1 of 13

October 13, 2022

Adam Lichtenheld

Immigration Policy Lab

Stanford University

Understanding Social Acceptance of Returnees in Post-ISIS Iraq

Saad Saadi

Mercy Corps

2 of 13

>1 million people remain displaced in Iraq

A lack of social acceptance has prevented return and led to re-displacement (IOM 2020, 2021, 2022)

Addressing this challenge is important for ending displacement and preventing future conflict

CHRISTY DELAFIELD/MERCY CORPS

3 of 13

Mercy Corps surveyed 511 Yazidi households in Sinjar and displacement camps in Duhok governorate to explore the conditions under which they were more or less likely to accept returnees.

Objectives

4 of 13

Findings

  1. Returnees’ movement patterns during ISIS rule shapes their social acceptance more than their ethno-religious identity
  2. A sense of shared victimhood under ISIS makes Yazidis, especially men, more likely to accept Sunni returnees

5 of 13

Finding #1

“I am going to describe a hypothetical person who is from Sinjar and wants to move back. He is a 35-year-old [Kurd/Sunni Arab] who...

1. …fled Sinjar after ISIS invaded the area [leaver]

2. …remained and lived under ISIS before fleeing later [stayer]

3. …worked in a government sector in Sinjar under ISIS [collaborator]”

6 of 13

7 of 13

“Guilt by Location”

“If he had not helped ISIS, he would not have stayed in Sinjar. He would have left too.”

“Everyone who remains under ISIS rule is a supporter of them.”

“I answered yes because I trust him and because he did not stay in Sinjar unlike those who stayed and helped ISIS.”

PHOTO CREDIT: MERCY CORPS

8 of 13

Finding #2

  • “Should Sunni Muslims be fully welcomed into your community?”
  • “How would you like having a Sunni Muslim as your neighbor?

“Treatment” prompt:

“Like your community, many Sunni Muslims lost and suffered through a lot because of ISIS. Their homes were destroyed, they were displaced, and many of them were killed, abused, and imprisoned by ISIS.”

9 of 13

10 of 13

11 of 13

Takeaways and Recommendations

  • Politics of wartime displacement can influence post-conflict attitudes and social relations.

  • Promoting inclusive perceptions of victimhood can improve the prospects of sustainable return and reintegration – even among a heavily persecuted population in a highly polarized environment.

  • Need to consider gender-specific barriers to social acceptance.

12 of 13

13 of 13

The Gender Gap

ISIS policies sanctioned the use of sexual violence, especially against Yazidi women (Revkin and Wood 2021), inflicting considerable trauma (Ibrahim et al. 2018; Kizihan 2018)

Survivors of sexual violence face a higher risk of PTSD compared to survivors of other violence (Campbell & Wasco 2005; Cortina et al. 2006)

SINJAR MOUNTAIN (SHUTTERSTOCK)