1 of 28

Native American Interests in the Tulare Lake Subbasin: Water Rights, Legal Challenges, and Environmental Restoration

2025 California Water Law Symposium

Presenter: Charmaine McDarment

Tule River Tribe

2 of 28

Historical Context of Water Rights

in the Tulare Lake Subbasin

3 of 28

IN OUR EVERY DELIBERATION, WE MUST CONSIDER THE IMPACT OF OUR DECISIONS ON THE NEXT SEVEN GENERATIONS.

FROM THE GREAT LAW OF THE IROQUOIS CONFEDERACY

4 of 28

PRE-CONTACT CALIFORNIA

Pre-Contact there were a variety of cultures and languages spoken
Pre-Contact, California Indians occupied the entire state, approximately 75 million acres.
Now, California Indians only occupy a small portion

5 of 28

CALIFORNIA �INDIANS �AND �THEIR �TERRITORY �(PRE-CONTACT)

6 of 28

CALIFORNIA INDIAN HISTORY

As Native Americans, we have been taught that we were always here.
Archaeology has proved that we have been here for thousands of years.
California Indians were very diverse:

Numbering about 300,000 in all;
Divided into more than 100 separate tribes or nations;
Four of the major North American linguistic groups were present;
Native speakers spoke over 100 dialects, 70% were as unintelligible as English and Chinese.

In the centuries before the settlement of CA a variety of Spanish institutions evolved for the exploitation of Indian labor—encomienda, repartimiento, hacienda. The most important was encomienda, under which Spaniards were granted groups of Indians from whom they were entitled to receive both tribute payments and labor. Later, encomienda was replaced by repartimiento, and Indian villages were required to send out a quota of their male population to work for a fixed number of weeks, in rotation, throughout the year. In practice a person wishing a repartimiento would file a petition that he needed the services of Indian laborers and that he would promise to treat them well. IF his petition was approved by colonial officials, the grant of Indian workers would be made. This system was ended in 1633 but by that time it had been replaced by a more efficient labor instiution of debt peonage and the hacienda. Under the new system, Indians either established a permanent residence on a hacienda or lived within an Indians community and hired themselves out to the hacienda. In this system, the Indian was free to choose his employer but this freedom was limited by the extension of credit from employer to employee, a relationship from which they rarely escaped.

7 of 28

YOKUTS

The Yokuts lived in the Central Area of California.
Yokuts means “the people”
There were approximately 63 tribelets or clans of Yokuts in Native California.
Social Organization
Traditional Dress and Housing
Foods

Acorns & Berries
Fish
Deer, Elk, Rabbit

8 of 28

9 of 28

10 of 28

11 of 28

The Yokuts and Their Connection to Pa’ashi (Tulare Lake)

Cultural and Ecological Interdependence

The Yokuts tribes' sustainable practices around Tulare Lake exemplify a profound understanding of ecological balance, where traditional fishing, gathering, and agricultural methods were intricately linked to the lake's seasonal cycles and biodiversity.

12 of 28

HISTORY OF UNITED STATES ACQUISITION OF CALIFORNIA

1848: U.S. acquired California
1850: California becomes a State
1851-1852: 18 Treaties with Indians of California

Tule River ancestors signed the Treaty of Paint Creek.

With the new Anglo-American settlers entering California, in the next few years hostilities increased between Indians and whites. During the next 25 years the Indian population of CA would decline at a rate more rapid than at any other time in its history.

To a degree often unrealized, the Hispanic past had a profound impact on the American present.

In spite of the increase in hostilities, for a quarter century after 1846, California Indians continued to be accepted by many Anglo-Americans as a useful class of laborers, agricultural workers, and domestic servants.

Anglo-Americans who came to California after 1846 perpetuated the system of labor exploitation that had already been established in Hispanic California. Indians continued to be subjected to forced labor; raids on native villages for Indian workers continued uninterrupted by the political changes of the 1840s.

Legal forms devised by the Anglo Americans to ensure the continued usefulness of the CA Indians.

Many white Californians came to depend on Indian labor. They complained that the new American governments were not providing adequate control and regulation of Indian labor, and they argued that steps should be taken to ensure continued access to this valuable resource. Laws or ordinances should be adopted to make the Indians useful.

