1 of 26

Sustainable Economies Law Center

2024 Project Gallery

Also see our 2023 Project Gallery here and our 2022 Project Gallery here

2 of 26

Overview of the Law Center

Since 2009, the Sustainable Economies Law Center has been a catalyzing force in creating more just and regenerative economies across the U.S. At the intersections of economic, racial, and climate justice, the Law Center supports and develops projects such as immigrant-owned cooperatives, community-controlled housing, Indigenous land trusts, and other enterprises that redistribute wealth, democratize governance, and provide long-term stewardship of vital resources. �

The Law Center is one of the few organizations focused on the legal needs of the solidarity economy and is widely considered to be a leader in developing new models and policies for cooperative and community-owned economies. We have partnered with over 100 local grassroots groups and a dozen national coalitions, offered donation-based legal advice to over 3,000 community leaders and organizations, and led more than a dozen policy advocacy campaigns that changed laws and removed barriers to cooperatives, urban agriculture, local food systems, and more.

3 of 26

Nourish an ecosystem

As you’ll see below, the Sustainable Economies Law Center is a rich ecosystem where dozens of diverse projects grow and flourish. Each project can stand alone and make an impact, but it is infinitely more powerful as part of an interconnected web of work, both within the Law Center and embedded in broader collaborations, coalitions, and movements.

We’ve arrived here after 14 years of responding to grant RFPs and seeking project-specific funding. Now, we’re clear that we will make our greatest contributions to the world if we prioritize and raise substantial general operating support. At minimum, we’re looking to raise $1M by mid-2024, and our projects are poised to go far deeper if we raise $1.5M or more.

�Law Center staff use participatory budgeting to allocate resources across our ecosystem. Our July 2023 budget process resulted in us growing several projects internally and giving $162,000 to four other organizations. The process also surfaced several projects that are poised to make excellent use of more funding. Your contribution will be spread in ways that enrich the whole ecosystem and deepen the impact of each project.

To discuss your contribution, we invite you to reach out to any staff member whose work inspires you and/or to any member of our Grants Circle: Alejandra, Itzel, Mwende, Elizabeth, and Sue. Everyone’s email address is their first name followed by @theselc.org �(e.g., elizabeth@theselc.org).

4 of 26

Our team:

5 of 26

Facts about the Law Center

  • Our team: 16 full-time, 2 part-time
  • Locations: Based in Oakland, with staff in Iowa, Chicago, New York City, and Michoacán, Mexico.
  • Structure and governance: We’re a worker-directed 501(c)(3). All staff participate in multiple program areas and contribute to operational work. Decision-making is decentralized among staff and circles throughout the organization. More info on our unique model here.
  • Leadership: Nearly every staff member 1) does public speaking, 2) teaches workshops, 3) participates in coalitions, 4) writes grants, 5) raises donations, and 6) speaks with the media. If you are looking for the organization’s leaders, you’ll find 18 of them! Read more about why we don’t have an Executive Director.
  • Equitable compensation: All staff earn a base salary of $70,390 to $92,397, depending on MIT Living Wage Calculator’s cost of living in their location. Staff with dependents receive additional compensation. Pay differentials are not based on hierarchies of position or educational privilege.
  • Our Budget: $1.9M in 2022, $2.5M in 2023, and $2.8M in 2024.
  • Our Funding: Between 70% and 90% of our income comes from grants, though a growing portion comes from earned income and individual donors. In 2022, 509 individual donors supported our work, with a total of $130,000 in gifts, plus one $500,000 donation. We earn income from public speaking fees, workshop fees, research and writing contracts, legal services, and other consultation work.

6 of 26

Our 7 Core Strategies

The following 7 slides detail our core strategies. All combined, these strategies position the Law Center to serve as a legal backbone of solidarity economy movements nationally.

