1 of 18

Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification Update

Scott Goodwin, Principal

March 30, 2023

pkfod.com

1

2 of 18

Scott Goodwin

  • Lead both technical and compliance-focused projects.

​

  • Work with the defense industrial base since 2015.

​

  • NIST SP 800-171 / CMMC gap analysis and implementation.

​

  • Mom & pop machine shops up to prime defense contractor implementation and audit support.

​

  • PKFOD is a candidate C3PAO.

Principal

Cybersecurity and Privacy Advisory

155 Federal Street

Suite 200�Boston, MA 02210�(781) 937 - 5722�sgoodwin@pkfod.com

pkfod.com

2

3 of 18

Agenda

  • Defining the Ecosystem
  • Brief History Lesson
  • Results of DIBCAC Compliance Survey
  • Certification Process Overview
  • Current State of CMMC Ecosystem

pkfod.com

3

4 of 18

Defining the Ecosystem

  • CUI: Controlled Unclassified Information
  • DFARS: Defense Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement
  • DIB: Defense Industrial Base
  • OSC: Organization Seeking Certification
  • CyberAB: Official accreditation body of the CMMC ecosystem
    • C3PAO: Certified Third-Party Assessment Organization
    • RP(O): Registered Practitioner (Organization)
    • CCP/A: Certified CMMC Professional / Assessor
  • DIBCAC: DIB Cybersecurity Assessment Center

​

​

pkfod.com

4

5 of 18

A Brief History Lesson

Image Credit: CyberSheath - https://cybersheath.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Timeline-Long-Road-to-the-CMMC.jpg

pkfod.com

5

6 of 18

A Brief History Lesson

Image Credit: ExoStar - https://www.exostar.com/solution/about-cmmc/

pkfod.com

6

7 of 18

DIBCAC Statistics

  • Top requirements “other than satisfied”
    1. 3.13.11 – FIPS validation
    2. 3.5.3 – Multifactor authentication
    3. 3.14.1 – Vulnerability management

​

  • Only 15% of organization’s undergoing a “High” confidence assessment reach 110 points out of the gate.
    • A high confidence assessment by DIBCAC is very similar to a CMMC assessment conducted by a C3PAO

​

  • Average initial entry in SPRS: 66 / 110

pkfod.com

7

8 of 18

DIBCAC Contractor Compliance Survey

  • DIBCAC conducted a “Medium Assessment Study”
    • Selected a sample of organizations who had submitted a “Basic” self-assessment score in SPRS.
    • Then, conducted a “Medium” assessment against that organization – SSP review.
    • “Contact an organization on a Monday, require their SSP by Friday”

​

  • In the lead up to this study, 156 organizations dropped their score by 100+ points
    • One company went from +110 (perfect) to -203 (worst possible)

​

  • Average Basic self-assessment score: 56
  • Average Medium DIBCAC assessment score: -57
    • Primary problem: lack of detail in the System Security Plan (i.e. the “how”)

​

​

That’s 100 points!

pkfod.com

8

9 of 18

Certification Process Overview

  • CMMC certification assessment process is defined by the “CAP” – CMMC Assessment Process document
    • Currently a “Pre-decisional draft” owned by the DoD’s CIO office

​

  • Objectives are to achieve accurate, consistent, verifiable results by C3PAO teams and minimize differences between C3PAOs.

​

  • To be used in conjunction with other official CMMC documents:
    • CMMC Model Overview
    • CMMC Assessment Guide
    • CMMC Scoping Guidance, etc.

Look at NIST SP 800-171A

pkfod.com

9

10 of 18

CAP Overview

  • Broken into four phases:
    • Phase 1: Plan and Prepare the Assessment
    • Phase 2: Conduct the Assessment
    • Phase 3: Report Assessment Results
    • Phase 4: Close-Out POA&Ms and Assessment

pkfod.com

10

11 of 18

CAP Phase 1 and 2

  • Phase 1: Plan and Prepare the Assessment
    • Roles and Responsibilities, Scoping, Lead Assessor

​

  • Phase 2: Conduct the Assessment
    • Requires certain milestone meetings
    • Specifics on evidence collection, interviews, testing
    • Guidance on establishing FedRAMP moderate equivalency for cloud platforms
    • Determining final met vs. not met results

​

pkfod.com

11

12 of 18

CAP Phase 2

  • Phase 2: Conduct the Assessment
    • Limited Deficiency Correction
      • The following are the only practices authorized for limited practice deficiency correction

​

pkfod.com

12

13 of 18

CAP Phase 2

  • Phase 2: Conduct the Assessment
    • Limited Deficiency Correction
      • The practices on the prior slide can only be eligible for the limited practice deficiency correction program if:
        • A practice was implemented, but missing minor updates, or
        • Consensus among the C3PAO team is that the practice in question does not change and/or limit the effectiveness of another practice scored as “met”

​

pkfod.com

13

14 of 18

CAP Phase 2

  • Phase 2: Conduct the Assessment
    • Limited Practice Deficiency Correction Program
      • If overall scoring after putting items on the LPDC results in >= 88/110 practices MET, certification is possible, but OSC must correct within 5 business days from final findings briefing
      • If overall scoring after putting items on the LPDC <88/110 practices met, CMMC Level 2 Certification is not achieved

pkfod.com

14

15 of 18

CAP Phase 2

  • Phase 2: Conduct the Assessment
    • POAMs
      • POAMs are allowed under certain circumstances for practices that are not fully or successfully implemented
      • OSCs leaving assessment with open POAMs can only achieve conditional certification
      • Only lowest scored items on DoDAM are eligible for the POAM
      • OSC must close POAMs within 180 days for conditional certification to convert to full certification

pkfod.com

15

16 of 18

CAP Phase 3 and 4

  • Phase 3: Report Recommended Assessment Results
    • Requirements/schedule of final presentations
    • Instructions for C3PAOs on organizing submission packages to eMASS
    • Instructions for C3PAOs on scheduling POAM close-outs, if any, within 180 days
  • Phase 4: Close-out POAMs and Assessment (if necessary)
    • Perform 180-day POAM review and confirm POAM items are now practices met
    • If POAM items remain open, OSC fails assessment and conditional status is revoked, OSC must reapply for certification

pkfod.com

16

17 of 18

Current State of CMMC Ecosystem

  • CMMC can only appear in contracts after “rule making” is complete
    • Best guess is sometime this fall

​

  • C3PAO’s are being assessed by DIBCAC

​

  • OSCs can volunteer to be assessed under the Joint Surveillance Program.
    • C3PAO assessment under the supervision of DIBCAC
    • Results in “High Confidence” DIBCAC score
    • Supposed to convert to three-year CMMC L2 certification

pkfod.com

17

18 of 18

Questions?

Scott Goodwin�Principal, Cybersecurity and Privacy Advisory�sgoodwin@pkfod.com | (781) 937-5722

Linkedin.com/in/scottcg

​

​

“PKF O’Connor Davies” is the brand name under which PKF O’Connor Davies LLP and PKF O’Connor Davies Advisory LLC, independently owned entities, provide professional services in an alternative practice structure in accordance with applicable professional standards. PKF O’Connor Davies LLP is a licensed CPA firm that provides attest services and PKF O’Connor Davies Advisory LLC and its subsidiary entities provide tax and advisory services. �PKF O’Connor Davies is a member of the PKF International Limited network of legally independent firms and does not accept any responsibility or liability for the actions or inactions on the part of any other individual member firm or firms..

pkfod.com

18