13 of 28

Paint Creek Treaty Lands

Unratified Treaty Lands in California

14 of 28

Paint

Creek

Treaty

Lands

15 of 28

THE 18 TREATIES WITH THE INDIANS OF CALIFORNIA SET ASIDE 7,488,000 ACRES OF LAND, OR APPROXIMATELY ONE-THIRD OF CALIFORNIA, FOR INDIAN USE.

16 of 28

Impact of Gold Rush and Settler Expansion on Indigenous Communities

Displacement of Indigenous Peoples

The influx of settlers led to the systematic removal of Indigenous communities from their ancestral lands, disrupting their traditional lifestyles and cultural practices.

Alteration of Ecosystems

Settler agriculture and water diversion drastically changed the natural environment, diminishing resources vital for Indigenous subsistence and cultural identity.

Legal Marginalization

New legal frameworks favored settler interests, undermining Indigenous rights and access to land and water, perpetuating historical injustices and ongoing struggles for recognition.

17 of 28

Legal Challenges Facing

Native American Tribes

18 of 28

NATIVE AMERICAN RESERVATIONS

FEDERAL INDIAN POLICY

19 of 28

WINTERS WATER RIGHTS �KEY POINTS OF WINTERS WATER RIGHTS INCLUDE:�

Reserved Water Rights
Senior Priority
Quantification of Water
Purpose-Driven
Do not lose due to non-use

The Winters Doctrine has played a crucial role in recognizing and protecting the water rights of Native American tribes, helping resolve many disputes over water access and ownership.

20 of 28

Recent legal cases in the Tulare Lake Subbasin highlight the urgent need for sustainable water management practices that balance agricultural demands with the rights of Indigenous communities and ecological restoration.

Ongoing litigation is setting important legal precedents that may redefine water rights in California, emphasizing the historical injustices faced by Indigenous tribes and their claims for equitable resource access.

Impact on Water Management

Precedents for Indigenous Rights

Overview of Recent Legal Cases and Their Implications

21 of 28

Environmental Restoration Efforts in the Tulare Lake Subbasin

22 of 28

Importance of Tulare Lake for Biodiversity

and Ecosystem Health

The revitalization of Tulare Lake enhances habitats for diverse species, supporting ecological balance and promoting the recovery of native flora and fauna.

Critical Habitat Restoration

Wetlands surrounding Tulare Lake act as natural filters, improving water quality and reducing pollutants, which is essential for surrounding agricultural lands.

Water Quality Improvement

The lake's restoration fosters cultural reconnection for Indigenous communities, integrating traditional ecological knowledge into modern conservation efforts for sustainable management.

Cultural Significance

23 of 28

TRIBAL ECOLOGICAL KNOWLEDGE IN WATER BASIN MANAGEMENT

What is Tribal Ecological Knowledge (TEK)?
Deep-rooted understanding of local ecosystems, developed over generations.
Knowledge passed down through oral traditions, ceremonies, and practices.
Integrates environmental, cultural, and spiritual perspectives.
Case Study: Beaver Reintroduction

24 of 28

BEAVER REINTRODUCTION ON THE TULE RIVER INDIAN RESERVATION

filelib.wildlife.ca.gov/Public/OCEO/Tule Beaver Release/Video/Media Kit B-roll and Interviews.mp4

25 of 28

26 of 28

Empowerment through Participation

Engaging local communities in restoration projects fosters a sense of ownership, enabling them to contribute their unique insights and traditional knowledge, which enhances project relevance and effectiveness.

Community Involvement in Restoration Projects

Building Collaborative Networks

Establishing partnerships among diverse stakeholders, including Indigenous tribes, environmental organizations, and agricultural interests, promotes shared goals and sustainable practices, ensuring comprehensive ecological restoration efforts.

27 of 28

Yokuts Tribal Websites

Tachi-Yokut Tribe Website

Picayune Rancheria of the Chukchansi Indians Website

Tejon Indian Tribe Website

Tule River Tribe of California Website

The Table Mountain Rancheria Tribe's Casino

28 of 28

Contact Info:

Charmaine McDarment

Tule River Tribal Council

Charmaine.McDarment@tulerivertribe-nsn.gov