1 of 51

From Cold War to Hot Peace

​

Can Trump Stop It?

Michael McFaul

​

Director and Senior Fellow at the Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies

Professor of Political Science

Peter and Helen Bing Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution.

​

2 of 51

U.S.-Russia Relations More Strained Today than Any Time During Last 30 Years

Russian intervention in neighborhood

​

Russian annexation of territory

​

Russian carpet bombing in Syria

Russian meddling in US elections

U.S. portrayed as enemy

80% of Russians have negative view of U.S.

For Putin, not just zero-sum struggle over interests but also ideological clash

  • Imperial America
  • Decadent West
  • Fight against Nazis

3 of 51

Signs of Conflict

Obama UN speech in 2014: Ebola, ISIS, Russia

​

NATO focused on Russia threat again

​

Russia kicked out of G-8

New Sanctions for Russia Interference in Presidential Election

Americans see Russia as enemy again (77%)

Western sanctions

  • Kremlin Chief of Staff has never been sanctioned by U.S.
  • Sanctions on Russian companies more comprehensive than any time in Cold War

Signs of Conflict

Signs of Crisis

Signs of Crisis

4 of 51

What Happened?

4

5 of 51

Explanations

(Waltz, Man, the State, and War)

The Structure of International System

1

U.S. Policy

2

Russian Domestic Politics

3

5

6 of 51

The Nature of International Politics

7 of 51

8 of 51

Rise of Russia

New Power = New

Capabilities

“Natural” Corrections to 1991

Weakness in late 1980s/ early 1990s aberration

New calls for treason charges against Gorbachev

Russia Behaving Like Great Power Again

8

9 of 51

Problems

Not all rising powers invade neighbors & threaten international system

  • Germany and Japan after WWII
  • China today

Why this Russian pivot now?

  • Why not in 2004?
  • No Putin speeches on Crimea before
  • Putin had different plan in 2013
  • Eurasia Economic Union
  • Olympics Outreach, Khodorkovsky release

9

10 of 51

U.S. (Western) Policy

11 of 51

Reaction to Aggressive U.S. Policies

Thermidor & NATO Expansion

Disappointment with the “revolution”

Tired of 1990s era of Western lecturing

Serbia Bombing

Iraq Invasion

U.S. Support for Revolution

Color Revolutions (2000, 2003, 2004)

Arab Spring (2011)

Russia (2011), Ukraine (2013)

1999

2003

2000-2013

11

12 of 51

Could West Have Done More To Help Consolidate Democracy and Markets in Russia?

​

“Failure [by the West] to embrace and defend the upstart leadership [after the fall of Gorbachev] would provide the real opportunity for a counterrevolutionary backlash. If economic decline and civil strife were to continue under a new regime, calls for order and tradition flavored with nationalist slogans will resonate with a suffering people. At this future but avoidable stage in the drama of the Soviet revolution, the specter of dictatorship will be real.”

​

-McFaul, San Jose Mercury News, August 19, 1990

13 of 51

Problem:

How to Explain Reset?

  • Cooperation with results
  • Interests not framed in zero-sum terms
  • Managed difficult issues
  • U.S. was not perceived �as enemy
    • Russia also not perceived as enemy by Americans

13

14 of 51

Moscow, July 2009

14

15 of 51

Reset Results

15

16 of 51

Reset Results: Security

New START Treaty

Northern Distribution Network (NDN)

  • Expanded through Russia
  • Kept Manas “Transit Center” open
  • U.S. purchases of Russian jet fuel

Iran

  • UNSCR 1929 (harshest sanctions ever)
  • P5+1 process

Managed Kyrgyzstani “Revolution” (2010)

16

17 of 51

Russian and American Troops Training Together

17

18 of 51

Reset Results: Economic Ties

18

19 of 51

Signs of Conflict

Russian membership in WTO

Granting Russia PNTR, repeal of Jackson-Vanik

123 Agreement (Civilian Nuclear Cooperation)

G-20 cooperation

Signs of Conflict

Signs of Crisis

Economic Successes

New Visa Regime

Visas for Russians up 20% since 2012 (51% since 2010), over 250K issued in 2013

Economic Success

20 of 51

U.S.-Russia Bilateral Trade

U.S. Exports to Russia hit a record $10.7 billion in 2012

20

21 of 51

Russian Opinion of the U.S.

Q: Do you have a favorable or unfavorable opinion of the U.S.?

