Sit-Stand Work Stations
Ergonomic Risk Factors
Sustained Posture
Awkward Posture
Inadequate Rest
Forceful Exertions
Repeated Motions
Contact Stress
These 6 ergonomic risk factors should be avoided whenever possible.
Note that many situations will expose you to more than one risk factor at a time.
This lesson will focus on posture and rest as they are most relevant to sit-stand desks.
Ergonomists study bodies at work and try to prevent injuries that develop over time.
Ergonomic Awareness
What We Hear…
Are You Sitting Yourself to Death?
Don't Let Your Desk Kill You
Is Sitting a Lethal Activity?
We all agree being completely inactive is an unhealthy way to live. However, you can sit during work, and avoid the sedentary lifestyle these articles discourage. Whereas regular exercise outside work hours may not reduce the specific risks correlated with prolonged sitting; taking short breaks to walk and stretch throughout the work day makes a significant difference!
“These findings provide initial experimental confirmation of hypotheses generated by epidemiologic observational studies on the deleterious health consequences of prolonged sedentary time (too much sitting as distinct from too little exercise). Of particular importance is the potential for reducing cardiovascular disease risk by briefly breaking up prolonged periods of sitting with activity of at least light intensity. ”
- David W. Dunstan PHD (from a study on Breaking Up Prolonged Sitting)
Do Sit-Stand Workstations Improve Cardiovascular Health?
Do Sit-Stand Workstations Improve Cardiovascular Health?
Study populations in epidemiological studies were on populations that were not working/retired or disabled.
“But Standing will reduce my weight…”
Long-Standing Myths
False, it isn’t that simple. Standing and sitting have their own pros and cons.
False, sitting makes detailed tasks easier and is great for stationary jobs. While standing is particularly good for jobs in open areas that involve material handling or provide a service; standing makes keyboarding, mouse use, and writing slightly more challenging.
False, scientific research on factory assembly supports that standing all day is harmful. Many careers involve standing for long durations. Nurses, hairdressers, and waiters will testify to the difficulties of standing. When possible, one should spend the day switching between standing and sitting.
False, change your behavior without changing your desk. Moving is better than sustained postures of sitting or standing, so take short breaks to walk and stretch throughout the day. Try the Mhealthy Sit for 60/Move for 3 program to relieve the stress of static postures.
False, although varying your position can provide some relief, standing is not a cure-all. Without proper training, sit stand users experience discomfort significantly more often.
Risks and Rewards
Take Away Message
Sitting/Standing Risks
Why sit/stand work is not for everyone:
Sitting/Standing Risks
Avoid a Sedentary Lifestyle
Healthy behaviors and proper chair fit counteract the risks of sitting without adding the risks of standing
Scientific research supports simply adding periodic stretching breaks and brisk walks to your everyday routine prevents the adverse effects related to prolonged sitting. Learn more about how to integrate moving into your work day on the Sit for 60/Move for 3 MHealthy web page. There you will find useful stretches that can be done in the office. Bookmark your favorite exercises and set a timer to start forming a life changing habit.
Behavioral Alternatives
“Since I have a standing desk, I need a taller chair to go with it…”
Try these adjustments to improve comfort during seated work:
Sitting Set-Up
Don’t perch on the edge of your seat, you need to support your back.
Sit/stand stools combine the worst of standing and sitting
Kneeling chairs cut off circulation to legs and provide no back support
Ball chairs quickly fatigue muscles, prevent good posture, and pose dangerous fall risks
Buyer Beware!
Standing set up
Standing Set-Up
Neutral standing posture is very similar to correct sitting posture.
Head to toe:
Comparing Postures
Sitting and Standing
Sitting Posture
Standing Posture
Neck
Arms
Back and Legs
Back and Legs
Similarities
Comparing Postures
Best Practice
Comparing Postures
5. Feet supported
3. Elbows at 90º
2. Shoulders relaxed
4. Wrists flat
1. Face forward
stand
sit ≥ 15 minutes
stand
During every 90 minute period you must take the time to sit for at least 15 minutes to restore circulation, reduce swelling in the legs, and reverse spinal shrinkage.
Hint #1 Set a timer or use calendar reminders for the first 2 or 3 weeks to help form a habit.
Hint #2 If this is physically demanding, other valid practices are sit 15 out of every 60 minute cycle, or simply change position every 30 minutes. Maybe standing for 60 minutes then sitting for 30 minutes fits your work rhythm.
How to properly practice sit/stand work
Best Practice
Up and Down and Up and Down and…
Best Practice
How to properly practice sit/stand work
Introduction to the different sit-to-stand products
With 10 adjustments per day, each change needs to be be quick and easy.
However, height adjustable desks start at $800, and cost increases with dimensions.
Sit/Stand Products
Luckily, you don’t need to replace the whole desk because
a desk modifier can sit on top of the current desk and raise your
keyboard, mouse, and monitor up and down. ($450)
adjustable desk
desk modifier
Sit/Stand Products
EHS has vetted the available products and can
identify the solution that best meets your needs.
Sit/Stand Products
Questions?
Sarah Cooney, OTR/L
Senior Ergonomic Professional
University of Michigan
scooney@umich.edu
734-763-7704