1 of 74

Centering Wellness in School��Susan Barrett�sbarrett@dragonflyforward.org�ADAPT-HOPE-HEAL

National Center on PBIS Implementer Partner, Co-developer of the Interconnected Systems Framework, Founder, Dragonfly Forward

2 of 74

Acknowledgement and Contributions

Dr. Kimberly Yanek

Dr. Bob Putnam, May Institute

Dr. Brandi Simonsen and Dr. Jennifer Freeman, UConn

Kelcey Schmitz, Dr. Clynita Grafenreed, Rayann Silva, SMART Center

Dr. Kira Mauseth, Seattle University

3 of 74

How will you apply your learning?

4 of 74

What’s my “Why”?

  • Special Educator
  • School Counselor
  • Middle School Administrator
  • PBIS State Coordinator, Maryland
  • Technical Assistance Director, Center on PBIS
  • Wife, Mom

5 of 74

6 of 74

  • Whole Child Teams- NURSE, Counselor
  • Story, strengths, needs
  • Quick access to support in math and coping skills

Supports w/o label, diagnosis, insurance plan

Middle School , 2010

7 of 74

  • Warm welcome
  • 2 champions
  • Connection and Belonging
    • Art and Music Department
    • Photography and Film
  • Pro-social group of friends
  • Consistent, predictable, routines and expectations

8 of 74

9 of 74

10 of 74

Current Context

11 of 74

Social media �2009-2010�available on mobile devices

The Social Dilemma

12 of 74

71.8 % of High School Students spend 3 more hours per day on screen time.

2021 Montana Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results

13 of 74

41.5 % of High School Students in Montana reported feeling so sad and hopeless for 2 week or more in row, they stopped doing usual activities

2021 Montana Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results

14 of 74

And ….

March 2020

15 of 74

16 of 74

Common Experiences AND

Intersection with Discipline Policies

17 of 74

National Trends

  • Increased Social Emotional Behavior and Mental Health have been on an increasing trends for over a decade
  • Majority of students/staff with anxiety, depression, trauma, generational trauma
    • Racism is an adverse childhood experience- major long term health implications
  • Social Determinants of Health and larger community context that impact student success
  • Staff shortages- increasing and expected prior to pandemic
  • 1:1 service delivery will not be enough
  • Impact of healthy, positive, predictable, consistent nurturing environments – significantly impact wellbeing and academic achievement

www.pbis.org

18 of 74

Across the board, teachers struggling to feel that they are effectively and appropriately supporting students with intensive behaviors.��Administrators struggling to feel that they are effectively supporting staff with well-being. ��Early childhood and primary buildings, rates of behaviors such as biting (others and self), hitting (others and self), anxiety, withdrawal, etc. program-wide that are unprecedented. ���At Secondary level, increase suicide ideation, drug and alcohol misuse/abuse�

SY 2022-2023

www.pbis.org

19 of 74

Guiding Questions �Redesigning how we do school…

  • How do we broaden of what mental health is in schools?
  • If we broaden scope of health and wellness, how do we change our approach to training and supporting our staff?
  • How do we ensure health and wellness is the backbone of what we do?
  • How do we get everyone to invest?

20 of 74

Educators are not mental health professionals, but they have a role to play (and may require professional learning, coaching, support to carry out that role)

21 of 74

Why Mental Health in Schools?School-based mental health services reach children in typical, every-day environments. The natural, non-stigmatizing location offers an early and effective environment for intervention.

  • Youth are 6x more likely to complete mental health treatment in schools than in community settings (Jaycox et al., 2010)
  • Mental health treatment has large effects on decreasing mental health symptoms (Sanchez et al., 2018)
  • Mental health services are most effective when they are integrated into students’ academic instruction (Sanchez et al., 2018)

Read more…

new brief on The Case for School Mental Health

22 of 74

WE CAN NOT HIRE OR BUY OUR WAY OUT OF THIS

22

Simple responses to increases in funding won’t be enough

Redesign how we do school using MTSS logic

Hire social emotional behavior and mental health experts

Transform the system. Consolidate teams, center wellness in the strategic plan, accountability system and ensure cabinet level staff are involved.

Blend funding so community employed MH providers become embedded members of the community and work alongside school employed MH staff to help build capacity of ALL staff.

Select and Buy Social Emotional Behavioral (SEB) curriculum

Make sure basics are in place first. (Climate/Culture/Adult Wellness)

Ensure formal process, team-based decisions. (same as academic curriculum)

School and Community data used to prioritize skills.

