Budget 2024 Proposals relating to International Taxation and Startups
NIRC ICAI Session-27th Jul-2024
CA Manish Aggarwal
Agenda- International Tax Proposals
2
Tax Rate Changes |
Capital Gains rationalisation |
Changes in Buy Back taxation regime |
Presumptive Scheme for Foreign Cruise Operators |
Abolishment of Equalisation Levy |
IFSC/Gift City Specific Direct Tax Amendments |
Changes in exempt transfers to exclude corporate gifts |
Transfer Pricing Changes and Safe Harbour rules announcement |
Procedural Changes |
Key International Tax Proposals
3
Budget 2024- India Economic Landscape
Key Economic Indicators & Highlights
The Budget proposals will be effective after the Finance (No. 2) Bill, 2024 (as finally approved by the legislature) receives assent of the Hon’ble President of India.
Tax Rate Changes- Non-Residents
5
Capital Gains Rationalization
6
01
02
03
04
Applicable with respect to transfer of capital asset on or after 23 July 2024
Capital Gains Rationalization- Current Period of Holding
7
Type of Asset | Current Short Term | Current Long Term |
| Less than 12 months | 12 months or more |
| Less than 24 months | 24 months or more |
| Less than 36 months | 36 months or more |
Capital Gains Rationalization- Proposed Period of Holding (w.e.f 23-Jul-24)
8
Type of Asset | Proposed Short Term | Proposed Long Term |
| Less than 12 months | 12 months or more |
All other assets including Immovable property Unlisted shares Unlisted bonds / debenture Gold | Less than 24 months | 24 months or more |
Capital Gains Rationalization- Tax Rates – Long Term Capital Gains (w.e.f 23-Jul-24)
9
Type of Asset | Non- Resident- Current | Non-Resident Proposed |
| 10% (without indexation and foreign exchange fluctuation benefit) | 12.5% (without indexation and with foreign exchange fluctuation benefit) |
Unlisted equity Shares | 10% (without Indexation and foreign exchange fluctuation benefit ) | 12.5% (without indexation and with foreign exchange fluctuation benefit) |
Unlisted bonds / debentures | 10% (without indexation | Deemed as STCG taxable at applicable Rates |
Immovable property | 20% | 12.5% |
Capital Gains Rationalization- Tax Rates – Short Term Capital Gains (w.e.f 23-Jul-24)
10
Type of Asset | Non Resident- Current | Non-Resident Proposed |
| 15% | 20% |
Other Assets | No Change- STCG Taxable as per slab rates | |
Capital Gains Rationalization- Tax Rates – Taxation of Unlisted Bonds/Debentures (w.e.f 23-Jul-24)
11
The Bill proposes to amend section 50AA of the ITA to deem the capital gains arising on transfer or redemption or maturity of unlisted bonds or debentures to be STCG in nature.
Accordingly, any payment received by an investor on transfer or redemption or maturity of unlisted bond or debenture will be characterized as STCG and tax rate of such gains will be the tax rate applicable to such investor depending on its form and residency.
In case of non-residents, where redemption premium is specifically included in definition of interest under the relevant tax treaty, one will have to analyze whether (i) non-resident can offer such amount received on redemption of bonds / debenture as interest (instead of STCG under section 50AA) or (ii) can claim exemption (if any) under capital gains article.
Capital Gains Rationalization- Tax Rates – Specified Mutual Funds-50AA (w.e.f 23-Jul-24)
12
Finance Act, 2023 deemed the capital gains arising from transfer of unit of a ‘specified mutual fund’ to be in nature of STCG.
In this regard, ‘specified mutual fund’ was defined to mean a mutual fund (by whatever name called) which invests not more than 35% of its total proceeds in equity shares of domestic companies.
The consequence of the amendment by Finance Act, 2023 was that capital gains arising from both debt and non-debt oriented mutual funds were deemed to be STCG in nature, taxable at applicable rates in hands of investor. Further, there was ambiguity on whether fund-of-funds will also be covered within the ambit of ‘specified mutual funds’.