7 of 26

Direct legal support

We have four approaches to providing direct legal support to communities:

  • Our Resilient Communities Legal Cafe is a “walk-in” advice clinic that happens 3 times per month, both in-person and on zoom, averaging 30 clients per month, and made possible by dozens of volunteers. Since 2013, we’ve provided legal advice to 3,000+ grassroots organizations and cooperatives.
  • Consultations: We provide one-time consultations to organizations needing more specialized support than we can provide in the Legal Cafe setting. Through these consultations, we aim to connect clients to resources and other sources of ongoing legal support, where needed.
  • Legal Support Teams: We form teams to provide ongoing legal support to organizations needing in-depth support. Teams tend to include staff, interns, and apprentices who meet regularly with clients, build relationships, and collaborate to creatively meet legal needs.
  • Legal Services Fund: We pay the cost of legal support provided by our Fellows to under-resourced organizations and cooperatives around the U.S., Canada, and Puerto Rico. Since 2019, we’ve disbursed over $100,000 to 26 Fellows to work on 42 clients and projects listed here.

Our legal support programs have taught us so much about the legal needs of communities, and in turn, this has informed our development of public policies, new program areas, and educational resources.

8 of 26

Training and supporting legal workers

Over the years, the Law Center has launched several programs to train and support lawyers and other legal workers, including the Cooperative Professionals Guild, a 300+ member online network, and an apprenticeship program through which four of our staff became lawyers without going to law school from 2013 to 2020. In 2024, our primary focus will be:

  • Fellows: Our 56-lawyer Fellowship Program supports these lawyers with two annual gatherings/trainings and 1-3 monthly webinars and discussions, including a “Legal Beehive” where Fellows solve legal puzzles together.
  • Apprentices: Our Radical Real Estate Law School is supporting four community leaders to become lawyers without going to law school under CA’s Law Office Study Program, while building resources for radical real estate projects.
  • Interns: We have an internship program that allows law students and other aspiring legal workers to get to know all aspects of the Law Center’s work, from internal governance to client support work. We also provide a living stipend to interns based on need.
  • Lawyers: We are a California-certified Mandatory Continuing Legal Education (MCLE) provider, and we maintain a library and annually offer for-credit training programs for lawyers. Beyond simply training lawyers on substantive legal topics, we also aim to offer a different vision for lawyering. See our blog and 3 training videos on Nurturance Lawyering.

9 of 26

Education and research

The Law Center has built a wealth of legal guides, resource libraries, sample documents, and even cartoon legal documents to make the law welcoming and navigable to everyone. We also do innovative legal research to help our communities understand their place in the vast grey areas of the law. Now and in 2024, some of our priorities include:

Legal resources, education, and sample documents in progress:

  • More legal resources to support return of land to Indigenous people, building on our Seeds of Land Return resource.
  • A complete re-design and new resources for our Co-opLaw.org resource library.
  • A bilingual cartoon Operating Agreement for a cooperative that supports the development of many small worker cooperatives. No legalese here! We engaged a reading specialist to write this for an audience with an 8th grade reading level.

Current research projects include:

  • Writing about the law of foundation endowments, to support redistribution of wealth and democratization of philanthropy.
  • Researching public utility regulations’ applicability to grassroots energy projects.
  • Fair housing and anti-discrimination laws and land return to BIPOC communities.
  • Researching the interplay of labor law and worker cooperative development.

10 of 26

Policy advocacy

We’ve spearheaded more than a dozen policy campaigns, passing laws to legalize homemade food enterprises, support worker cooperatives, and remove barriers to housing cooperatives, urban farming, and more.

We work with a dedicated state-level policy advocate to execute our policy strategies and bring the Law Center’s voice into many legislative conversations. We’re tracking legislation on housing, land, food, and worker cooperatives, while working in coalitions to catalyze new legislation.

Current policy work includes:

  • Exploring local ballot measures as a path to direct democracy and transformative legislation. Last year, we sponsored Community Democracy in Action to gather signatures for an Oakland ballot initiative on participatory budgeting.
  • We co-founded the Worker-Owned Recovery California (WORC) Coalition, which advocates for policies that help transition small businesses to employee-owned models.
  • Working to fund and implement SB 1407: the CA Expanding Employee Ownership Act, legislation we helped pass in 2022 that created a worker cooperative technical assistance hub within CA's Office of Business and Economic Dev.
  • Engaging in policy advocacy explorations with the California Food and Farm Network (CFFN).
  • Supporting Earth Equity to explore California legislation to reform prisons in alignment with the Norwegian model.
  • Exploring ways to remove barriers to co-living and shared housing in California by working to remove or redefine the definition of “family” under state law.