All instructional staff model, teach alongside academic content.

Train staff on trauma-informed practices

Healing/Equitable Centered System-Team based training. Time to embed new learning. Time to develop evaluation plan.

Strengthen partnerships with families and community providers.

Normalize having families, youth, community members participate in teams and co-design effort

Expanded Team use school AND community data to inform efforts across all tiers.

AND

23 of 74

MTSS and PBIS are widely used. How can we enhance to fit mental health needs?

“MTSS is something to help organize the adults and their implementation of best practices within classrooms and schools.  MTSS is not about organizing kids as much as it is about organizing what we do for and WITH kids and their families.” - Dr. George Sugai, Professor Emeritus, University of Connecticut

24 of 74

Expanding PBIS to include MH with ISF�Interconnected Systems Framework

A Structure and process for education and mental health systems to interact in most effective and efficient way.

guided by key stakeholders in education and mental health/community systems

who have the ability to reallocate resources, change role and function of staff, and change policy.

25 of 74

Key Messages

1. �Single System of Delivery

2. ��Access is NOT enough

3. ��Mental Health is �for ALL

4. �MTSS essential to install SMH

One Set of Teams

Success defined �by Outcomes

26 of 74

“Do the best you can until you know better. Then when you know better, do better.”-~Maya Angelou�

27 of 74

Improved Student Outcomes

academic achievement

(Angus & Nelson, 2021; Horner et al., 2009; Lassen et al., 2006; Nelson et al., 2002)

prosocial behavior

(Metzler et al., 2001; Nelson et al., 2002)

attendance

(Flannery et al., 2020*; Freeman et al., 2015*)

emotional regulation

(Bradshaw, Waasdorp, & Leaf, 2012)

reduced bullying behaviors

(Ross & Horner, 2009; Waasdorp, Bradshaw, & Leaf, 2012)

decreased rates of drug/alcohol use

(Bastable et al., 2015*; Bradshaw et al., 2012)

social & academic outcomes for SWDs

(Lewis, 2017; Tobin, Horner, Vincent, & Swain-Bradway, 2012)

Reduced Exclusionary Discipline

office discipline referrals

(Bradshaw, Mitchell, & Leaf, 2010; Bradshaw et al., 2012; Bradshaw et al., 2021*

Elrod et al., 2022*; Flannery et al., 2014*; Freeman et al., 2015*; Horner et al., 2005; Horner et al., 2009; Metzler et al., 2001; Nelson et al., 2002; Solomon et al., 2012)

suspensions

(Bradshaw, Mitchell, & Leaf, 2010*; Freeman et al., 2015; *Gage et al., 2018; Gage et al., 2019; Nelson, 1996; Nelson et al., 2002; Solomon et al., 2012)

restraint and seclusion

(Reynolds et al., 2016; Simonsen, Britton, & Young, 2010)

racial inequities

(Fox et al., 2021; Gion et al., 2022; McIntosh et al., 2018; McIntosh et al., 2021a; McIntosh et al., 2021b; Muldrew & Miller, 2021; Payno-Simmons, 2021; Swain-Bradway et al., 2019)

Improved Teacher Outcomes

teacher efficacy & well-being

(Kelm & McIntosh, 2012; Ross & Horner, 2006; Ross, Romer, & Horner, 2012)

teacher-student relationships

(Condliffe et al., 2022)

student engagement & instructional time

(Algozzine & Algozzine, 2007; Condliffe et al., 2022; Flannery et al., 2020*)

school culture & organizational health

(Bradshaw et al., 2008; Bradshaw et al., 2009; McIntosh et al., 2021; Meng et al., 2016)

climate & safety

(Elrod et al., 2022*; Horner et al., 2009; McIntosh et al., 2021)

When Implementing Positive Behavior Interventions and Supports (PBIS) with Fidelity

28 of 74

�PBIS: A Continuous Improvement Framework

  • We organize our teams and resources to be effective, efficient and we continuously examine our needs
  • We make sure our kids are known, feel connected, valued and get help early.
  • We invest in what is likely to work for our students
  • We invest in our staff so they can support ALL students
  • We make sure we are implementing well as we review student outcomes
  • We continuously adjust based on need and improve based on our family, youth, staff and community input and leadership.

29 of 74

Inclusion is engagement within a community where the equal worth and inherent dignity of each person is honored. An inclusive community promotes and sustains a sense of belonging; it affirms the talents, beliefs, backgrounds and ways of living of its members.

