1 of 12

Taped Entanglement

Cassette Curation, Community Building & Music Criticism in the Age of Digital Streaming

2 of 12

Central Epistemological Node: Cassette collage as a core-binding object for dissertation project

  • Intersection of Centralized Theory & Practice (Music Criticism & Format Theory)
  • Active site for queer phenomenology, archival labor, forced intimacy, expansion of fan-artist dynamic
  • Realization of a political refusal of streaming as well modern news & media cycles as totalizing modalities of listening and overconsumption

3 of 12

Research Questions

  1. What do the material affordances of cassette collages offer the listening and critical habits of popular music critics and general audiences?
  2. How does the cassette collage’s deliberate format produce, maintain, and reclaim tactile methodologies of fan appreciation?
  3. How can collage prove an expansive and ethic of joyful practice in music criticism?
  4. How does cassette collage and curation utilize hauntology to eulogize and understand the past and the dead?
  5. How does the material intervention of PopMusicology as an independent cassette boutique label utilize the cassette assemblage to build community?

4 of 12

Tensions, Problems & Conflicts

  • Shortened listening spans
  • Interruption of album as discrete statement of artist intentionality
  • Fast consumption and critique of music and related criticism as problematic
  • Corporate ownership of rentable media (YouTube, Spotify, Apple Music, etc.)
  • Diminished material opportunities for appreciation and fandom
  • Exhaustion narratives in popular music criticism
  • Historical and personal erasure of listening lives
  • Disenfranchisement from engaging in music industry, music, and musicalia
  • Underrealized articulation of the assemblage of human and non-human technologies in contemporary cassette practice

5 of 12

Integrated Theoretical & Methodological Framework

Question Domain

Theoretical Framework

Methodological Approach

Material affordances of cassette collages for listening habits of people and critics

Format Theory�Sonic Phenomenology�Durational Listening

Auto-Ethnography�Embodied Curation of Collages, Slow Listening & Durational Experiences

Cassette Collage reclamation of fandom demonstration and music appreciation

Counter-archival Care

Reparative Historiography

Creation and Curation of Cassette Collages (Mariah Carey, Lady Gaga, Beyoncé)

​

​

Ethic of Joyful Practice in Music Criticism

Aesthetic Stewardship & Counter Systemic Media Ecology

Black Feminist Ethics of Care

Reparative Critique

Tactile Media Assemblage

​

Curation and Deployment of Collages Through Alternative Networks of Corporate Refusal

Tape Hauntology as individual or collective preservation of bygone listening lives

Hauntology

Black Music Historiography

Refusal of Format and Listening History Erasure

Material Analysis and Restorative Archaeology of New Orleans Tape Lot & Helen Wright Tape Collection

PopMusicology; Tape Assemblage for Community Building and Growth with Others

DIY-Independent Punk Business Aesthetics

Community Development

Public Musicology

Participant Observation, Ethnography, Deployment of Cassette Collage from PopMusicology among other products

6 of 12

Methods

  • Creation and curation of Cassette Collages (Contiguous Albums & Recorded Commentary)
  • Reflexive Auto-Ethnography / Participation-Observation (PopMusicology, LLC)
  • Material Analysis / Collaborative & Restorative Archaeology
  • Ethnography of Other Tapeheads (Assemblage Friction, Relational Intimacy, Refusal of Digital Hegemony)
  • Deployment of Collage through alternative non-corporate networks
  • Curation of slow listening, durational experiences and public exposure to musical immersion opportunities

7 of 12

Political, Social, & Methodological Stakes

  • Suggestion of an alternative critical mode of criticism-as-appreciation (ethic of joyful listening and critique)

​

  • The building of digital-analog networks that function on the cassette assemblage (human and non-human resources working in tandem) for listening, trading, distribution

​

  • Ethic of joyful and radical care of the archive through the recording of audio liner notes

8 of 12

Taped Entanglement Critique�(Against Disciplinary Norms, Methodology Gaps, or Institutional Oversights)

Prevailing Disciplinary Norms, Method Gaps, Institutional Oversights

Taped Entanglement Critique

Cassette Obsolescence & Subpar Fidelity to Streaming

Cassette Cultures; Material Vitality & High Fidelity

Eventual Listening Modalities of Contemporary Popular Music

Forced Intimacy & Queer Phenomenology of Tape

Durational Listening to Albums

Social Media Demonstration & Performance of Pop Fandom/ Music Appreciation

Reclamation Through Active Collaging

Cynical Exhaustion Narratives / Fast Consumption & Critique of Media and Music

Slow Listening as Critique and Criticism

Corporate Erasure of Grey Recording Markets

Restorative Historiography, Tangible Archive Tending, Media Archaeology

Individual Erasure & Intangibility of Listener's Lives

Tapes as Testament, Collage as Preservation

9 of 12

Interlocking Progression of Case Studies

  • Ch 1: Anatomy of the Tape Self & the Cassette Collage
    • How do I navigate the tape (analog) / digital relationship with cassette collages and slow-listening curation?
    • How can a public musicologist build community based on tape assemblage?
    • What does my practice as the label head of PopMusicology do for listening, community stakeholders, audiences of listeners, and music criticism?
  • Ch 2: Comparative Chapter on Other Tapeheads
    • How does the practice of cassette collage at PopMusicology engage with other Tapeheads and critics?
    • Ethnographies with Elmo Brown, Vincent Kazslauskas, Aadam Jacobs, RJ Helton
    • Proposed interviews with Anthony DeCurtis, Anthony Fantano, r/cassetteculture, Tapeheads

10 of 12

Interlocking Progression of Case Studies: Public Musicology

  • Ch 3: Mariah Carey, Glitter 25 How does the cassette collage assist in reclaiming Glitter’s sonic concept and narrative while revealing cynical and injurious exhaustion narratives in 21st century popular music criticism?
  • Ch 4: Beyoncé, B’Day 20
    • How can the material affordances of durational listening to the collage restore and allow for nuanced understanding of Beyoncé’s intention behind B’Day’s third resequencing in twenty years?
  • Ch 5: Imperfect Celebrity: Slow Listening to Lady Gaga in the Age of Digital Streaming
    • How does cassette collage preserve critical historiography of Mayhem, promote alternative listening engagement for fans, and reclaim the pop object from the market?

11 of 12

Interlocking Progression of Case Studies

  • Ch 6: The Sonic Hauntology of Helen Wright (1941- 2026)
    • How can cassette collage honor the sonic legacy and historic listening networks of 20th century black music archives?
    • How does the preservation, digitization and analysis of old tape collections (and sharing in public musicological forums) contribute to a radical remystification of the archive?

12 of 12

Scholarly Intervention & Broader Contribution

  • Taped Entanglement anticipates a return in techno-nostalgia for compact cassettes and wishes to meet the occasion by exploring the wide berth and capabilities of tape as a form of fandom empowerment and agency
  • The dissertation proposes the cassette as a useful tool for critics to encourage durational listening in audience members and a joyful ethic in slow criticism for those who wish to move at a different pace than the digital maelstrom.
  • Cassette collage is a guaranteed deep listening tool for both audiences and critics; a mew methodological and pedagogical tool for future media archaeologists and critics alike
  • Reinvests agency into listeners as owners as opposed to renters while resisting corporate incentives to advance streaming as a totalizing modality