1 of 56

The Historical Origins and Contemporary Consequences of Trump’s Worldview

​

Michael McFaul

July 29, 2019

2 of 56

2

Foreign Policy Debates Are Not Between Parties But Within Parties

  • No such thing as a “Republican” foreign policy
  • No such thing as a “Democratic” foreign policy

3 of 56

T

Realism vs. Liberalism

Isolation vs Internationalism

​

Divides

4 of 56

4

Isolationists

Avoid “entangling” alliances

Drag us into conflicts (Libya 2011)

NATO not pulling its weight

​

Free trade not fair

NAFTA, TPP, WTO

​

Intervention rarely works

Need to regime change at home

​

International institutions constrain American power

United Nations

5 of 56

5

Internationalists

Alliances enhance U.S. security

In Europe and Asia

Allies share burden of security

​

Free trade benefits U.S. economy

NAFTA, WTO, TPP

​

Intervention necessary part of U.S. leadership

​

International institutions enhance American power

United Nations, World Bank, IMF

6 of 56

6

Retrenchment Presidents vs. Expansionist Presidents

7 of 56

Democrats

Republicans

Retrenchment

Presidents

Expansionist

Presidents

8 of 56

Democrats

Republicans

Isolationists

Internationalists

9 of 56

9

Realism vs. Liberalism

  • How to respond to the French Revolution? Support ally?
  • Support those embracing our values?
  • Debate mostly abstract until U.S. had global power
  • Became more prominent after the end of the Cold War

Debate started at the beginning of our country

10 of 56

10

Liberalism (“Neocons”)

  • Anarchy can be reduced through cooperation / international institutions
  • States & non-governmental actors in international system
  • Regime type matters
  • Democracies do not fight each other
  • Win-Win outcomes
  • Anti-status-quo
  • Think of world as it should be

Realism

  • Anarchy
  • States are actors in international system
  • Regime type does not matter
  • Balance of Power drives international politics
  • Zero sum
  • U.S. should preserve status quo
  • Accept world as is

11 of 56

Democrats

Republicans

Realists

Liberals

12 of 56

Democrats

Republicans

Realists

Liberals

13 of 56

Trump’s World View

  • Isolationist
  • Realist
  • Nationalist
  • Extreme (rhetorically) on All Fronts

14 of 56

14

Domestic Constraints on Trump

  • Divides within the Trump Administration
  • Divides within the Republican Party
  • Professional Bureaucracy
  • Congress
                  • Investigations
  • Independent Media
  • Civil Society

15 of 56

15

Divides within the Trump Admini-stration

  • Divide between Judeo-Christians & rest
  • Islam is the enemy
  • China is an enemy
  • America First
  • Trade wars OK
  • Destroy S.Q.

Nationalists

  • No racial / ethnic divides between Judeo-Christians and rest
  • Need Muslims to defeat ISIS
  • China’s rise can be managed
  • Must preserve American leadership
  • Trade wars must be avoided
  • Preserve S.Q.

Internationalists

16 of 56

16

United on Realism

  • Hobbesian World
  • Only Power Matters
  • International Institutions Don’t Help
  • No democracy promotion
  • Support for Autocrats
  • Cutting USAID budgets
  • Radical Departure from Reagan & George W Bush

17 of 56

17

International Constraints on Trump

  • Other Big Powers in System�China gets a vote�Russia may not want to join a “Holy Alliance”

​

  • Allies

​

  • International Institutions / Norms

Difficult to rip up NAFTA, violate WTO

18 of 56

Results So Far

Globally

3 Regions

  • Middle East
  • Europe/Russia
  • Asia

Africa and Latin America barely on Trump’s radar - Blessing in disguise?

19 of 56

19

Radical Retreat

Retrenchment and Isolationist

Iran Nuclear Deal

01

TPP

02

Paris Climate Change accords

03

Threatening Allies

04

INF Treaty

05

New Start Treaty next?

06

20 of 56

20

Resignation as �Leader of the Free World

No Discussion of Values

Putin, Kim Jong Un, Sisi, Duterte, Mohamed bin Salman, Erdogan

Embrace of Autocrats

Moral Equivalency

Bombing of Assad,

Sanctioning Maduro

Minor Caveats

21 of 56

21

Israel and Russia

Decline in Positive View of U.S. in Every Country Except Two

France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Japan, South Korea, Spain, and Turkey

Citizens in 9 of America’s Allies trust Putin more than Trump

Merkel Now Leader of Free World? (but stepping down)

World Reaction

22 of 56

Trump Policy Impact Regionally

Impact

    • Continuity
    • Positive Changes
    • Negative Changes
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • Asia

Regions

23 of 56

23

Middle East: Continuity

  • Operation Inherent Resolve�(Mosul & Raqqa have fallen)
  • War in Afghanistan (so far)
  • Support for Israel

24 of 56

24

Middle East �Positive Changes under Trump

Military Attack on Assad

But one off

​

Strengthening Ties with Arab Partners

Double-Edged Sword

Increasing tensions in the region

Autocracies not stable

​

Acknowledging Iranian Expansionism & Missile Program

But strategy to contain? So far, few results

25 of 56

25

Middle East �Negative Changes under Trump

Withdrawing from Iran Deal

  • Isolating U.S.
  • Could lead to restart of nuclear program
  • Uniting Iranians
  • Makes hard to achieve agreement with North Korea

Syria

  • De facto Supporting Assad & his coalition
  • Disengaging
  • To whom to hand the keys to Raqqa?

