The Historical Origins and Contemporary Consequences of Trump’s Worldview
Michael McFaul
July 29, 2019
2
Foreign Policy Debates Are Not Between Parties But Within Parties
T
Realism vs. Liberalism
Isolation vs Internationalism
Divides
4
Isolationists
Avoid “entangling” alliances
Drag us into conflicts (Libya 2011)
NATO not pulling its weight
Free trade not fair
NAFTA, TPP, WTO
Intervention rarely works
Need to regime change at home
International institutions constrain American power
United Nations
5
Internationalists
Alliances enhance U.S. security
In Europe and Asia
Allies share burden of security
Free trade benefits U.S. economy
NAFTA, WTO, TPP
Intervention necessary part of U.S. leadership
International institutions enhance American power
United Nations, World Bank, IMF
6
Retrenchment Presidents vs. Expansionist Presidents
Democrats
Republicans
Retrenchment
Presidents
Expansionist
Presidents
Democrats
Republicans
Isolationists
Internationalists
9
Realism vs. Liberalism
Debate started at the beginning of our country
10
Liberalism (“Neocons”)
Realism
Democrats
Republicans
Realists
Liberals
Democrats
Republicans
Realists
Liberals
Trump’s World View
14
Domestic Constraints on Trump
15
Divides within the Trump Admini-stration
Nationalists
Internationalists
16
United on Realism
17
International Constraints on Trump
Difficult to rip up NAFTA, violate WTO
Results So Far
Globally
3 Regions
Africa and Latin America barely on Trump’s radar - Blessing in disguise?
19
Radical Retreat
Retrenchment and Isolationist
Iran Nuclear Deal
01
TPP
02
Paris Climate Change accords
03
Threatening Allies
04
INF Treaty
05
New Start Treaty next?
06
20
Resignation as �Leader of the Free World
No Discussion of Values
Putin, Kim Jong Un, Sisi, Duterte, Mohamed bin Salman, Erdogan
Embrace of Autocrats
Moral Equivalency
Bombing of Assad,
Sanctioning Maduro
Minor Caveats
21
Israel and Russia
Decline in Positive View of U.S. in Every Country Except Two
France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Japan, South Korea, Spain, and Turkey
Citizens in 9 of America’s Allies trust Putin more than Trump
Merkel Now Leader of Free World? (but stepping down)
World Reaction
Trump Policy Impact Regionally
Impact
Regions
23
Middle East: Continuity
24
Middle East �Positive Changes under Trump
Military Attack on Assad
But one off
Strengthening Ties with Arab Partners
Double-Edged Sword
Increasing tensions in the region
Autocracies not stable
Acknowledging Iranian Expansionism & Missile Program
But strategy to contain? So far, few results
25
Middle East �Negative Changes under Trump
Withdrawing from Iran Deal
Syria
Strengthening Autocrats
Afghanistan Withdrawal Next?
26
Europe/Russia: Continuities
Has Not Abandoned NATO
Has Maintained Support for Ukraine
Has not recognized Crimea as part of Russia
Maintained sanctions
Congress has tied Trump’s hands
27
Europe/Russia: �Positives under Trump
Closed down Russian Consulates in San Francisco and Seattle
Provided lethal assistance to Ukraine
28
Europe/Russia �Negatives under Trump
29
Asia: Continuities
No War with China
“Pivot” Proceeding
Alliances (So Far) In Tact
30
Asia: Positives under Trump
31
Asia: Negatives under Trump
Trade war with China
China filling void left by American retreat
No results (yet) from engagement with North Korea
ASEAN neglect
32
Realism and Retrenchment
Here to Stay?
33
The Good News
For America & the World
U.S. is Not a Dictatorship
Democratic Institutions Allow for Renewal and Change
Churchill: Americans Will Always Do the Right Thing — After Exhausting All the Alternatives
Structural Conditions for American Leadership in the World Still Exist
Economy * Military * Alliances * Ideals
Top 10 Countries With the Largest GDP
Source: Statista, https://www.statista.com/statistics/268173/countries-with-the-largest-gross-domestic-product-gdp/a
35
Source: IMF - World Economic Outlook (WEO) Database, April 2019
Top Countries Ranked by GDP per capita (US dollars)
Top 10 Most Valued Companies in the World
Source: https://www.statista.com/statistics/263264/top-companies-in-the-world-by-market-value/, The 100 largest companies in the world by market value in 2017 (in million U.S. dollars)
FSI.STANFORD.EDU I 38
39
Source: The Rise of Robots in China by Hong Cheng, Ruixue Jia, Dandan Li, and Hongbin Li - Journal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 33, Number 2—Spring 2019—Pages 71–88
The Rise of Robots in China
Research & Development
Top 10 Countries with the Largest Military Spending
Source: USA Today, Countries spending the most on the military, https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2014/07/12/countries-spending-most-on-military/12491639/
42
43
U.S.-China Nuclear Reactors in 2014
Number of Allies
World Top 50 Universities
Support for Democracy Around the World
48
Cycles of American Renewal
Not the First Time Its Seemed Like US Was in Decline
49
Inter-War Period, 1930s
Political Regime Map 1930
Communist Rise, 1950s
Soviet Union Rise, 1970s
53
JAPANESE RISE, 1980s
“It is a matter of urgent national interest for Americans to confront Japanese successes.”
Ezra Vogel Japan As Number One (1980)
54
Predictions of Permanent American Decline, Retrenchment & Isolation Premature
Don’t Bet Against America Just Yet !
55
A Strong, Engaged America
Committed to Strengthening Liberal World Order
Can Be Good for All
Let’s Keep Talking
@McFaul
www.michaelmcfaul.com