Considering the above, the Bill proposes to amend the said definition to provide that specified mutual fund means (a) a mutual fund (by whatever name called) which invests more than 65% of its total proceeds in debt and money market instruments or (b) a fund which invests 65% or more of its total proceeds in units of a fund referred to in clause (a).
Capital Gains Rationalization- Tax Rates – Specified Mutual Funds-50AA( w.e.f FY 2025-26)
13
Type of Asset | Current Taxability | Proposed Taxability |
| Deemed STCG as per applicable rates | Deemed STCG as per applicable rates |
Hybrid Funds/Arbitrage Funds /FOFs/ETFs where less than 35% in equity but not more than 65% in Debt or Money Market Instruments | Deemed STCG Taxable as per slab rates | Taxable as per period of holding(24) and applicable LTCG/STCG rates(12.5%/Slab rate) |
| | |
Capital Gains Rationalization- Immovable Property Transactions( w.e.f 23-Jul-24)
14
Particulars | Capital Asset being Immovable Property (Land / Building) (Period of Holding = 24 months) | ||||
Before 23 July 2024 (Pre-amendment) | On or after 23 July 2024 (Post-Amendment) | Remarks | |||
Short Term | Long Term | Short Term | Long Term | ||
Tax Rate | Slab Rates | 20% | Slab Rates | 12.5% | The rate of tax in case of long-term gains has been reduced to 12.5% by simultaneously withdrawing the indexation benefit*. |
Indexation Benefit on Cost | NA | Available | NA | Withdrawn | |
Changes in Buyback Taxation- S.2(22)(f),10(34A), 46A, 57, S.115QA,194 (w.e.f. 01st Oct-2024)
15
Particulars | Existing Provisions (before 1 October 2024) | Proposed Provisions (on or after 1 October 2024) |
Taxability |
b) In the hands of shareholders - Exempt under section 10(34A) of the Act |
b) In the hands of shareholders - Considered as deemed dividend under section 2(22)(f) of the Act and taxable at applicable rates |
Treatment of cost of shares bought back in the hands of shareholders | Not applicable | The cost of acquisition of the shares bought back would be treated as capital loss (short term / long-term depending on the period of holding of shares) in the hands of the shareholders eligible for set-off / carry forward against other capital gains as applicable. |
TDS applicability | Not applicable | Company is liable to deduct tax @ 10% under section 194 of the Act |
What happens to section 80M benefit for recipient of buy-back consideration and company declaring buy-back?
Does treaty rate apply to non-residents?
What if no capital gain in year of buy-back?
Dividend v. Buy-back – what is beneficial?
Changes in Buyback Taxation- S.2(22)(f),10(34A), 46A, 57, S.115QA,194 (w.e.f. 01st Oct-2024)
16
Consideration received by shareholders on buy-back of shares treated as deemed dividend
Buy-back consideration treated as a deemed dividend regardless of accumulated profits, without any deduction with respect to the issue price of such shares
Company undertaking buy-back must withhold taxes as applicable to dividend distribution
Cost of acquisition of the shares bought-back is allowed as a capital loss to shareholders
Capital losses cannot be set-off against any income other than capital gains
Changes in Buyback Taxation- �S.2(22)(f),10(34A), 46A, 57, S.115QA,194 (w.e.f. 01st Oct-2024)
17
Changes in Buyback Taxation- S.2(22)(f),10(34A), 46A, 57, S.115QA,194 (w.e.f. 01st Oct-2024)
18
No clarification regarding shares held as stock-in-trade
Corresponding amendments proposed under Section 57 of the IT Act, restricting deduction of any expenses in relation to buy- back of shares
Buy-back distribution tax and tax exemption to shareholders will be withdrawn
Beneficial rates under tax treaties should be available for non-resident shareholders
Buy-backs likely to become extinct in the listed company space
Amendments applicable from October 1, 2024
Presumptive Scheme for Foreign Cruise Operators-44BBC , 10(15B) (w.e.f. FY 24-25)
19
20% of the gross receipts from cruise operations will be deemed as business income