​

Strengthening Autocrats

  • Saudi Arabia, Egypt

Afghanistan Withdrawal Next?

26 of 56

26

Europe/Russia: Continuities

Has Not Abandoned NATO

Has Maintained Support for Ukraine

Has not recognized Crimea as part of Russia

Maintained sanctions

Congress has tied Trump’s hands

​

27 of 56

27

Europe/Russia: �Positives under Trump

Closed down Russian Consulates in San Francisco and Seattle

​

Provided lethal assistance to Ukraine

28 of 56

28

Europe/Russia �Negatives under Trump

  • Alliance Divided Politically
  • Ideological Encouragement of Populist Nationalists�Le Pen, Salvini, Farage, Orbán, Johnson, Putin
  • Losing Turkey
  • Reform Fatigue Regarding Ukraine
  • Helsinki Summit

29 of 56

29

Asia: Continuities

No War with China

“Pivot” Proceeding

Alliances (So Far) In Tact

​

30 of 56

30

Asia: Positives under Trump

  • Trump-Abe personal relationship?

​

  • Trump-Modi personal relationship?

​

  • Trump-Xi personal relationship?

​

  • Push for access to Chinese markets & to protect US intellectual property

​

  • The “Indo-Pacific” Region

31 of 56

31

Asia: Negatives under Trump

Trade war with China

​

China filling void left by American retreat

  • Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) in place of TPP
  • One Belt, One Road (BRI)
  • Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB)
  • Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO)
  • Xi the most powerful leader in the world?

​

No results (yet) from engagement with North Korea

​

ASEAN neglect

32 of 56

32

Realism and Retrenchment

Here to Stay?

33 of 56

33

The Good News

For America & the World

U.S. is Not a Dictatorship

  • Multiple actors shaping foreign policy
  • Trump: no deep ideological convictions
  • Continuity so far greater than change

​

Democratic Institutions Allow for Renewal and Change

Churchill: Americans Will Always Do the Right Thing — After Exhausting All the Alternatives

​

Structural Conditions for American Leadership in the World Still Exist

Economy * Military * Alliances * Ideals

34 of 56

Top 10 Countries With the Largest GDP

Source: Statista, https://www.statista.com/statistics/268173/countries-with-the-largest-gross-domestic-product-gdp/a

35 of 56

35

Source: IMF - World Economic Outlook (WEO) Database, April 2019

Top Countries Ranked by GDP per capita (US dollars)

36 of 56

37 of 56

Top 10 Most Valued Companies in the World

Source: https://www.statista.com/statistics/263264/top-companies-in-the-world-by-market-value/, The 100 largest companies in the world by market value in 2017 (in million U.S. dollars)

38 of 56

FSI.STANFORD.EDU I 38

39 of 56

39

Source: The Rise of Robots in China by Hong Cheng, Ruixue Jia, Dandan Li, and Hongbin Li - Journal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 33, Number 2—Spring 2019—Pages 71–88

​

The Rise of Robots in China

40 of 56

Research & Development

41 of 56

Top 10 Countries with the Largest Military Spending

Source: USA Today, Countries spending the most on the military, https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2014/07/12/countries-spending-most-on-military/12491639/

42 of 56

42

43 of 56

43

U.S.-China Nuclear Reactors in 2014

44 of 56

Number of Allies

45 of 56

World Top 50 Universities

46 of 56

Support for Democracy Around the World

47 of 56

48 of 56

48

Cycles of American Renewal

Not the First Time Its Seemed Like US Was in Decline

​

  • 1930s
  • 1950s
  • 1970s
  • 1980s

​

49 of 56

49

Inter-War Period, 1930s

  • Rise of Autocrats
  • Decline of Democracies
  • Strengthening of Illiberal Ideologies
  • Decline of American Economic Performance

50 of 56

Political Regime Map 1930

51 of 56

Communist Rise, 1950s

52 of 56

Soviet Union Rise, 1970s

53 of 56

53

JAPANESE RISE, 1980s

“It is a matter of urgent national interest for Americans to confront Japanese successes.”

​

Ezra Vogel Japan As Number One (1980)

54 of 56

54

Predictions of Permanent American Decline, Retrenchment & Isolation Premature

Don’t Bet Against America Just Yet !

55 of 56

55

A Strong, Engaged America

Committed to Strengthening Liberal World Order

Can Be Good for All

56 of 56

Let’s Keep Talking

​

@McFaul

​

www.michaelmcfaul.com