11 of 26

Cultural change and creative storytelling

The Law Center is as much a cultural organization as we are a legal organization, because we see law and culture as completely intertwined. We create films, cartoons, gatherings, events, writings, and other media to craft the story of the world we are co-creating with our clients and partners. When we bring this future to life through story, it lays the groundwork to shape the necessary laws and legal structures.

We’re co-creating a film on Indigenous and Black land justice with partners at The Cultural Conservancy. See the Film Project Vision here.) This film builds on a convening we co-hosted in 2019, where a broad network of deep-rooted organizations collectively articulated a 100-year vision for land justice in the Bay Area.

Other examples of recent cultural work include our #TenantsWithoutLandlords event and blog series, recapped here.

We are also in the process of creating a series of cartoon videos and accompanying discussion guides for land justice organizations seeking to have deeper conversations about their work and envision a transformed world. Recent cartoon videos:

12 of 26

Incubation and fiscal sponsorship

The Law Center has created, incubated, fiscally sponsored, and/or spun-off nearly a dozen organizations. Most of these are projects conceived by Law Center staff in partnership with clients or collaborators.

Some projects operate as largely autonomous organizations under our umbrella. These include:

  • Minnow, a project to advance land justice for BIPOC farmers.
  • Nonprofit Democracy Network, a group of more than 100 nonprofits �transitioning to workplace democracy.
  • Community Democracy in Action, a project to advance direct democracy �through signature-gathering for local ballot initiatives.

We also incubated and continue to administer funding to three cooperatives:

We helped launch the following five organizations that now operate autonomously, while we continue �to collaborate: Worker-Owned Recovery California Coalition, Cooperative Professionals’ Guild, �The Next Egg, Initiative for Energy Justice, and California Alliance for Community Composting.

Lastly, we receive and administer funding to Hasta Muerte Coffee Cooperative and the Network of Bay Area Worker Cooperatives (NoBAWC) for their cooperative education and development work. We have also fiscally sponsored funding to several other groups on a one-time basis, when access to funding would otherwise have been a barrier.

13 of 26

Building partnerships, coalitions, and ecosystems

  • New Economy Coalition
  • Prospera
  • Cooperative Professionals Guild
  • Network of Bay Area Worker Cooperatives
  • Nonprofit Democracy Network
  • East Bay Community Law Center
  • People’s Land and Housing Alliance
  • California Community Land Trust Network
  • Colmenar Cooperative Consulting
  • Immigrants Rising

We are intentional about building relationships, participating in coalitions and working groups, and nurturing ecosystems that enable broader transformation. In 2024, our closest collaborators will include:

  • Agroecology Commons
  • Center for Ethical Land Transition
  • East Bay Permanent Real Estate Cooperative
  • Sogorea Te’ Land Trust
  • Homefulness / POOR Magazine
  • Winnemem Wintu Tribe
  • Community Democracy Project
  • People Power Solar Cooperative
  • U.S. Federation of Worker Cooperatives
  • Climate Justice Alliance
  • Nuns & Nones Land Justice Project
  • The Cultural Conservancy
  • Earth Equity
  • Minnow

14 of 26

Our 7 Project Themes for 2024

Over the years, our work has addressed dozens of issue areas, including urban farming, local investing, retirement savings, seed sharing laws, community compost law, local currencies, technology cooperatives, and much more. Often, once we have made an impact in a particular sector – or when we see other organizations stepping in to take leadership – we step back and shift our focus. At present, our hearts are drawn to focus on the seven �themes addressed in the following slides:

15 of 26

Projects to support land return

We work for widespread return of land to Indigenous stewardship, offering all people a liberatory vision for more nurturing and just ways of living with land and each other.

A key project in 2024 will be co-creating a film on Indigenous and Black land justice.

