amherst's real property value is tax exempt
Data: Four Towns Fiscal Study Group, Report to the Community, October 2026, from the Mass. Division of Local Services, FY2025
Six systems-level leverage points?
9
State level
The 82.5% cap in Ch. 70 target local contribution
The wealthiest 100 towns receive $1.4B in effective aid — that could be redistributed to the 250 other towns
Rebalance state aid
Rural aid in full; Ch. 70 aid for fixed costs, less focus on head counts
S.394 · H.517 / S.314, the rural schools bill
Charter schools
Reimburse the towns that send students
HD.4439
Local level
Capital improvements that cut operating costs
A district and school budget strategy:
Invest once to spend less every year
School committees and towns
The ARPS regional agreement
Amend it to right-size and reshape the regional school district in a way that makes sense for our four towns
Regional School Committee design and approval, then a vote in each of the four towns, then approval by the state Commissioner
Tax base diversity: Commercial, industrial, and affordable housing
Plan zoning changes and water and sewer infrastructure that create opportunities for smart growth
Planning boards, selectboards and town meetings
Data: Massachusetts DESE, FY2005–FY2025, after inflation by the Northeast CPI · timshores.com/muni-spending
People working to push those leverage points
10
Our school admins and committee members
Budgeting, line by line, in search of cost efficiencies year in and year out
Leverett Education Foundation
Knowledge-sharing (like today)
Charitable giving provides for students when taxes fail
Rural Schools MA
ruralschoolsma.org
MASS Promise to Invest
The 82.5% cap campaign
masspromise2invest.org
Four Towns Fiscal Study Group
“The walls are closing in … we believe the first step is to clearly understand the challenges we face”
Our legislators
Sen. Jo Comerford · Rep. Mindy Domb
Rep.-elect Lora Wondolowski
Data: Massachusetts DESE, FY2005–FY2025, after inflation by the Northeast CPI · timshores.com/muni-spending
Smart towns compare costs.
Explore comparisons for yourself:
timshores.com/muni-spending