Source: Office of Opinion Research surveys, 1992-2012

21

22 of 51

American Opinion of USSR/ Russia

22

23 of 51

American Opinion of Russia

23

24 of 51

Reset Results Happened After

01

03

NATO

Expansion

Orange

Revolution

02

Iraq

War

24

25 of 51

Reaction to Obama Weakness

“Reset” created permissive conditions for Russian aggression

​

R

Obama did not deter Putin soon enough

O

Weak Western response so far not enough to stop further Russian intervention

W

25

26 of 51

“When you look at this chaos that’s going on, does anybody think that Vladimir Putin would have gone into Crimea had George W. Bush been president of the United States? No! Even Putin is smart enough to know that Bush would have punched him in the nose in about 10 seconds.”

​

  • House Speaker John Boehner, Oct 27, 2014

27 of 51

Problems

Obama did push back in 2012-2013

  • Missile defense
  • Magnitsky
  • Canceled Moscow summit (September 2013)

Historic pattern clear

  • George W. Bush: Georgia (2008)
  • Reagan: martial law in Poland (1981)
  • Johnson: Czechoslovakia (1968)
  • Eisenhower: Hungary (1956)
  • Roosevelt: Red Army stayed in Eastern Europe (1945)

27

28 of 51

Russian Domestic Politics

29 of 51

Domestic Sources of Russian Foreign Policy

FP

1

2

Medvedev to Putin

Demonstrations against Regime (2011-2012)

29

30 of 51

Putin to Medvedev

United Russia Party Congress

  • Putin sees world in zero-sum terms
  • U.S. as competitor, not partner
  • U.S. as fomenter of regime change

30

31 of 51

Egypt 2011

31

32 of 51

Libya 2011

32

33 of 51

Syria 2011

33

34 of 51

Russia 2011

34

35 of 51

Russia 1991

35

36 of 51

Putin Reaction to Demonstrations against the Regime, 2011-2012

01

02

04

Putin needed new argument for legitimacy

Economic growth no longer sufficient

Strategy to mobilize base & discredit opposition

03

Revived U.S. as enemy

36

37 of 51

Putin: U.S. Supporting Opposition

​

“We know, regrettably, that … some representatives of some foreign states are gathering those to whom they are paying money, so-called grant recipients, carrying out instruction sessions with them and preparing them to do the relevant work, in inverted commas, in order to influence, ultimately, the election campaign process in our country.”

​

- Vladimir Putin, United Russia Congress, November 2011

38 of 51

U.S. (McFaul) Responsible for Demonstrations

“Therefore, the author of the Aleksey Navalny project is none other than Michael McFaul.”

“…he (McFaul) started working thoroughly on making anti-Putin rallies in Moscow more creatively. It seemed that the February 4 rally was bound for success.”

- Russia Today, Feb 7, 2012

39 of 51

40 of 51

41 of 51

42 of 51

42

43 of 51

And Yet, Putin’s Dual Impulses (2012-2014)

1

2

U.S. is Enemy

But need to cooperate with outside world

  • Exxon-Mobile-Rosneft
  • Syria chemical weapons deal
  • Sochi courtship of world

43

44 of 51

Last Straw: Fall of Yanukovych (2014)

Before February 21: different strategy

  • Eurasian Economic Union + Ukraine
  • Limited engagement with West

After February 21: Putin’s pivot

  • No longer concerned about Western reaction
  • Compartmentalization over
  • Enemy even better defined (Nazis and NATO)

44

45 of 51

Counter Attack �Interfering in U.S. Elections

Goals

  • Hurt Clinton, Help Trump
  • Delegitimize Electoral Process
  • Fuel Doubt about Democracy More Generally

Means

  • Theft and Publication of DNC/Podesta Data
  • Propaganda: RT and Sputnik and Twitter
  • Ad Buys
  • “Kompromat”?
  • Economic leverage?

45

46 of 51

Implications?

Good news

​

  • No master design
  • Tactical, emotional reaction
  • Annexation of more territory not inevitable
  • No cultural or historical cause for conflict with Russia

Bad news

  • Russia unlikely to change while Putin in power
  • End of second term: 2024
  • Putin works out 2-3 hours a day

46

47 of 51

A New Trump Reset?

47

48 of 51

Factors in Favor a New Reset

Central driver of past conflict no longer present

  • Arab Spring Over
  • Russian protests waning
  • Ukraine “democracy” weak

C

Trump Worldview

  • Likes Putin
  • Does not care about democracy
  • Yalta 2.0?

T

48

49 of 51

Common Agenda Small

ISIS? Iran? China?

1

Putin Needs an Enemy

​

2

NSC Not as Pro-Russia as Trump

  • Mattis, McMaster,
  • The Professionals at State, Pentagon, CIA

3

Trump Temperament?

Ongoing Investigations

Makes Reset harder

1

Putin Actions

Crackdown on Protestors

2

Allies

3

Factors Against a New Reset

50 of 51

The One Wild Card

President Donald J. Trump

51 of 51

Let’s Keep Talking

​

@McFaul

​

www.michaelmcfaul.com