We will also launch a specialized legal advice clinic to support land-based organizations whose work is rooted in spirituality and/or non-dominant worldview systems.

We continue to develop user friendly resources like Seeds of Land Return and the Rematriation Easement.

Our current work also includes:

16 of 26

Housing justice projects

We organize communities, build coalitions, change laws, and provide legal support to organizations doing inspiring work to secure housing for all. Our work currently includes:

  • Partnering with Homefulness to navigate and shine light on laws in Oakland that repress development of multi-unit permanent cohousing, education, arts, and social change projects for unhoused people on two parcels in East Oakland.
  • Incubation and legal support for East Bay Permanent Real Estate Cooperative (EB PREC), a multi-stakeholder BIPOC-centered cooperative organizing communities to vision, finance, acquire and permanently steward housing, land, and commercial space. Our work has included co-creating EB PREC’s cartoon Bylaws, legal support for a groundbreaking national securities offering under Reg A+, supporting a Black cooperative and cultural corridor, and publishing a guide to starting a permanent real estate cooperative.
  • Legal support for Asian-Pacific Self-Development and Residential Association (APSARA), a grassroots membership organization and affordable housing community transitioning to cooperative ownership by hundreds of Cambodian refugees and their families in Stockton.
  • Collaborating with several California community land trusts to strategize for long-term stability and growth of land trusts, supportive public policies, and participatory governance.
  • Short-term legal support for Richmond LAND a women of color-led organization that acquires and co-stewards land and housing to build staying power in Richmond, CA.

Law Center Staff with EB PREC Staff

17 of 26

Food and energy sovereignty projects

Food and energy have long been focal points for the Law Center’s work. We support the land, funding, and workplace democracy needs of these sectors, while continuing to work with sector-specific clients and collaborators described here:

  • The Law Center collaborates closely with People Power Solar Cooperative, which enables community members to self-organize, build community, learn, pool resources, and apply their ingenuity to diverse projects that give communities access to electrical, political, social, and economic power in the face of our climate emergency.
  • Legal support for Fresh Future Farm, an urban farm and cooperative grocery serving disinvested Black communities in South Carolina. We also made a $50,000 grant to this farm after we received a large unexpected gift.
  • Partnering with Agroecology Commons to let the wisdom of agroecology shape our work, while developing legal workshops to integrate with their farmer trainings.
  • Serving as an administrative and fiscal sponsor for Minnow, a project to advance land justice for BIPOC farmers.
  • Our team member, Dorian Payán, is serving on the California Agricultural Land Equity Task Force to develop policy recommendations to equitably increase access to agricultural land for food production and tribal uses.
  • Supporting the Sonoma County Land Justice Project, Latinx farmworkers developing their own cooperative land project. Their vision of food production is founded on a non-extractive relationship to the land. Cooperatives are not only just, but are also culturally affirming.

Erika Sato and Dorian Payán at an Agroecology Commons work party:

18 of 26

Projects to support nonprofit workplace democracy

Social change organizations need tools and frameworks for organizational development and governance that match their visions and values for a more equitable, inclusive, and liberatory world. We offer training, resources, and consultations on worker self-direction in the nonprofit sector. We also co-host the Nonprofit Democracy Network, a peer network of more than 100 organizations developing more democratic and equitable workplace practices — from innovative pay structures to shared leadership — to counter models of hierarchy and white dominant organizational cultures.

In mid-2023, we wrapped up the first iteration of Collaborate to Co-Liberate: Structures and Practices for Democratic Organizations, a 15-month peer learning journey that brought together 200 participants from nearly 100 organizations. The program explored the stickiest questions facing movement groups striving to build equitable, democratic, and life-giving organizations, with modules led by leading practitioners, including adrienne maree brown, Gopal Dayaneni, and more. The journey was divided into four seasons: Transformative Relationships, Organization Fundamentals, Navigating Capitalism, and Connecting to Your Web of Relations.