Cobb and Krownapple, 2019

Core Values of PBIS

Inclusion, Equity, Dignity and Unconditional Belonging

30 of 74

“Inclusion Is NOT a strategy to help people fit into the systems and structures which exist in our societies. It is about transforming those systems and structures to make it better for everyone. Inclusion is about creating a better world for everyone.” Diane Richler

Cobb and Krownapple, 2019

“PBIS is NOT a curriculum adoption, it is about Transforming the System”-Dr. Kurt Hatch

31 of 74

What are the ways we are designing a healthy environment for all ?

    • Effective teams that include youth, family and community mental health providers (expand opportunity and access for members who historically have been excluded)
    • Data-based decision making that include school data beyond ODRs and community data
    • Formal processes for the selection & implementation of evidence-based practices (EBP) across tiers with team decision making and customized to fit culture/context/strengths/needs of community.
    • Early access through use of comprehensive and equitable approach to screening, which

includes uncovering strengths, story & internalizing and externalizing needs

    • Rigorous progress-monitoring for both fidelity & effectiveness of all interventions regardless of

who delivers

    • Ongoing coaching at both the systems & practices level for both school and community employed professionals (e.g., continuously examining the “health” of the system and the strengths and needs of the caregivers and helpers in the system)

32 of 74

Team Check

Effective leadership team that include youth, family and community mental health providers (expand opportunity and access for members who historically have been excluded)

  • Do you have executive level leadership actively engaged ?
  • Do you have members represent school community?
  • Should you consider adding members to this team?
    • Student, family, community employed mental health provider?
  • Is the team clear about its purpose?
  • How is it linked to the school improvement plan?

33 of 74

Mental Health

Teaching and Learning

Suicide Prevention Planning Team

Threat Assessment

Equity Team

Data Team

Midtown Community Partners

SEL Team

Climate and Culture Workgroup

Safety Committee

MTSS Leadership Team

PBIS Leadership Team

Inclusion Committee

Attendance Team

Discipline Team

Whole Child Committee

Restorative Practices

UDL

Current Teams

Doing Great work, but….

34 of 74

Consolidate Your Teams- From 25 to 3 �Expand your membership, Expand Your Data�Expand Your Results

Multidisciplinary Tier 1

Systems Team

Youth/Family/Community 

Multidisciplinary Tier 2

Systems Team

Youth/Family/Community

Multidisciplinary Tier 3

Systems Team

Youth/Family/Community

  • Coordinates and monitors support for all students, all staff, and all settings
  • Reviews aggregate data from both school and community to inform priorities/programming.
  • Focuses on positive classroom systems and early identification of student needs across the school/community
  • Monitors data to identify when and how to adjust system to meet the needs of whole school/community
  • Develops decision rules for when a student receives additional supports/ interventions
  •  
  • Coordinates and monitors interventions for groups of students needing support beyond Tier 1
  • Ensures data-based selection of evidence-based practices for small groups of students
  • Monitors and ensures timely access for students identified through data and/or request for assistance from student, family, or staff
  • Reviews how many interventions are in place, how many students are supported through each intervention, and how many of those students are responding
  • Coordinates and monitors interventions for all students receiving individual interventions
  • Ensures data-based selection of evidence-based practices for individual students
  • Monitors the number of students receiving individual interventions
  • Evaluates the number of students are responding to individual intervention
  • Considers needs for additional staff PD and coaching as needed per aggregate data review of effectiveness

 

Center on PBIS

35 of 74

COVID-19

36 of 74

Team Check�

Do we have data-based decision making routines that include school data and community data?

37 of 74

What is the story, strength and need of our larger community?

  • School Community
  • Neighborhood

Life outside of school directly impacts our children in school.

Partnerships with family, youth and community essential to transformation.

38 of 74

Tier 1 Team

  • Do you have an accurate picture of ALL of your student’s story, strengths and needs? Across ALL Subgroups
    • % of students meeting attendance criteria, % in each sub group
    • % of students who feel connected
    • % of students with 0-1 office referrals
    • % of students on track to graduate
    • % of students meeting academic benchmark
    • % of students with adequate health, housing, food
    • % of students who have experienced trauma
    • % of students with relationship with at least 1 adult

39 of 74

Tier 1 Team

  • % of staff who feel connected
  • % of staff who meet attendance requirements
  • % of staff who feel like they can manage their workload
  • % of staff who feel like they have skills to manage student academic and social emotional behavior needs.

40 of 74

Are the basics in place?�Creating an ecosystem where everyone thrives�If not, how do make decisions about what we need?