Existing presumptive regime for foreign ships u/s 44B will not be applicable to foreign cruse operators
Exemption from the leasing income of a foreign company from lease rentals of cruise, if such foreign company and the non-resident cruise ship operator have the same holding company
2% Equalization Levy Removed ( S.165A FA 2016 and 10(50) IT Act,1961)(w.e.f. Aug 01, 2024)
20
IFSC/Gift City related Amendments�� 94B/68/10(4D)�(w.e.f. FY 24-25)
21
IFSC/Gift City related Amendments�94B/68/10(4D)��(w.e.f. FY 24-25)
22
Expanded definition of a ‘Specified Fund’
sponsor and manager) are non-residents
Change in Definition of Exempt Transfer- S.47(w.e.f. FY 24-25)
23
Change in Definition of Exempt Transfer- S.47(w.e.f. FY 24-25)
24
Transfer Pricing Proposals
25
Key Proposals related to Startup Sector
26
Agenda- Startup related Proposals
27
Removal of Angel Tax |
Capital gains rationalisation for unlisted securities |
Reduced Withholding tax rates on domestic payments |
Mechanism to obtain lower withholding tax certificate on sale/purchase of goods |
Changes in Partnership Taxation |
Budget 2024 Vision for Startups
28
Over the past decade, India has transformed into a global economic powerhouse, with nominal GDP rising from INR 113.5 trillion in FY14 to INR 273.1 trillion in FY23 (10.25% CAGR).
With over 100,000 startups and more than 100 unicorns, the startup ecosystem shows immense potential for growth.
Budget 2024 aims to build on this progress, address challenges, and cement India’s position as a global innovation hub.
Removal of Angel Tax�(W.e.f FY 24-25)
29
Removal of Angel Tax�(W.e.f FY 24-25)
30
Removal of Angel Tax�(W.e.f FY 24-25)
31
The Bill proposes to abolish angel tax from FY 2024-25. Elimination of angel tax will increase capital availability with companies and simplify investment structures.
It is a positive step towards creating a conducive environment for companies especially startups in India.
However, this amendment is prospective in nature and angel tax provisions will continue to apply for past investments.
Provisions of Section 68 continues to apply
The issuer Indian company will continue to comply with valuation guidelines prescribed under FEMA
Capital Gains on Unlisted Securities
32
Previously, unlisted equities were subject to a long-term capital gains tax rate(20%) that was double that of their listed counterparts.
The budget's decision to equalise the tax rates for listed and unlisted securities(12.5%) is a significant boost for startups.
This change encourages greater rupee capital participation and reduces the preference for mutual funds and listed equities over startups.
Reduced Withholding Tax Rates on Domestic Payments (W.e.f 01st Oct-2024)
33
Section | Provisions | Existing TDS rate | Proposed TDS rate |
194H | Payment of commission or brokerage | 5% | 2% |
194-O | Payment of certain sums by e-commerce operator to e-commerce participant | 1% | 0.1% |
Lower TDS/TCS Certificate on Sale/Purchase of Goods- S.194Q/S.206C�(w.e.f 01st Oct-2024)
34
Scope of Section 197/206C(9) expanded to include the application for lower TDS rate u/s 194Q
Many of the companies are in loss making stage and deduction of TDS on gross value of sales/purchases creates working capital blockage
To ease the compliance burden and work capital relief, provisions amended to include application for lower TDS rate
Changes in Partnership Taxation (w.e.f FY 24-25)
35
Changes in Partnership Taxation(w.e.f FY 24-25)
36
Introduction of withholding tax provisions
10% tax withholding by the firm on payment salary, remuneration, commission, bonus or interest to a partner
Taxes withheld on payment/ accrual or transfer to partner's capital account
Withholding obligations continue even on interest/ salary payments above specified limits
No withholding tax on the distribution of the share of profits to partners
Amendment applicable on sums paid/ credited from April 1, 2025 (FY 2025-26) – clarity required
CA Manish Aggarwal
+91-9654989776
Office-316, 3rd Floor, Westend Mall, Janak Puri, Delhi-110058
37
Thank You
Q&A ?
38