Now and in 2024, we are growing the Network while expanding our online community of practice, planning a second cohort of Collaborate to Co-Liberate, and developing new videos in our popular worker self-directed nonprofit (WSDN) TV series.�

More resources for worker self-directed nonprofits:

19 of 26

Worker cooperative development projects

The Law Center provides the most comprehensive collection of legal resources available for U.S. worker cooperatives, filling what had previously been a significant gap in essential resources. This includes:

  • Co-opLaw.org: This site contains sample documents and educational materials covering a wide range of legal topics relevant to worker cooperatives. We are currently redesigning and revamping this site to ensure the rich legal information is accessible to everyone.
  • Our Cooperative Law Practice Guide is the first guide of its kind for cooperative legal professionals.

We also build ecosystems of support for worker cooperative development and provide direct legal services to cooperatives. In 2024, this will include:

20 of 26

Projects to support immigrant cooperatives

We partner with Prospera, Immigrants Rising, Colmenar Cooperative Consulting, and others to fill the gap in legal resources and support for immigrant cooperatives and to support the leaders who are building economic resilience and job stability for their communities. Each year, we provide legal advice and training to dozens of cooperators.

Our work includes:

  • Advising community partners in the Central Coast who are forming an innovative support cooperative, which will provide dozens of immigrant-owned cooperatives with accounting, marketing, and other technical assistance. We plan for this design to be replicable in other areas as well. We are creating bilingual cartoon legal documents for this project.
  • Providing legal advice to Spanish-speaking participants in Prospera’s Crece Comunidad Program through Cafecitos Legales held twice per year.
  • Providing legal consultations to start-up and existing immigrant owned coops referred by partner organizations.
  • Training attorneys to advise immigrant-owned cooperatives.
  • We produce engaging and accessible resources, like this bilingual cartoon cooperative operating agreement, which includes cooperative governance and finance resources.

21 of 26

Wealth redistribution projects

In 2024, we will center several projects on the theme of wealth redistribution, which we believe is critical to supporting all other work we do. This work builds on our prior projects focused on Mutual Aid and on Grassroots Finance, but with a focus on activating larger sums of money to flow in the form of gifts to nourish cooperatives and other solidarity economy initiatives.

Our work includes:

Additional background: From 2019 to 2022, the Law Center co-led TheNextEgg.org, where we built tools so people could invest retirement savings in their communities. We’ve moved away from this project, and it is now managed by LIFT Economy. See our essay on our shift away from The Next Egg and our essay describing the structural problems of 401(k)s and IRAs.

22 of 26

A day in the life

To paint a picture of what the above work looks like, here’s what our coworkers might be doing on a typical day:

  • Hosting our Legal Cafes
  • Scheming about policy initiatives
  • Advocating for alternative housing models
  • Legal apprentice at our Radical Real Estate Law School
  • Ensuring law accessibility to the People
  • People’s Land and Housing Alliance Coalition
  • Solving legal puzzles and reviewing documents for land stewardship clients
  • Drawing cartoons for our bite-sized legal guides
  • Co-managing finances for the Law Center
  • Teaching workshops on staff compensation, boards, and more.
  • Organizing with a farmworker cooperative
  • Facilitating a meeting with Sogorea Te’ Land Trust
  • Handling property tax exemptions for clients
  • Meeting with California’s Land Equity Task Force
  • Representing the Law Center in Climate Justice Alliance meetings
  • Collaborating on policy advocacy and cooperative development within California’s prison system.
  • Co-stewarding strategy, organizational design, and working groups with the U.S. Federation of Worker Cooperatives
  • Providing tech support to Law Center staff
  • Training coop developers on securities law

23 of 26

2023 highlights and celebrations (p. 1 of 3)

24 of 26

2023 highlights and celebrations (p. 2 of 3)

25 of 26

Even more 2023 highlights and celebrations

Thank you to our collaborators, supporters, volunteers, and fans for a wonderful 2023!

26 of 26

Thank you

To discuss your contribution, we invite you to reach out to any staff member whose work inspires you and/or to any member of our Grants Circle: Alejandra, Itzel, Mwende, Elizabeth, and Sue. Everyone’s email address is their first name followed by @theselc.org (e.g., elizabeth@theselc.org).