NAME, STORY, STRENGTH, NEED

To what extent does everyone experience feeling a sense of connection, unconditional belonging, love, joy, fun everyday?

Is every classroom a nurturing place to be for every student?

What does that look like/sound like?

What are the skills competencies staff need?

Are we organized to uncover the needs of staff ?

41 of 74

True or False

ALL teachers in your school employ basic classroom evidence-based practices.

    • A warm welcome is provided to everyone
    • Behavior Specific Praise statements to error correction is at least 5:1 and classroom system does not promote teacher attention to student errors
    • Wait time is 4 seconds
    • OTR rate. Teacher talk should be no more than 40-50% of instructional time.
      • New material: a minimum of 4-6 responses per minute with 80% accuracy.
      • Review of previously learned material: 8-12 responses per minute with 90% accuracy.
    • Routines and procedures defined and explicitly taught across year
    • Social skills explicitly taught in context with behavior examples
    • Pre-correction is used prior to transitions.
    • Active Supervision used in classroom (and non classroom) areas.

42 of 74

43 of 74

44 of 74

Incorporate Wellness Practices

Warm Welcome/Positive Greetings

Active Listening

Press Pause/ Neutralizing Routines

Space between behavior and response

Box Breathing

Movement to increase neural integration

Using Social Media Responsibly

45 of 74

Skill of the Month�One Pagers…Coming soon…

46 of 74

What happens when District MTSS Create Systems of Support to Install Positive Classroom Practices?�

47 of 74

District MTSS Drivers for Classroom Level Success

These Tier 1 Classroom Level Systems, Data & Practices are a part of our Larger District Level Systems that Ultimately make them Sustainable

48 of 74

Decrease in ODRs for SWD

49 of 74

Decrease in Risk Ratio for ODR’s for Race/Ethnicity Elementary 22-23 SY

97% decrease in Risk ratio for Black/African American Population

50 of 74

Decrease in Risk Ratio for ODR’s for Race/Ethnicity Multi- Years Elementary

2020-2021 SY When we gained fidelity with PBIS and began MTSS ISF

Yellow line (Internal Equity Gap criteria)

Red Line (State Equity Gap criteria)

51 of 74

Decrease in Suspensions

37.5% decrease

52 of 74

Time Gained from Decrease in ODR’s

53 of 74

Tier 2-3 Effectiveness Outcomes

Improvements in % of students making progress, ready to fade/graduate to less intensive tier/supports

54 of 74

Effectiveness of Tier 2 and Tier 3 Interventions

Tier 2 N=66 as of March 23rd

Tier 3 - N= 24 as of March 23rd

55 of 74

SWD Drop Outs

56 of 74

Graduation Rates

57 of 74

Exceeded Goals for Reduction in Spec. Ed Referrals

Special Education referrals will be reduced by 10% annually EXCEEDED GOAL (-47%)

Correlative Outcomes from DIP 18-21

PBIS Introduced

58 of 74

Improved Teacher Retention

59 of 74

Where to start?

60 of 74

Connection Matters

In its 85 years and counting, the Harvard Study of Adult Development has found that personal connections are the most important factor in long-term health and happiness.

https://www.cnbc.com/2023/02/10/85-year-harvard-study-found-the-secret-to-a-long-happy-and-successful-life.html

61 of 74

Are all students feel connected? Do they have a trusted an adult in school? How do you know? How can you find out?

% of students who feel like they belong (climate survey, walk through)

% of students who belong to club, sport, social aspect of school

% of students connected to adult who knows their name, story, strengths and needs

62 of 74

PBIS

63 of 74

Connect, Learn about your students �Uncover strengths and needs. �What do you know about your students? How do we track information? How do we adjust? How do we ask for assistance?

Teachers Level: Build a Routine

  • Daily checks
  • Weekly reviews
  • Monday adjustment

School Level: Build a Routine

  • Provide prompts and supports for staff
  • Check in with staff
  • Use fidelity checks and outcome data to celebrate

64 of 74

  • Research indicates that students are twice as likely to fail a class in 9th grade than in any other grade.

FICTION – 3-5 TIMES MORE LIKELY

  • In a large multi-school study, 15% of students performing in the top quartile of their 8th grade class were found to be off track by the end of their 9th grade year.

FICTION – 25% OF HIGH ACHIEVING STUDENTS

  • The national SWIS dataset demonstrates that 9th grade behavioral infractions in high schools across the country dramatically outnumber those of students in the upper grades.

FACT

  • Lower attendance during the first 30 days of 9th grade is a stronger indicator that a student will drop out than any other 8th grade predictor, including test scores, other indicators of academic achievement, and age.

FACT

  • Students who fall behind in 9th grade have a graduation rate 30% lower than that of student who are able to stay on track during the 9th grade year.

FICTION – 59% LOWER GRAD RATE IF OFF TRACK AS FRESHMEN

65 of 74

District Community

66 of 74

Ensure WELLNESS is central component and evident in … Strategic Plan-Evaluation Plan- Implementation Plan-School Improvement

67 of 74

Explicitly connecting to the Strategic Plan

68 of 74

Mental Health

Teaching and Learning

Suicide Prevention Planning Team

Threat Assessment

District Equity Team

Superintendent and Admin

Midtown Community Partners

SEL Team

Climate and Culture Workgroup

Safety Committee

District MTSS Leadership Team

District PBIS Leadership Team

Inclusion Committee

Attendance Team

District Discipline Team

District Whole Child Committee

Restorative Practices

UDL

Current Teams

Doing Great work, but….

69 of 74

Cabinet

Superintendent, Assistant Superintendents, Executive Directors

Executive Functions

Implementation Functions

District Community Leadership Team

Assistant Superintendents, Executive Directors, Community Partners (Agency, Families, Students, First Responders)

Directors, Wellness Coordinators

Elementary Implementation Team

Secondary Implementation Team

Workgroup 1: SEL Adoption (Wellbeing)

Workgroup 2: Data Dashboard (Accountability)

Workgroup 3: Threat Assessment (Safety)

Workgroup 4: ESA roles and functions (Wellbeing)

WELLBEING-ACADEMIC SUCCESS-SAFETY-COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT-ACCOUNTABILITY

70 of 74

Midtown School District Goal 1: Creating a Culture of Wellness

Measure

Considerations

20% annual increase in number of building level staff who report feeling supported by school and district leaders. (Goal of 100% by 2025)

Climate Survey

20 % annual increase in number of staff who report positive job satisfaction (Goal 100% by 2025)

20% annual increase in number of staff who report they have skills and competencies to manage student SEBA needs by March 2024. (70% by March 2023)

Professional Quality of Life

Increase Staff Retention Rate by 20% by March 2023

20% annual increase in number of of students who report feeling a sense of belonging by April 2023.

Climate Survey

20% of students can identify trusted adult at school by December 2022.

Climate Survey, TFI walk through

How do we build capacity to do walk throughs?

80% of students are connected to social club/activity by March 2023, 100% by March 2024.

Club Roster

How do we add more clubs, how much will it cost?

10% decrease in students in elevated and highly elevated risk range between Fall and Spring SY 2022-23.

BIMAS

How much does it cost to install a screener responsibility? Cost of instrument, staff to respond

All schools report 70% fidelity of PBIS implementation indicating a consistent, positive, predictable SW environment by March 2024. (current rate is 50% of schools with 70% )

Tiered Fidelity Inventory/SET

How do scale PBIS? What is the cost of training and coaching?

Decrease use in exclusionary discipline by 30% by March 2025, 50% by March 2026.

SWIS

Risk Ratio= 1 across all race and ability subgroups by March 2026.

SWIS

Attendance rates increase across all subgroups by 2% by March 2023. (comparison to base line- September 2022)

Attendance Rates

71 of 74

Suspensions do more harm than good…�So why are we continuing that practice?

“The findings underscore that suspending students does little to reduce future misbehavior for the disciplined students or their peers, nor did it result in improved academic achievement for peers or perceptions of positive school climate. Plus, the more severe the exclusionary discipline, the greater its negative effects were on a student’s future academic performance, attendance, and behavior.”

An Empirical Examination of the Effects of Suspension and Suspension Severity on Behavioral and Academic Outcomes

Christina LiCalsi, David Osher, Paul Bailey American Institutes for Research AUGUST 2021

https://www.air.org/sites/default/files/2021-08/NYC-Suspension-Effects-Behavioral-Academic-Outcomes-August-2021.pdf

Do No Harm

72 of 74

How do policies impact wellness?

  • Vaping- Marketing-Addiction- ???
  • Attendance and Tardy
  • Exclusionary Discipline

73 of 74

Social problems are not solved by individuals; they require collective action, collective thinking and collective courage. ”

-BELL HOOKS

74 of 74

Susan Barrett�sbarrett@dragonflyforward.org